First Windows 8 Update Halfway Done

http://xkcd.com/1172/

That's all I hear from people crying about the move from a start menu to a start screen.

You don't like live tiles? Disable them
Don't like the metro apps? Delete them, and only install desktop apps
Want an apple-like dock? Pin to the taskbar
Need something not pinned on start screen? Start typing to search, just like the 7 menu


Yes you really are making mountains here... A drill down menu is not more efficient than the start screen. Anyone that drills down to the application has a stupid workflow anyway. If you need access frequently it should be pinned to somethig. If you use something sporatically, it should be searched for. You can't get more efficient than that, and 8 is the same as 7 in that aspect.

This arrogance is exactly the problem with Windows 8. I will not have Microsoft or anyone else dictating how I use MY computer or what MY workflow should be like. Good interface design caters to the user and not to the idiot fashion designer that they put in charge of creating the interface.

Yes, the Start Screen is less efficient because it disrupts the workflow. It forces everything else away and takes over the entire screen. It is obnoxious and poorly thought out. Do not try and tell me that it is the same or that it is more efficient when I have tried and used both.
 
This arrogance is exactly the problem with Windows 8. I will not have Microsoft or anyone else dictating how I use MY computer or what MY workflow should be like. Good interface design caters to the user and not to the idiot fashion designer that they put in charge of creating the interface.

Yes, the Start Screen is less efficient because it disrupts the workflow. It forces everything else away and takes over the entire screen. It is obnoxious and poorly thought out. Do not try and tell me that it is the same or that it is more efficient when I have tried and used both.

THIS!
 
Really? So your complaint is it should be what you want out of the box or else it sucks? These are minor customizations to tailor the OS (start screen) to how you want. I have to do the same thing with a fresh install of windows 7... No OS is perfect out of the box, but at least you have the option to customize it yourself.

And obviously it has to suck if people complain right? Because 90% of the complaints I see are from forum parrots that have spent little to no time on the OS. Yet they continue to spam every windows 8 post with rants about how much it sucks and MS failed. Most of the bitching can be boiled down to change. It doesn't matter what change MS made, there would still be an 'outcry' of how shitty MS is for making the change.

*Forgot to add this to my previous post, and I can't edit.

I made these changes on my surface pro as well. So this is not something you have to do to make the start screen more "non-touch friendly". It's extra customization you need to do on a new OS.

Well, yes. As a paying customer, the product SHOULD BE what I want it to be out of the box. Win95 was, Win98 was, Win2K was, WinXP was, WinVi was, Win7 is, and Win8 is not. I don't see a "need" to have to customize anything on whatever OS I use. Win8 is the first turd of a MS OS I've encountered since WinME, but not because it's overly buggy and unstable, but because the revamped interface and removal of key features I want are how it is out of the box. Like I said, if you love Win8 because it works for you, then great. That's certainly no reason to think that everyone should use and love it. People are allowed to like or dislike the same things, you know.
 
This arrogance is exactly the problem with Windows 8. I will not have Microsoft or anyone else dictating how I use MY computer or what MY workflow should be like. Good interface design caters to the user and not to the idiot fashion designer that they put in charge of creating the interface.

Yes, the Start Screen is less efficient because it disrupts the workflow. It forces everything else away and takes over the entire screen. It is obnoxious and poorly thought out. Do not try and tell me that it is the same or that it is more efficient when I have tried and used both.

It's customizable. Set it how you want it... and oftentimes, the UI designer DOES know better than you. People whinged about the Ribbon UI for a few, before realizing it kicks ass and is incredibly efficient, too ;). People whined about the XP being "fisher price start button crap" way back when as well. I like Win8 and find it superior to Win7, as do many.
 
It's customizable. Set it how you want it... and oftentimes, the UI designer DOES know better than you. People whinged about the Ribbon UI for a few, before realizing it kicks ass and is incredibly efficient, too ;). People whined about the XP being "fisher price start button crap" way back when as well. I like Win8 and find it superior to Win7, as do many.

UI designers are nothing more than glorified fashion designers.

The ribbon doesn't work better for me. I challenge any Word user to beat me in efficiency or speed with me using VIM/LaTeX. It wouldn't even be a competition; I'd be done while the Word user would be ready to toss their computer out the window because Word refuses to allow them to layout the document exactly how they want it and they can't find the functions because Microsoft moved them around.
 
UI designers are nothing more than glorified fashion designers.

The ribbon doesn't work better for me. I challenge any Word user to beat me in efficiency or speed with me using VIM/LaTeX. It wouldn't even be a competition; I'd be done while the Word user would be ready to toss their computer out the window because Word refuses to allow them to layout the document exactly how they want it and they can't find the functions because Microsoft moved them around.

Bwahaha, you clearly haven't used Word since Office 97. Word is extremely intuitive and efficient. As far as UI designers, they are actually usability designers, the "Fashion" is just window dressing to make it look pretty. Pretty sad you don't even know the things you're trying to talk about... I guess there's little point in bothering to argue further since you simply don't have the knowledge to have any meaningful discussion with. :(
 
UI designers are nothing more than glorified fashion designers.

The ribbon doesn't work better for me. I challenge any Word user to beat me in efficiency or speed with me using VIM/LaTeX. It wouldn't even be a competition; I'd be done while the Word user would be ready to toss their computer out the window because Word refuses to allow them to layout the document exactly how they want it and they can't find the functions because Microsoft moved them around.

What does a document markup language used for typesetting have to do with a WYSIWYG word processor that's used to create content for typesetting or conventional printing? Not at all the same tools.
 
What does a document markup language used for typesetting have to do with a WYSIWYG word processor that's used to create content for typesetting or conventional printing? Not at all the same tools.

Both are designed to allow the user to create formatted documents.
 
Bwahaha, you clearly haven't used Word since Office 97. Word is extremely intuitive and efficient. As far as UI designers, they are actually usability designers, the "Fashion" is just window dressing to make it look pretty. Pretty sad you don't even know the things you're trying to talk about... I guess there's little point in bothering to argue further since you simply don't have the knowledge to have any meaningful discussion with. :(

And you've clearly never used VIM or LaTeX. I have experience with all versions of Word; I have to support other users who use it so I am completely familiar with all of its shortcomings and idiosyncrasies.

"Usability designers" is to user interface designers what "executive assistant" is to secretary.
 
And you've clearly never used VIM or LaTeX. I have experience with all versions of Word; I have to support other users who use it so I am completely familiar with all of its shortcomings and idiosyncrasies.

"Usability designers" is to user interface designers what "executive assistant" is to secretary.


Actually, a UI designer encompasses the look, layout, and functionality of a user interface. As I said, you have no idea what you're talking about here. And, Word is not a plain-text editor ;).
 
Both are designed to allow the user to create formatted documents.

I used to work for a large printer and the comparison you make is specious at best. Typesetting is all about layout, a word processor is very primitive by comparison in the layout department and focused on the creation of content. Give a typical officer worker typesetting tools to produce the standard work products that come out of Word and they will shot you.
 
Actually, a UI designer encompasses the look, layout, and functionality of a user interface. As I said, you have no idea what you're talking about here. And, Word is not a plain-text editor ;).

LaTeX isn't for creating text files. LaTeX is a document markup language used to create formatted documents. The only commercial word-processor that even comes close to LaTeX is Wordperfect with reveal codes. LaTeX is used to do the same functions as Word.

As for usability designers, you yourself just wrote :
As far as UI designers, they are actually usability designers
 
I gave windows 8 a legitimate shot. Windows 8 isn't that bad if you :

Can get drivers for your hardware that actually work correctly.

Only use 1 monitor.

Completely ignore all the metro apps.
 
I used to work for a large printer and the comparison you make is specious at best. Typesetting is all about layout, a word processor is very primitive by comparison in the layout department and focused on the creation of content. Give a typical officer worker typesetting tools to produce the standard work products that come out of Word and they will shot you.

Before the dumbing down of computing for the lowest common-denominator of people, people whose intelligence barely qualifies as human, office workers used WordPerfect's Reveal Codes feature all the time. Reveal Codes is not unlike LaTeX; in both cases, you are manually manipulating the format of documents by using a markup language.
 
This arrogance is exactly the problem with Windows 8. I will not have Microsoft or anyone else dictating how I use MY computer or what MY workflow should be like. Good interface design caters to the user and not to the idiot fashion designer that they put in charge of creating the interface.

Yes, the Start Screen is less efficient because it disrupts the workflow. It forces everything else away and takes over the entire screen. It is obnoxious and poorly thought out. Do not try and tell me that it is the same or that it is more efficient when I have tried and used both.

This is what I love about Linux-distros. You get your choice of desktop environments, themes and customizations that on Windows would require hacking something like the uxtheme.dll file or buying one of Stardock's different products to do something equivalent. KDE, e17, Cinnamon, and if you don't mind it too much Gnome 3.

It's between your choice (your computer) versus their choice (Microsoft's). I'm not sure how much money spent on user research to determine this was the best UI for BOTH tablet and desktop. Even the Windows 8 commercials are only showcasing touchscreen desktop monitors, tablets and laptops. They're not showing how "normal" user can use it with a traditional input method-- keyboard and mouse.

Not everyone has a touchscreen monitor. Heck, I've tried a graphics tablet, it's not the same thing.
 
This is what I love about Linux-distros. You get your choice of desktop environments, themes and customizations that on Windows would require hacking something like the uxtheme.dll file or buying one of Stardock's different products to do something equivalent. KDE, e17, Cinnamon, and if you don't mind it too much Gnome 3.

Windows has never been about UI customization, it has been about 3rd party support for applications and software. Customization is great but the choice of lots of hardware and software is more compelling for people that simply want to use their computers to do things more than customize it infinitely.

They're not showing how "normal" user can use it with a traditional input method-- keyboard and mouse.

Not everyone has a touchscreen monitor. Heck, I've tried a graphics tablet, it's not the same thing.

Everyone already has a keyboard and mouse pointer driven PC already,
 
Who else saw the thread title and thought "heatlesssun is going to be in there white knighting Microsoft?"
 
Who else saw the thread title and thought "heatlesssun is going to be in there white knighting Microsoft?"

Who else knew the typical OMG FOSS RULEZ crowd would be there in a heartbeat? Get off the pretend high-horse with your double standards.
 
Even the Windows 8 commercials are only showcasing touchscreen desktop monitors, tablets and laptops. They're not showing how "normal" user can use it with a traditional input method-- keyboard and mouse.

And breakdancing. A whole lot of clicking in keyboards and creepy breakdancing like some aspergers GAP commercial and really not much else. These ad agencies must be pinching themselves for multi-million dollar checks to churn out criminal level of uninspired wannabe-hipster dreck.

Prepare to be douche-chilled: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vS_tHDr0Z4Y
 
And as a disclaimer, I've been using W8 on my HTPC for a while. Just like Apple products, it does a fine job of it's primary purpose: content consumption.

Win8 is a great OS to run on a toy. Works beautifully for watching movies and TV. But my workstation will be running Win7 for a long time yet.
 
If you don't like Metro, just use a start replacement. Holy fuck you have to spend 30 seconds downloading something that will easily fix your most major gripe, world ending.

What is the problem again?
 
And as a disclaimer, I've been using W8 on my HTPC for a while. Just like Apple products, it does a fine job of it's primary purpose: content consumption.

Win8 is a great OS to run on a toy. Works beautifully for watching movies and TV. But my workstation will be running Win7 for a long time yet.

This makes no sense. The same apps that I people use to work as well or better in Windows 8 compared to 7. If you're in the Start Menu or Start Screen you're not really doing much work, all of that's done in the apps.
 
And as a disclaimer, I've been using W8 on my HTPC for a while. Just like Apple products, it does a fine job of it's primary purpose: content consumption.

Win8 is a great OS to run on a toy. Works beautifully for watching movies and TV. But my workstation will be running Win7 for a long time yet.

Huh? The start menu/screen has zero to do with working.
 
Huh? The start menu/screen has zero to do with working.

Covered above, the start screen is a direct disruption of workflow. "OH YOU NEED TO LAUNCH SOMETHING HOLD ON LET ME HIDE EVERYTHING AND DISPLAY THIS REALLY COOL FLIPPY ANIMATION WHILE WE FIND WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING FOR, YOU DIDN'T NEED TO SEE THAT LOG FILE YOU HAD OPEN DID YOU?"
 
Covered above, the start screen is a direct disruption of workflow. "OH YOU NEED TO LAUNCH SOMETHING HOLD ON LET ME HIDE EVERYTHING AND DISPLAY THIS REALLY COOL FLIPPY ANIMATION WHILE WE FIND WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING FOR, YOU DIDN'T NEED TO SEE THAT LOG FILE YOU HAD OPEN DID YOU?"

HUH? WHAT AM I LOOKING FOR THAT MY ATTENTION ISN'T DIVERTED ANYWAY AND I CAN'T JUST TYPE IT LIKE I WOULD HAVE UNDER WINDOWS 7? AND WHY DO I NEED TO SEE THIS LOG FILE TO KNOW WHAT I ALREADY DECIDED I NEEDED TO OPEN? FINALLY I CAN TYPE INSTANTLY EVEN WITH THE ZERO POINT TWO (TWO TENTHS OF A SECOND) FLIPPY ANIMATION GOING ON, SO WHY WOULD I WAIT FOR IT TO FINISH IN THE FIRST PLACE? WHY AM I SPENDING TIME IN THE START MENU/SCREEN INSTEAD OF WORKING? Oh, oops, capslock.... ;).
 
HUH? WHAT AM I LOOKING FOR THAT MY ATTENTION ISN'T DIVERTED ANYWAY AND I CAN'T JUST TYPE IT LIKE I WOULD HAVE UNDER WINDOWS 7? AND WHY DO I NEED TO SEE THIS LOG FILE TO KNOW WHAT I ALREADY DECIDED I NEEDED TO OPEN? FINALLY I CAN TYPE INSTANTLY EVEN WITH THE ZERO POINT TWO (TWO TENTHS OF A SECOND) FLIPPY ANIMATION GOING ON, SO WHY WOULD I WAIT FOR IT TO FINISH IN THE FIRST PLACE? WHY AM I SPENDING TIME IN THE START MENU/SCREEN INSTEAD OF WORKING? Oh, oops, capslock.... ;).

Pssst... Someone said something bad about Nvidia in the video card section. :D
 
Covered above, the start screen is a direct disruption of workflow. "OH YOU NEED TO LAUNCH SOMETHING HOLD ON LET ME HIDE EVERYTHING AND DISPLAY THIS REALLY COOL FLIPPY ANIMATION WHILE WE FIND WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING FOR, YOU DIDN'T NEED TO SEE THAT LOG FILE YOU HAD OPEN DID YOU?"

If there was something one needed from that log file for their next task they'd copy and paste. Because the next app or task coming out of Start Menu or Start Screen would probably cover up that log file anyway.
 
Better check again. I don't participate in forum trolling.

IOW, I have a life.

Really? Could have fooled me. :D

I just like to come in and kick various <Insert Product Name Here> Hammer Legion members and I noticed you a long time ago. I'm beginning to wonder if you and heatless have signed some secret troll pact. ;)
 
people use windows 8 by choice?

everybody I know is still buying what ever windows 7 they can find.

Win 8 is pretty nice for an HTPC. I also am running it on my laptop and I ran it on my desktop until I started parting it out. I don't love Win 8 but it's not nearly as bad as a lot of people say it is. If you put the desktop tile in the upper left corner of the metro screen then metro is more or less a cool screen saver that you have to push enter to get past.
 
Back
Top