Windows 9 Will Offer Desktop Or Start Screen

Is it an improvement? No, categorically, the modern UI is not an improvement for desktop productivity. When you fuck with something that's been more or less the same for the past two decades, it better damn well be an improvement. It better be a fucking major improvement, not just look pretty and work well on tablets.

The point was being made that anyone would be more productive using 7 with a keyboard and mouse than 8.1. That's not true.

Not only did you admit that productivity remains unchanged from 7. Not only did you have to omit Windows 8.0 as the failure that is. You had to qualify your statement by saying "a person comfortable with the 8.1 UI".

Much of 8.1 was about addressing issues with 8.0 and I personally haven't used 8.0 since the day 8.1 was publically available and updated the rest of machines not already on 8.1 at the time. And since then I'm moved on to 8.1 Update which bought a few more keyboard and mouse improvements over 8.1. Not much new is coming with 8.0 anymore, it's almost a year from being the mainstream version.
 
Every time I see Windows 8 I think of this....



They are gonna have to move mountains to get me to switch from W7.
 
What was wrong, exactly?

If you're managing Server 2012 R2, you're using RSAT (or you're making WAY more work for yourself than need be).

Get a clue :rolleyes:

LOL...the few 2012 R2 servers we have right now do not justify even buying 1 Windows 8 license for the amount of times we actually need to login. I guess we'll have to suffer with antiquated RDP sessions.
 
When people go one about not being able to find the Control Panel or only one modern app per screen or still complaining about issues that were resolved from 8.0 to 8.1, it's hard to see where they invested a lot of time.

This is still nothing but a complete assumption. You still have no clue as to how much time had been invested by anyone other than by first hand observation.

But you have to learn to swim first to become familiar with it.

That's fine, except MS changed the water into something people didn't know how to swim in.
 
"COUGH***MORE***BULLSHIT***RDP***IS***SO***LAST***YEAR***COUGH"! :rolleyes:
RDP hasn't been needed for most administrative tasks for a long time (Server 2012 isn't the first version to have RSAT tools and remote management, after all).

A good portion of our servers are Server Core installs (because there's literally no point in them having a GUI in the first place). I think our only servers running the full desktop are our terminal servers and a utility server that runs some software that refuses to work without desktop components installed.
 
Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days

Just admit it. You're wrong. Or you can keep rolling your eyes and deflecting.

To say that 8.1 is a requirement is hysterical. Nobody in the corporate IT world has transferred over, nor will they.
 
Just admit it. You're wrong. Or you can keep rolling your eyes and deflecting.
Wrong about what, exactly?

What I said was true, the easiest way to manage a Server 2012 box is RSAT, and the RSAT tools for 2012 R2 require Windows 8.1

Not sure what you're disagreeing with.

To say that 8.1 is a requirement is hysterical.
It IS a requirement, the tools I'm talking about REQUIRE it. They WILL NOT install on Windows 7.

Doesn't get any more required than that.
 
RDP hasn't been needed for most administrative tasks for a long time (Server 2012 isn't the first version to have RSAT tools and remote management, after all).

A good portion of our servers are Server Core installs (because there's literally no point in them having a GUI in the first place). I think our only servers running the full desktop are our terminal servers and a utility server that runs some software that refuses to work without desktop components installed.

I find RDP more useful than picking a specific task for RSAT tools if I have more than one action to perform. For the love of god its the same difference, its just a different way to get to the server(s). The software is not a holy grail...
 
Wow, what a surprise! Unknown-One's comments being misconstrued on [H]ardForum.
 
Not sure what you're disagreeing with.


It IS a requirement, the tools I'm talking about REQUIRE it. They WILL NOT install on Windows 7.

Here I'll post it for you again, for the fourth time:

And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days, as it's needed to run the Remote Server Administration Tools for Windows Server 2012 (R2).

Mhmm. You aren't saying that windows 8.1 is a requirement for you and your work. You're saying that it's "pretty much a requirement these days for anyone who works in IT managing servers all day". Either you're dead wrong, or your English is atrocious and misleading, or you're going to backpedal and claim that you were only talking about yourself and your personal work (which is patently false and you know it).
 
This is still nothing but a complete assumption. You still have no clue as to how much time had been invested by anyone other than by first hand observation.

How can one have invested much time in something and not have the most basic knowledge about it? I can't believe that someone complaining about not being able to find the Control Panel in 8.x spent any time with it.

That's fine, except MS changed the water into something people didn't know how to swim in.

Or some people are better swimmers than others. And those learning to swim at an earlier age pick it up easier. I'm not at all discounting the severity of the lack of familiarity that the Windows 8.x UI cause a lot of people. But that's not the same thing as the UI being inherently unproductive.
 
That's not what he said. He specifically mentioned Windows 2012 remote admin tools.

Its funny but I logged into 2 Server 2012 R2 cluster hosts today via rdp (Windows 7 oh no!) and it didn't seem like I needed Windows 8 or I that I was wasting my time....of course what do I know, I'm just a noob! :rolleyes:
 
Its funny but I logged into 2 Server 2012 R2 cluster hosts today via rdp (Windows 7 oh no!) and it didn't seem like I needed Windows 8 or I that I was wasting my time....of course what do I know, I'm just a noob! :rolleyes:

PS: And I realize you need Windows 8 for the admin tools to work on 2012 R2...just making another point.
 
That's not what he said. He specifically mentioned Windows 2012 remote admin tools.

No, he spoke from a position of fabricated authority and told us that Windows 8.1 is necessary for IT server admins.

"And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days."

How the hell else is someone supposed to take that? Oh, he just meant Windows 8.1 is a requirement for his own work with Server 2012 R2? Give me a break.
 
PS: And I realize you need Windows 8 for the admin tools to work on 2012 R2...just making another point.

This is what he said. and you're saying that is correct. So why is a mountain turning into a mole hill over something that is factually correct?:confused:
 
This is what he said. and you're saying that is correct. So why is a mountain turning into a mole hill over something that is factually correct?:confused:

I never stated he was wrong, what I disagreed with (calling bullshit) him stating that you pretty much need RSAT tools to administrate 2012 R2 and if still you use RDP then your a noob....I called bullshit on that particular point.
 
This is what he said. and you're saying that is correct. So why is a mountain turning into a mole hill over something that is factually correct?:confused:

When someone attempts to speak from a position of authority, and then provides misleading information, that's a problem. It's deceitful and it's damaging to anyone who doesn't have the knowledge to see through the bullshit.

And I say this as an anti-malware researcher: antivirus software is pretty much unnecessary these days, we don't need it on our intranet.
 
I'm not at all discounting the severity of the lack of familiarity that the Windows 8.x UI cause a lot of people. But that's not the same thing as the UI being inherently unproductive.

Totally disagree. If the masses you sell to are inherently unfamiliar with what you sell then it absolutely is inherently unproductive.

You really can go on and on about it. But, ultimately it doesn't matter. It's like pointing out the good points in Vista. Nobody cares. It was a commercial failure. It gained no traction. 8 is going to be the same. It won't gain any traction and you'll have all these super awesome posts that nobody cares about because they'll all be looking towards 9. At this point, even MS is.
 
I guess I was more easily swayed toward 8 because I got it for free from my University, or more precisely, i paid for it in my tuition. After getting 8, I adapted to it very quickly, and now I enjoy 8 more than ever. I could not see myself going back to 7. I can see how someone would be hesitant to switch if it had a cost of $60-100.

I can get it for free, but still don't care for it.
I know I can jump through some hoops to create a local account, it's the principle of the thing.
 
I never stated he was wrong, what I disagreed with (calling bullshit) him stating that you pretty much need RSAT tools to administrate 2012 R2 and if still you use RDP then your a noob....I called bullshit on that particular point.

When someone attempts to speak from a position of authority, and then provides misleading information, that's a problem. It's deceitful and it's damaging to anyone who doesn't have the knowledge to see through the bullshit.

And I say this as an anti-malware researcher: antivirus software is pretty much unnecessary these days, we don't need it on our intranet.

This is what he said:

And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days, as it's needed to run the Remote Server Administration Tools for Windows Server 2012 (R2).

There's nothing misleading about it as he said precisely why he thought 8.1 was a requirement from his perspective. Maybe it could have been worded better, but he provided the SPECIFIC reason behind his thinking. And in these debates about Windows 8.x, specifics are often rare. People constantly get things wrong about 8.1 and I don't see 8.1 opponents correcting those errors.
 
Totally disagree. If the masses you sell to are inherently unfamiliar with what you sell then it absolutely is inherently unproductive.

You really can go on and on about it. But, ultimately it doesn't matter. It's like pointing out the good points in Vista. Nobody cares. It was a commercial failure. It gained no traction. 8 is going to be the same. It won't gain any traction and you'll have all these super awesome posts that nobody cares about because they'll all be looking towards 9. At this point, even MS is.

Whether or not anyone cares isn't the point. Most of this stuff over blown. You're saying that Windows 8 is a commercial failure? Compared to what? Linux? OS X? Chrome OS? Did Microsoft lose money on Windows 8? Something is inherently unproductive because someone didn't take five minutes to read up on something? And who is to say that the way that someone is using Windows 7 for that matter is inherently productive? Doing the same thing the same way forever is a sign that you might not be productive as you think.
 
Whether or not anyone cares isn't the point. Most of this stuff over blown. You're saying that Windows 8 is a commercial failure? Compared to what? Linux? OS X? Chrome OS? Did Microsoft lose money on Windows 8? Something is inherently unproductive because someone didn't take five minutes to read up on something? And who is to say that the way that someone is using Windows 7 for that matter is inherently productive? Doing the same thing the same way forever is a sign that you might not be productive as you think.

Wow, you've outdone yourself with this one.
 
MS must really be retreating from all the usability and productivity improvements it made in Windows 8. lol

Gosh, if they had only kept Sinofsky!

Foisting Metro on everyone was a huge blunder virtually everyone inside and outside of MS recognizes. There's always the one last holdout...
 
The saddest part is...for what? It bombed on tablets too, so it was all just a giant shot in the foot.
 
Mhmm. You aren't saying that windows 8.1 is a requirement for you and your work.
Huh? I'm not saying that? What are you talking about?

I said it's "pretty much a requirement" these days due to the fact that you can't install the latest version of RSAT without it.

Again, this is 100% true. You CANNOT install the latest version of RSAT without 8.1

your English is atrocious and misleading, or you're going to backpedal and claim that you were only talking about yourself and your personal work (which is patently false and you know it).
Not backpedaling, I said exactly what I meant.

As someone who manages servers every day, 8.1 is pretty much a requirement.
 
No, he spoke from a position of fabricated authority and told us that Windows 8.1 is necessary for IT server admins.
Learn. to. read. English.

I said "pretty much a requirement," not "absolutely necessary"

Nothing fabricated about my authority. I spoke form the position of admin-ing servers every day, which is EXACTLY what I do.

"And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days."

How the hell else is someone supposed to take that?
By not editing the quote, for starters. You omitted a key sentence and swapped a comma for a period. Could you get any more disingenuous?

The original quote, for those following allong:
"And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days, as it's needed to run the Remote Server Administration Tools for Windows Server 2012 (R2)."

This was a statement based on a condition, not a statement in its own right (as you attempted to frame it in your blatant misquote)
 
Wow, you've outdone yourself with this one.

Yep, ask someone how Windows 8.x is a commercial failure and yeah, just outdoing myself. No answer to the question at all about the bottom line economics, just another Windows 8 defender asking a question that no one can answer beyond a personal reference.

The saddest part is...for what? It bombed on tablets too, so it was all just a giant shot in the foot.

Windows 8.0/8.1 combined according to Stat Counter is the #2 desktop OS on Earth. So ultimately a Windows failure is better than anything not called Windows 7 on the desktop. Fair enough except that a general failure isn't is the same thing as a commercial failure. A commercial failure means a significant realized financial loss and to date not a soul has said that.

Windows tablets haven't nearly haven't done as well as needed. Price was a significant issue at launch but as much as people say Microsoft doesn't listen they have listened here and Windows 8.1 is free for small tablets and there are going to be a lot of sub $200 x86 Windows 8.1 tablets coming this fall. The other problem though is apps, and that's a much tougher issue and indeed one issue that Microsoft will struggle with perhaps forever. Much as OS X and Linux have struggled with desktop apps forever.
 
Yep, ask someone how Windows 8.x is a commercial failure and yeah, just outdoing myself. No answer to the question at all about the bottom line economics, just another Windows 8 defender asking a question that no one can answer beyond a personal reference.



Windows 8.0/8.1 combined according to Stat Counter is the #2 desktop OS on Earth. So ultimately a Windows failure is better than anything not called Windows 7 on the desktop. Fair enough except that a general failure isn't is the same thing as a commercial failure. A commercial failure means a significant realized financial loss and to date not a soul has said that.

Well, we don't really know if it lost money or not. I am not aware of Microsoft releasing the total cost of development vs profit. It probably was a net plus, but e.g. +20% is a failure if +120% was expected.

Beating OS X or Linux desktop is not much of an acomplishment and beating XP isn't either. "#2 desktop OS on Earth" sounds much grander that it really is. If it weren't for mandatory OEM sales/penetration, the numbers would be even worse.

That kind of poor execution is quite a feat when all they basically had to do was a SP2 for Win7.
 
Well, we don't really know if it lost money or not. I am not aware of Microsoft releasing the total cost of development vs profit. It probably was a net plus, but e.g. +20% is a failure if +120% was expected.

Beating OS X or Linux desktop is not much of an acomplishment and beating XP isn't either. "#2 desktop OS on Earth" sounds much grander that it really is. If it weren't for mandatory OEM sales/penetration, the numbers would be even worse.

That kind of poor execution is quite a feat when all they basically had to do was a SP2 for Win7.

I'm perfectly willing to except that Windows 8.x is a complete and utter disaster on the desktop. Has anything not called Windows 7 on the desktop done objectively better? Windows is certainly a monopoly on the desktop, one on which the government ruled to be so. And we all know how much government is respected around here.
 
"And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days, as it's needed to run the Remote Server Administration Tools for Windows Server 2012 (R2)."

This was a statement based on a condition, not a statement in its own right (as you attempted to frame it in your blatant misquote)

I think your English is just terrible. You don't seem to understand conditionals and how they are perceived.

This is what you should have posted, if you're genuine about this:


"And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. If you need to run Remote Server Administration Tools for Windows Server 2012 (R2), Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days."


You'll note that that's an actual conditional statement.

Your original post is not a conditional statement, at all:

And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days, as it's needed to run the Remote Server Administration Tools for Windows Server 2012 (R2).

What does that mean? It means that, according to an "IT manager", Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days BECAUSE it's needed to run the RSAT on Server 2012 R2. Not that Windows 8.1 is a requirement IF you need to run RSAT on Server 2012 R2. Simple facts here.

You spoke from authority and deliberately misled people, or your English is terrible and you don't understand conditional statements/the usage of the word 'as'. Pick one.
 
XP and 9x have done better.

Probably 3.1x too, relatively speaking.

XP and 9x were on sale for how long? Again, I have no problem declaring Windows 8.x a complete disaster on the desktop. I just don't think anything not called Windows has taken much advantage of it. And really, does anyone in their right mind think that give the mythos of the "good release/bad release" cycle of Windows think that Windows 9/Threshold is going to be challenged by anything on the desktop?

Windows sucks. I get that. All people want is something better and if it's free then all the better. I don't want to take more than an hour to get up to speed with it and it has to pretty much all the software I do know. That's all it takes to beat Windows. 90% compatibly and familiarity. Stop with the BS and just to that.
 
What does that mean? It means that, according to an "IT manager", Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days BECAUSE it's needed to run the RSAT on Server 2012 R2. Not that Windows 8.1 is a requirement IF you need to run RSAT on Server 2012 R2. Simple facts here.

He gave the EXACT reason why he said what he did. There are a bazillion criticisms on Windows 8.1 where absolutely no exact or precise reason is given and you'd fist bump it in second.
 
What is this the fucking twilight zone? English words, put together in the proper sequences, carry a certain meaning. If you don't understand that, don't comment. Not that that'll stop heatlesssun, of course.
 
Can't wait Windows 8/8.1 goes nail in coffin when Windows 9 preview next month or early Oct.

Windows 8/8.1 married to Vista recently by reported TMZ hehe.
 
Can't wait Windows 8/8.1 goes nail in coffin when Windows 9 preview next month or early Oct.

Everyone that hates Windows 8 and has claimed to have studied it and know it well and proclaim that it sucks will claim to have studied 9 well. Whether or not that proclaim it's suckness has yet to be determined.

Whatever we say Windows is a force of nature in the IT world. It's ancient by today's norms and still well known and debated. Microsoft makes many mistakes but it doesn't receive a lot of credit for what it hits bulls eye. Windows 8 is far from a bulls eye, but if it is the Titanic, not a soul alive can explain how any other non-Windows OS has done better in any objective terms.

Microsoft is in a lot of trouble when it comes to the consumer client. What's interesting is how many people that hate Windows 8 want Microsoft to ignore or fail in the consumer computing client area. Enterprise or bust is their motto.
 
Microsoft makes many mistakes but it doesn't receive a lot of credit for what it hits bulls eye. Windows 8 is far from a bulls eye, but if it is the Titanic, not a soul alive can explain how any other non-Windows OS has done better in any objective terms.

Negative feedback can be measured objectively, and I don't know of any other modern OS that has created this much of a public relations disaster for the developer. ME had it's problems and there was a lot of dumb FUD going around about Vista, but they didn't lead to a corporate re-org and big hardware losses like 8/Surface did.

The fact that the Windows platform has a lot of inertia doesn't invalidate the criticisms of 8. Between the low-cost licenses, pre-installed OEM machines, and the fact that most of us would like to keep using one primary OS on the desktop it would obviously be very difficult for something else to unseat Windows after one bad release.
 
Back
Top