Wow Dan your faith in me sucks...lol.
I knew someone would ask about the almost, but I decided to say almost for brevity. However, I hoped the response would have been more inquisitive. It has more to do with the limitations of the x264 encoder than anything else. For every additional thread added to an encode the effect on performance is halved.
During an encode my system utilization is at 50%. In order to max the system out I encode 2 files at the same time which has a negligible impact (meaning minutes not hours) on the first encode. What does this mean? If you need numbers my old system could only do 1 encode at a time at 100% utilization. DVD's encoded at somewhere between 1 - 2 hours (high profile) and BR titles were anywhere from 3 - 5 hours. This is now 30- to 45 minutes for 2 DVDs or 2 BR titles at no more than 3 hours. I'm sorry but I'm loving that performance every day even on Sundays. I ran the numbers before I committed. I wouldn't spend that kind of money if it wasn't going to perform. I knew what my workload was before I bought it. You have to consider the resources available for highly threaded workloads.
In addition that CPU costs $1000+ vs the $700 I spent I think i can live with the 30 fps deficit and 300 more dollars in my pocket. Just to be thorough, there's a 30 fps deficit in my favor between a Extreme 980x at stock and this system.
Who runs a Core i7 980X at stock speeds? My CPU only ran $700 at Microcenter on clearance. The 990X had just came out when I bought mine. They are even cheaper on Ebay.
I still can't see any reason to go AMD for that type of workload.