Will Windows 7 Be The New XP?

"Post-PC Era" indeed. Most all real work is still done on desktop machines or laptops be they Win or OSX. The gripe with Win8 is that they're gimping the OS UI on desktops. Hell, you don't see Apple gimping its Macbooks/iMacs/MacPros by forcing everyone to use iOS on them. Tablets are still play toys and internet terminals for the most part. They are more fun to use in terms of user experience, but real work needs a "real computer".

An OS is just a tool to get at other programs. Nothing more and nothing less. If the OS gets in the users' way by hiding features, it is a poor tool.

No one is talking about OSX, and people aren't talking about iOS in and of itself either really...they're talking about the user experience of OS and device together....something Microsoft has never worried about. Sooner or later Microsoft needs to realize that users hate having to relearn how to do the same damn tasks with every iteration of Windows.

What about Windows 8 is so different for corporate users, who will likely be running on a heavily locked down group policy to the point the only thing they have access to are the basic apps they need? Essentially nothing is different at that point, except that the start menu is full screen.
 
"Post-PC Era" indeed. Most all real work is still done on desktop machines or laptops be they Win or OSX. The gripe with Win8 is that they're gimping the OS UI on desktops. Hell, you don't see Apple gimping its Macbooks/iMacs/MacPros by forcing everyone to use iOS on them. Tablets are still play toys and internet terminals for the most part. They are more fun to use in terms of user experience, but real work needs a "real computer".

I'd agree with the gimping other than the fact that every significant piece of desktop software I've tried with Windows 8 works the same as it does in Windows 7. I've lost absolutely no functionality or capability and have some new ones.

An OS is just a tool to get at other programs.

Which is why it's hard for me to conclude that Windows 8 is gimped since it allows me to run those very same programs as always.
 
so to enjoy the benefits of win8 i need to upgrade to a touch screen ?
my desktop monitor is a good 3 feet away from me, who wants a desktop that you have to be that close to the monitor?? i will just stick to a more user friendly traditional win 7 as i think most of the desktop crowd will. it may be the cats-ass for laptops and tablets, but MS is screwing the pooch by trying to market this for the desktop.
 
What about Windows 8 is so different for corporate users, who will likely be running on a heavily locked down group policy to the point the only thing they have access to are the basic apps they need? Essentially nothing is different at that point, except that the start menu is full screen.

I'd point you to a recent thread on [H] where someone had to ask how to multi-task in Windows 8. "Nothing is different at that point" indeed.

Most corp IT will likely skip Win8 I'll bet. In part because many just adopted Win7...and also because the dumbed down UI is crap for productivity and makes things more complicated to do simple tasks....like I dunno, having an email window open next to the corporate scheduling software that requires a VM.
 
The iPad is also useless to most people and costs $600+ while Windows costs what, $300 for the most expensive one?
A copy of Windows without a device to use it on certainly has its uses. These include: drink coasters, mini-frisbees and for use in a child's mobile (as discs are quite shiny and fascinating to infants).
 
Not exactly as tablet sales in retail will exceed that of desktops. The pooch is kind of dying anyway.

i agree that tablet sales will exceed the desktop units. but i dont think that desktops are going to be going away any time soon. maybe in a hundred years, but not in our lifetime.
 
I can only speak for myself, but I foresee using Win 7 Ultimate x64 for many, many years. I love this OS.
 
I'd point you to a recent thread on [H] where someone had to ask how to multi-task in Windows 8. "Nothing is different at that point" indeed.

On the only desktop actually it's not different. That thread was talking about Metro apps and the OP seemed to have a driver or some other issue because he couldn't do something on his dual screen desktop machine with Metro apps that I do all the time on my dual screen desktop and have had an issue with.
 
i agree that tablet sales will exceed the desktop units. but i dont think that desktops are going to be going away any time soon. maybe in a hundred years, but not in our lifetime.

And I don't think so either. So regardless of Metro it's kind of nice that Windows 8 runs every desktop app I've tried and the behavior is identical with keyboards and mice compared to Windows 7.
 
What features does it remove?

Well for one, windows media player can't play DVD's now. I was actually expecting them to bring Windows media player into the future by allowing blueray playback with HD audio. Instead they just axe it all together. What the hell is that?

Someone is going to reply, "who uses DVD's?" and I will say no one, because windows media player can't even play them.
 
I myself have no plans to move to Windows 8. I will continue to use Windows 7 64-bit for the foreseeable future. I haven't read or seen anything about Windows 8 that makes me want to use it at all. I had no problems moving to Windows Vista (started out dual-booting with Vista and XP just so I could get used to the OS and learn to tweak it and configure it before I moved to it at as my main OS), but I have no intentions of even bothering with Windows 8.
 
Someone is going to reply, "who uses DVD's?" and I will say no one, because windows media player can't even play them.

If you buy a machine with a DVD drive or even an stand alone DVD drive the codecs will be there. This is no different than Windows XP, which everyone loved, the title of this thread after all implies that XP was awesome.

Not saying that I like the decision and indeed I'm into Blu Ray on my PC, even 3D BD. But at the same time it's just something that fewer and fewer people are doing.
 
Well for one, windows media player can't play DVD's now. I was actually expecting them to bring Windows media player into the future by allowing blueray playback with HD audio. Instead they just axe it all together. What the hell is that?

Someone is going to reply, "who uses DVD's?" and I will say no one, because windows media player can't even play them.

I won't ask the question, but I will point out that lots of mainstream laptops aren't being shipped with optical drives. I actually don't really like that fact, but I understand the point when I think about how often I actually stick a disc of any sort into my laptop. The vast majority of the time, it's just space that's wasted and could be used to hold more batteries (which it frequently does in the case of my Latitude C640 so I can get ~5 hours of light use out of a Pentium 4 processor).
 
I set up my laptop to dual-boot Win7 and Win8, been using Win8 exclusively for the last few weeks.

Had to boot into 7 to run Photoshop because I hadn't installed in on 8 yet, and I realized just how much faster Windows 8 is than Windows 7. No joke, I was tempted to install an SSD to get performance up to the levels I wanted under Windows 7. With Windows 8 on that machine, it's not needed, everything is lightning fast off the ok-ish laptop hard disk in the machine.

Can't go back to Windows 7 now, it just feels so slow...
 
Don't know about you guys, but I'm really baffled at why Microsoft can't create something drool worthy.

When it comes down to it, that is why we are all pissed off right?

I mean we don't hate Microsoft, but we don't want an Apple either. It really grinds my gears that a company with a bazillion dollars can't seem to hire a bunch of artists, ergonomic specialists, and psychologists and create software that will make people forget iPads and Macbooks even exist.

I have seen countless absolutely gorgeous rigs built by people on these forums. Built by people who obviously are full of passion for PCs and very talented. Where the fuck is that passion and talent at Microsoft?

When they showed Windows 8 for the first time, they should have gone back to the drawing board the very moment they didn't get a universal reaction that said OMG! I have to have that! on the New York Times front page.

The jarring mix of a modern mobile interface using a completely different design perspective, graphics, fonts and controls popping up all the time right on top of a older traditional desktop is a joke.

I'm not saying they should copy Apple, or even try to get some of their customer base. I'm just totally blown away by the fact MS can't create something that takes back the limelight. Something we can be proud of to put on our rigs. Windows 7 is great, but with one freaking once of the passion of [H]'s users, Windows could be SO much more.....
 
Really, how often do people get excited about a user interface on any other product? I don't see Apple people screaming, "The UI in OSX makes me wet!" The fact that people are even talking about the interface at all shows how much importance people assign to Windows in their lives.
 
Would you run windows 7 on a phone 4" screen. ?
Why would you run Windows Mobile OS on a 20"+ screen?

I have sat and trained lots of people and most of them can barely grasp copy and past and the start button.
How the fuck are they going to grasp Metro.

Apple was right to say different designs are needed for different platforms. How would you feel if Apple turned OSX into IOS?

Also high security enviornments ie most corporate enviornments in north america WILL NEVER allow tablets to leave most buildings. Then how do you think corporate people will work on a dinky 10" screen..

Not to mention ARM version of windows can't even join a domain.
X86 tablets are nicefor troubleshooting but I couldn't fatho working on one 8+ hours a day.
I have Windpad which I love for being in confined space.

Also metro is going to be fun using a trackpad on a laptop.

Also how do you like having fingerprints all over your screen? You don't? the fuck is the point of metro on the desktop then?

The worst part is that they stuk this shit on server2012. Fuck this I will just install Core and do everything by powershell then I guarantee myself a job cause there will be so few that will be able to use the OS.
 
Really, how often do people get excited about a user interface on any other product? I don't see Apple people screaming, "The UI in OSX makes me wet!" The fact that people are even talking about the interface at all shows how much importance people assign to Windows in their lives.

I don't think I've ever gotten excited over a UI, however I often get pissed off with them when they inhibit my work.

The UI is just that, a user interface, I don't use a computer because I want to use a user interface, the user interface is there so I can use my computer.

As such, change in a UI is bad unless it is clearly for the better. Change for the sake of change in a UI is fucking retarded and I hate when companies do it, moving options around in menus for no reason, moving buttons to different locations for the sake of it. Change for the worse I hate even more and induces much swearing and abuse. Change for the better I appreciate and embrace because it allows me to spend less time fucking with the UI and more time actually doing what I'm on the PC to do in the first place.
 
I've been using Windows 8 DP, CP, and now RP. For me, performance has been similar to Windows 7 and in some places better. I'm willing to admit that the future may not include the Start Menu. Squares and two-Squares instead of small icon lists may be more efficient.

I struggle with the idea that I need to leave the multi-tasking desktop and desktop application(s) I'm working in and take a trip to single or double-tasking Metro world to launch another desktop application that will dump me back down to that same multi-tasking desktop with my already running desktop applications and my newly launched application. I like that the experience being deprecated did not hijack my experience and entirely steal my attention from what I was doing. As an analogy, it is as if my regularly scheduled programming is being interrupted to bring me a weather alert. I know I will be returned, but it will have advanced in my absence. "The Windows 8 Start Screen now interrupts what you were doing to bring you... Oh Look, It's Your Metro! Apps! And Notifications from your Live Tiles! Oh, And Your Programs!"

Right-click the Start corner is a good tip. I tend to Windows key R to open Run and type the program I want to launch or double-click desktop shortcuts. In other words, Microsoft has spent a lot of time trying to perfect a mechanism that I mostly do an end run around. It's evident that they expect this because they try to combat this by starting you in Metro land (when Windows Server 2012 takes you to Server Manager, not Start Screen)

I'm not convinced one way or another whether Microsoft sees an entirely WinRT/Metro future or a Metro/Desktop future. There is Windows (Server) for IA64. There was Windows on Alpha, MIPS, and PowerPC at one point. Is there any reason to think the ARM processor could not power a desktop? Linux distros can run on ARM. Maybe no Windows 8 Desktop for ARM was a bone thrown to Intel? Or is it the start of Microsoft retiring a "legacy system" in the Desktop? Did Microsoft not initially want to release Visual Studio Express Edition for Desktop programming for that reason? I have a hard time imagining some software running on Metro. And how does the Microsoft .NET Framework fit in with new "first class citizen" programming languages of the Windows 8 and Windows Runtime?
 
When they showed Windows 8 for the first time, they should have gone back to the drawing board the very moment they didn't get a universal reaction that said OMG! I have to have that! on the New York Times front page.

The jarring mix of a modern mobile interface using a completely different design perspective, graphics, fonts and controls popping up all the time right on top of a older traditional desktop is a joke.

And what does any of this actually do with how the OS actually functions and what it can do? As SkribbelKat said, people did go OMG over the iPad UI but when people played around with it they liked the touch capabilities and the simplicity of the device. The iOS UI is getting kind of long in the tooth itself.

The problem with most reviews is that they are looking at Windows 8 and want it to be Windows 7. They aren't using it with multiple devices and different input methods. The first thing that made me happy about Windows 8 is how easy it was to launch an application with a mouse and touch using the SAME UI. A Metro IE 10 that pretty much kills any mobile OS device in speed when web browsing with touch (of course this was an i7 Tablet PC so not that surprising really). Having favorites and settings all sync up by simply singing into the same Microsoft account.

I've seen almost NO ONE talk about the things that Windows 8 can do or use it on hardware similar to what it's going to be on. Many say that Windows 8 is Vista 2.0. Thing is if you installed Vista on the machine you had at the time, there was nothing you were going to see much beyond that. There were few hybrids and convertibles or touch devices or Metro apps and indeed Vista was often slower and had tons of compatibility issues.

There's a lot to like about Windows 8 when using it beyond mice and keyboard desktops. No, the focus of Windows 8 wasn't on a dying form factor.
 
pff the "immah retard" OS.. it comes to this these days.. the impression is that humankind turned into a big single mongoloid.. well whatever.. using enterprise x64 just for games anyway..
 
How the fuck are they going to grasp Metro.

Why is it that people think that Microsoft designed a UI that they think is incompressible by average people? I mean they've had to have tested this and have some confidence that people can use this. It's different but I don't see anything here that's alien science.
 
I'm not convinced one way or another whether Microsoft sees an entirely WinRT/Metro future or a Metro/Desktop future.

I'm perfectly convinced that for now that they see RT and desktop as mix and match. The WHOLE point of Windows 8 is to mix and match based on the user running whatever application they want in a particular situation. And why would Microsoft give up perhaps their greatest asset, the Windows desktop. The thing that so many of you say has been destroyed by Windows 8 yet is still there in pretty much all it's glory, at least to the point that pretty much every desktop program I've installed on Windows 8 works exactly like it does in Windows 7.
 
I don't think I've ever gotten excited over a UI, however I often get pissed off with them when they inhibit my work.

The UI is just that, a user interface, I don't use a computer because I want to use a user interface, the user interface is there so I can use my computer.

As such, change in a UI is bad unless it is clearly for the better. Change for the sake of change in a UI is fucking retarded and I hate when companies do it, moving options around in menus for no reason, moving buttons to different locations for the sake of it. Change for the worse I hate even more and induces much swearing and abuse. Change for the better I appreciate and embrace because it allows me to spend less time fucking with the UI and more time actually doing what I'm on the PC to do in the first place.

It took me a couple days to figure out and get comfy with the Metro thing and I was a lot slower getting around until I got used to it. But really, it's nto a huge thing and even the average person, I think, would get accustomed to it in a matter of about a week or two.

If you read the dev blogs posted by the design team you'll see that they moved stuff after a lot of analysis of existing usage and study about how to make things more efficient. It wasn't done randomly for the sake of doing it. They're betting a lot of profits on this stuff so they're doing their homework.

Also...just saying...profanity doesn't add credibility. :p
 
Trust me there are plenty of retards that have jobs they shouldn't be in and they are dumb as you can get.
I also fmet a lot of people that are good at their jobs but suck on computers and when you change stuff on them there is nothing but missery.

People are not upset about METRO people are upset that there is NO legacy start button alternative. Microsoft has been excellent supporter of Legacy and this is why they are a multibilion corporation. This really kind of kills that. When you own a company and your told that a core program that you use is not compatible and will cost you in the neighbourhood of 20k-100k to replace then you can safely tell me that its easy to migrate a user.

Thank god for virtualization and not that shit that microsoft calls HyperV
 
It's just a button...it's not even a real button. If someone gets upset about a missing button on a computer, then they're probably unstable and insane.
 
It's just a button...it's not even a real button. If someone gets upset about a missing button on a computer, then they're probably unstable and insane.

Ever read any techblogs/Admin blogs. Some of the shit I am asked on a regular basis make me tilt my head like a dog in confusion and say WTF?@?
Work as full time system admin for more then 1 week and the myriad of stupid/insane/assenine shit that comes out of peoples pie holes would make you think that their is something definetley wrong with that individual.
 
Looks like Microsoft is repeating the same mistake with Windows 8 just like Windows Vista, to be honest Windows 8 looks like shit and by removing certain features that people have grown accustomed to is a big mistake. Maybe Microsoft will get it right with Windows 9, or whatever its going to be called. Just like Windows Vista, Microsoft got it right with Windows 7.
 
I remember being amazed by Win 7 after sticking with XP (and hating Vista).

Looks like I'm going to continue to be amazed by Win 7 :p

7 and Vista and very similar. Right now, Vista is solid. When it first came out, driver and software support was poor for it. Now it runs perfectly fine.
 
Really, how often do people get excited about a user interface on any other product? I don't see Apple people screaming, "The UI in OSX makes me wet!" The fact that people are even talking about the interface at all shows how much importance people assign to Windows in their lives.

The UI design isn't just about looks. Its how you operate any computer for christ sakes. Huds and menus can make or break a good game. Just imagine if they made you open up a text box and you had to type in a long command line at a prompt to reload a weapon in Mass Effect. It ain't pretty, but it would work. Hows that sound?

What if the software industry decided to ditch all on screen menus and went with a kinect based gesture system where you needed to dance to Dubstep to launch programs? Again it doesn't look nice, but it just needs to work right?

Compatibility, performance and stability in all software is useless without a good interface.

This is especially true for an OS. If you bury commonly used, everyday features under tons of vague confusing menus would you want to use it? What if you couldn't change anything if it was terrible and it couldn't be customized? Would you just accept it because it gets the job done or say screw it and buy something else?
 
It took me a couple days to figure out and get comfy with the Metro thing and I was a lot slower getting around until I got used to it. But really, it's nto a huge thing and even the average person, I think, would get accustomed to it in a matter of about a week or two.

If you read the dev blogs posted by the design team you'll see that they moved stuff after a lot of analysis of existing usage and study about how to make things more efficient. It wasn't done randomly for the sake of doing it. They're betting a lot of profits on this stuff so they're doing their homework.

Also...just saying...profanity doesn't add credibility. :p

Just because they supposedly "did their homework" doesn't mean I have to agree with it or like it ;) A lot of mistakes have been made in many fields after doing things which were based on research and studies.

I'm pretty sure the main study they did was "holy fuck iOS and Android have a huge market, lets try and get some of that". :p
 
Ever read any techblogs/Admin blogs. Some of the shit I am asked on a regular basis make me tilt my head like a dog in confusion and say WTF?@?
Work as full time system admin for more then 1 week and the myriad of stupid/insane/assenine shit that comes out of peoples pie holes would make you think that their is something definetley wrong with that individual.

I do the whole IT thing in real life and have for a while now so I know how end users respond to stuff. I also know that they get over it eventually. The only injustice we're doing by telling them how horrible 8 is going to be is to ourselves because they're make it worse and more difficult when they have to deal with it because of a negative opinion prior to using it.
 
The UI design isn't just about looks. Its how you operate any computer for christ sakes. Huds and menus can make or break a good game. Just imagine if they made you open up a text box and you had to type in a long command line at a prompt to reload a weapon in Mass Effect. It ain't pretty, but it would work. Hows that sound?

What if the software industry decided to ditch all on screen menus and went with a kinect based gesture system where you needed to dance to Dubstep to launch programs? Again it doesn't look nice, but it just needs to work right?

Compatibility, performance and stability in all software is useless without a good interface.

This is especially true for an OS. If you bury commonly used, everyday features under tons of vague confusing menus would you want to use it? What if you couldn't change anything if it was terrible and it couldn't be customized? Would you just accept it because it gets the job done or say screw it and buy something else?

Games aren't the OS...that's incomparable and a pretty absurd notion, both the Mass Effect thing (which I've never played, btw) and the Kinect thing too. Picking really insane, unlikely stuff to compare to a UI change doesn't pull the change along into the land of absurdity as well.
 
I do the whole IT thing in real life and have for a while now so I know how end users respond to stuff. I also know that they get over it eventually. The only injustice we're doing by telling them how horrible 8 is going to be is to ourselves because they're make it worse and more difficult when they have to deal with it because of a negative opinion prior to using it.

I don't tell my customers anything. They buy what ever and then I just charge them my fee per hour. I just hate dealing with untrained users. More and more I am moving to nothing but server managment. You can hire a monkey for a level 1 support tech but a level 3 is hard to find.
 
Back
Top