heatlesssun
Extremely [H]
- Joined
- Nov 5, 2005
- Messages
- 44,154
Negative feedback can be measured objectively, and I don't know of any other modern OS that has created this much of a public relations disaster for the developer. ME had it's problems and there was a lot of dumb FUD going around about Vista, but they didn't lead to a corporate re-org and big hardware losses like 8/Surface did.
The fact that the Windows platform has a lot of inertia doesn't invalidate the criticisms of 8. Between the low-cost licenses, pre-installed OEM machines, and the fact that most of us would like to keep using one primary OS on the desktop it would obviously be very difficult for something else to unseat Windows after one bad release.
Indeed the "good release/bad release" legend of Windows. I've never said that the market share of Windows invalidated all of the criticisms of Windows 8.x. I've essentially agreed with those critics while being criticized. Windows 8 is too unfamiliar to too many of today's current Windows users. Windows 8 doesn't offer enough to today's Windows 7 users to migrate. Two years after the release of Windows 8, these are simple facts that really can't be disputed. Windows 8.x can even be considered a failure.
Much of the issue I've had with many around here is that I'm a very reasonable person. I don't think at any point that I ever said Windows 8 was awesome or would overtake Windows 7 in market share. All I've ever said about Windows 8.x is that if one actually learns to use it, it's far from the nonsense that's said online. I've never said to anyone that was happy with Windows 7 on a desktop to move to Windows 8. Not once. Not ever. I've never said to anyone that was happy with any other desktop OS to move to Windows 8. Not once. Not ever.
So much has been said about Windows 8 out of emotion that listening to customers isn't enough. While many, if not most, want Microsoft to just stay pat with a desktop OS that considers nothing about how many use computers today, Microsoft doesn't have the luxury of just accommodating today's users. It's a reality that just is and that's often how life works.
