Is Linux Mint 17 the Ubuntu Killer?

I just completed upgraded and/or re-installing 17 on all my PC's and VM's that had 16 up this evening.

In the past 2-3 weeks I've installed AMD and nVidia's proprietary drivers on Ubuntu, Mint w/ Cinnamon and Fedora 20. I have had 0 problems with either of them but actually the nVidia install process is a little more involved.

I don't even bother with the open source drivers from either camp or what's in the repo's via the "additional drivers" tool. I just grab the latest from the amd/nVidia sites. I've seen a lot of complaints about both camps drivers recently starting from 13.04 -> 14.04.

AMD Install:

1. Download latest Beta via Firefox or wget
2. Extract the files
3. Fire-up terminal
4. cd Documents or wherever I extracted the fglrx folder and then into that folder
sudo ./amd-driver-installer-...
select "Install Driver X on X.Org...."
Hit express installation just as I would in Windows
Reboot
5. Log back in and I'm done and everythings gravy

nVidia Install:

1. Download latest Beta via Firefox or wget
2. Extract the Files
3. Drop into one of the default tty's using ctrl + alt F*
4. sudo service lightdm/gdm/mdm stop
5. cd into the directory containing the .run file
chmod +x on the NVIDIA-Linux.run file
sudo ./NVIDIA-Linux.run
accept the EULA, answer yes/no to all the questions in the TUI
wait for install to finish
6. sudo service lightdm/gdm/mdm start
7. switch back to my desktop environment with ctrl + alt F7
8. Log back in and I'm done and everythings gravy


I've personally not run into any problems recently with any of the hardware, distro or desktop environment combo's I've been running (GTX 670, HD 5450, R9 290X | Gnome 3, Cinnamon, Unity, KDE).

Back in the 9.10 -> 12.10 days when we first started seeing hardware acceleration, never UVD stuff and gaming pick-up a bit on Linux this used to be a fucking mess between nouveau, open source radeon drivers, proprietary nvidia/AMD drivers and what was available in the repo's. It was a fucking shitshow trying to find a working driver with the features you need. You'd get piss poor 2D performance out of driver but dual monitor setups would work, dual/triple monitor wouldn't work but 2D performance would be good and wouldn't freeze. There were always trade off or shit just simply didn't work.

If you ask me in the last 2 years we've come a damn long way as far as the quality and ease of use of acquring, installing and USING graphics drivers on Linux go. In my recent experience as long as you have a semi-new card from AMD/Nvidia you really can't go wrong using either camps proprietary drivers from the web on any of the more common distro's or with any of the major DE's. The other thing is if there is an issue it's usually pretty well documented, where as before you'd have to google fu up a storm to find what you were looking for.

I've heard great things about Intel's recent GPU drivers as well for the iGPU's in Sandybridge+, I just haven't bothered to try.

Mint 17 is a really solid release and I'm glad they are changing their development cycle and are going to use this as their base for the next two years. It should make updating incredibly easy, yield a much more stable product and allow them to innovate and iterate more efficiently.

Things are getting much better for us on the GPU support side of things. I'm excited to see what the tail end of this year brings with SteamOS.
 
And this is why Linux as it is today is still a bajillion years away from being a full on 3rd option for normals in the desktop space. Manually installing drivers instead of using vendor provided scripts is a huge pain in the ass even for me (I'm by no means super great with Linux, but certainly going to do better than your average chud).

Have to agree with this.
Solid video support is so spotty from distro to distro it is ridiculous.
I have 1 real mission critical system I use for work and I switched to a modest Nvidia card just for the stability aspect. But will the next version play nice with this card? Hard to say.
:(

But with that said would I go back to windows for my day to day work tasks? NO WAY.
Overall stability for productive tasks, I find linux faster, and more stable.
 
Does Mint send info to Amazon and other "partners" like Ubuntu does?

No.

Unity isnt that bad... locking the task bar to the bottom left is BAD, locking the windows controls on the left is BAD, locking a stupidly redundant bar (top panel) at the top of the screen that severs no purpose but steal screen real estate and clutter our ui is BAD.

Its a nice idea to offer a UI that is the same accross all devices but they know they are going against currents, they should allow us to customize these things. The task bar is too damn far, same thing for the windows control... pay attention to how people use their computers, their mouse will usualy idle and center back to the right of the screen, we have all developed that habbit it not so bright to go against it in the first place and ill even call it stupid to force it on people.

Especially when Ubuntu has the support and exposure to be THE distro that makes the linux desktop a viable alternative.

Its very weird when you look that the number 1 ubuntu bug on their website. Bug #1 = windows has more market share. They are definitly not doing what is needed to win market shares here.

The first place they could win some ground is as a business os but beign in IT for over 20 years I can tell you that its a very tough sell to promote Ubuntu as a windows alternative when 90% of the people have negative feedback right off the bat by looking at the launcher placement... imagine when you tell them its locked in place.

Cannonical has it wrong, its not time to innovate for linux, its time to be as good so people switch from windows painlessly. Which also means that wine has to be worked on a lot more! We cant expect people to go off in terminal just cause they want to change a few settings they had for granted in any other os.

One other thing.. .god damn font rendering in linux... it sucks balls. They think they have it all figured out with RGB sub pixel rendering... that is nothing like Cleartype, cleartype is an hybrid of subpixel rendering and grayscale. Straight up subpixel rendering adds a dirty fuzzy rainbow looking aura around fonts... its ugly. Its just wrong when ppl look at their screens and wonder if they need glasses just cause of bad default fonts and font rendering issues.

I wish all the linux devs would stop spreading out on all those different projects/distros and just came together for a year to fix all the basic issues this os has. No instead they create new UIs .... damn shame. :rolleyes:
 
If a noob posts a question on the Ubuntu forum a typical response is "Do a search idiot!!"

I have to disagree here. It's been awhile since I was over there but that was never my experience. The forums have pretty well-defined rules of engagement and they seem to be enforced. In general, responses tend to be quite helpful but there are also times when nobody has a clear answer.
 
It's the reason why canonical developers have had spats with Mint developers. Too much attention being taken away from Ubuntu because of Mint. It's also the reason why Mint also maintains a Debian version, and probably why Valve went Debian as well.

Also pay attention Windows 8 supporters, as even Ubuntu pays for having a UI that nobody likes. People want their taskbar and start button.

Pay attention to the market that has little to no penetration on the desktop, sure thing. :rolleyes: Oh wait, you mean the taskbar and start button that is there right now in Windows 8.1?
 
I've had problems installing drivers from both AMD and Nvidia. When I do a fresh install of Mint, I always install openssh-server. A lot of times the system will boot with a blank screen but the system is still working. So I can use PuTTY from another machine to get the drivers properly installed. The hardware driver installer that Mint has doesn't always work.

You shouldn't need to use SSH since you can get to a terminal console by pressing Ctrl-Alt-F1, F2, etc. The display not coming up shouldn't affect the console functionality.

However it is weird that people are having problems with driver installs. It should be that they go pretty smoothly, especially when installed from a package manager.
 
Pay attention to the market that has little to no penetration on the desktop, sure thing. :rolleyes: Oh wait, you mean the taskbar and start button that is there right now in Windows 8.1?

Right now 8.1 has it, but how long did it take Microsoft to go from 8 to 8.1? Also, linux may not have much penetration in the market but it's getting attention. It won't be long before Linux has no disadvantages over Windows. Certainly for a lot of people, whatever disadvantages there maybe, it's not enough to deter them.

You shouldn't need to use SSH since you can get to a terminal console by pressing Ctrl-Alt-F1, F2, etc. The display not coming up shouldn't affect the console functionality.

However it is weird that people are having problems with driver installs. It should be that they go pretty smoothly, especially when installed from a package manager.
For me it sometimes happens that I can't enter console no matter what I try. I have problems because I like to update my kernel, which makes it difficult for AMD and Nvidia drivers to deal with. Kernel 3.15 will be out soon, and probably both AMD and Nvidia don't properly support it. Newer kernels have so many performance improvements that it makes no sense not to update them.
 
This. It's like the steering wheel and gas pedals in a car, it's old technology, but IT WORKS! Devs have to stop changing stuff just for the sake of change. People get used to a certain way the GUI is, and it should be left alone.
Damned straight. Take something simple, like the hostname of your machine. Here's how you change it for different OS:

/etc/sysconfig/network
/etc/hostname
/etc/HOSTNAME

Three different files, for the same purpose. Oh, it gets better. Running SLES? Have anything in the /etc/hosts file after the 127.0.0.1 line? Guess that's your new hostname, even if you have a /etc/HOSTNAME file set up.

There's no reason for this. They only changed the file to be "different". Don't even get me started on Solaris 11.1's ridiculous "Oh, we ignore the config files now - Only commands entered via our proprietary netcfg tool are actually useful."

Here's a philosophy for OS designers - If it ain't broke, don't fix it. There's plenty that IS broke you could be focusing on instead.
 
Right now 8.1 has it, but how long did it take Microsoft to go from 8 to 8.1? Also, linux may not have much penetration in the market but it's getting attention. It won't be long before Linux has no disadvantages over Windows. Certainly for a lot of people, whatever disadvantages there maybe, it's not enough to deter them.

Linux has been getting attention and its diehards have been saying the same thing you are saying for the past 15 years. I have nothing against Linux and in the right situation (basic PC tasks like web browsing, email, light office work, etc) its a good alternative. That being said how bad is your product when you can't get 1% market share when giving it away? There is something fundamentally wrong with Linux on the desktop. I personally think its because of the fragmentation of the product. If a Linux noob wants to convert to Linux they have to decide on a distro, decide on a shell, decide on whether to go with a LTS release, etc. That alone is at least a couple of hours of research.

Linux on the desktop had several chances to capitalize on Microsoft's blunders (Windows ME, Windows Vista, Windows 8) and upon every opportunity its failed to cash in. Linux on the desktop is dead and buried. Its time to stop trying to re-animate its corpse and let it go.
 
Oh wait, you mean the taskbar and start button that is there right now in Windows 8.1?
I think by "Start Button", he was actually referencing the start button + menu concept, and not the start button in Windows 8.1, which only takes you to the same start screen in Windows 8. (All they did was make the 1x1 pixel in the lower left of Windows 8 into a regular sized button)
 
Linux has been getting attention and its diehards have been saying the same thing you are saying for the past 15 years.
You mean the same people that warned Microsoft how bad Windows 8 was going to be, and Microsoft fell on deaf ears? Be careful of the vocal minority.
I have nothing against Linux and in the right situation (basic PC tasks like web browsing, email, light office work, etc) its a good alternative. That being said how bad is your product when you can't get 1% market share when giving it away? There is something fundamentally wrong with Linux on the desktop. I personally think its because of the fragmentation of the product. If a Linux noob wants to convert to Linux they have to decide on a distro, decide on a shell, decide on whether to go with a LTS release, etc. That alone is at least a couple of hours of research.
Modern linux is nothing like linux from 15 years ago, or 5 years ago even. A lot has seriously changed. But the reason why Linux is still 1% is the same reason why Microsoft can't get people to step away from XP. XP probably has the best compatibility when it comes to Windows applications and hardware. Linux does not have good compatibility with Windows applications. It's seriously the reason why I don't use it on my gaming desktop PC. If linux has things like Photoshop and all my games working perfectly at 100% then I would have switched. I don't need those things on my laptop, so I primarily use Mint on my laptops.
Linux on the desktop had several chances to capitalize on Microsoft's blunders (Windows ME, Windows Vista, Windows 8) and upon every opportunity its failed to cash in. Linux on the desktop is dead and buried. Its time to stop trying to re-animate its corpse and let it go.

Microsoft can barely get XP users to switch over to newer versions, and you really think that Linux's problem is something different? Look at how many people are switching over to Windows 8. People have an easier time voting for presidents then switching over to a newer Windows OS.

I think by "Start Button", he was actually referencing the start button + menu concept, and not the start button in Windows 8.1, which only takes you to the same start screen in Windows 8. (All they did was make the 1x1 pixel in the lower left of Windows 8 into a regular sized button)

Can we seriously not call what Windows 8.1 has as a start button? It's more like a "fuck you, you'll do what we want button". It's like Microsoft can never get over the idea that people hate the Metro UI.

Unless it looks like this, it's not a start menu.

Mint13-5-menu.jpg
 
Is Mint lighter than Ubuntu? I run Linux on a AMD C-50 notebook. So far all the Linux distros I've tried are slower than Windows 8 on the same machine. Wonder if I can expect more from Mint.
 
Is Mint lighter than Ubuntu? I run Linux on a AMD C-50 notebook. So far all the Linux distros I've tried are slower than Windows 8 on the same machine. Wonder if I can expect more from Mint.

No.

Your problem is that AMD is awful.
 
For now Mint is most likely going to rule the roost. If you've ever played around on Distrowatch it can be interesting to see the Hits per Day for previous years. As old as the site goes Mandrake used to be all the rage. Then Mandriva happened and Ubuntu came onto the scene. The same thing happened a few years ago with Ubuntu and Mint.

What's actually interesting is that if you go by hits per day Ubuntu is actually pretty stable, it's just that Mint is far more popular. Hits per day has in fact increased considerably over the years, so Linux is in fact growing. (The internet is likely the biggest advantage here.)

If anything you could almost draw a conclusion that commercial support seems to be part of the limiting factor. Anytime someone wants to come in and improve upon it the community would rather just fork their work than having a company decide a direction which to take the operating system in.
 
Ubuntu is much better than Mint in terms of security simply because of Mint's lack of security updates. Am I wrong?
 
Is Mint lighter than Ubuntu? I run Linux on a AMD C-50 notebook. So far all the Linux distros I've tried are slower than Windows 8 on the same machine. Wonder if I can expect more from Mint.

I can't speak for AMD hardware but my Latitude 2100 (an Atom n270 netbook) with 2 GB RAM and a 160 GB hard drive seems pretty much the same running Mint 16 as it does with Windows 8.1 with the exception of boot up. Windows 8.1 is MUCH faster about going from powered off to the point where you can start doing stuff. Mint 16 is, I think, as fast or faster at loading applications and just generally doing "stuff" on the interwebs. Mint uses a lot less RAM which leaves more for applications to work with without resorting to virtual memory.

Unfortunately, I think that's really where a lot of people start and finish how they measure the performance of an operating system. They pretty much focus exclusively on how fast it boots as the only factor in their judgement of a computer's performance and ignore everything else. Microsoft has done a good job shortcuting the boot process, but they copy quite a bit to the hard disk and then load it back into memory, even during a cold boot. It's kinda weird for people to focus on the difference between a 10 second boot and a 40 second boot when that's a very tiny amount of time in the overall usage experience and a lot of tasks these days cause the computer to wait for the user ask the system to do something. Like typing or web browsing...tons of that time is idle or very low demand on the system.

So I dunno...maybe there's something wrong with AMD hardware under Linux. Intel systems seem perfectly happy though. Since you're getting better whatever out of Windows 8.1, maybe sticking with it is better for your situation. Linux does take a pretty technically minded person once in a while (because of the occasional CLI stuff), so that's kinda a turn off for casual Windows users or non-technical people. :)
 
Ubuntu is much better than Mint in terms of security simply because of Mint's lack of security updates. Am I wrong?

The update manager downloads security updates automatically and notifies the user to install them. Those are combined with general package updates too. Versions that aren't under long term support get updates for 18 months and the LTS stuff (17 is LTS) get security updates for 3 years from the time it was released.
 
Trying to download and all those USA links suck nuts. Maybe I should try an overseas one.
 
Linux has been getting attention and its diehards have been saying the same thing you are saying for the past 15 years. I have nothing against Linux and in the right situation (basic PC tasks like web browsing, email, light office work, etc) its a good alternative. That being said how bad is your product when you can't get 1% market share when giving it away? There is something fundamentally wrong with Linux on the desktop. I personally think its because of the fragmentation of the product. If a Linux noob wants to convert to Linux they have to decide on a distro, decide on a shell, decide on whether to go with a LTS release, etc. That alone is at least a couple of hours of research.

Linux on the desktop had several chances to capitalize on Microsoft's blunders (Windows ME, Windows Vista, Windows 8) and upon every opportunity its failed to cash in. Linux on the desktop is dead and buried. Its time to stop trying to re-animate its corpse and let it go.


People are afraid of change and too many companies rely on windows for their income. It would be a disaster if their windows professionals wouldn't be needed anymore. The biggest problem is an image problem - people have the image that linux is for nerds only and nothing works on it. They complain about stupid things such as not being able to run windows software x when linux would have a free alternative to that.

Oh, and gaming. Try offering a teenage gamer a linux box. If he can't play even one of his library of 100 games it's the end of the world.
 
Xubuntu on the C-50 with fglrx drivers - easily installed through the GUI - is so far the best I've tried on this puny notebook. Lubuntu is lighter, but too spartan for my tastes.
 
People are afraid of change and too many companies rely on windows for their income. It would be a disaster if their windows professionals wouldn't be needed anymore. The biggest problem is an image problem - people have the image that linux is for nerds only and nothing works on it. They complain about stupid things such as not being able to run windows software x when linux would have a free alternative to that.

Oh, and gaming. Try offering a teenage gamer a linux box. If he can't play even one of his library of 100 games it's the end of the world.

Image has nothing to do with it. The simple fact is that software support for Linux sucks. The free alternatives you speak of are generally not equal. The free office suites can't properly handle the xml office default formats that began being used in Office 2010. Popular commercial software support is non existent on Linux. No SMB is going to convert to Linux because that means abandoning all of its off the shelf software that works on Windows, finding Linux alternatives (free or otherwise), training staff how to use it, training or finding staff to support it, etc.

Linux will never gain a foothold as far as business desktops are concerned.
 
There really is no reason to use Linux as an enterprise desktop. Windows is good enough.
 
Depending on the type of work, I would say it's better. Linux web browsing means an almost - and I say that just to be on the safe side - malware-free experience. If I had a dime for every minute I've spent fixing Windows machines that were infested with web browsing-related malware, I would have a fair amount of dough right now.
 
Also, if I had a dime for every person I know that decided to go Mac just to not bother with malware I would have another chunk of money. They would get the same experience, minus the cool factor, going Linux on their standard laptops.
 
Also, being a circa-1998 Slackware Linux user, I would say that Linux today is pretty easy to set up.

People expect it to be "just like Windows", ignoring the fact that you have to do some prepping on every Windows machine, like installing dlrivers, things like Flash and Java, and so on. All the Linux distros I've tried on this laptop worked just as Windows would out of the box. The tweaking I did to make it better was the same I would do on a Windows install: drivers, plugins and custom software. It took longer because I had to learn how to do it, but I had to do this with Windows before, so it's an apples to oranges comparison.

Also, after set up, it's just as easy for my mother to pick my Linux laptop and use it right now as it would be for her to pick it if it were running Windows. Except for Libreoffice, that really messes with .docx documents. But nothing is perfect.
 
Jimmy vs Timmah! is what I thought after reading the title.
 
FYI, some three-letter agency developed SElinux which happens to be in Mint, Ubuntu, etc. Still want to use it considering a possible backdoor?
 
FYI, some three-letter agency developed SElinux which happens to be in Mint, Ubuntu, etc. Still want to use it considering a possible backdoor?

It doesn't worry me at all as I'm sure a true tinfoil hat wearer proposing that there are government built backdoors would also insist the same is true of Microsoft products and the ever popular HP-UX and Solaris.
 
FYI, some three-letter agency developed SElinux which happens to be in Mint, Ubuntu, etc. Still want to use it considering a possible backdoor?

But SELinux isn't a default installed option in Mint and Ubuntu. Besides, if it's open source it's open to finding vulnerabilities.

Contrast that to Larry Ellison's slobbering all over the NSA's balls.
 
Mint is decent, some of the features like HD temp you can put into the bottom tray are nice although last I checked you were limited to just 1 and nobody makes a program like crystaldiskinfo for linux that I know of.
My biggest problem is if you do not have a recent GPU [nvidia] in which you can use the latest drivers you have some serious hoops you have to jump through to get archive drivers to load.
First you have to get the driver but then sudo, try and get nouveau to blacklist so you can remove it, jump more hoops and if your lucky you can get it to work.

The nouveau driver sucks ass, half my icons were washed out and when you move the mouse of them they turn their color then go back to washed out white.
it also slows down the interface.

The official nvidia driver of course fixes all of this.

I managed to get it to work on 12 but I tried 14 and it just would not work no matter what.
 
My biggest problem is if you do not have a recent GPU [nvidia] in which you can use the latest drivers you have some serious hoops you have to jump through to get archive drivers to load.


What? My Intel GMA 950 from 2006 worked right away with no need to load any additional drivers. I think if your graphics card is such a problem, it'd be better just to get rid of it and use integrated graphics as they're a lot better in the drivers department. On Windows, you're not constantly loading the latest Catalyst or Nvidia driver since Windows Update usually has the latest Intel driver published and in Linux, I've never really even had a reason to think twice about graphics drivers since they're always supported and work very well.
 
Intel drives are probably not proprietary, that is why.

With Nvidia and old cards you must use the old legacy drivers and that means jumping hoops to get them to work.

.....no integrated graphics on a 10+ year old P4 board in which I was using as my test platform.
The trusty old Geforce MX400 with 64MB of ram was used.
Maybe it just does not have the ump to run damn near an aero type GUI like unity/mint/ubuntu have.
 
Back
Top