Is Linux Mint 17 the Ubuntu Killer?

Intel drives are probably not proprietary, that is why.

With Nvidia and old cards you must use the old legacy drivers and that means jumping hoops to get them to work.

.....no integrated graphics on a 10+ year old P4 board in which I was using as my test platform.
The trusty old Geforce MX400 with 64MB of ram was used.
Maybe it just does not have the ump to run damn near an aero type GUI like unity/mint/ubuntu have.

XUbuntu. XFCE may be designed to be lightweight but the XUbuntu distro also seems the most sane and polished of all the Ubuntu derivatives. I'd still use XUbuntu on a pretty beefy system.
 
Image has nothing to do with it. The simple fact is that software support for Linux sucks. The free alternatives you speak of are generally not equal. The free office suites can't properly handle the xml office default formats that began being used in Office 2010. Popular commercial software support is non existent on Linux. No SMB is going to convert to Linux because that means abandoning all of its off the shelf software that works on Windows, finding Linux alternatives (free or otherwise), training staff how to use it, training or finding staff to support it, etc.

Linux will never gain a foothold as far as business desktops are concerned.

So you think that because Microsoft decided to limit competition by releasing a proprietary document form, it's the fault of linux somehow?

There's a simple solution to that, just tell people to save their attachments in a readable form instead. I have been using free office alternatives or OSX alternatives for closer to 10 years now and I've never yet encountered a situation where I would have needed MS office.

I also know for a fact that for general office use, linux contains all the tools that are needed. There are mainly some specialized software that will become a problem in business use such as designing systems and even those can be executed through wine in linux in some cases (not all). Most other enterprise systems have moved to the cloud already so they're OS agnostic.
 
Also, being a circa-1998 Slackware Linux user, I would say that Linux today is pretty easy to set up.

People expect it to be "just like Windows", ignoring the fact that you have to do some prepping on every Windows machine, like installing dlrivers, things like Flash and Java, and so on. All the Linux distros I've tried on this laptop worked just as Windows would out of the box. The tweaking I did to make it better was the same I would do on a Windows install: drivers, plugins and custom software. It took longer because I had to learn how to do it, but I had to do this with Windows before, so it's an apples to oranges comparison.

Also, after set up, it's just as easy for my mother to pick my Linux laptop and use it right now as it would be for her to pick it if it were running Windows. Except for Libreoffice, that really messes with .docx documents. But nothing is perfect.

The main problem with people moving from windows to linux is that they expect linux installations to work like in windows where you go to a website and then download an .exe and just double click it to run it. When they realize there are no .exe to run and for the most part, no websites to load it from they get confused and give up. In many cases they give up even before checking if the said thing is available through the software center.

File permissions are another issue, windows users just do not understand that you have to set a file executable before it runs. Also the fact that many distros do not allow you to switch to sudo using the GUI stops many people in their tracks as they fear the CLI.

So it's actually all the things that people are used to that make windows a virus paradise which become a problem if they try out linux.

I also set up a xubuntu laptop to my mother and stepfather for his desktop. I did so after getting tired to disinfecting or reinstalling their windows every 2 months. I said to them that if they get infected one more time, I'll install linux. They took the threat seriously, my mother was quite angry from the threat. Even angryer she was when the day came that I wiped windows off and installed linux to their first computer lol.

She just couldn't use it. She was mad as a bunch of wasps. I sat down with her and spent 5 minutes listening to what she couldn't do. I installed flash, pipelight and made shortcuts to firefox just like they were in her old computer. I showed her how openoffice opened her powerpoint attachments just as office did before. I showed where to find the document scanning application and set up their printer as it was linuxes fault they had the usb cable unplugged.

The phone calls stopped. Then they one day mentioned they'll be getting a new laptop with Windows 7 on it. I told them that we should install linux right away because I don't want to be called again to fix it. No, it had to be windows.

2 weeks pass and their new computer was infected again. You guessed it, it now runs on xubuntu too.

And now when I go visit them, they're happily browsing the internet with their linux computers and doing whatever they need to do without problems.
 
Decided to take my Linux notebook (AMD C-50, 6GB DDR3 RAM) to a distro round-up!

I guess this is a good measure of what to expect from different Linux distros on a low-end system. Keep in mind I compared all the distros as they are out-of-the-box, *except* for installing fglrx-updates and enabling Chromium GPU acceleration tweaks.

They're ordered from best to worst in my opinion.

1) Xubuntu 14.04 LTS. It rocks. Lightweight but functional with a clean, elegant and easy to use interface. Being an Ubuntu derivative, it's compatible with everything. I was using it before doing the distro dance, and I missed it every single time. It's really fast and the interface is one of the best out there IMO.

2) Ubuntu 14.04 LTS. Slower than Xubuntu, but faster than Mint Cinnamon and on par with Mint MATE performance. I found out I'm really not a fan of Unity - I kinda liked it at first, but after messing with Xubuntu's UI I find Unity clunky as hell. Xfce has it all laid down on a simple, but functional interface. It also came with Amazon widgets. I like Amazon, and I not really the paranoid type, but when I run Linux I guess one of the pluses is being able to know what you're running. Ubuntu messes with that feeling a bit, and it's not good.

3) Fedora 20 XFCE. Fast, functional and easy on the eye. It can be compared to Xubuntu, except for the fact that Fedora's software repository isn't as good as Ubuntu's.

4) Linux Mint MATE. It's as fast as Ubuntu. Its functionality can be compared to Xubuntu's, but noticeably slower and uglier, as it has a Windows 2000 feeling to it. That makes it harder on the eye than Ubuntu's Unity. On the plus side, the interface isn't as clunky as Ubuntu's. I could run it on the C-50 forever, but, as I said, Xubuntu is faster, easier on the eye and has a more functional interface.

5) Linux Mint Cinnamon. That thing is slow on the puny C-50, easily on the "annoying slow" side. Having many slow machines, I'm very patient. But it was really over the top. Also, I did not find Mint Cinnamon's interface was any better than Xubuntu's. It's not bad, but it's not really beautiful, especially considering it's so slow.

6) Lubuntu. It's FAST. Felt faster, albeit not THAT fast, than Xubuntu right out of the box. But it's ugly, and I didn't like the fact that I had to work a little to get a Wireless icon on the taskbar so I could switch networks. And it's also too ugly, and does not have many customization options. I take the small performance hit to use Xubuntu instead, thank you.

7) Fedora 20 Gnome 3. Gnome 3 sucks and it's so slow, slower than Cinnamon which was already on the "damn slow" side. That's all there's to it.
 
The phone calls stopped. Then they one day mentioned they'll be getting a new laptop with Windows 7 on it. I told them that we should install linux right away because I don't want to be called again to fix it. No, it had to be windows.

2 weeks pass and their new computer was infected again. You guessed it, it now runs on xubuntu too.

And now when I go visit them, they're happily browsing the internet with their linux computers and doing whatever they need to do without problems.

Every time you mention a Windows computer, two weeks later everyone of them gets infected but these same users have no problems with Linux, or at least don't after you spend some time setting up the machines and training the users. Seriously, what are these people doing with their machines? I've setup tons of people with Windows over the years and 100% infection rate in two weeks is just hard to believe.
 
Every time you mention a Windows computer, two weeks later everyone of them gets infected but these same users have no problems with Linux, or at least don't after you spend some time setting up the machines and training the users. Seriously, what are these people doing with their machines? I've setup tons of people with Windows over the years and 100% infection rate in two weeks is just hard to believe.

Trust me, it's not. I worked many years doing customer support and it happens. It's not as widespread as many say, but it does happen. Still, it's a lot less frequent after Windows 7.
 
Trust me, it's not. I worked many years doing customer support and it happens. It's not as widespread as many say, but it does happen. Still, it's a lot less frequent after Windows 7.

Of course it happens. But 100% infection rate in two weeks with Windows 7 and above?
 
Decided to take my Linux notebook (AMD C-50, 6GB DDR3 RAM) to a distro round-up!

I guess this is a good measure of what to expect from different Linux distros on a low-end system. Keep in mind I compared all the distros as they are out-of-the-box, *except* for installing fglrx-updates and enabling Chromium GPU acceleration tweaks.

They're ordered from best to worst in my opinion.

1) Xubuntu 14.04 LTS. It rocks. Lightweight but functional with a clean, elegant and easy to use interface. Being an Ubuntu derivative, it's compatible with everything. I was using it before doing the distro dance, and I missed it every single time. It's really fast and the interface is one of the best out there IMO.

2) Ubuntu 14.04 LTS. Slower than Xubuntu, but faster than Mint Cinnamon and on par with Mint MATE performance. I found out I'm really not a fan of Unity - I kinda liked it at first, but after messing with Xubuntu's UI I find Unity clunky as hell. Xfce has it all laid down on a simple, but functional interface. It also came with Amazon widgets. I like Amazon, and I not really the paranoid type, but when I run Linux I guess one of the pluses is being able to know what you're running. Ubuntu messes with that feeling a bit, and it's not good.

3) Fedora 20 XFCE. Fast, functional and easy on the eye. It can be compared to Xubuntu, except for the fact that Fedora's software repository isn't as good as Ubuntu's.

4) Linux Mint MATE. It's as fast as Ubuntu. Its functionality can be compared to Xubuntu's, but noticeably slower and uglier, as it has a Windows 2000 feeling to it. That makes it harder on the eye than Ubuntu's Unity. On the plus side, the interface isn't as clunky as Ubuntu's. I could run it on the C-50 forever, but, as I said, Xubuntu is faster, easier on the eye and has a more functional interface.

5) Linux Mint Cinnamon. That thing is slow on the puny C-50, easily on the "annoying slow" side. Having many slow machines, I'm very patient. But it was really over the top. Also, I did not find Mint Cinnamon's interface was any better than Xubuntu's. It's not bad, but it's not really beautiful, especially considering it's so slow.

6) Lubuntu. It's FAST. Felt faster, albeit not THAT fast, than Xubuntu right out of the box. But it's ugly, and I didn't like the fact that I had to work a little to get a Wireless icon on the taskbar so I could switch networks. And it's also too ugly, and does not have many customization options. I take the small performance hit to use Xubuntu instead, thank you.

7) Fedora 20 Gnome 3. Gnome 3 sucks and it's so slow, slower than Cinnamon which was already on the "damn slow" side. That's all there's to it.

Thanks for taking the time to play around with all those Linux distros (which probably used a lot of free time to download and install let alone tinker). I haven't really noticed Mint 17 with Cinnamon is as slow, but I'm using different hardware and didn't really explore many distros before settling on it. Anyhow since no one else replied to say thanks, I will. :)
 
Back
Top