Windows 9 Will Offer Desktop Or Start Screen

Negative feedback can be measured objectively, and I don't know of any other modern OS that has created this much of a public relations disaster for the developer. ME had it's problems and there was a lot of dumb FUD going around about Vista, but they didn't lead to a corporate re-org and big hardware losses like 8/Surface did.

The fact that the Windows platform has a lot of inertia doesn't invalidate the criticisms of 8. Between the low-cost licenses, pre-installed OEM machines, and the fact that most of us would like to keep using one primary OS on the desktop it would obviously be very difficult for something else to unseat Windows after one bad release.

Indeed the "good release/bad release" legend of Windows. I've never said that the market share of Windows invalidated all of the criticisms of Windows 8.x. I've essentially agreed with those critics while being criticized. Windows 8 is too unfamiliar to too many of today's current Windows users. Windows 8 doesn't offer enough to today's Windows 7 users to migrate. Two years after the release of Windows 8, these are simple facts that really can't be disputed. Windows 8.x can even be considered a failure.

Much of the issue I've had with many around here is that I'm a very reasonable person. I don't think at any point that I ever said Windows 8 was awesome or would overtake Windows 7 in market share. All I've ever said about Windows 8.x is that if one actually learns to use it, it's far from the nonsense that's said online. I've never said to anyone that was happy with Windows 7 on a desktop to move to Windows 8. Not once. Not ever. I've never said to anyone that was happy with any other desktop OS to move to Windows 8. Not once. Not ever.

So much has been said about Windows 8 out of emotion that listening to customers isn't enough. While many, if not most, want Microsoft to just stay pat with a desktop OS that considers nothing about how many use computers today, Microsoft doesn't have the luxury of just accommodating today's users. It's a reality that just is and that's often how life works.
 
The saddest part is...for what? It bombed on tablets too, so it was all just a giant shot in the foot.

And the Metro Store aka Windows Store on both Windows8 and Windows Phone is loaded to the rafters with crapware and scam apps because Microsoft in their desperation to press release an ever greater number of total apps have just rubberstamped everything that gets submitted.
 
So much has been said about Windows 8 out of emotion that listening to customers isn't enough. While many, if not most, want Microsoft to just stay pat with a desktop OS that considers nothing about how many use computers today, Microsoft doesn't have the luxury of just accommodating today's users. It's a reality that just is and that's often how life works.

This is where you are also quilty. And the users that voice concerns are automatically assumed to be "Dumb coz they didnt learn it". You patriots of "Whatever is new is always better" are the worst offenders! This is what you lot won't get in your fat heads. And it makes us (the consumers that you really DO want to listen to), start making hot comments simply to try and get a look in because we get shot down with voicing out dislike and so we play the same game.

If people were to actually have a discussion about this instead of reading typed out text... you'd see the over assumed emotion you speak of doesn't really exist until you mob completely ignore what we are telling you.

And i'm a seasoned technical user. Not a complete smart einstien programmer type. Just a generally.. technically minded guy that can be considered to actually know his $hit. Like many on here are. Yet you just assume we are to "not learned" enough.

The same thing happened with this ridiculous Ribbon UI! Anyone worth their salt knows its no more efficient. peple that aren't over the moon with 8.x are not saying MS have to stay put, that they'd shouldn't advance or try new things. But they aren't doing this. They leave out BLINDINGLY OBVIOUS usability features or functionality... hell.. they even REMOVE said functionality when it was already there! These things really irk me as a user that wants to get shit done.. not just fluff around on a computer to waste time on FecesBook. And when i do want to spend some relaxing time on a computer.. i don't want to be forced to do things in a more difficult manner just because some CEO want's to chamge something for the sake of changing it... all while leaving out core usability features that have been lacking for over a decade (here is another gem... how long was it before we got a button to create a damn Folder in Windows Explorer?!?!?!!?!??!).
 
Every time I see Windows 8 I think of this....



They are gonna have to move mountains to get me to switch from W7.

Every time I see Windows 8, I think this:

idiocracy3.jpg
 
In all these OS bitch fests I often wonder: What do you guys actually do with your PCs?

As I've expressed in the past. I still don't see the practicality of a Start menu. Whatever floats people's boat though. My advice: Don't ever use something you are not comfortable with. If you need to click on that start menu to open up Chrome or My Documents I completely understand. :)
 
Whether or not anyone cares isn't the point. Most of this stuff over blown. You're saying that Windows 8 is a commercial failure? Compared to what? Linux? OS X? Chrome OS? Did Microsoft lose money on Windows 8? Something is inherently unproductive because someone didn't take five minutes to read up on something? And who is to say that the way that someone is using Windows 7 for that matter is inherently productive? Doing the same thing the same way forever is a sign that you might not be productive as you think.

Was Win8 a commercial failure?

Considering that it took 10 MONTHS to surpass VISTA?
Considering that OEMs stopped offering Windows 7 for the Win8 Blitz, then, when people began returning machines in droves, began offering Windows 7 again?

I'd say that's a "yeah".

Did Microsoft lose money on Win8?

Dunno. Not sure how their accounting department spun this. Traditionally, their OS division has been a loss leader, regardless of OS.

Compared to what?

Previous versions of the Windows OS?

The OS release is a failure because they failed to capture the business market.

Why? Retraining costs. You can pooh pooh it all you want. Getting users up to speed on Win8 requires retraining. Training, in any business, is an expense. And Microsoft sure as hell wasn't paying for it. They were just trying to pass that little gem along to their clients.

The fact is, the Metro UI, after how many decades of Start Button/Start Menu UI, is just NOT intuitive. The fact that they go to great lengths to hide (and worse, obfuscate) functionality (something that began back in 2007 with the idiots Office UI crew) just makes it even worse. Now, instead of nice, straightforward, well documented and organized menu systems, we have a bunch of obscure buttons and hidden screens that you need to jump through. Why the hell should anyone have to spelunk their system to this level for something that should be accomplished in a couple mouse clicks?

But please, keep backing your "horse".
 
In all these OS bitch fests I often wonder: What do you guys actually do with your PCs?

Remote management and support of ~7000 sites (not websites, physical locales) around the world.
 
In all these OS bitch fests I often wonder: What do you guys actually do with your PCs?

As I've expressed in the past. I still don't see the practicality of a Start menu. Whatever floats people's boat though. My advice: Don't ever use something you are not comfortable with. If you need to click on that start menu to open up Chrome or My Documents I completely understand. :)

I actually have to agree about that last part with some employee's I deal with. :)

If the icons aren't on their desktop and on the right part of the screen where it normally is they are lost. At least the start menu lets me direct them to where it is in all programs until i get around to seeing what the messed up...

And I'm not even kidding...:(
 
I actually have to agree about that last part with some employee's I deal with. :)

If the icons aren't on their desktop and on the right part of the screen where it normally is they are lost. At least the start menu lets me direct them to where it is in all programs until i get around to seeing what the messed up...

And I'm not even kidding...:(

I agree. The majority of my user base is fairly "with it" and could probably take something like Win8 in stride (they just don't want to). But there's a significant portion of my user base (usually older people who were in the workforce long before computers on every desk was mainstream) that's drops into a coma the second the least little thing changes in their setup. New systems (even of the same OS) cause an outbreak of the raging dumbass.

Most of the latter I wouldn't put on Windows 8 on a dare. I'd be on the phone with them 24x7x365.
 
To the third party thing:

I run windows 8.1, made a local account (not hard to do at all) and simply avoid the fullscreen apps, which isn't hard to do at all. My customised metro is much faster than a start menu could ever be. No need for a start8 or whatever.

This forum is full of crybabies who will seemingly complain at any and all.
 
Was Win8 a commercial failure?

Considering that it took 10 MONTHS to surpass VISTA?
Considering that OEMs stopped offering Windows 7 for the Win8 Blitz, then, when people began returning machines in droves, began offering Windows 7 again?

I'd say that's a "yeah".

Did Microsoft lose money on Win8?

Dunno. Not sure how their accounting department spun this. Traditionally, their OS division has been a loss leader, regardless of OS.

Compared to what?

Previous versions of the Windows OS?

So in other words, you really have no idea about the commercial success or failure of Windows 8. I'm perfectly fine with people calling Windows 8 a failure. However as with all things Windows 8, calling it a commercial failure is just more unprovable negative hype.

The OS release is a failure because they failed to capture the business market.

Why? Retraining costs. You can pooh pooh it all you want. Getting users up to speed on Win8 requires retraining. Training, in any business, is an expense. And Microsoft sure as hell wasn't paying for it. They were just trying to pass that little gem along to their clients.

The fact is, the Metro UI, after how many decades of Start Button/Start Menu UI, is just NOT intuitive. The fact that they go to great lengths to hide (and worse, obfuscate) functionality (something that began back in 2007 with the idiots Office UI crew) just makes it even worse. Now, instead of nice, straightforward, well documented and organized menu systems, we have a bunch of obscure buttons and hidden screens that you need to jump through. Why the hell should anyone have to spelunk their system to this level for something that should be accomplished in a couple mouse clicks?

But please, keep backing your "horse".

A bunch of obscure buttons? There are only five buttons on the Charms Bar. Yes, that's hidden but so are other things in Windows. Context menus and aero snap for instance. There are just some things that simply don't expose themselves readily, you just have to know that they are there.

But I agree, any UI change in something like Windows NO MATTER WHAT IT IS, can be disruptive and certainly the modern UI as implemented in 8.x was very disruptive for far too many keyboard and mouse users. I am just saying that it can be learned without too much hassle, particularly 8.1 Update, and that desktop productivity wouldn't be significantly different between that user and a someone familiar with 7.
 
To the third party thing:

I run windows 8.1, made a local account (not hard to do at all) and simply avoid the fullscreen apps, which isn't hard to do at all. My customised metro is much faster than a start menu could ever be. No need for a start8 or whatever.

This forum is full of crybabies who will seemingly complain at any and all.

LOL...your comparing a start menu vs a desktop with icons. Windows 7 or 8 desktop mode has icons that are just as customizable as Metro, if not more. Yes if you have desktop icons or whatever the hell they call them on the Metro screen programs will be faster to open than using a menu system....good going mr obvious.
 
So in other words, you really have no idea about the commercial success or failure of Windows 8. I'm perfectly fine with people calling Windows 8 a failure. However as with all things Windows 8, calling it a commercial failure is just more unprovable negative hype.

I think we do. It's not going to gain any significant market share before the release of 9. True, the accounting spin doctors will do their best to bury the costs, and they probably will. But, profit this quarter, I believe, has much more to do with the 18,000 salaries they snipped and not from the wonderful adoption of 8. BTW, I am not an 8 hater. I think they got a lot of it right. But, they executed it on the order of A Nightmare on Elm Street. And, I'm done with this thread.
 
The fact that they go to great lengths to hide (and worse, obfuscate) functionality (something that began back in 2007 with the idiots Office UI crew) just makes it even worse.
You got that backwards. Office 2000, Office XP, and Office 2003 were the ones that began the trend of hiding functionality.

Office 2000 was the first version to have "personalized menus" that hide functionality of the main window menus (file, edit, view, etc) behind an additional "show all" arrow. This was done because the menus were simply too large for some screens AND it overwhelmed normal users with piles of power-user options that they'd never touch.

The ribbon was designed to SOLVE this problem. It's like a drop-down menu on steroids, that uses the entire width of your monitor to display loads of options to you (divided up by category). Switching from vertical list-menus to a horizontal menu-bar was designed to take advantage of the fact that monitors offer more resolution in the horizontal dimension, giving them room to show even MORE stuff without having to hide anything.
 
Charms bar, ugh, what the hell were they thinking with that name?! That alone would be a reason to avoid the OS :)
 
The ribbon was designed to SOLVE this problem. It's like a drop-down menu on steroids, that uses the entire width of your monitor to display loads of options to you (divided up by category). Switching from vertical list-menus to a horizontal menu-bar was designed to take advantage of the fact that monitors offer more resolution in the horizontal dimension, giving them room to show even MORE stuff without having to hide anything.

As much as Microsoft gets the rap of not listening to customers, the ribbon was developed indirectly as response to listening to customers. Microsoft began to notice that the vast majority of customer request for Office features were for functions already in the product. The ribbon was designed to help increase function discoverability
 
I love ya Heat. The Windows White Knight in shining armor to save the day. :)

Microsoft would've avoided so much hassle for everyone if they'd just let people turn off metro from the get go. Options are not horrible things. I just don't see how anyone can defend what they did, pushing a touch screen UI on people for everything. A hybrid OS that favors one UI over the other is not hybrid.
At least 8.1 made some things better but I still see the start screen as a big desktop that isn't really all that faster than the start menu when it comes to launching programs.

I was upgrading an 8.0 laptop to 8.1 last weekend. Its still a fight to move around in win8 for me. So many things buried underneath charms bars and hot corners. Full screen search apps and browsers, ugh. All the more aggravating when you see that under the hood they've improved things nicely.
 
Microsoft would've avoided so much hassle for everyone if they'd just let people turn off metro from the get go. Options are not horrible things. I just don't see how anyone can defend what they did, pushing a touch screen UI on people for everything. A hybrid OS that favors one UI over the other is not hybrid.

I've never said that options are a bad thing. I just think that much of what has been said about 8.x, particularly 8.1, of it's ability, or lack thereof, on the desktop is overblown. I understand that a lot of people don't like the 8.x UI on a desktop and it certainly could have been better implemented and those issues need to be addressed. Even if I think the issues are being overblown, that matter of the fact is that there's simply too much resistance to the UI.

At least 8.1 made some things better but I still see the start screen as a big desktop that isn't really all that faster than the start menu when it comes to launching programs.

The Start Screen is more than an app launcher. Of course a lot of people don't use modern apps and don't see anything that live tiles have to offer.

I was upgrading an 8.0 laptop to 8.1 last weekend. Its still a fight to move around in win8 for me. So many things buried underneath charms bars and hot corners. Full screen search apps and browsers, ugh. All the more aggravating when you see that under the hood they've improved things nicely.

If you don't want a full screen browser then don't use it. The Charms search is full screen by default, however is can be snapped to the side,
 
As much as Microsoft gets the rap of not listening to customers, the ribbon was developed indirectly as response to listening to customers. Microsoft began to notice that the vast majority of customer request for Office features were for functions already in the product. The ribbon was designed to help increase function discoverability

The ribbons obscured function discovery, Your statement is dead wrong. A hierarchical menu structure that lays out all the options available at a given level at once is what promotes it.

Ribbons were done from with the customer in mind from a condescending perspective. From Microsoft's own viewpoint and the viewpoint of IT service personnel that hold end users in contempt for the dumb and repetitive questions they get from the bottom 10%. It views IT departments as their customers and empathizes with them. The ribbons put simple tasks in the fore in glyphs and moved more advanced tasks out of the way where the muppets couldn't hurt themselves. The options menu is a freaking nightmare now as well.
 
The ribbons obscured function discovery, Your statement is dead wrong. A hierarchical menu structure that lays out all the options available at a given level at once is what promotes it.

It has nothing to do with me being right or wrong. I'm just stating Microsoft's rationale behind the ribbon and how it came to be. Clearly they saw a problem when the bulk of the requests they were getting for new Office features were already there.

The ribbons put simple tasks in the fore in glyphs and moved more advanced tasks out of the way where the muppets couldn't hurt themselves. The options menu is a freaking nightmare now as well.

It flattened options and combines menu selection and dialog interaction into a more streamlined UI. Not really sure how more advanced functions were moved out of the way as all functions are accessible in the ribbon just like the old hierarchical menus.
 
I don't understand how, in this quest for usability, they haven't managed to do something as common as page numbering more user friendly. It should have been a one dialog, few clicks action, not a mess it is to this day.

Or the transition from 2007 to 2010 flattened look. My god, what a step back that is. Instead of clearly visible buttons and selections, they've made a uniform flat panel. They made the same move with Win8 and we see how that turned out.
 
The ribbons obscured function discovery, Your statement is dead wrong. A hierarchical menu structure that lays out all the options available at a given level at once is what promotes it.
Except Office didn't have a hierarchical menu structure that lays out all the options availabl

Like I mentioned above, starting with Office 2000, Microsoft began intentionally HIDING options from the main window menus in order to keep user's heads from exploding (and to avoid running out of screen to display the entire menu).

Office 2007 started to undo this horrible trend by exposing more options, and automatically exposing options based on current context.

The ribbons put simple tasks in the fore in glyphs and moved more advanced tasks out of the way where the muppets couldn't hurt themselves
You realize you have this 100% backwards, right?

That's what the personalized menus in Office 2000, Office XP, and Office 2003 did... they hid advanced options from the list menus automatically.

Rose-tinted glasses. Seriously...
 
LOL...your comparing a start menu vs a desktop with icons. Windows 7 or 8 desktop mode has icons that are just as customizable as Metro, if not more. Yes if you have desktop icons or whatever the hell they call them on the Metro screen programs will be faster to open than using a menu system....good going mr obvious.

Sure, if you want your desktop to look like an ugly piece of ass filled with icons.

I however, prefer minimalism and clean looks. Makes for more faster going later on.
 
I don't understand how, in this quest for usability, they haven't managed to do something as common as page numbering more user friendly. It should have been a one dialog, few clicks action, not a mess it is to this day.

Maybe you're thinking of something else, I don't know how much simpler page numbering gets. This is how it's worked from the Insert tab in Word since the 2007 version:

Word%20Page%20Numbering.png
 
Maybe you're thinking of something else, I don't know how much simpler page numbering gets. This is how it's worked from the Insert tab in Word since the 2007 version:

Yeah, it's a bit more complicated when you have a couple of pages first, then index and then page no.1.
 
Yeah, it's a bit more complicated when you have a couple of pages first, then index and then page no.1.

You have to insert a section break and then start numbering from there. Perhaps this is easier to do with other office suites, I don't know. Extra steps but not really complicated.
 
Back
Top