Microsoft Talks Privacy And Windows 10

Sigh...after years of fighting him I'm going to have to side with Heatless on this one.

I'm well known for my resentment of Win 8. So before any of you discount a thing I say, just remember that I fought Win 8 with a passion from the very first preview.

I think sometimes we forget that reasonable people can disagree, even much of time, and that no one is always right. Somethings I got wrong about Windows 8, such as the level of willingness and/or ability to pick up the new UI on traditional hardware. I still think it's not as bad as UI as you and others think on the desktop but clearly your side won. Somethings I think I got right, on the right hardware it's a very good hybrid OS and actually did help to push that category far enough that it even got Apple's interest.

Security - Now I'll be the first to state that I dislike the amount of "spying" that goes on in the background. And that they could certainly be quite a bit more upfront with it. However the base amount really isn't any different than what Windows would always do if you submitted an error report. Sure it takes a bit of knowledge to turn it all off beyond that and that is obviously difficult for some users. However at the same time there are lots of things that basic users can't do in any version of windows, so Ignorance comes at a price. Beyond that, I STILL Fully agree with windows updates being mandatory. I'm sorry but I've had to fix far too many shit boxes over the years that got that way because johnny jackass turned off their updates.

Are there privacy concerns with Windows 10? Yes. Are they any different from the countless mobile devices and online services and applications that billions each day use religiously? Even with older versions of Windows and potentially even Linux? No. I got a chuckle the other day reading the comments in an article about Microsoft's email policy when one of the posters mentioned how he was going to stick with Windows 7. I think these kinds of comments prove just how little some of the most vocal people on this issue really haven't thought it through and are just using it to bash Windows 10.

TLDR: This is what Win 8 Should have been and if it Had been would have been far better received.

Outside of the typical bubble in places like this, that has indeed been the case with Windows 10. Whatever the privacy issues are they are no where the visibility issues of Windows 8's UI. The free upgrade has been an overall positive thing. People will complain about security and the forced updates and this and that but overall Windows 10 seems to be doing what it needs to. Work well as a desktop OS and still be viable on tablets. That was thing this it HAD to do and I think there it's already succeeded. The other issues are secondary. The privacy stuff can be tweaked a bit if push comes to shove. The forced updates is a lot tougher one with an Agile process that's all about incremental improvements and updates. You pretty much break that process with skipped updates. Drivers could probably me more flexible.
 
Once again I point out, privacy concerns or not, all this telemetry data can badly effect internet speeds for those of us with marginal internet speeds to begin with (and from what I read that's not just those of us in rural areas). It also effects people with data caps. Just want a way to easily opt out of this in my situation.

Maybe, but I'm looking at my network meter, and my upload oscillates between 0 and 1KB where it's 0 for several seconds and then for a second (or less) it changes to 1KB.

if that affects anyone's speed, then they're on bad dialup. I can't speak to how it affects caps, but I had at least that much action in Windows 7 and 8.

Now it's possible that every so often they actually send more data, but none that I've seen, and I've been watching for 5 minutes now.

Note, I'm not excusing them if they're sending data that's not for bug fixing and perhaps info on how the OS is used, but I'm not convinced they are.
 
Now speaking of that, will I be updating my desktops? That I am still on the fence about. Probably not or at least not until I'm almost out of free upgrade time. The reason is that although I'm quite pleased with it overall on my Laptop, I don't really have any incentive to put it on my desktop. That runs perfect, it isn't going to benefit at this moment in any tangible way and will be quite a bit more effort since I will do a clean install. However neither will I actively discourage people away from 10 at this point. As a Mobile OS I am very pleased with it for my laptop and I imagine I will be when I eventually get a Surface. I don't see any real hurdles for it on the desktop front, other than no need to upgrade if you have 7 and it meets your existing needs.

TLDR: This is what Win 8 Should have been and if it Had been would have been far better received.

I installed it last weekend, because I built a new machine. I may put it on the old one when I rebuild it, but I may go with 7 or 8 (8 didn't bug me, but I like 10 better, so far)
 
Personally I just dislike the direction Microsoft is heading with Windows, though I'm not your common connected person. Never owned an android or ios phone, think paying for internet on a cell phone is a waste of money, don't use social media of any kind, don't use any built-in Microsoft apps, only install security updates without first checking KB for usefulness, disable unneeded first/third-party startup programs, expect my computers to be almost fully under my control with no background process using essentially 0% CPU I/O Network traffic at idle. The only type of metrics I find acceptable are those which can be disabled if I don't desire the related feature which necessitate them. I desire my desktop OS to behave closer to a barebones offline workstation than a connected consumer device with lots of fluff I'd never use.

My OS upgrade cycle is also slow and staggered in dual-boot fashion since I value long-term stability of both core OS and legacy software at home, similar to enterprise customers. Will I install Win10, sure, but it will likely be negated to a secondary OS I only boot into once or twice per year until Win7 starts nearing end-of-support in 2020 like WinXP did. Even giving away free copies of an OS isn't reason enough to instantly use it as a primary OS. I think WinXP was the last OS I actually paid for. WinVista, Win7, Win8, and now Win10 were all free licenses I received directly from Microsoft for one reason or another. Of those, so far only Win7 met the threshold of being upgraded to my primary OS, and still then that was ~3 years after I received it free and sitting on an almost never used dual-boot partition. It feels doubtful Win10 will fare any better than that, especially since WinXP->Win7 was a much more desired upgrade than Win7->Win10.

Fight the good fight guys. I'll reap the results of your efforts (or alternatively all the metrics you send MS) in a few years. ;)
 
Personally I just dislike the direction Microsoft is heading with Windows, though I'm not your common connected person.
I'll admit, that's motivates some of my thinking. I also feel that Microsoft is trying to play catch-up with Apple and Google and wants to be new/fast/feature-forward, consumer, mobile/modern beginning with Windows 8, where before they seemed more focused on stability, enterprise, and traditional PC (and before that, trying to cater to both separately). The optimist (or heatlessun) might say Windows 7 was desktop and keyboard and mouse first, Windows 8 was mobile and touch-first and Windows 10 is unified, but I'm not there yet.

People will complain about security and the forced updates and this and that but overall Windows 10 seems to be doing what it needs to. Work well as a desktop OS and still be viable on tablets. That was thing this it HAD to do and I think there it's already succeeded. The other issues are secondary. The privacy stuff can be tweaked a bit if push comes to shove. The forced updates is a lot tougher one with an Agile process that's all about incremental improvements and updates. You pretty much break that process with skipped updates. Drivers could probably me more flexible.
I think forced updates are needed to secure and homogenize the Windows ecosystem. Microsoft can't eliminate the zero day but can strive to eliminate the arguably bigger problem (at least currently, maybe not going forward), the unpatched Windows operating system (although the Linux botnet was in the news). If it were "Agile"-first (and primarily), then why would Microsoft allow the delaying or considerable postponement of non-critical and non-security updates? Appeasing enterprise is part of that answer, but Windows security-first is the clear winner here. After all, Pro is allowed to postpone, and I'm running pro as an individual who is not self-employed or contract. And forced drivers probably help homogenize Windows. I wish you could see past the almost 50 years old concept of agile software (almost 15 years since the "Agile Manifesto"). It speaks poorly of Microsoft if they're only now using it with Windows. I would suspect Longhorn/Windows Vista was the wake-up call for Microsoft on that front for Windows (if not sooner with the Bill Gates security or Trusted Computing memo).
 
While the 'heatlesssun vs. the forum 2012' thread was funny, this thread is just scary. :eek:
This has nothing to do with cats, anime, or Microsoft... just the lack of common sense and the ability to read between the lines (of code). ;)

Well, not including this post, heatlesssun has like 36 out of 125 posts in this thread. So like about 30% of this thread is just him arguing. It's kinda like 2012, but yeah it needs more cats and anime...how about both at the same time? :D

cats-anime-animal-6657215-800-600.jpg
 
It speaks poorly of Microsoft if they're only now using it with Windows. I would suspect Longhorn/Windows Vista was the wake-up call for Microsoft on that front for Windows (if not sooner with the Bill Gates security or Trusted Computing memo).

Agile certainly isn't new but it has evolved over the years. The culture of Windows does clash with Agile. How many people are complaining about the forced updates? How many people are freaking out over forced basic automated telemetry? And there are reasons to be upset about these things but you can't do Agile without forced updates and you have to have some level of automated telemetry to help drive the process.
 
Agile certainly isn't new but it has evolved over the years. The culture of Windows does clash with Agile. How many people are complaining about the forced updates? How many people are freaking out over forced basic automated telemetry? And there are reasons to be upset about these things but you can't do Agile without forced updates and you have to have some level of automated telemetry to help drive the process.
I disagree and believe you're wrong. The idea that you cannot use the agile software development methods unless x is true is anathema to the principles of agile software development. Agile software development evolves and adapts and exists on a continuum. Its principles have been taught at university for decades.

I'm surprised you feel you can speak for "the culture of Windows". When you say "the culture of Windows does clash", the implication is that the Microsoft's Windows (OS) developers clash with agile software development, which I do not believe is the case, especially given the collaboration with customers, OEMs, and partners that has always preceded and followed a Windows release. Maybe you know Microsoft, and I'm talking out of my butt though.
 
I disagree and believe you're wrong. The idea that you cannot use the agile software development methods unless x is true is anathema to the principles of agile software development.

There are most definitely principles that you have to adhere to in Agile. Continuous, incremental improvement through time boxed development cycles. How you do it is how you do it and of course there are other considerations but if you're not doing continuous, incremental improvement through time boxed development cycles then you just threw out 2 of the first 3 points of the Agile Manifesto.

1.Customer satisfaction by early and continuous delivery of useful software
2.Welcome changing requirements, even late in development
3.Working software is delivered frequently (weeks rather than months)
4.Close, daily cooperation between business people and developers
5.Projects are built around motivated individuals, who should be trusted
6.Face-to-face conversation is the best form of communication (co-location)
7.Working software is the principal measure of progress
8.Sustainable development, able to maintain a constant pace
9.Continuous attention to technical excellence and good design
10.Simplicity—the art of maximizing the amount of work not done—is essential
11.Self-organizing teams
12.Regular adaptation to changing circumstance

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agile_software_development#The_Agile_Manifesto

Agile software development evolves and adapts and exists on a continuum. Its principles have been taught at university for decades.

You are correct, the details of a specific Agile process will evolve and change but the not the principles of the manifesto. You don't evolve out of doing continuous improvement and time boxed deliverables. You don't evolve out of trust or communicating with customers. You don't evolve out of adapting to constant change. That's why they called it a manifesto and not a list of suggested practices.

I'm surprised you feel you can speak for "the culture of Windows". When you say "the culture of Windows does clash", the implication is that the Microsoft's Windows (OS) developers clash with agile software development, which I do not believe is the case, especially given the collaboration with customers, OEMs, and partners that has always preceded and followed a Windows release. Maybe you know Microsoft, and I'm talking out of my butt though.

Again, how many people hate the idea of forced updates? Resistance to this is in direct conflict with the very first principle of the Agile Manifesto.
 
I disagree and believe you're wrong. The idea that you cannot use the agile software development methods unless x is true is anathema to the principles of agile software development. Agile software development evolves and adapts and exists on a continuum. Its principles have been taught at university for decades.

I was in school in the 90s, and there was nothing about Agile or any of its core principles. My guess is that it hit schools in the early to mid aughts.
 
Gee, thanks for the Let Me Google That For You. My assertion was not that everything is Agile Software Development. My assertion was that you do not have to have forced updates across your entire user base to utilize software development. I agree, an astronaut is probably not using agile software development. My assertion is Microsoft is a software development company that has been using agile software development for some time in their products, including Windows. Is your assertion that Microsoft has only started using agile software development? Is your assertion that Microsoft has only had this ah-ha moment with Windows 10? Do you disagree with my assertion that they have been implementing it, probably since Windows Vista with Windows? I believe that's why the Windows 7 release went so smooth, quick, and was received so well. I think Windows 8 wasn't received well because they weren't responding to what customers wanted but what they thought customers needed. Same thing with Windows 10.

Besides, by your (Wikipedia's) definition, Microsoft can't use agile software development because they cannot have face-to-face, co-located meetings with the their customers "Face-to-face conversation is the best form of communication (co-location)".
 
I was in school in the 90s, and there was nothing about Agile or any of its core principles. My guess is that it hit schools in the early to mid aughts.

The principles are new, like most anything. But the codification of these principles into a cohesive development process as they are known today is about where you say, the Agile Manifesto came out in 2001.
 
Gee, thanks for the Let Me Google That For You. My assertion was not that everything is Agile Software Development. My assertion was that you do not have to have forced updates across your entire user base to utilize software development. I agree, an astronaut is probably not using agile software development. My assertion is Microsoft is a software development company that has been using agile software development for some time in their products, including Windows. Is your assertion that Microsoft has only started using agile software development?

I'm sure Microsoft has been using Agile for a while. But it certainly hasn't applied Agile to this level with Windows before. When as the last time there have been three test build of Windows, available to the general public, two months AFTER the first production build? Never I believe. That's straight out of Agile and something they hadn't done before with Windows.

Is your assertion that Microsoft has only had this ah-ha moment with Windows 10? Do you disagree with my assertion that they have been implementing it, probably since Windows Vista with Windows? I believe that's why the Windows 7 release went so smooth, quick, and was received so well. I think Windows 8 wasn't received well because they weren't responding to what customers wanted but what they thought customers needed. Same thing with Windows 10.

Windows 7 went well for reasons that had nothing to with Agile. Responding to customer feedback is something that Microsoft has always done with Windows, as much as people think otherwise. And you don't have to be doing an Agile process to respond to feedback. 7 was a response to the issues of Vista but it followed the basic long development cycle with just a few test releases as is common in waterfall. Plenty of waterfall projects work and are common today, there's nothing necessarily wrong with the process. But lack delivered function software on a frequent basis beyond internal testers and closed groups by definition isn't Agile.

Besides, by your (Wikipedia's) definition, Microsoft can't use agile software development because they cannot have face-to-face, co-located meetings with the their customers "Face-to-face conversation is the best form of communication (co-location)".

Ideally, Agile does work better with smaller, collocated teams and customer bases. But that could be said of any process. The though is feedback and there is a feedback app even in the production versions of Windows 10. That's also a new thing to Windows that's once again straight from Agile.

All I was saying is that it's very, very difficult to do a continuous improvement process like Agile if at the same time you have a large group of users who are fighting and refusing the updates. Of course there has to be the consideration for stability and predictability but that doesn't negate the issue.
 
Maybe it's just me but I think heatlessun was way more reasonable back in 2012.
 
Maybe it's just me but I think heatlessun was way more reasonable back in 2012.

Oh yes, the ever-reasonable.

2012: "The start menu is never coming back. So just shut up and let Metro happen."
2015: "Google and Facebook are spying too. So just shut up and let Spyware 10 happen."
 
I'm sure Microsoft has been using Agile for a while. But it certainly hasn't applied Agile to this level with Windows before. When as the last time there have been three test build of Windows, available to the general public, two months AFTER the first production build? Never I believe. That's straight out of Agile and something they hadn't done before with Windows.
I disagree. Microsoft was working on Windows 7 before Windows Vista went "Gold" or RTM. Builds of Windows get leaked before the release of the Betas and RCs because Microsoft works with partners outside of the company. What about WinBlue, Threshold, etc? All leaked codenames that were being worked on before the OS release, and a lot of the leaked information originating from partners.

Microsoft has a history of doing the same thing with SQL, Exchange, SharePoint, Windows Server, etc. I know companies that have run beta versions of all of this in production before RC or RTM.
 
Oh yes, the ever-reasonable.

2012: "The start menu is never coming back. So just shut up and let Metro happen."
2015: "Google and Facebook are spying too. So just shut up and let Spyware 10 happen."

The classic Start Menu isn't back. And you have no proof that Windows 10 is spying on anyone, i.e. that it's collecting personal data when the options are set to turn off the particular data.
 
I disagree. Microsoft was working on Windows 7 before Windows Vista went "Gold" or RTM. Builds of Windows get leaked before the release of the Betas and RCs because Microsoft works with partners outside of the company. What about WinBlue, Threshold, etc? All leaked codenames that were being worked on before the OS release, and a lot of the leaked information originating from partners.

Microsoft has a history of doing the same thing with SQL, Exchange, SharePoint, Windows Server, etc. I know companies that have run beta versions of all of this in production before RC or RTM.

Internal testing, limited external releases and unofficial leaks are one thing. Official builds delivered generally in weeks, not months, to anyone who wants them is a whole other matter that's simply more in line with an Agile process.
 
Internal testing, limited external releases and unofficial leaks are one thing. Official builds delivered generally in weeks, not months, to anyone who wants them is a whole other matter that's simply more in line with an Agile process.
Under that criteria, Microsoft is not using the agile process with Windows (or anything else, probably). Point to companies that are under that criteria.
 
Under that criteria, Microsoft is not using the agile process with Windows (or anything else, probably). Point to companies that are under that criteria.

I have no idea what the specifics are in the Windows development process so I have no idea if it would be considered an entirely Agile process. But continuous, incremental releases to everyone including test builds to anyone who wants them is straight out of by the book Agile and something that Microsoft hasn't done before with Windows. The forced updates are at least in part a by product of at least this tenet of Agile. How can you do constant incremental improvements with a software product that accumulate on top of one another and have people skip updates?

I'm not saying that forced updates are a panacea but without them continuous, incremental improvements would be far more difficult.
 
Imagine a representative from the chair company is standing by you at your desk, taking notes on how you use your chair. You're sitting up straight. Now your slouching. Your boss walks buy, so you sit up straight. You're at an 11.5 degree angle. Now at 7.64 degrees. Your knees are bent and your feet are under your chair. Now your knees are straight. You take off your shoes. You get up for a bathroom break. You get up for lunch. Your chair is 2.5 feet off the ground. You've been shifting more often, so when you leave, the chair representative adjusts the cushion. The representative changes the height of your seat because they think you'd enjoy it more. You can't change it back. They think your posture is bad, so they add something to make it harder to slouch. They think you'd be more comfortable with memory foam, so they replace the cushion with memory foam. You fall off your chair. The chair company wants to know all of the details surrounding the fall, but they seem more interested in making sure you can't blame the fall on then, not if you are ok or if you make have dropped something or smudged what you were writing. So that the chair company can't identify you, they have the chair rep yell across the country to Redmond, Washington to another employee who doesn't know you and don't include personally identifiable information. To further protect you, the other employee is a twin, and they speak to each other using a twin language that only they know. At least before, you could tell what they were saying. Now you don't know. Heatlesssun posts on a forum that this is all ok because all the other chair companies do the same thing, this is agile chair manufacturing, which results in only the best, most responsive chairs. Chairs can't function these days without chair agility, really. This is modern chair personalization. You just know you picked this chair because it was most comfortable. The chair company didn't used to behave this way. You want the chair company to explain itself, but it says it is committed to providing transparency and a secure and reliable chair experience. You're hoping the chair company will go back to making great chairs but you're looking to other chair companies who don't act so suspiciously. When Heatlesssun keeps going on about chair agility, you want to punch him in the face and introduce a metaphor about how you shouldn't have to concern yourself with how the sausage company makes it's sausage or what goes into sausage making. As a consumer of sausage, you just want to enjoy your sausage and know it isn't slowly poisoning you or slowly eroding the lining of your digestive tract. You want the sausage you know and love.

Creepy, huh?
 
My privacy concerns? If I turn off Bing/internet searches and Cortana, then when I press Start and type to search, I'm telling Microsoft that I only want to do a local search. Windows shouldn't be sending data to Microsoft or Bing or anyone else because I have done this search. If I have Cortana and/or Bing enabled, then an exchange is going on. I am giving Microsoft my search term in return for search results from them over the internet. If I have opted out and data still gets sent, Microsoft is just taking information.

Maybe Microsoft is just noting that the Start Menu was used to search and whether my search was successful (resulted in a click). Maybe they're gathering this information to make local only searches better in the future. The point is I didn't agree to this and sort of indicated this is the sort of thing I wanted to opt out of. And I don't really care that much that about this particular example, but now I am wondering what else they're doing and where they're doing it. I have no indication to believe if i have disabled Spotlight Suggestions on Spotlight search on a Mac that the search still sends data to Apple. I don't have any reason to think if I turn off Internet search in Unity in Ubuntu that my search still gets sent across the internet, nor that if I choose another search engine in a browser that my search will be sent to the browser's preferred search engine anyway. If I use Safari to search on iOS, I believe my search goes to Google, not Siri. I haven't seen anything to suggest Siri Now or Hey Google sends data unless I am specifically using it. This is not the case with Windows 10.

As I've said before, I have one dedicated install of Windows 10 and a dual boot installation. This doesn't make me want to avoid Windows 10. It does make me pay attention and look askance in Microsoft's general direction.
 
Creepy, huh?

What is the essence of Agile? Constant, deliverable improvement indefinitely. That's 100% by the book Agile. Think about what natural process that should remind you of if you believe in mainstream science. Of course it's creepy at some level.
 
I have no indication to believe if i have disabled Spotlight Suggestions on Spotlight search on a Mac that the search still sends data to Apple.

Because no one bothered to look perhaps? Amazing that everyone is saying that it's wrong for Microsoft to be doing "the same thing as everyone else" yet no one gave a damn what everyone was doing until Microsoft was doing it and have no idea even what it is that everyone else was doing. But they're damned sure Microsoft is doing something nefarious.

This is why these arguments are so weak. I'm not defending Microsoft. I'm saying that I've never seen people discuss this privacy issue to this degree while buying the latest iPhone or whatever mobile OS device. I've never seen a person give it a single thought while happily giving Apple or Google their life history.

You say I don't think about things logically but only practically. Here's some of both. The average consumer that's creeped out about Windows 10's privacy isn't going to build or buy a desktop Linux system, they'll get an iOS or Android device because on those platforms no one ever gave a shit about this stuff to the point that Windows is a small minority of computing devices overall even today. Logic dictates that is the average consumer were this concerned about privacy, why would they constantly buy devices that have the same or more privacy concerns as Windows 10?

Logic is a bitch.
 
When you continuously try to justify a monopoly company's decision to force CUSTOMERS to give up privacy/usage information (same umbrella) under the guise of "to make it better customized to your needs" and not be clear about their intentions and to PURPOSELY make it impossible for them to clearly and simply opt out or turn *actually* off by exclaiming its ok as "others do it" and now your new one, "but you didn't complain when Another-Company-I-Fucking-Hate-For-Datamining-Too did it...

Logic really is a bitch.

And so is brand loyalty.
 
Back
Top