Respawn Attacks Titanfall Bribery Claims

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
You hear this kind of stuff every time a new triple A game comes out. Respawn Entertainment was not happy at all about it and has responded to the allegations directly.

Anyone who thinks we weren't living in the shadow of decade+ old established franchises at our reveal at E3 are as crazy as their conspiracy theories of anyone getting paid off. We've had to fight tooth and nail to have a game that anyone would even know existed, let alone be excited for and want to create coverage of. I get it that its not for everyone, but to say we're paying anyone off is downright insanity. Not to mention the height of insulting.
 
Payoffs are the only reasonable way to explain the hugely positive reviews. That's the bottom line, payoffs or free drugs.
 
They don't pay them off directly but they do pay for them to fly out to LA, put them up in a hotel, pay for their food and any after hours activity (paintball, firing range.....) It's not respawn's job to let people know this. The publishers of said articles, should tell their readers know what they got in return for writing an article.

I always told my readers/forum members what I got for what I was posting. I did it every time I wrote about EA, Dice, IW, Treyarch, MOH, CoD and BF. They would fly us out there, put us up in a nice hotel, take out out for dinner and other activities and I was always up front. Then again I always told EA/DICE/IW/Treyarch what was wrong with their games. I also got black listed for calling Medal of Honor Airborne a turd (had a great time at Fort Brag but it is what is it and they new that by inviting me).

Some of the bigger media outlets don't tell their readers, that they got all this stuff comped. They really don't want to upset their hosts by calling attention to issues with the game as they want to be invited back the next time or get that scoop when they release the next game in the franchise.
 
Respawn may have not paid for the good reviews, but that doesn't mean that EA hasn't. EA being the publisher means that they spent all the money marketing the product, and I'm sure they want to make sure they get a return on their investment by making sure the sheeple see those high scores.

I don't pay attention much to the review noise, anyway. My opinion is that Titanfall is a lot of fun to play and I will be picking it up on March 11 on PC. Now to figure out which I'm going to play first: Dark Souls 2 or Titanfall... :confused:... :D
 
Respawn may have not paid for the good reviews, but that doesn't mean that EA hasn't. EA being the publisher means that they spent all the money marketing the product, and I'm sure they want to make sure they get a return on their investment by making sure the sheeple see those high scores.

I don't pay attention much to the review noise, anyway. My opinion is that Titanfall is a lot of fun to play and I will be picking it up on March 11 on PC. Now to figure out which I'm going to play first: Dark Souls 2 or Titanfall... :confused:... :D

The answer to that question hands down would be Darks Souls 2, however I'm not sure Darks Souls 2 will be out on PC at that point so that might make your decision a little easier. That is unless you plan on getting Dark Souls 2 for a console.
 
The answer to that question hands down would be Darks Souls 2, however I'm not sure Darks Souls 2 will be out on PC at that point so that might make your decision a little easier. That is unless you plan on getting Dark Souls 2 for a console.
Getting DkS2 for both PC & PS3 ;). I own the first DkS for every platform it was on. I think PC DkS2 is coming out at the end of March.
 
It's not really "paying somebody off" if you just advertise on their site and then pull your advertising if they give you a bad review, is it? I mean, it's not direct. Relying on some reviewers' complete lack of spine to cause them to censor themselves on behalf of their advertisers isn't so much a bribe as it is the (wink wink nudge nudge) industry at work.
 
Considering this is one of the best multiplayer FPS games I've ever played (and i've been playing multiplayer FPS games since Quake 2), I don't see why they would need to bribe anyone.
 
WAIT WAIT WAIT!!! People pay to make sure that products are marketed well? Oh the surprise! After Kane and Lynch I never read another review I believed.
 
Considering this is one of the best multiplayer FPS games I've ever played (and i've been playing multiplayer FPS games since Quake 2), I don't see why they would need to bribe anyone.

Exactly! This game is awesome!
 
What makes it awesome? Can you explain? From all of the videos it looks very bland.
 
Terrible bot AI combined with a gun that aims for you. How is that interesting?

If they had an option to remove the bots and increase the player count I would consider it. As is, no thanks. Our only hope is that they introduce mod support down the line but since it's being published by EA I doubt that is going to happen.

On a positive note, the movement feels nice and I like the mech vs soldier dynamic. Maybe Titanfall 2 will be next-gen only and they can up the map size/player count and ditch the crappy bots.:)
 
If they had an option to remove the bots and increase the player count I would consider it. As is, no thanks. Our only hope is that they introduce mod support down the line but since it's being published by EA I doubt that is going to happen.

If you want mods EA will provide them. They'll add the ability to modify your mech/soldier weapons and look with micro-transactions.
 
WAIT WAIT WAIT!!! People pay to make sure that products are marketed well? Oh the surprise! After Kane and Lynch I never read another review I believed.

There's a little bit of a difference between marketing and flat-out lying on a review for money.
 
Not sure why people are surprised...

It has this COD look to it, can't explain it. Player models/view the way the gun/arms look and move looks like COD. Seems to play like COD.

I know a few that love it and this its fun. The parkour, climbing, jumping dynamic is fun and pretty cool... no need to swipe a good jet/help asset like in BF4 to get to a roof.

Seems like people that like COD multiplay will like this game. Nothing wrong with that.
 
Seems like people that like COD multiplay will like this game. Nothing wrong with that.

Ehhh, wouldn't count on it. I don't like it, it's too boring and the bots just make it worse. Some of the people I play CoD with also don't like it, only one of us actually enjoys it. Maybe the ones who like Ghosts will like it, but that game is even worse than Titanfall. I just don't see the appeal of Titanfall, there's nothing even slightly competitive about it.
 
Considering this is one of the best multiplayer FPS games I've ever played (and i've been playing multiplayer FPS games since Quake 2), I don't see why they would need to bribe anyone.

Lol
 
Not sure why people are surprised...

It has this COD look to it, can't explain it. Player models/view the way the gun/arms look and move looks like COD. Seems to play like COD.

I know a few that love it and this its fun. The parkour, climbing, jumping dynamic is fun and pretty cool... no need to swipe a good jet/help asset like in BF4 to get to a roof.

Seems like people that like COD multiplay will like this game. Nothing wrong with that.
Well I hate Call of Duty multiplayer and I am absolutely loving Titanfall ;). Sure, the gunplay on foot is identical to CoD, but the speed and verticality alone make Titanfall far more enjoyable. Having the Titans and AI actually add depth that make it even more interesting, in my opinion. If you ever bother to do anything but pilot Titans yourself you will see a few awesome tactical options available to you.
 
EA: How badly do you want our ad dollars propping up your site?
Reviewer: Badly!
EA: Well we just love to advertise on sites where we get good reviews....
 
Unless a person puts such reliance on reviews to buy the game, who cares what the marketing tricks were or were not involved?

For me, I'll check it out on Gamefly and if I like it, I'll buy it. I don't give a crap on the veracity or mendacity of the reviews.
 
We already know these kind of shenanigans go on, look at the deal Bioware/EA got for having an IGN employee as part of the Mass Effect 3 game, in return for an almost perfect score (non-biased review my arse).
 
Terrible bot AI combined with a gun that aims for you. How is that interesting?

If they had an option to remove the bots and increase the player count I would consider it. As is, no thanks. Our only hope is that they introduce mod support down the line but since it's being published by EA I doubt that is going to happen.

On a positive note, the movement feels nice and I like the mech vs soldier dynamic. Maybe Titanfall 2 will be next-gen only and they can up the map size/player count and ditch the crappy bots.:)

Oh wow, you're one of those people that want too make this another traditional FPS. We'll it's not a traditional FPS, so get over it. The grunts (bots) aren't meant to challenge you, they're meant to be both tactical by providing attrition points and lower the for your next titanfall, not to mention they provide depth to the battlefield. In all honesty, the grunts are like a mix of MOBA creeps and those adrenaline pills from UT2003.

And the smart gun is essentially useless in a head to head gun fight. I would know since I used it exclusively in the Fracture map. It was the perfect gun for me on that map to kill multiple grunts to get quick titanfall; not to mention it was the perfect gun down oblivious pilots that I could have just jump kicked or executed without having to actually get up close and personal. The smart pistol is easy to avoid by always paying attention to your surroundings and always on the move by way of parkour. Stop running around like infantry, that's what the grunts are for.

It seems the people complaining about these 2 things never played a real twitch shooter in their lives and have only ever played BF and MW. The sort of MoH/CoD elitists that would get their asses handed to themselves in old school twitch shooters like UT and Quake 3 Arena.
 
Oh wow, you're one of those people that want too make this another traditional FPS. We'll it's not a traditional FPS, so get over it. The grunts (bots) aren't meant to challenge you, they're meant to be both tactical by providing attrition points and lower the for your next titanfall, not to mention they provide depth to the battlefield. In all honesty, the grunts are like a mix of MOBA creeps and those adrenaline pills from UT2003.

And the smart gun is essentially useless in a head to head gun fight. I would know since I used it exclusively in the Fracture map. It was the perfect gun for me on that map to kill multiple grunts to get quick titanfall; not to mention it was the perfect gun down oblivious pilots that I could have just jump kicked or executed without having to actually get up close and personal. The smart pistol is easy to avoid by always paying attention to your surroundings and always on the move by way of parkour. Stop running around like infantry, that's what the grunts are for.

It seems the people complaining about these 2 things never played a real twitch shooter in their lives and have only ever played BF and MW. The sort of MoH/CoD elitists that would get their asses handed to themselves in old school twitch shooters like UT and Quake 3 Arena.

If they really wanted to make the Smart Pistol only for farming Grunts, they would have made it far weaker (it's more powerful than the Carbine right now) and made it a secondary (instead of a primary). It's obvious it's supposed to be powerful against everyone, not just Grunts, but the problem is that right now it's a bit too powerful (IMO, anyway). When you get like 50%+ of people all running around with the Smart Pistol most of the time, there's a problem.
 
i tired this game and it's insanely fun on both the PC and xbox. everything feels right but yet it feels like a new kind of a game. The entire gaming community has great reviews on the game from the individual level all the way up to the big reviewers.

Every positive review i read lines up well with my experience in the beta. looking forward to buying it.
 
There's a little bit of a difference between marketing and flat-out lying on a review for money.

Maybe I'm stupid please enlighten me. Money is changing hands to make the product seem more desirable. Newspapers have been doing it for years under the guise of news. You can shape the public opinion fairly easily by paying people to make your product to look needed/awesome/useful. Reviews are very opinion based in their nature, so how can we have adequate standards for writing them? Meaning it is very difficult to prove if I am reviewing a game based on the games merits or simply because I want to keep my job/they paid me to go on a two week vacation to review the game/or because they have vested advertising business in my company.
I think it was Gamespot who steered me wrong with Kane and Lynch and that it came out afterwards that they had been paid off but at that point I had already smashed my controller against the wall and sworn of consoles. The. Controls. Were. So. Bad.
I'm not some crazy anti-marketing stooge but if you don't take the time to actually read what other "respected" gamers(the type are doing than one deserves Sim City (or whatever piece of shit game you are suckered into buying). Just remember Sim City, BF4, and all the other EA games of recent years that failed at launch. Please everyone buy it day 1, then head to your favorite message boards to bitch about how a game was released that is buggy, doesn't do what it's supposed to and is otherwise garbage. The Sim City furor has been dying down and I could use some good laughs again. Don't worry all these games will be playable eventually... Maybe. Please also remember to write that you will never buy another EA game because of it, then run off the purchase whatever steaming pile of shit they use to pull the wool over your eyes, again.
 
If they really wanted to make the Smart Pistol only for farming Grunts, they would have made it far weaker (it's more powerful than the Carbine right now) and made it a secondary (instead of a primary). It's obvious it's supposed to be powerful against everyone, not just Grunts, but the problem is that right now it's a bit too powerful (IMO, anyway). When you get like 50%+ of people all running around with the Smart Pistol most of the time, there's a problem.

The smart pistol is already weak against pilots vs grunts, it takes about 3 seconds to fully lock onto a pilots when it only takes about a second to fully lock onto a grunt. And when aiming down sights the smart lock is disabled making it a weapon that needs as much skill as the Carbine or the SMG.

People like me are running around with the smart gun catching people completely oblivious to their surroundings off-guard. I have lost in almost every single head to head shoot out against a Carbine/SMG welding user; and only in a handful of occasions have I won due to luck or atrocious aiming skills of my opponents.

There are hordes of people who played in the beta as if they were playing BF or MW; running around and barely jumping, double jumping, wall running and wall grabbing. This mad them extremely easy targets to anyone playing with a UT or Quake twitch shooter play style.

The complaints about the smart pistol come from people who are killed by it and lack the skills to avoid that death. Every single person who has the skills to avoid those deaths and have used the smart pistol have said it is incredibly well balanced as is. When comparing 2 players of equal skill on a head to head shoot out, the smart pistol user will lose every single time; but it's incredibly fun to catch sitting ducks off-guard and kill them after a lock on. Why? Because you know they're staring at their screen cursing the smart pistol and lying to themselves thinking that if it were any other gun they would have survived.
 
Maybe I'm stupid please enlighten me. Money is changing hands to make the product seem more desirable. Newspapers have been doing it for years under the guise of news. You can shape the public opinion fairly easily by paying people to make your product to look needed/awesome/useful. Reviews are very opinion based in their nature, so how can we have adequate standards for writing them? Meaning it is very difficult to prove if I am reviewing a game based on the games merits or simply because I want to keep my job/they paid me to go on a two week vacation to review the game/or because they have vested advertising business in my company.

I get your point, but on the one hand you are putting out marketing materials (screenshots/ads/whatever) which, admittedly, could and have been deceptive from certain companies in the past (and those companies get called out on that..."false advertising" is a thing), but you are still seeing the materials and judging for yourself. With a review, you are inherently trusting that the reviewer knows something about games and that, while their opinion may differ from yours on the whole, they are presenting what the game is objectively as well as giving a review score (which you don't have to pay attention to, necessarily). If reviewers are paid off they are intentionally deceiving their audience, same as false advertising. As you said, at that point there is no reason to believe their reviews, but without an aggregate idea of how a game is based on reviews, videos, etc...how would you know whether or not a game is worth buying?

So yeah, I guess you could loosely call it a form of "marketing" but it really seems a lot more devious than that.
 
They don't pay them off directly but they do pay for them to fly out to LA, put them up in a hotel, pay for their food and any after hours activity (paintball, firing range.....) It's not respawn's job to let people know this.
I only have first hand experience with the auto-industry, but manufacturers there will actually blacklist a journalist that are either known to provide negative reviews, or worse have given that manufacturer a negative review in the past.

That means that not only that they don't get the luxury pamper treatment, they don't get the ad revenue dollars for their publication, but they don't even get early access or loaners of the product at all so their review is painfully late.

This means that they are quickly rendered poor and irrelevant timetable wise, making it not just a honey-pot reward for a good review but a merciless D-in-your-A if you write a bad review and get blacklisted.
 
I couldn't care less if they bribed anyone or not because EA publishes it. It can be the best game in the world but because EA publishes it I will not even consider touching it.
 
The smart pistol is already weak against pilots vs grunts, it takes about 3 seconds to fully lock onto a pilots when it only takes about a second to fully lock onto a grunt. And when aiming down sights the smart lock is disabled making it a weapon that needs as much skill as the Carbine or the SMG.

I think 3 full seconds is questionable...I've watched kill cams and it's really more like 1.5 seconds with the better targeting perk, around 2 or so without. It's pretty fast.

When you aim down sights, as you said it needs the same skill as the Carbine or SMG...except, it actually does more damage than those weapons so already it is ahead there.

People like me are running around with the smart gun catching people completely oblivious to their surroundings off-guard. I have lost in almost every single head to head shoot out against a Carbine/SMG welding user; and only in a handful of occasions have I won due to luck or atrocious aiming skills of my opponents.

That can happen, yes, but as I said before, it does more damage than either of those other weapons, so in a close-range head-to-head fight you can still be killed by the smart pistol faster than you can shoot with the other weapons. It's happened to me several times, even when every single one of my shots connected with the Carbine or SMG. You can basically fire the smart pistol as fast as you can click the mouse, so ROF isn't really an issue with it.

The complaints about the smart pistol come from people who are killed by it and lack the skills to avoid that death. Every single person who has the skills to avoid those deaths and have used the smart pistol have said it is incredibly well balanced as is. When comparing 2 players of equal skill on a head to head shoot out, the smart pistol user will lose every single time

Funny, because I've heard barely anyone saying the smart pistol is balanced. And I don't think it's because no one knows how to play a twitch shooter. And again, your last statement there is wrong as I explained above.
 
Just remember Sim City, BF4, and all the other EA games of recent years that failed at launch. Please everyone buy it day 1, then head to your favorite message boards to bitch about how a game was released that is buggy, doesn't do what it's supposed to and is otherwise garbage. The Sim City furor has been dying down and I could use some good laughs again. Don't worry all these games will be playable eventually... Maybe. Please also remember to write that you will never buy another EA game because of it, then run off the purchase whatever steaming pile of shit they use to pull the wool over your eyes, again.

Titanfall so far is a very good game, but I'll be waiting for reviews from real gamers before purchasing. The Beta was very limited in content (2 maps, 4 main weapons, 2 side weapons, 2 anti-titan weapons, 1 titan model Atlas but Ogre burn card for those lucky to get one).

The only real problems I encounter where flickering in the burn card menu screen, the occasional crash to desktop and the worst one was the atrocious netcode; but giving that it is a Beta I'm hoping that the full game will be much more robust and that the netcode is improved.

Sometimes my ping would be 130'ish ms and I'd get a "Trying to re-connect" warning 3-4 times every minute. And let's be honest, 130ms ping sucks, but I shouldn't have been seeing that warning at all, so I'm hoping it was just the stress to the already limited servers online for the beta. That and the killcam sometimes showing something entirely different than what happened; yeah, wow.
 
I couldn't care less if they bribed anyone or not because EA publishes it. It can be the best game in the world but because EA publishes it I will not even consider touching it.

Honestly I mean this in a not creepy way. I want to hug you. Tightly. I don't support not buying a game just because EA publishes it but at least you know to wait to see if it is riddled with bugs to the point of zero playability.
 
Titanfall so far is a very good game, but I'll be waiting for reviews from real gamers before purchasing. The Beta was very limited in content (2 maps, 4 main weapons, 2 side weapons, 2 anti-titan weapons, 1 titan model Atlas but Ogre burn card for those lucky to get one).

The only real problems I encounter where flickering in the burn card menu screen, the occasional crash to desktop and the worst one was the atrocious netcode; but giving that it is a Beta I'm hoping that the full game will be much more robust and that the netcode is improved.

Sometimes my ping would be 130'ish ms and I'd get a "Trying to re-connect" warning 3-4 times every minute. And let's be honest, 130ms ping sucks, but I shouldn't have been seeing that warning at all, so I'm hoping it was just the stress to the already limited servers online for the beta. That and the killcam sometimes showing something entirely different than what happened; yeah, wow.
I've had the same connection problems, but I think it depends on how quickly the game retrieves a matchmaking list. Every time I have had a problem I would be connected to the 9th or 10th list according to the game. When this happened my pings would be in the 150-200 range with frequent spikes to 600-700. If the game is able to connect to the 1st - 4th list, my pings would be in the 40-50 range with no connection problems. You can force the game to change lists by quitting to the main menu and selecting Play again. This is just my theory based on my own experience.
 
I think 3 full seconds is questionable...I've watched kill cams and it's really more like 1.5 seconds with the better targeting perk, around 2 or so without. It's pretty fast.

When you aim down sights, as you said it needs the same skill as the Carbine or SMG...except, it actually does more damage than those weapons so already it is ahead there.



That can happen, yes, but as I said before, it does more damage than either of those other weapons, so in a close-range head-to-head fight you can still be killed by the smart pistol faster than you can shoot with the other weapons. It's happened to me several times, even when every single one of my shots connected with the Carbine or SMG. You can basically fire the smart pistol as fast as you can click the mouse, so ROF isn't really an issue with it.



Funny, because I've heard barely anyone saying the smart pistol is balanced. And I don't think it's because no one knows how to play a twitch shooter. And again, your last statement there is wrong as I explained above.

This video proves my point nicely:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HCTlgxCtJL0

Every single person he kills is a siting duck and/or has atrocious aiming skill. They do nothing but strafe; no jumping, no wall running, no wall climbing, no wall grabbing, just straight up strafing left or right or just being completely unaware of their surroundings and having incredibly slow reaction times.

If you have video proof of otherwise, please post it; otherwise everything you've said is just plain FUD.
 
i tired this game and it's insanely fun on both the PC and xbox. everything feels right but yet it feels like a new kind of a game. The entire gaming community has great reviews on the game from the individual level all the way up to the big reviewers.

Every positive review i read lines up well with my experience in the beta. looking forward to buying it.

Thank you, a token of our appreciation is in the mail.

Best,
Andrew Wilson
CEO, Electronic Arts
 
This video proves my point nicely:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HCTlgxCtJL0

Every single person he kills is a siting duck and/or has atrocious aiming skill. They do nothing but strafe; no jumping, no wall running, no wall climbing, no wall grabbing, just straight up strafing left or right or just being completely unaware of their surroundings and having incredibly slow reaction times.

If you have video proof of otherwise, please post it; otherwise everything you've said is just plain FUD.

In the first 10 seconds of that video you can see him gaining a full lock on a Pilot in just under 2 seconds, according to the YouTube timecode.

The damage thing is clearly displayed in the weapon statistics.

So what part of what I said is FUD again?
 
In the first 10 seconds of that video you can see him gaining a full lock on a Pilot in just under 2 seconds, according to the YouTube timecode.

The damage thing is clearly displayed in the weapon statistics.

So what part of what I said is FUD again?

My apologies, you didn't directly say it, but the impression that I got was that somehow a Carbine user should never be killed by a smart pistol user in a head to head shoot out. When in reality it has enough rate of fire and damage for a skilled player to not only survive a head to head shot out, but win depending on his/her opponents skill.

The damage is less than the shotgun at close quarters combat and the Carbine with proper aiming for the head. The rate of fire seems correct for a gun it's size, but all of this is currently inconsequential as the majority of the people complaining about it are siting turds on the map ready to be stepped on. My stats were a perfect example of just how powerful the smart gun is; most used weapon was the smart gun which I used for almost the entire first day I started the beta and the used exclusively in the Fracture map, the most efficient weapon was the shotgun which I used exclusively in the Angel City map when I became proficient with the smart gun because Angel City has just too many parkour possibilities and a slew of of nooks and crannies to duck behind making the shotgun perfect for one shot in your face kills when you run into each other or for those trying to parkour away from you.

Besides, this was only the beta, I'm sure Respawn will tweak certain aspects of the game as time goes on after release. But make no mistake, people crying about "Bots have to go" or "smart pistol has to go/get nerfed" are the ones who want to ruin this game, and I for one hope that Respawn sticks to it's guns and keeps this game almost identical to the beta with only small or minor improvements along the way.

The gameplay is fun for everyone, even the casual FPS players like myself (I turned from hard-core FPS to casual when nearly all FPS shooters started going the way of military simulators such as America's ARMY). This game is designed to be a game that casual players can enjoy while still appealing to those of us that like to be competitive, and so far it's got a wonderful balance for both camps. Casual players can feel some achievement by killing grunts and specters all the while helping their team gain attrition points instead of being annoyed of being killed over and over and never killing anything or anyone, competitive players can go all out on pilots and titans to boost their K/D ratio and feeling like they pwn the opposing team.
 
Back
Top