Is Linux Mint 17 the Ubuntu Killer?

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
The new version of Linux Mint dubbed Qiana has been touted as the latest and greatest alternative to disgruntled Windows 8 users and Ubuntu dis-aficionados. Mint is well known for its easy adaptability from Windows and ease of use over Ubuntu even though Linux Mint 17 is based on Ubuntu.
 
It's the reason why canonical developers have had spats with Mint developers. Too much attention being taken away from Ubuntu because of Mint. It's also the reason why Mint also maintains a Debian version, and probably why Valve went Debian as well.

Also pay attention Windows 8 supporters, as even Ubuntu pays for having a UI that nobody likes. People want their taskbar and start button.
 
People want their taskbar and start button.

This. It's like the steering wheel and gas pedals in a car, it's old technology, but IT WORKS! Devs have to stop changing stuff just for the sake of change. People get used to a certain way the GUI is, and it should be left alone.
 
It's the reason why canonical developers have had spats with Mint developers. Too much attention being taken away from Ubuntu because of Mint. It's also the reason why Mint also maintains a Debian version, and probably why Valve went Debian as well.

Also pay attention Windows 8 supporters, as even Ubuntu pays for having a UI that nobody likes. People want their taskbar and start button.

Mint doesn't do stupid shit just because "because".

Nice group of guys who are pragmatic about things especially like codecs...and releasing things when they work.
 
It's the reason why canonical developers have had spats with Mint developers. Too much attention being taken away from Ubuntu because of Mint. It's also the reason why Mint also maintains a Debian version, and probably why Valve went Debian as well.

Also pay attention Windows 8 supporters, as even Ubuntu pays for having a UI that nobody likes. People want their taskbar and start button.

I'm surprised the same vitriol isn't reserved for kUbuntu and xUbuntu (and even LUbuntu)... All three have done what Ubuntu couldn't: Put together a familiar, updated desktop without alienating the shit out of new users.

That said, xUbuntu seems to be doing it the best. Their new Menu is nice and simple and their defaults (apps, settings and themes) are actually pretty reasonable.
 
Mint doesn't do stupid shit just because "because".

Nice group of guys who are pragmatic about things especially like codecs...and releasing things when they work.
I didn't say Mint does stupid shit. Not sure what you're referring about.
 
^ meant I'm really looking forward to using Mint 17, as it's been freshly released already.
 
Hell yeah. I'm on Mint 14, and I like it. How easy is it to upgrade from Mint 14 to 17?
 
Installed Mint 16 on a good a few months back, tried to update the nvidia drivers and X shat itself... nope.
 
Hell yeah. I'm on Mint 14, and I like it. How easy is it to upgrade from Mint 14 to 17?
I probably do it differently than others but I just install into the existing root (/) partition since I have it divided as four partitions:
Code:
/boot
/
/home
swap
My settings and documents/files are under the /home partition so that's not going anywhere.

I'm sure there is another way of doing a proper upgrade from one version to another, but this has worked out for me so far.
MATE or Cinnamon... which one to go with...
I usually go with Cinnamon, and XFCE for the netbook.
 
Mint is a great operating system I started using it on my PowerPC Macs first when I heard there was a PowerPC derivative at version 11 unfortunately Mint PPC hasn't been updated since version 11 but ran much better then even lubuntu. On the PC side of things I started running Mint 12 Lisa on many of my Pentium 4 machines and I have Mint 16 Petra on my Shuttle cube e8500 with a GT240 I cannot believe how blindingly fast it runs Once 17 is out of RC i will put it on the cube and its nice 17 will have support till 2019, heck even mint 13 support will last till 2017.
 
LMDE with MATE is amazing, and Mint has been very good for many others from what I've heard.
Canonical is digging it's own grave with Unity on Ubuntu.

Last good version of Ubuntu was 10.10, RIP.
 
When I finally upgrade to 14.04 I'm just going to install MATE. I'm done with the Unity crap. If Canonical doesn't improve things I'll just move off their distro altogether.
 
Mint was the Ubuntu killer for me a long time ago. I went Debian on some (CentOS for WWW servers). But, for desktop PC's, it's mostly Mint. That's what I recommend to anyone wanting to go Linux as a newbie. I look at it as a very polished Ubuntu, where Ubuntu is the rough product. Used to be Ubuntu was the polished Debian. Unity kind of killed it for Ubuntu....
 
Mint was the Ubuntu killer for me a long time ago. I went Debian on some (CentOS for WWW servers). But, for desktop PC's, it's mostly Mint. That's what I recommend to anyone wanting to go Linux as a newbie. I look at it as a very polished Ubuntu, where Ubuntu is the rough product. Used to be Ubuntu was the polished Debian. Unity kind of killed it for Ubuntu....

Heh Unity is only a recent symptom. The things that killed it date back to all the shit post-Gutsy. Hardy came along and all the long-term users suddenly realized how much better the older releases were re: stability etc.
 
I hate these article titles that posite as questions, even if the article is well researched and written. It's not like anything will be an "killer" except fading into irrelevence.

And if that's the case, then Android would be the Ubuntu "killer" since it's the most dominate in mobile space, which is where computing is rapidly heading.
 
cept no one will be running Mint *nix servers at anytime soon, over Ubuntu/debian/RHEL.

So in the grand scheme of things, this is non news.
 
I need HELP!

I use Mint 14 for my VM's. When I login there is a panel that always comes up showing the contents of my desktop folder. I accidently hit the X to close the panel and now it will not come back up and I have no idea how to bring it back up or what it's even called.
 
In other news, okra is the new brussel sprouts killer.

Not sure how you can consider an OS "alive and well" to begin with if it only has .08% market share. *shrugs*
 
In other news, okra is the new brussel sprouts killer.

Not sure how you can consider an OS "alive and well" to begin with if it only has .08% market share. *shrugs*

More than likely because the OS is alive and well on the server side, which would bleed over to the desktop market due to user familiarity. I also believe .08 is a little off, granted the true number (around 1.6%) isn't amazing.
 
Installed Mint 16 on a good a few months back, tried to update the nvidia drivers and X shat itself... nope.

This has been Mints downfall. I have got it broken on average on second boot after doing updates and installing drivers. Partly that has probably been because I used to have AMD only graphics.

Nvidia seems to work marginally better, but only marginally.
 
This has been Mints downfall. I have got it broken on average on second boot after doing updates and installing drivers. Partly that has probably been because I used to have AMD only graphics.

Nvidia seems to work marginally better, but only marginally.

Those issues aren't Mints fault. Remember, Mint is just Ubuntu with a lot of customizations. Same problems happen to Ubuntu. You're just better off getting the drivers from the manufacturer and installing them manually.

I've had problems installing drivers from both AMD and Nvidia. When I do a fresh install of Mint, I always install openssh-server. A lot of times the system will boot with a blank screen but the system is still working. So I can use PuTTY from another machine to get the drivers properly installed. The hardware driver installer that Mint has doesn't always work.

If you use AMD then just still with the open source drivers. They don't have those problems at all, and they're getting faster. For me, Open source drivers seem faster. If you want latest and fastest open source graphics on Mint then get oibaf's PPA. Just wait until 3.16 kernel is released with the PTE patches, which gives a big speed boost.

3dmark2001.png

3dmark2006.png
 
Those issues aren't Mints fault. Remember, Mint is just Ubuntu with a lot of customizations. Same problems happen to Ubuntu. You're just better off getting the drivers from the manufacturer and installing them manually.

I've had problems installing drivers from both AMD and Nvidia. When I do a fresh install of Mint, I always install openssh-server. A lot of times the system will boot with a blank screen but the system is still working. So I can use PuTTY from another machine to get the drivers properly installed. The hardware driver installer that Mint has doesn't always work.

If you use AMD then just still with the open source drivers. They don't have those problems at all, and they're getting faster. For me, Open source drivers seem faster. If you want latest and fastest open source graphics on Mint then get oibaf's PPA. Just wait until 3.16 kernel is released with the PTE patches, which gives a big speed boost.

3dmark2001.png

3dmark2006.png

And this is why Linux as it is today is still a bajillion years away from being a full on 3rd option for normals in the desktop space. Manually installing drivers instead of using vendor provided scripts is a huge pain in the ass even for me (I'm by no means super great with Linux, but certainly going to do better than your average chud).
 
I've used Cinnamon Mint and Ubuntu (prefer Ubuntu, call me crazy), 32 bit and 64 bit, and the AMD GPU drivers just blow. Proprietary AMD on a lower end card isn't worth a damn. Don't have a high end AMD card to test but with as bad as the drivers are, no way I'm sinking a couple hundred into my *nix box.
Networking, great, printing, fantastic, sound, amazing! Linux has come a long way.
Just has a bit more to go and is in desperate need of GPU drivers.
 
And this is why Linux as it is today is still a bajillion years away from being a full on 3rd option for normals in the desktop space. Manually installing drivers instead of using vendor provided scripts is a huge pain in the ass even for me (I'm by no means super great with Linux, but certainly going to do better than your average chud).

For me manually installing drivers is running vendor provided scripts. Driver manager bypasses all that and does it automatically, but it just doesn't always work. There was a wifi driver that didn't work and I had to disable it. Eventually they released a newer working driver in Driver Manager that did.
 
Installed Mint 16 on a good a few months back, tried to update the nvidia drivers and X shat itself... nope.

I tried Linux Mint 16 on my linux test bed laptop, and the touchpad didn't work until after I finished the installation. I had to plug in a mouse to install. Nothing major, but I was annoyed by that and decided to try something else. Tried CentOS, Fedora and now I'm running Ubuntu. Will give it a shot again.
 
Fedora (w/ XFCE) is nice. CentOS is nice too, but too slow on my underpowered laptop. Ubuntu is OK.

Still, Windows 8 is faster than all of them on this notebook. Let's see what happens with Mint.
 
And uh, I like Unity. For me it's like the Win7 taskbar, you pin the most used stuff in there and use the applications menu to launch things that you don't use that often.

Also, installing proprietary AMD drivers worked flawlessly using the built-in driver installer. The Open Source ones worked fine, but this machine is way too whimpy to run videos without proper video acceleration, and open source drivers didn't manage that very well. The proprietary ones worked without issue.
 
Linux is the Ubuntu killer

I was thinking the same thing...

Why exactly does Linux on the desktop get any attention in tech news, anyway? Hardly anybody uses it, and despite years of updates and hype it's never really gained ground. SteamOS is interesting, but who knows if it will actually go anywhere.
 
Why exactly does Linux on the desktop get any attention in tech news, anyway?

Because desktop mean much wider audience than server. The same apply to Windows desktop vs Windows server. everyone is talking about windows 8.1 Metro and barely anyone talking about servers.
 
Mint 16 has been great for moving away from Windows. I last tried it with 14 and it was sorta *meh* then mainly because of 3rd party problems (in my case, it was because LibreOffice didn't do the whole MS Office translation well enough for publication-quality work and that was in both directions). Since Microsoft is going ultra-stupid with their subscription based stuff and clunky, inelegant UI and the dumb-tastic upgrade from 8 to 8.1, it was time to get ahead of the rest of the world in getting more comfy with something Linux-based before the subscription-only OSes start coming out of Redmond. Mint 16 was a super smooth transition from Windows XP/Vista/7 that Windows 8 could never manage to become and I'm really happy to be trying something new. I did have to resort to the CLI to get a few things installed that I wanted (printer drivers for my luffable old black and white laser and Adobe Reader which is a lot more flexible than the built-in document viewer), but the painless install, basically totally free suite of software, and the fact that LibreOffice is really coming together and documents are pretty much publication-worthy made it all work okay. My Latitude D620 is perfectly happy running Mint and I'm looking forward to installing 17 which I downloaded over the weekend. It's still not for everyone, but I do like the familiar UI in Cinnamon a lot more than I like Ubuntu's Unity which, just like Windows 8/8.1 was inefficient and ineffective even after a couple of months of daily use.

Also, the GMA 950 does okay with video playback and any of the few Linux native games I tried. It also is happy on Pogo.com and my Webkinz are problem-free in Firefox. Play-on-Linux/IWINE likes Master of Orion 3 so I can have galaxy conquest fun once in a while too.
 
No. Unity (UI) is the Ubuntu killer.

TRUE, that is why I bailed on Ubuntu.

What I have found is the Mint community is much more friendly. This is very important.
If you get a nasty response to a honest question, it is toxic.

If a noob posts a question on the Ubuntu forum a typical response is "Do a search idiot!!"
I found the few guys that post on the non-windows OS page on [H] more helpful than those ass clowns on the ubuntu forums.

More proof that [H] Rocks! :D
 
Back
Top