Raid Questions

MichiganPC

n00b
Joined
Aug 19, 2014
Messages
47
Never set one up so I have a lot of newbie questions.

What is the easiest configuration to recover from a drive failure running Win7 or Win10? Is it Raid-1 because each drive is a copy/mirror or is it 5, 6, 10 etc.?

I have a GigaByte GA-880GA-UD3H Rev2.0 board with AMD Athlon II x2 240e CPU. The board has 6 Sata-3 6Gb/s and 2 Sata-2 3Gb/s.

Can you setup RAID and non raid drives on the same controller; the Sata-3 in this case?

Can the OS drive be on this controller or is that what the 2 Sata-2 port are for?

I assume with hardware Raid the pair of drives need to be identical. Will Raid also pool the drives assuming there are 4? And would all these drives need to be identical or just the pairs?

:confused:
 
Yes raid-1 is easy to recover if a drive dies from mechanical failure. Just pop a new drive in with the same size [brand, firmware helps but not absolute] and let the controller rebuilt/copy to the new drive.

The downfall is if you get a virus it will copy to both drives.

Not positive AMD used on that board but when I set up a UP4 APU board it's promise which might be firmware, not hardware unless there is an actual raid chip.

You can set up non-raid on the same controller but the way AMD does it 0-3 will be raid if set to that with 4-6 not in raid mode.

Intel with RST makes it much easier to set up especially post-OS and keep tabs with their program.

AMD's program is online like Marvell does.
 
I don't mean to be an asshole with this question... but why are you using RAID, if you don't even know what it is?
 
Not helpful.
I'm just trying to figure out why you want RAID, especially since you don't know what it is / understand it.
There's quite a lot of deep information on the various RAID levels online, with very detailed information on what you gain/lose with each, along with what the requirements are.

Are you looking for an increase in performance?
Are you looking for redundancy?
Both?
Do you believe RAID is equivalent to backup?

http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2370235,00.asp
 
Yes raid-1 is easy to recover if a drive dies from mechanical failure. Just pop a new drive in with the same size [brand, firmware helps but not absolute] and let the controller rebuilt/copy to the new drive.

The downfall is if you get a virus it will copy to both drives.
That's my aim, protect against single drive failure with relative ease of recovery. Hopefully the AV and additional offsite backup I can minimize the virus risk.

You can set up non-raid on the same controller but the way AMD does it 0-3 will be raid if set to that with 4-6 not in raid mode.
If I install 4 drives in a Raid-1 array am I able to pool/span/concatenate the drives for one large Raid-1 volume or do I get two separate logical drives each running Raid-1? The reason I ask is to help me decide what size and how many drives to buy ie 2 (6TB) or 4 (3TB). Trying to figure out the lowest cost approach. The OS will reside on a separate drive non-raid, I'll just image that.
 
Ask a mod to move this thread to Data Storage, you will get a lot more help there.

Generally, the only raid modes worth considering with onboard mobos are 0,1,10. Any other RAID mode and a "quality" dedicated controller is strongly advised, for safety and performance reasons.

Raid 1 is a max of 2 drives btw, so if you want 4 with an onboard mobo you'd be looking at RAID 10.
 
Originally started as a board question and kinda got off topic.

Raid 1 is a max of 2 drives btw, so if you want 4 with an onboard mobo you'd be looking at RAID 10.
I did not know that, that detail never came up in my online searches, thank-you! :)
 
AMD least the board I built allowed you to have a global hotspare set up in case one drive failed it would mark it inactive and then start copying to the spare.

What would work best for you if you don't want backup on the fly would be Intel RST rapid recovery which is raid1 but you can set it to update manually if you wish.

This way if you did get a virus the 2nd drive would not be effected and you would only lose any new files from the last time you updated it.

AMD does not offer this feature that I am aware of.
 
AMD least the board I built allowed you to have a global hotspare set up in case one drive failed it would mark it inactive and then start copying to the spare.

What would work best for you if you don't want backup on the fly would be Intel RST rapid recovery which is raid1 but you can set it to update manually if you wish.

This way if you did get a virus the 2nd drive would not be effected and you would only lose any new files from the last time you updated it.

AMD does not offer this feature that I am aware of.
Unfortunately the PC already exists so I'll stick with the AMD/GigaByte combo for the near future.

I have shelved so many working PCs over the years. I'd hate this to be another one. So if I can upgrade one more time and get 2-5 more years out of it I'd be good with that.
 
Do you have any docs about what raid system that board uses? Should be able to round up a pdf or if you still have the manual.

AMD SB850 provides 6 native SATA3 storage interfaces with superfast 6Gbps link speed and RAID 0, 1, 5, 10 support

What size do you need for your C drive?

If you only need 1TB you can pick up 4 WD RE drives and do 10.
 
AMD SB850 provides 6 native SATA3 storage interfaces with superfast 6Gbps link speed and RAID 0, 1, 5, 10 support
Yes it is the SB850 controller. I'm going Raid-1 2x3TB, The OS (Win7 64bit) will reside on a 500MB drive. I just hope I can run the OS off one of the non raid Sata-3 ports.
 
ACHI is included in raid so you should have no issues having your C drive on port 0 and
having your raid set on ports 2/3 for example.
My board states to set up raid 0-3 set onchip sata to raid, for 4-7 set onchip sata to raid and set it as sata type.

Moot point but intel is much easier to set up plus you can have two sets of raid.

I have my C drive in raid1 and my huge media drives in raid1 as well for two sets.
 
Also, just a hint. I know this isn't exactly what you are asking, but just some extra info. Last I checked (this is Bulldozer) AMD's RAID controller sucked ass, so go for Intel, and if you are using intel, make sure to plug it inn to the Intel controller, and not the shitty Marvel controller. Mobo manual will explain more.

But yeah, Raid is awesome, RAID 0, 1 , and 1+0 all have their benefits, depending on what you are doing.
 
AMD's RAID controller sucked ass,
Yea! found out the hard way. :(

However I'm presently up and running with my Raid-1 setup. :) I still have some concerns though.

I placed this post in the motherboard forum because I feel my struggles have to do with the GigaByte board and implementation of AMD's SB850 controller.

No matter what I tried I could not get the OS (Win7-64) to see the raid drives even though Device Manager and Drive Manager saw them. The fix was to load the old AMD RaidXpert 32-bit utility. Even though the raid was setup already via the raid BIOS I had to repeat the setup under RaidXpert only then would the OS see the raid-1 array.

I'm concerned about the reliably of the 32-bit utility. Is there a 64-bit version or alternative utility from GigaByte?
 
Raid 1 is a max of 2 drives btw,

Sorry, but this is incorrect information.

You can, ostensibly, RAID1 as many drives as your controller can handle.
It just doesn't really get you any tangible benefits.

Also, RAID1 still has the problem of having no recovery mode if, while restoring the second disk, you blow up the first one (which happens more frequently than one might think, as mirroring the data to the second drive can be taxing on the primary).
 
I'm concerned about the reliably of the 32-bit utility.

To my knowledge, AMD has only ever provided a 32 bit utility. The behavior you're describing sounds about par, as AMD's RAID implementation works a bit differently than most. Like most raid controllers, without the correct raid driver, you will be unable to access the volume, which was resolved when you installed the utility. However, most controllers won't let you see the independent drives in the OS once they've been configured for RAID, but AMD does. This can lead to a bit of confusion, but it sounds like you're heading down the right path.

Unfortunately, AMD's RAID solution is not very well supported. As an alternative option to help simplify things, have you considered just setting up a software mirror in disk management, and forgo AMD's RAID altogether? It also doesn't offer many features, but cuts out the middleman, and has the added bonus of being hardware independent (if you motherboard fails, you can easily plug the drives into any other Windows computer and recover your files)
 
As an alternative option to help simplify things, have you considered just setting up a software mirror in disk management, and forgo AMD's RAID altogether? It also doesn't offer many features, but cuts out the middleman, and has the added bonus of being hardware independent (if you motherboard fails, you can easily plug the drives into any other Windows computer and recover your files)
I contemplated that or Win8 Storage Spaces. I was concerned my Athlon II 240e wouldn't be up to the task. I'm trying to keep cost down by re-purposing existing equipment.
 
AMD and Marvell do not allow pass through like Intel thus programs like crystaldiskinfo cannot see the drives which sucks if you like to keep tabs.

You have to go through their browser based program raidxpert which I want to say will show you raw which is not very helpful.
 
Back
Top