A laptop amplifier now?Seriously!

murkris118

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 5, 2012
Messages
467
Given the performance of the latest GTX 970M and 980M Maxwell cards, is Alienware totally nuts in bringing out an amplifier designed for laptops?. I mean the 980M is nearly the performance of a desktop 780/780Ti or a 980, only 10-15% slower. Given Maxwell is a beast overclocker because of its tiny power envelope I can only assume that future nvidia architectures are gonna decrease the gap between desktop and mobile parts even further. What is the point of an amp if u get the same performance on your notebook?. Any thoughts?

http://www.anandtech.com/show/8653/alienware-graphics-amplifier
 
well it would be nice to around a light laptop with nothing but integrated graphics, and then go home and plug in the external graphics card for gaming.

that psu should be way smaller though.
 
If my (or any) 13" laptop even remotely approached the performance of my desktop, I'd buy it. However, the reality is, there isn't.

Especially not one that is realistically portable.
 
That amp is completely wasted on the AW13 with the absolutely worthless i5-4210U CPU. That POS will bottleneck any high end desktop card like crazy.

On a side note, 980M while offering much better performance over the 780M and broken 880M, still only manages to be about 81% of a desktop 970 on average.
 
Tis be wise to get the better cpu and skimp on the video card if purchasing this. CPU is going to be the biggest factor. No upgrade for the cpu on the 13" though.
 
If my (or any) 13" laptop even remotely approached the performance of my desktop, I'd buy it. However, the reality is, there isn't.

Especially not one that is realistically portable.

I guess but how many pixels can you ideally pack on a 13" screen?. If the answer is 4k you would not notice any difference between a 1080p and a 4k screen of that size. If you are going to power a 13" laptop with an amp that has a 980 in it I dont see the point. a 15.6" screen however makes sense although at that size you get better laptops with a 980M in it.

http://www.geforce.com/whats-new/articles/geforce-gtx-900m-laptops-available-now

I am pretty sure Razer or some other manufacturer will release a 13" portable model soon given the power requirements of the 980M and Maxwell in general.
 
I'm also of the opinion that the base specs of the 13 don't lend well to this design. Drop the discrete gpu to a lower end model (or remove it altogether) and bump up the cpu to a quad core. Then you have some very basic portable gaming ability, and a powerhouse when combined with the amp.

Still glad to see an effort is being made to provide gpu upgrade options for the mobile market. If I didn't already have plans to makea SFF, something of this design would work well for my office machine (capable of gaming when docked at work or at lan parties, but sufficiently powerful to run basic CAD operations when on the go or at a makerspace).
 
Depending on a combination of visual acuity, device usage (eg. viewing distance), and content you can notice from ~170ppi to a ~331ppi change.

Despite the 970/980s efficiency their TDP is still quite high if you look at it from a mobile perspective, keep in mind efficiency gains also went to leverage more performance (Maxwell mobile parts have a higher performance delta over last gen Kepler parts compared to the desktop). Also keep in mind in this case they are competing in terms of efficiency also against a Maxwell part (GTX 860m). A chassis and cooling solution designed around a GTX 860m is not going to accommodate a 970m/980m as is. Nvidia doesn't release official TDP numbers for mobile parts but you are likely looking at least a 2x increase in TDP and power system demands.

So far there has not been any 13 inch laptop with a discrete GPU in the higher power categories. Clevo's 13 inch also only used a GTX 765m (last generation) and 860m (this generation).

The interesting thing with mobile pricing is that the total cost of a laptop (with a a weaker GPU, eg. 860m) + amplifier + a GTX 970 could actually still be cheaper than simply buying one with a GTX 980m as well as providing better upgrade ability. You'd also still get pros/cons of each each setup to consider as well.
 
if it was more universal rather than proprietary connector for the one laptop it will ever work on then yes i could see this being useful as long as the gpu onboard and the gpu you stick in the box could work together or let the beefy desktop card do the work and send it back to be displayed by the onboard gpu.

I predict this will sell like mud to a mud farmer.
 
Meh, a company finally is trying external card enclosures, but proprietary, single card only + maybe to late. I know I've gotten quite used to streaming games on Steam from my main rig to my laptops if I want more eye candy than they can give natively.

Will see how long Dell will support this.
 
I don't know why I'd personally buy it. If I traveled a lot I'd probably build a tiny ITX system and throw it in my luggage with a decent sized monitor. I can't imagine gaming on a laptop screen again. That was horrid, better than nothing, but horrid.

My work laptop has a quadro card... That covers everything work related.
 
I don't know why I'd personally buy it. If I traveled a lot I'd probably build a tiny ITX system and throw it in my luggage with a decent sized monitor. I can't imagine gaming on a laptop screen again. That was horrid, better than nothing, but horrid.

My work laptop has a quadro card... That covers everything work related.
exactly why this thing wont work why carry 2 boxes when you only need 1.

This is a nice idea but it will work out about as well as replaceable discrete gpu in laptops... I do look forward to seeing this thing show up on ebay in a year after they discontinue it...
 
Been keeping an eye out for the Alienware releases from Monday and I am sad to see the direction Dell is taking them. While everyone else is releasing refreshed model laptops Alienware decides to release the 13 with a gimped CPU and last gen GPU. I have an Alienware 17 and love it but its probably going to be my last laptop from them as they totally do not get it anymore.
 
I find this pretty interesting too. a few weeks ago i picked up a lenovo Y50 (haswell i7 + 860M) Performance wise its all i "need" even though the laptop is razor thin, its quite hefty. I almost think a 13" one that uses just intel graphics and this amp is a better solution. Super portable, super powerful.
 
That's a cool looking case, wonder if you could squeeze a mobo in there.
 
Do you guys seriously not realize how much of a bottleneck that useless i5-4210U chip is going to create with high end desktop cards?

Comparing CineBench R15 scores, it's about as good as a Pentium G3420.

That's right, it doesn't even measure up to an i3, but a fucking Pentium.
 
People aren't excited about the laptop, they are excited about the premise of a modular video card system.
 
eGPUs are nothing new, ViDock has been around since at least 2009. There's an entire forum on DIYing your own eGPU.

Granted, this graphics amplifier presents a readily available commercial solution. But right now it is proprietary and only available for the AW13. We don't even know if Dell has plans to make future Alienware laptops compatible with the GA, let alone make a generic version that'll benefit all laptops.
 
Last edited:
For a commercial system that's a pretty shitty design, e.g. they couldn't even hook up an SFX PSU? Hoping this is just the first and later revisions will be more palatable as I'd very much like to have a nice lightweight laptop that I could hook up to a GPU/storage/large monitor at home.
 
Do you guys seriously not realize how much of a bottleneck that useless i5-4210U chip is going to create with high end desktop cards?

Comparing CineBench R15 scores, it's about as good as a Pentium G3420.

That's right, it doesn't even measure up to an i3, but a fucking Pentium.

You do realize the alienware 13 is just the flagship model for this device, right?

There will be more laptops with this connector on it from Alienware.
 
Already addressed that. Yes Dell mentioned they have "plans", but until we see new Alienware laptops equipped with this GA connector, all we have right now is the AW13, and pairing it up with the GA is a waste of money.
 
Will definitely it this thing if it ever work on none Alienware laptop.

I will most likely get a Apple's trashcan (Mac Pro) and hook this one up to it...
 
Back
Top