Apple Wins A Broad User-Interface Patent

lol, no they're basically identical

even my left-brain dominant roommate and his broadcom co-workers were all joking about the new "s-pad" [samsung iPad] over lunch when we went into the store last week looking at new phones to buy.

Sorry but if you can't distinguish the physical and cosmetic differences between an iPad and a Samsung Galaxy Tablet you are retarded.
 
hmmm random internet troll vs. broadcomm engineers....

bet you're a fun guy to spend a lunch break with
 
lol, no they're basically identical

even my left-brain dominant roommate and his broadcom co-workers were all joking about the new "s-pad" [samsung iPad] over lunch when we went into the store last week looking at new phones to buy.

It is much more likely that Apple copied the idea from Samsung.

Samsung have been developing flat panel display components, as well as full consumer products, for years. Such a display developer is likely to have produced a substantial amount of graphic drawing evidence for a wide range of enclosure designs going way back.
 
hmmm random internet troll vs. broadcomm engineers....

bet you're a fun guy to spend a lunch break with

Put it this way: Apple would be a threat the Human Race, because Apple would be a threat to the Internet, because you would only be allowed to view it through their interface.:eek:
 
hmmm random internet troll vs. broadcomm engineers....

bet you're a fun guy to spend a lunch break with


As an engineer you should be able to visually tell the difference between the two products. I am a traffic manager at steel service center and I can go out to our plant and eye ball the difference between something that is 9.56" tall by 7.47" wide the original iPad dimensions and something that is 7.484" tall by 4.72" wide the dimensions of the original Galaxy Tab. Then there is the phyical difference in overall aspect ratio of the screen, the different physical location of the front facing camera and finally the cosmetic difference of SAMSUNG across the top of the Galaxy Tab. If you're comparing the newer 10.1" Galaxy Tab the dimensions are 10.11" tall by 6.9" wide again you should be able to eye ball the 1/2" + difference in dimensions, different aspect ratio, camera placement and again SAMSUNG on the front of the product. Hell we haven't even looked at the differences of the physical buttons and what the backs to each product looks like. Yep they look identical to me. And yes my co-workers enjoy having me around cause I am the smart-ass that breaks up the monotony of our long days ;)
 
Why didn't someone patent this before 2007 so Apple wouldn't get it and everyone could use it freely?
 
Why didn't someone patent this before 2007 so Apple wouldn't get it and everyone could use it freely?

one acronym...(F)RAND. Before apple got too big for their britches...people had patents...they cross licensed and the world moved on. Only time lawsuites happened is when either something was truely special or somebody tried to not pay their reasonable share. However, apple thinks everything they do is special and a fair share is your child's virginity.
 
Why didn't someone patent this before 2007 so Apple wouldn't get it and everyone could use it freely?

Because of this?
5095760071_4b6a55e31a_m.jpg
 
I don't know how old you are, but this was not the first. You can go back further (unless you don't want to).

_PILOT.GIF


Philosophy: Don’t kill the competition. Just do it better.:cool:
 
[H]ocusPocus;1038949733 said:
Funny, the pic posted on the front page reminds me of my old Compaq iPaq.

Basically none of the old PDA entities exist or car about this type of item anymore. Why not make a grab for the IP associated with those devices.

I hope this is just a vague patent title, which are allowed to be vague, and we're really talking about some very specific nuance.
 
I don't know how old you are, but this was not the first. You can go back further (unless you don't want to).

_PILOT.GIF


Philosophy: Don’t kill the competition. Just do it better.:cool:

Before your Palm PDA, there was this:

404px-Apple_Newton-IMG_0454-cropped.jpg


And before Apple, there was Psion.
 
Before your Palm PDA, there was this:

404px-Apple_Newton-IMG_0454-cropped.jpg


And before Apple, there was Psion.

Yes. (I used to program for the Palm. Still have dev tools). I think that they later did an Internet access version.

One thing that is significant, though, is that they were never major products. The new tablet products are, and are likely to be the common interface to access all information.

Philosophy: Don’t kill the competition. Just do it better.:cool: (I am going to see if I can spread this slogan)
 
The Patent "system" needs simply to be returned to the way it was from 1790 to 1980.

Then Ronnie Raygun and the conservatives "fixed" it, well done.

Meantime, almost every patent Apple or any of the others have filed in the last 30 years are... OBVIOUS UNDER THE ART. Meaning any engineer in the field can and would come up with the same thing.

Just because a business decides to build a "thing" doesn't make it PATENTABLE, patent-ability is actually a well defined quality. The problem is, the US Patent Office no longer assesses or determines or judges on patent-ability, they instead rubber stamp everything and pass responsibility on to business and the courts to make the judgments and determinations that the US Patent Office was established under the constitution to make.

The Patent Office just collects the filing fees and ships the responsibility off to someone else. This was the precise defect that was warned of at the time, when Raygun was switching the Patent Office from a congress funded government agency to a 100% FEE based and funded agency.

Welcome to the world of unintended (yet well warned of) consequences of changing something that worked fine for 200 years.... and simply needed MORE FUNDING to handle the increased demand for and complexity of the task at hand.

The concept of a patent or copyright, as defined by the founding fathers is REQUIRED for the smooth running of commerce and business. What we have now is an abomination wrought by accident by the "all gubment is bad" wing of the conservative party.
 
If you're comparing the newer 10.1" Galaxy Tab the dimensions are 10.11" tall by 6.9" wide again you should be able to eye ball the 1/2" + difference in dimensions, different aspect ratio, camera placement and again SAMSUNG on the front of the product. Hell we haven't even looked at the differences of the physical buttons and what the backs to each product looks like. Yep they look identical to me.
You haven't actually seen one in real life apparently.

The most obvious part of your post is that you keep repeating that they have "Samsung" emblazoned across the front...when in fact there is no such thing:

34-131-162-04.jpg

and if you think that doesn't look exactly like an iPad, then you haven't actually held an iPad in real life either which seems fairly obvious from your past few posts in this thread.
 
You haven't actually seen one in real life apparently.

The most obvious part of your post is that you keep repeating that they have "Samsung" emblazoned across the front...when in fact there is no such thing:

34-131-162-04.jpg

and if you think that doesn't look exactly like an iPad, then you haven't actually held an iPad in real life either which seems fairly obvious from your past few posts in this thread.

The image you pasted was of a Samsung Tablet PC not the android one that clearly does have the word Samsung on it. They don't look the same at all. One has a giant fucking stupid button at the bottom, the other actually has a working UI that inst made for the brain dead.

34-131-230-10.jpg
 
whichever one they have in the tmobile store...doesn't have samsung along the bottom but regardless that's the only difference and they're identical otherwise when you pick them up

but if you want to nitpick go right ahead every sensible person knows they are far more similar than different
 
The image you pasted...

Just put the troll on ignore. He'll keep responding and responding with bullshit remarks using as much selective information as possible. He'll argue semantics that have nothing to do with the topic at hand... If it's about a defective GPU subject to recall, he'll split hairs about when the thing was made to avoid acknowledging that it was still a defective part in design. All else fails, he'll accuse you of following him into threads to troll when you posted in the thread before he did.
 
Just put the troll on ignore. He'll keep responding and responding with bullshit remarks using as much selective information as possible. He'll argue semantics that have nothing to do with the topic at hand... If it's about a defective GPU subject to recall, he'll split hairs about when the thing was made to avoid acknowledging that it was still a defective part in design. All else fails, he'll accuse you of following him into threads to troll when you posted in the thread before he did.

+1, not worth pursuing the conversation.
 
Just put the troll on ignore. He'll keep responding and responding with bullshit remarks using as much selective information as possible. He'll argue semantics that have nothing to do with the topic at hand... If it's about a defective GPU subject to recall, he'll split hairs about when the thing was made to avoid acknowledging that it was still a defective part in design. All else fails, he'll accuse you of following him into threads to troll when you posted in the thread before he did.
selective information like a picture of the actual device vs. a mock-up with samsung along the bottom?

how can you guys who champion android devices have no real world experience with them? you haven't ever held one in your hand? they don't have samsung written across the bottom. that would be stupid, for one thing, then the samsung would be all weird when you turn the device in portrait mode or upside down :|

as for the rest of your commentary you're referring to an old locked thread from what, five months ago? I can't believe you're still butthurt over that but whatever LMAO. and you *do* follow me around and post derogatory remarks about me just like you've done in this thread right here in this quoted post. and then you usually follow it up with a public expression of how you've got me on ignore or how you'll put me on ignore...instead of just you know doing it and not posting about me???

although at least you don't go around pm'ing me like maverick to continue the conversation while publicly pretending to have me on ignore. not sure which one takes the cake but you both have some strange issues
 
Today, 04:39 PM
Remove user from ignore list
mope54
This message is hidden because mope54 is on your ignore list.

rSwPG.jpg


(I don't even need to be able to read his post to know he's sniveling about me. Even in silence, he's that predictable.)
 
although at least you don't go around pm'ing me like maverick to continue the conversation while publicly pretending to have me on ignore. not sure which one takes the cake but you both have some strange issues

Oh god... :rolleyes:

I love how you continue to bring that shit up. The reason I PMed you ONE FUCKING TIME was because I didn't want to continue to crap up the thread and you wouldn't let it go. So I decided to do the responsible/considerate thing and take it to PM, yet you keep using it as some example of insanity.

Seriously, stop trolling. Just stop.
 
how is you pm'ing me after a thread gets locked equate to me not letting it go?

and the both of you bringing it up every chance you get in every other thread I post in?


I didn't say it's insanity but it is weird to me...
 
Just put the troll on ignore. He'll keep responding and responding with bullshit remarks using as much selective information as possible. He'll argue semantics that have nothing to do with the topic at hand... If it's about a defective GPU subject to recall, he'll split hairs about when the thing was made to avoid acknowledging that it was still a defective part in design. All else fails, he'll accuse you of following him into threads to troll when you posted in the thread before he did.

+1 from me to.
I have had the same problem with “mope54” on other threads.
He seems to go around projecting his crap onto things, just so that he can say that it is crap.;)
(Probably some school kid. Perhaps I should know better.:eek:)
 
+1 from me to.
I have had the same problem with “mope54” on other threads.
He seems to go around projecting his crap onto things, just so that he can say that it is crap.;)
(Probably some school kid. Perhaps I should know better.:eek:)

I just saw your response in that thread, so yeah, you know exactly what I'm talking about. It takes a special kind of idiot to willfully and continually engage in those kinds of mental gymnastics.

Personally, I'm still trying to figure out just what exactly is so "enthusiast" about Apple iProducts.
 
whichever one they have in the tmobile store...doesn't have samsung along the bottom but regardless that's the only difference and they're identical otherwise when you pick them up

but if you want to nitpick go right ahead every sensible person knows they are far more similar than different

A tablet is a screen with some electronics behind it. It looks like any other screen with stuff behind it. I don't get why it's worth even arguing about looks when there's really no other way to make a screen look than like a screen.

Apple makes laptop computers. Apple didn't make the first laptop computer. I don't see anyone jumping up and down, trolling, and screaming about how Apple stole the look of a laptop from some other company or how they stole the idea of a keyboard from a typewriter.
 
A tablet is a screen with some electronics behind it. It looks like any other screen with stuff behind it. I don't get why it's worth even arguing about looks when there's really no other way to make a screen look than like a screen.

Apple makes laptop computers. Apple didn't make the first laptop computer. I don't see anyone jumping up and down, trolling, and screaming about how Apple stole the look of a laptop from some other company or how they stole the idea of a keyboard from a typewriter.
I agree with what you're saying here and I should have known better than to even bother engaging with some of these guys...although to be fair I wasn't :)

I only responded to the guy who said that the tablets looked nothing alike and only an idiot would confuse the two.

You and I are in agreement: the tablets looks essentially the same
I didn't make any kind of assessment as to whether one copied the other or whether it was right or wrong, just pointed out that I'd actually recently been to a tmobile store a couple days ago and some intelligent people, the kind who frequent these kinds of boards (left-brained engineers working at Broadcom) made a joke that "oh look it's the new sPad"

that's all but it apparently caused a cacophony of insult toward me and anyone who might think that two basically rectangular, black beveled objects bearing any resemblance to one another are tards.
 
I just saw your response in that thread, so yeah, you know exactly what I'm talking about. It takes a special kind of idiot to willfully and continually engage in those kinds of mental gymnastics.

Personally, I'm still trying to figure out just what exactly is so "enthusiast" about Apple iProducts.

Yes. I made a number of risky statements. For example, one involved arguing that currently most servers on the Internet were in fact PCs running Linux. This was to help make a point that the Internet would not be as advanced as it is today had x86 PC architecture advancements been held back (as PowerPC was held back by Apple). I backed this up by referring to Apples move to x86 PC and Google’s current server setup. The reply that I got seemed to claim that I said that all servers were PCs, and that I was wrong because of that.

In my reply to that, at first, I did type “idiot”, but then deleted it before posting. I figure that I have to try to see some of the replies here as coming from youngsters who are just trying to take part, and that I should know better than to bully them. At least he spent time criticising it, I suppose that is a plus.

Anyway, sometimes I come here to have a laugh and fool around, others times I do serious stuff particularly when it comes to the evolution of Computer Technology.

(No need to reply to this)
 
What you wrote was that case modding, water cooling, and Android OS was causally related to CISC architecture which is ridiculous.

The PC was ahead because there was very little resistance to its diversity leading to things like case-modding, water-cooling, over-clocking and Linux etc. Thanks to PC Linux, you have the Internet, plus Android OS
If you want to continue bashing me at least take 30 seconds to google ARM
 
Back
Top