Apple Wins A Broad User-Interface Patent

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Apple has been granted a patent that covers "graphical user interfaces for displaying electronic lists and documents on portable devices." So, that's like...everything.

“From our point of view, it’s important that Apple not be the developer for the world. We can’t take all of our energy and all of our care and finish the painting, then have someone else put their name on it,” Apple CEO Tim Cook said at the D10 conference earlier this year.
 
isnt there like a thing where to get a patent it has to be non obvious?
 
Good luck on Apple to actually defend this patent. It sounds like a BS patent that will be thrown out when challeneged. Apple collects thos patents like a hobby.
 
Apple has been granted a patent that covers "graphical user interfaces for displaying electronic lists and documents on portable devices." So, that's like...everything.

It is *only* for mobile devices, a Ttruly revolutionary idea. I mean everyone knows this has been done for years on stationary devices...but mobile devices? Why are you such an innovation hating apple hating PC snobbist, Steve?
 
This page details it a little better, specifically, the third image from the top.

Which is still overly vague IMO. Display part of a document and allow scrolling if it's too big to fit the entire document on the screen? Vague. Okay, I oversimplified, but not by much.

Original patent filed in 'Q1 2007'. Sheesh.
 
Let me know when apple actually invents some technology rather than some software magickery.
 
Apple: "We're the only creative people on the planet. Everything you do, we've already done. Pay us for your copying of our original everything."
 
Nothing is original and great artist steal; Thanks Steveo for being the world's best hypocrite, I see your legacy lives on. The modern day computing world gets bleaker everyday as evildoers become kings.
 
Don't hate the player, hate the game. Every MFR does this.

Oh, wait. This is Apple. Hate is automatic.
 
Spose a link would be handy.

http://www.patentlyapple.com/patent...nother-major-iphone-ios-interface-patent.html

*applies for patent on invisible hyperlinks* :p

Here's the other listed granted patents from that page:

8,225,228 Collaborative media production

8,225,208 Interactive frames for images and videos displayed in a presentation application

8,225,181 Efficient re-read operations from memory devices

8,225,121 Forced idle of a data processing system

8,225,100 Hash functions using recurrency and arithmetic

8,225,079 Accelerating system boot using a set of control data recorded by operating system during a first OS boot

8,225,061 Method and apparatus for protected content data processing

8,225,035 Systems and methods for operating a disk drive

8,224,972 Invitation to bind to a device
 
Let me know when apple actually invents some technology rather than some software magickery.

Coming up with ideas is not hard, implementing them is. The idea of incandescent light was WELL KNOWN before Edison, but he was the first one to perfect it, and thus is 'credited' with inventing it. Does it matter that the idea was not his at all?

Sure this patent is bullshit, but so is your argument.
 
Apple: "We're the only creative people on the planet. Everything you do, we've already done. Pay us for your copying of our original everything."

Or as I like to say.

Apple: Think Same!

How are people more creative or unique when they all use the same device ;)
 
Shhhh dont let the Harley Davidson riders hear you......

At least guys like me who ride Supermoto bikes have varying differences upon manufacturers... where as every cruiser is pretty much the same 30 year old air cooled boring design.
 
“From our point of view, it’s important that Apple not be the developer for the world. We can’t take all of our energy and all of our care and finish the painting, then have someone else put their name on it,” Apple CEO Tim Cook said at the D10 conference earlier this year." - Tim Cook

Well, there goes hope of Tim Cook not being a Steve Jobs. I understand it's "the business" but I call bullshit. They've filed patents on ideas that have long existed before they came about to relevance again but they cry about not wanting to be the "developer for the world"? Hypocritical statement at best from Mr. Cook.

Honestly, even though I dislike Apple and their business practices, there was a time where I did not really care for all the focus on them in the media (negativity). But at this point even I am fed up with their bs and they really need to be brought down to reality. Not only for kharma's sake but for their products and their customers.

Fan boys and hipsters living in unicorn land can defend them till they are blue in the face but they need to wake up and realize this is going to hurt everyone in the end, including Apple and their products.
 
Good luck on Apple to actually defend this patent. It sounds like a BS patent that will be thrown out when challenged. Apple collects thos patents like a hobby.

It will actually hold up in court under challenge UNLESS existing legal precedent is struck down and replaced. There is an existing ruling in Federal court stating that judges do not have the legal authority to overturn a patent based on validity, as that power resides with the USPO alone. Once the USPO grants a patent, they are the only ones currently able to retract based on validity under current court rulings.

The sad part is, to be a patent attorney or a judge in a Patent case, you actually have to have some sort of engineering degree+ law degree to be admitted to the Federal Patent Bar. To be a USPO patent clerk, you only need a degree in whatever and someone on the inside to give you a job via nepotism. This leaves us in the position of having unqualified individuals granting patents that only the unqualified individuals can then retract.
 
this ridiculous they need to make some rules to prevent obvious patent and user interface to be trade marked!
 
Coming up with ideas is not hard, implementing them is. The idea of incandescent light was WELL KNOWN before Edison, but he was the first one to perfect it, and thus is 'credited' with inventing it. Does it matter that the idea was not his at all?

Sure this patent is bullshit, but so is your argument.

Problem is that a lot of other companies have made incandescent light bulbs long before Apple did. The iPhone was the not the first to do much of anything. Majority of the user interface can be copied from Windows Mobile, which is like 10 years before iOS. The only real distinction is that WinMO didn't have an app store, and used crappy resistive touch screens.

Throwing a bunch of icons in the interface and making a patent on it is bullshit.
 
Coming up with ideas is not hard, implementing them is. The idea of incandescent light was WELL KNOWN before Edison, but he was the first one to perfect it, and thus is 'credited' with inventing it. Does it matter that the idea was not his at all?

Sure this patent is bullshit, but so is your argument.

But implementing software ideas is just a few keystrokes away, and being able to patent that seems absurd.
 
It is *only* for mobile devices, a Ttruly revolutionary idea. I mean everyone knows this has been done for years on stationary devices...but mobile devices? Why are you such an innovation hating apple hating PC snobbist, Steve?

Don't recall any Apple macbooks in '86?
 
You know I don't hate on Apple just cause but it's like they want to be hated by the tech community. I hate these iFans and their typical "oh here we go with the apple hate..." like Apple is such a nice company. *rollseyes*
 
It is *only* for mobile devices, a Ttruly revolutionary idea. I mean everyone knows this has been done for years on stationary devices...but mobile devices? Why are you such an innovation hating apple hating PC snobbist, Steve?

3XQqW.png


Context lists have been done on mobile devices since forever.
 
If a tree of sarcasm falls in a forest unnoticed...did it actually fall?
not in an apple thread. if you say anything other than mouth-frothing irrational hatred towards apple you're automatically labeled an apple fanatic
 
It seems like this is just a patent on scrolling the entire screen by dragging with your finger on a touch screen. No scroll bars, no buttons to click, or wheels to turn. You just touch the content and move it. I am not aware of any touch interfaces that did this before the iPhone, but my experience was limited to some PocketPC PDAs for the most part.
 
I was thinking that Skripka simply forgot the sarcasm smiley, but one can never be sure.
He didn't need it. You don't need a sign telling you about falling rocks when one's just fallen on your head, do you?
 
It is *only* for mobile devices, a Ttruly revolutionary idea. I mean everyone knows this has been done for years on stationary devices...but mobile devices? Why are you such an innovation hating apple hating PC snobbist, Steve?

It says "portable devices". PC Laptops are portable devices. Plus, there is no such thing as "stationary devices". :(

I might want to port some Windows 7 Laptop GUI based software to work on a Windows 8 Pad or Phone. I can't tell from those pictures whether I will end up in Court.:mad:
 
It says "portable devices". PC Laptops are portable devices. Plus, there is no such thing as "stationary devices". :(

I might want to port some Windows 7 Laptop GUI based software to work on a Windows 8 Pad or Phone. I can't tell from those pictures whether I will end up in Court.:mad:

Good point. Haven't actually thought of that. A lot of patents like hyperlinks have been on desktops for years, what about the old windows 95 tablets?
 
Apple can apply for and receive as many patents as it likes, but defending them if they are challenged--which they will certainly be should Apple try and use them against its competition--does not mean that Apple's patents will be upheld. Big, major difference between being granted a patent and being able to successfully defend it.

Just today we all read of a British judge ruling for Samsung against Apple--throwing out Apple's bodacious claim that the Samsung tablet was a "slavish copy" of the Apple iPad. Further, he ordered Apple to post on its website that Samsung had *not* "slavishly copied" the iPad at all. The judge even made a joke about Apple calling the iPad unique and absolutely the "coolest" tablet available while at the same time suing Samsung for ostensibly having copied the iPad to the smallest detail!

The judge reminded Apple that it could not claim the "coolest" if Samsung's was equally as cool on account of its being an exact copy of the iPad! The judge found that Apple's advertising was far more correct than its lawsuit, since he could see no evidence of Samsung closely copying the iPad whatever.

And really, unless you are an idiot and think looking at competing tablets from ten feet away will tell you "who copied whom," you are going to know that people don't buy tablets from ten feet away...;) They get up close and personal with them before they buy them. Chance that anyone might buy a Samsung thinking it to be an Apple iPad? 0. Up close, the two tablets aren't the same size (Samsung is bigger) and they aren't the same aspect ratio (the Samsung is narrower and longer.) Additionally, the Samsung has the word "Samsung" plastered on the front in big chrome letters. Maybe someone could think that word spelled "Apple" but I don't think it's really true at all...;)
 
lol, no they're basically identical

even my left-brain dominant roommate and his broadcom co-workers were all joking about the new "s-pad" [samsung iPad] over lunch when we went into the store last week looking at new phones to buy.
 
Back
Top