Is it time to jump?

Wow Dan your faith in me sucks...lol.

I knew someone would ask about the almost, but I decided to say almost for brevity. However, I hoped the response would have been more inquisitive. It has more to do with the limitations of the x264 encoder than anything else. For every additional thread added to an encode the effect on performance is halved.

During an encode my system utilization is at 50%. In order to max the system out I encode 2 files at the same time which has a negligible impact (meaning minutes not hours) on the first encode. What does this mean? If you need numbers my old system could only do 1 encode at a time at 100% utilization. DVD's encoded at somewhere between 1 - 2 hours (high profile) and BR titles were anywhere from 3 - 5 hours. This is now 30- to 45 minutes for 2 DVDs or 2 BR titles at no more than 3 hours. I'm sorry but I'm loving that performance every day even on Sundays. I ran the numbers before I committed. I wouldn't spend that kind of money if it wasn't going to perform. I knew what my workload was before I bought it. You have to consider the resources available for highly threaded workloads.

In addition that CPU costs $1000+ vs the $700 I spent I think i can live with the 30 fps deficit and 300 more dollars in my pocket. Just to be thorough, there's a 30 fps deficit in my favor between a Extreme 980x at stock and this system.

Who runs a Core i7 980X at stock speeds? My CPU only ran $700 at Microcenter on clearance. The 990X had just came out when I bought mine. They are even cheaper on Ebay.

I still can't see any reason to go AMD for that type of workload.
 
Who runs a Core i7 980X at stock speeds? My CPU only ran $700 at Microcenter on clearance. The 990X had just came out when I bought mine. They They are even cheaper on Ebay.

Clearance prices are available for any item that goes on... well clearance. I don't think that would be exclusive to just Intel. In terms of overclocking the 980x I don't know what the score would be. You can bench it though and find out where it would land.

They are even cheaper on Ebay.
Ebay?

I still can't see any reason to go AMD for that type of workload.
I don't know why that would be so weird. Look at it's benchmarks it's competitive with SB when it comes to that. It loses in games and any non multithreaded workload. I knew this before I did it. My workload is highly multithreaded in general so it made sense. I have no allegiance to either brand. I wanted to go dual socket whether it was Intel or AMD. The problem was that Intel wanted obscene amounts of money to do it. For work that's one thing, I'm not buying those systems with my own money. For home? That's quite another.
 
Last edited:
Zarathustra[H];1038765884 said:
Wouldn't one be better served by the competitor that can do everything well?
This would be true. I thought about that too. But I needed cores and lots and lots of memory. If I wanted to go Intel for this and I thought about it seriously when it came to the SR-2 I would spend more... way more. This was the problem. Next I thought about work load. My main OS is Linux, not Windows and I run VMs along with encoding or playing a game. I know it's niche, but that's my workload what can I say?
 
Just because you won't do less than a Sabertooth doesn't mean that there aren't viable cheaper options. If you only need the most basic features, there is no sense in buying a board with tons of features you will never use just because it's the same price on the AMD side. If a simple board gives you what you need but gives you the option for Intel processors, I'd take it. Additionally, it's hard to quantify what the value of more performance is. For me $110 difference or even more for a much better performing product is absolutely worth while and justified.

You are a motherboard editor. You are suggesting moving from a high quality, feature-rich, extremely stable board (with 2 TRUE PCI-E x16 buses), that supports 1866 memory as a STOCK option.

Not sure how an enthusiast site's motherboard editor would directly place the processor over the motherboard, especially when it comes to overclocking, which most enthusiast will do eventually, if not always.

Maybe you should be the CPU editor?
 
You are a motherboard editor. You are suggesting moving from a high quality, feature-rich, extremely stable board (with 2 TRUE PCI-E x16 buses), that supports 1866 memory as a STOCK option.

Not sure how an enthusiast site's motherboard editor would directly place the processor over the motherboard, especially when it comes to overclocking, which most enthusiast will do eventually, if not always.

Maybe you should be the CPU editor?

I sorta felt the same thing when I read that.
 
You are a motherboard editor. You are suggesting moving from a high quality, feature-rich, extremely stable board (with 2 TRUE PCI-E x16 buses), that supports 1866 memory as a STOCK option.

Not sure how an enthusiast site's motherboard editor would directly place the processor over the motherboard, especially when it comes to overclocking, which most enthusiast will do eventually, if not always.

Maybe you should be the CPU editor?

No I'm not. There are plenty of capable enthusiast boards which have solid performance oriented feature sets that don't have 3 drive controllers, WiFi, dual NICs, etc. that cost less and can be had for prices which match the more feature rich AMD solutions. If you want processor performance and don't need the extra features of the motherboard platform, I'd choose the option that lets me use the faster CPUs.

A P8Z77-V is fine if I don't need 3-Way SLI, dual NICs, 3 separate RAID arrays, multiple SSD caching volumes, etc. Cost wise it's comparable to a more feature rich solution like the Gigabyte 990FXA-UD5. If I've only got two storage devices, and only one GPU and game at 1920x1080, I don't need the extra features offered by the 990FXA-UD5 do I? The P8Z77-V would therefore give me all I need.

It's about being honest with yourself and knowing what you really do and do not need. Now if you are the kind of person that has system configurations that change all the time and you buy lots of drives, things like that, and will go multiGPU, then obviously the P8Z77-V won't get the job done. You'd need something like the P8Z77 Deluxe, or maybe even the P8Z77 WS or more. At that point, if you are on a limited budget you can decide if outright performance is more important, or is the feature set of the board more important for system flexibility.

I stand by the statement that Intel offers the better performing product, and just because the cheaper boards may not be as feature rich as AMD's, doesn't necessarily equate to the Intel platform having to be significantly more expensive to deliver that performance. Obviously specialized workloads where more cores are needed may make it more appealing, and gamers may want to go the Intel route regardless as low end Intel options tend to offer awesome bang for your buck. And specific needs can be evaluated on a case by case basis, and maybe there is a call occasionally to go the AMD route. I believe these instances are probably fairly rare outside of those who already own AM3 / AM3+ based motherboards though.

Quoted again to address specific points.

You are a motherboard editor. You are suggesting moving from a high quality, feature-rich, extremely stable board (with 2 TRUE PCI-E x16 buses), that supports 1866 memory as a STOCK option.

Not sure how an enthusiast site's motherboard editor would directly place the processor over the motherboard, especially when it comes to overclocking, which most enthusiast will do eventually, if not always.

Maybe you should be the CPU editor?

2 TRUE PCI-Express x16 slots? This one is funny. It's irrelevant in all but the highest end multiGPU / Multimonitor setups which will still perform better on the Intel platform. So this is laughable at best. DDR3 1866MHz you say? Doesn't matter. The AMD platform has significantly less memory bandwidth in tests. Intel platforms show very little if any real world improvement with memory speeds beyond DDR3 1600MHz. Though of course the scores improve dramatically in synthetic tests if you look at the numbers. They are still capable of DDR3 2400MHz speeds.

I also do not care what the "stock" option for memory speeds is. X58 officially only supported DDR3 1066MHz speeds. I have NEVER run at those speeds on any board I've tested that I can recall. In fact most of my X58 systems have run well north of DDR3 1600MHz speeds for a long time. The one I'm using now has DDR3 1600MHz memory running at just that. Let's not forget that at the time, Nehalem and later Gulftown, along with their LGA1156 counterparts performed much better than Phenom II processors in the day. Memory bandwidth rarely translates into real world performance gains. In tests like Cinebench and Sandra, AMD still loses horribly pretty much regardless of configuration to Sandy Bridge/Sandy Bridge-E and Ivy Bridge. Most of the time Bulldozer isn't even all that competitive with Nehalem or Gulftown.

Nice try. :) Any platform advantages AMD has are rendered moot by the weaknesses of their CPUs.
 
Last edited:
Even when considering the FX line for pure VM usage, wouldn't (3930k) six cores performing significantly better than eight (FX) be more ideal? I guess if you ran one core for your main OS and had 7 vms... but really, who does that?
 
Even when considering the FX line for pure VM usage, wouldn't (3930k) six cores performing significantly better than eight (FX) be more ideal? I guess if you ran one core for your main OS and had 7 vms... but really, who does that?

If I was building a pure virtualization server with only that purpose in mind, then I'd opt for whatever gave me the best virtualized performance for the budget I had to work with. If you do anything else with the machine, most of the time the Intel CPUs will perform significantly faster.

Most of the time there are only two reasons to go AMD.
  • User's of existing AM3 / AM3+ motherboards already have the hardware. Thus a simple processor upgrade will give them the best performance to cost ratio for most usage. Even if that performance is signficantly lower than it is on the Intel platform. You simply can't beat the cost of such a low priced drop in upgrade.
  • Situations where cost is virtually the only factor considered. This is when the performance requirements are so minimal the needs can be met by the least expensive hardware available. In such cases absolute cost becomes the primary decisive factor. In this situation AMD's motherboards are cheaper, as are their CPUs.
 
Even when considering the FX line for pure VM usage, wouldn't (3930k) six cores performing significantly better than eight (FX) be more ideal? I guess if you ran one core for your main OS and had 7 vms... but really, who does that?

Depends on what you are doing and what your VM's are for.

If you have a few high CPU requiring VM's an Intel based solution is going to be better. Far better. Most VM's I use however, don't use much CPU power, in which case its better just to have many cores.

A Intel based solution with fewer cores might struggle when you start getting many VCPU's going, but it depends. CPU switching is not extremely efficient, and does not scale linearly. For some loads having faster fewer cores may be faster than having dedicated cores for each. It really is going to depend.

Personally I won't need 8 or 6 cores on my ESXi server up front. I'm currently doing just fine with my dual core AMD E-350, from a processing power perspective. (Alas it lacks IOMMU / VT-D or I'd keep it). With a FX-8120 I figure I'm giving myself some more room to experiment and expand. The main reason for my upgrade is IOMMU support.

Most of my load is going to come from routing with pfSense and file serving, neither which are particularly high CPU load functions, but I do want to have them on their own cores, as doing so makes them run smoother.

I probably wouldn't see, much of a difference in performance for my needs between a FX-8120 and a 6 core Intel CPU, but I can get an FX-8120 with a good motherboard for $244.98 as a combo from microcenter. No way I can get an Intel combo for anywhere near this.

Also, AMD consumer solutions seem to be much easier than Intel solutions when it comes to getting one that actually supports IOMMU/VT-D. With intel consumer products it seems hit or miss (and more often in the miss column). The only way to really guarantee VT-D support from both CPU and motherboard, seems to be to go the Xeon+server motherboard route (which I was planning for a while). With AMD's consumer products there are many more CPU and motherboard combos that just support IOMMU out of the box.

So, while I agree that for most cases there is no reason at all to get AMD chips for most enthusiasts, in this rather narrow circumstance, for me, it makes sense. You won't find me putting one of these in my main rig though :p

I still maintain that AMD chips are great for most servers, most desktop clients, most laptops, etc. The narrow spectrum where they are insufficient is for the Geming/Hardware enthusiast crowd, where I'd almost universally go Intel.
 
Even when considering the FX line for pure VM usage, wouldn't (3930k) six cores performing significantly better than eight (FX) be more ideal? I guess if you ran one core for your main OS and had 7 vms... but really, who does that?

It depends on the hypervisor. If you're planning on running ESX Intel is the way to go by a pretty good margin. However if you run KVM or XEN the opposite is true. AMD runs neck and neck on XEN. However, it's faster than the Intel solution in KVM.

AMD solutions can make sense, but you need to make sure of the workload. If your workload compliments BD's arch then you'll enjoy nice performance while saving money. If it doesn't, then you'll wish you had bought the Intel system.

For my system it's apart of a long line of upgrades (which is why saving money mattered a little bit more). The current dual C32 will eventually end up in my file server. It's 128GB memory capacity will go a long way in testing out dedup. It's replacement (for the main rig) I wanted to do a 4S water cooled system. Now this one I just might do Intel just to see the performance level of it all.
 
Last edited:
If I was building a pure virtualization server with only that purpose in mind, then I'd opt for whatever gave me the best virtualized performance for the budget I had to work with. If you do anything else with the machine, most of the time the Intel CPUs will perform significantly faster.

Most of the time there are only two reasons to go AMD.
  • User's of existing AM3 / AM3+ motherboards already have the hardware. Thus a simple processor upgrade will give them the best performance to cost ratio for most usage. Even if that performance is signficantly lower than it is on the Intel platform. You simply can't beat the cost of such a low priced drop in upgrade.
  • Situations where cost is virtually the only factor considered. This is when the performance requirements are so minimal the needs can be met by the least expensive hardware available. In such cases absolute cost becomes the primary decisive factor. In this situation AMD's motherboards are cheaper, as are their CPUs.

I think a third reason for AMD would be someboody that games at 1920x1080 and is not going to be dropping cash on 2 more monitors and 3 more GPU's. For that setup, an AMD rig will work just as well and for less money.

I break out my credit card and slap a 3570K and Max V in my Newegg cart every time I read these threads because theyre very convincing that Im missing out with my AMD rig but then the more I think about it, would I actually see a difference in actual use? Aside from Civilization and ARMA 2, is my $450 in new CPU and motherboard going to make any difference at all? From all the benchmarks Ive seen, I dont think it would.

Intel is obviously the answer for high powered systems running high resolutions with multiple GPU's. But for single GPU systems, an AMD rig will work just as well for less money.

At the end of the day though, there is no disputing Intel is the faster processor but I think it gets exaggerated by how much faster it is. On a benchmark graph, a few seconds looks like a big huge score, but at the end of the day are you really going to notice that your AMD rig took 5 seconds longer to encode that video?
 
I think a third reason for AMD would be someboody that games at 1920x1080 and is not going to be dropping cash on 2 more monitors and 3 more GPU's. For that setup, an AMD rig will work just as well and for less money.

I break out my credit card and slap a 3570K and Max V in my Newegg cart every time I read these threads because theyre very convincing that Im missing out with my AMD rig but then the more I think about it, would I actually see a difference in actual use? Aside from Civilization and ARMA 2, is my $450 in new CPU and motherboard going to make any difference at all? From all the benchmarks Ive seen, I dont think it would.

Intel is obviously the answer for high powered systems running high resolutions with multiple GPU's. But for single GPU systems, an AMD rig will work just as well for less money.

At the end of the day though, there is no disputing Intel is the faster processor but I think it gets exaggerated by how much faster it is. On a benchmark graph, a few seconds looks like a big huge score, but at the end of the day are you really going to notice that your AMD rig took 5 seconds longer to encode that video?

Well there is also more to computing than gaming. For a lot of work, I think that going Intel would be the better investment nearly every time. At the time I purchased my CPU, AMD didn't even have Bulldozer, and on average I can encode a movie inside of 7 minutes. I've got 535 movies on Blu-Ray, HD-DVD and regular DVD alone. If I have a CPU that takes 8 or 9 minutes to do the same task, multiplied by 535, that adds to a significant amount of time saved on the Intel side. Probably not necessarily as big a deal for someone who doesn't do anything productive for a living, but rendering tasks, video editing and other things which are faster on one platform or another, time savings means getting more done. Sometimes time really is money.

It depends on what you are doing, but often times I think that the cost increase is justified. Now this is for buying a new system. If you already have a Bulldozer or AM3/AM3+ rig, then no. It probably isn't worth th emoney.
 
We can and will make good use of BD at work. We can recompile CentOS with BD opimizations, and we will if it seems useful. At least once a week I want to throw a brick reinforced foam brick at someone for having a loud kernel-related discussion within earshot while I'm trying to get work done.

Alas, I can't entirely explain why. I work for a hardware and software vendor that primarily sells to the financial industry, so there are a lot of secrets. Our products run in real time. We guarantee that job x will run in y nanoseconds, and we design hardware to help make that happen. We underload cores and in a lot of cases more slower cores is better than fewer faster cores. If I have 16 cores I can let the OS have 2 and run 14 realtime threads. If I only have 12 I only get 10 realtime threads assuming the OS gets two.

All that said, my main personal rig has an i7-3820. It runs my personal stuff faster than an AMD chip generally would.
 
All these great debates on intel basically vs amd once again haha much love for both sides. Our company just switched from intel to amd, the intels kept just dieing out after a few months. The 2 current amds have been around for 6 months now and handle the multitasking of our systems very well. I switched from intel to amd myself and really I would say to me feels about the same. As Dan_D said though depending on what your doing depends on what truly is honest and best for what needs to get done and what is more cost effective even if you have to spend the little extra money for intel because you need to to run whatever your needs may be. Most the time it seems to me is if your biased to one side or not you will always defend that side as I can see in this thread has been done. Last just look what is going to be the major function of that computer and decide from there.
 
All these great debates on intel basically vs amd once again haha much love for both sides. Our company just switched from intel to amd, the intels kept just dieing out after a few months. The 2 current amds have been around for 6 months now and handle the multitasking of our systems very well. I switched from intel to amd myself and really I would say to me feels about the same. As Dan_D said though depending on what your doing depends on what truly is honest and best for what needs to get done and what is more cost effective even if you have to spend the little extra money for intel because you need to to run whatever your needs may be. Most the time it seems to me is if your biased to one side or not you will always defend that side as I can see in this thread has been done. Last just look what is going to be the major function of that computer and decide from there.

I have a hard time believing stories like this. Intel's die more frequently? In pure numbers this is probably true due to vastly larger amounts of them being sold. Not true percentage wise. In my experience the DOA rate on AMD CPUs vs. Intel's is higher. (Not that either is high.) I've probably seen one or two DOA AMD's and zero Intel's. Doing repair work I've seen far more AMD processors die than Intel's despite seeing the vast majority of machines using Intel CPUs. More to the point, I've rarely seen any CPU die specifically due to anything having to do with it being defective. I've seen more AMD's die from thermal issues back in the day, because AMD thermal protection measures were lagging behind Intel's at the time. (Pentium III & IV vs. Athlon / Athlon XP.) Since AMD improved on that front I can't recall ever seeing a CPU just die. Motherboards taking out the CPU, bad PSU's killing stuff, etc. happens to both.
 
I have a hard time believing stories like this. Intel's die more frequently? In pure numbers this is probably true due to vastly larger amounts of them being sold. Not true percentage wise. In my experience the DOA rate on AMD CPUs vs. Intel's is higher. (Not that either is high.) I've probably seen one or two DOA AMD's and zero Intel's. Doing repair work I've seen far more AMD processors die than Intel's despite seeing the vast majority of machines using Intel CPUs. More to the point, I've rarely seen any CPU die specifically due to anything having to do with it being defective. I've seen more AMD's die from thermal issues back in the day, because AMD thermal protection measures were lagging behind Intel's at the time. (Pentium III & IV vs. Athlon / Athlon XP.) Since AMD improved on that front I can't recall ever seeing a CPU just die. Motherboards taking out the CPU, bad PSU's killing stuff, etc. happens to both.

Im with ya on this. I think the odds of getting a defective AMD or Intel proc are probably the same as the odds of being mauled by a polar bear and a regular bear in the same day. Ive had a ton of AMD processors because Im a chronic upgrader and I build computers for friends and such, and none of them have been DOA or defective in any way and Ive beat the ever lovin' crap out of the ones I buy for myself. Since I dont buy expensive ones and upgrade frequently I OC their nads off cause I dont really care if I fry it or not. To date, none have ever been damaged and Ive had up to 1.6V running thru them. I recently built a PC for my wife to replace her old rig running a Pentium 4 1.6GHz! That thing was 12 years old and still chugged right along. Couldnt handle Youtube videos at full screen but it kept trying.

Im sure a lemon will sneak thru every once in a while but Id be shocked if the same person ever saw 2 defective CPU's in their lifetime. Ive been tinkering with computers since 1983 and I have yet to see one!
 
Our company just switched from intel to amd, the intels kept just dieing out after a few months.

Processors die? What the heck are you doing with them? At work over 15 years in being in charge of the department network and hundreds of processors purchased from AMD and Intel we have had 1 single processor die and that was an athlon that did not have thermal protection.
 
Processors die? What the heck are you doing with them? At work over 15 years in being in charge of the department network and hundreds of processors purchased from AMD and Intel we have had 1 single processor die and that was an athlon that did not have thermal protection.

I don't buy this either. I've worked in data centers with thousands of servers, many with more than one CPU. I've done repair work in high volume service centers, built computers for a living and deployed hundreds of them myself. I can't tell you how many bad sticks of RAM, PSUs, or motherboards I've seen, but I can tell you that I've seen a single DOA AMD processor and zero Intel's. Any CPU death I've seen has been the result of overclocking them too far, or power surges, bad motherboards / PSUs taking them out. Even then 9 times out of 10, the CPU doesn't die from that either.

CPU deaths are just rare. It's probably the hardest single component to damage in the machine electronically speaking.
 
You don't have to buy it ;) , basically for whatever number of years your experience goes other people will have a greater odds at experiencing cpu failure. Can be anything really , does it matter for you and me , no , to them it did and it worked out might as well been a reversed situation...

If AMD stops asking premium prices at launch I'll consider Piledriver if they pull the same stupid stuff they did with the launch of Bulldozer I am not going to bother and skip it as well.

At launch Bulldozer FX 8150 was like 240 Euro and I7 26K was 260 (I5 25K was 190), this really ticked me of.
 
All these great debates on intel basically vs amd once again haha much love for both sides. Our company just switched from intel to amd, the intels kept just dieing out after a few months.

I'm sorry but I have trouble believing that story. I have seen hundreds of computers, and TWO CPU deaths, an Athlon 64 that a customer killed with too much voltage while overclocking, and Pentium 4 that suffered a similar fate. Saying AMD is somehow more reliable than Intel is just straight up spreading FUD (as much as I hate using that word, it seems like the perfect word here).
 
Wow Dan your faith in me sucks...lol.

I knew someone would ask about the almost, but I decided to say almost for brevity. However, I hoped the response would have been more inquisitive. It has more to do with the limitations of the x264 encoder than anything else. For every additional thread added to an encode the effect on performance is halved.
During an encode my system utilization is at 50%. In order to max the system out I encode 2 files at the same time which has a negligible impact (meaning minutes not hours) on the first encode. What does this mean? If you need numbers my old system could only do 1 encode at a time at 100% utilization. DVD's encoded at somewhere between 1 - 2 hours (high profile) and BR titles were anywhere from 3 - 5 hours. This is now 30- to 45 minutes for 2 DVDs or 2 BR titles at no more than 3 hours. I'm sorry but I'm loving that performance every day even on Sundays. I ran the numbers before I committed. I wouldn't spend that kind of money if it wasn't going to perform. I knew what my workload was before I bought it. You have to consider the resources available for highly threaded workloads.

x264 is perfectly capable of using 100% of any current CPU, provided that you use high quality settings and a Blu Ray Source. What you describe, betray that you don't use high quality settings or you are using software that isn't fully multithreaded, as in the 2nd pass, x264 should occupy all CPU (1st pass, if used, is different, B-frame positioning isn't multithreaded). Try using Vidcoder x64 and a preset from slow and above and let's see if you can't get 100% or if you can encode 2 BR is 3 hours... :rolleyes:
 
Not spreading anything just truth about our work computers which must have been bad intel processors or at night a power surge could be possible. However the intel has a hard time running our Millenium work program along with some other programs our work uses for DUI clients.
 
x264 is perfectly capable of using 100% of any current CPU, provided that you use high quality settings and a Blu Ray Source. What you describe, betray that you don't use high quality settings or you are using software that isn't fully multithreaded, as in the 2nd pass, x264 should occupy all CPU (1st pass, if used, is different, B-frame positioning isn't multithreaded).

I'm using the x264 encoder. I don't use 2-pass I use constant and if I mentioned BR then I was using a BR source. There's probably a really good chance that I was using a "high quality" setting as well.

Try using Vidcoder x64 and a preset from slow and above and let's see if you can't get 100% or if you can encode 2 BR is 3 hours... :rolleyes:

That's a great idea...... if I used Windows. You know instead of offering a bunch of guesses, it might behoove you to have known what I was running first. Either way I don't find my "issue" to be much of one. As I stated before I just encode a second file to get max utilization. Both the first and second encode finish around 3 hours. So I don't have a problem. My previous 920 system could only do one file at a time and with 100% utilization for a single file it was much much longer. 5 hour encodes were the norm for high action.
 
I'm using the x264 encoder. I don't use 2-pass I use constant and if I mentioned BR then I was using a BR source. There's probably a really good chance that I was using a "high quality" setting as well.

So, in Bulldozer, you need to run 2 BR encodes at high quality (but you don't know what settings you use for sure) in order to max CPU use and you encode 2 films in 3 hours, while i on a 1090T, max out the CPU and get about 16 fps at preset slow+subme 9+partitions=all in a 720p... Either my CPU is defective or your settings aren't so "high quality".


That's a great idea...... if I used Windows. You know instead of offering a bunch of guesses, it might behoove you to have known what I was running first. Either way I don't find my "issue" to be much of one. As I stated before I just encode a second file to get max utilization. Both the first and second encode finish around 3 hours. So I don't have a problem. My previous 920 system could only do one file at a time and with 100% utilization for a single file it was much much longer. 5 hour encodes were the norm for high action.


Sorry,yes, i assumed you run Windows, but whatever you run though, there is something wrong. x264 should max out your CPU with 1 file. If not, you have a software problem, like the decoder isn't multithreaded. And you should check your settings, cause 2 films in 3 hours, sound like preset medium or worse for me, even for 720p. If it's 1080p, you use less than preset medium... Anyway, each eyes' are different. If you 're happy with it...
 
You don't have to buy it ;) , basically for whatever number of years your experience goes other people will have a greater odds at experiencing cpu failure. Can be anything really , does it matter for you and me , no , to them it did and it worked out might as well been a reversed situation...

If AMD stops asking premium prices at launch I'll consider Piledriver if they pull the same stupid stuff they did with the launch of Bulldozer I am not going to bother and skip it as well.

At launch Bulldozer FX 8150 was like 240 Euro and I7 26K was 260 (I5 25K was 190), this really ticked me of.

I've been doing this for almost 20 years. I've seen few CPUs from either side actually die on their own.

I'm sorry but I have trouble believing that story. I have seen hundreds of computers, and TWO CPU deaths, an Athlon 64 that a customer killed with too much voltage while overclocking, and Pentium 4 that suffered a similar fate. Saying AMD is somehow more reliable than Intel is just straight up spreading FUD (as much as I hate using that word, it seems like the perfect word here).

It's bullshit is what it is.

Not spreading anything just truth about our work computers which must have been bad intel processors or at night a power surge could be possible. However the intel has a hard time running our Millenium work program along with some other programs our work uses for DUI clients.

Listen, I don't necessarily doubt that someone believes this, but if this is how things are getting diagnosed, it's bad technicians doing the troubleshooting. Swap monkeys who don't understand how things work, who diagnose things based on little more than the shotgun approach to diagnosing computers. Replace crap until things work. And any technician who would start with replacing a CPU to see if it was bad is a poor technician. Statistically it's among the least likely failure points. Virtually everything if not everything would die first.
 
There is no software out yet that makes full use of the 8 cores or the architecture of bulldozer. we will ahve to wait like another 6 months.
 
There is software out there that does. Even when all of Bulldozers "cores" are under load, it cannot compete with an Intel system while simultaneously inhaling far more power. The architecture sucks, and people should just face that reality. It is AMDs Pentium 4. Or worse.
 
There is no software out yet that makes full use of the 8 cores or the architecture of bulldozer. we will ahve to wait like another 6 months.

There is and it is even worse if you have Linux you can recompile sources and use bulldozer optimized flags for faster code.
 
So, in Bulldozer, you need to run 2 BR encodes at high quality (but you don't know what settings you use for sure) in order to max CPU use and you encode 2 films in 3 hours, while i on a 1090T, max out the CPU and get about 16 fps at preset slow+subme 9+partitions=all in a 720p... Either my CPU is defective or your settings aren't so "high quality".

Sorry,yes, i assumed you run Windows, but whatever you run though, there is something wrong. x264 should max out your CPU with 1 file. If not, you have a software problem, like the decoder isn't multithreaded. And you should check your settings, cause 2 films in 3 hours, sound like preset medium or worse for me, even for 720p. If it's 1080p, you use less than preset medium... Anyway, each eyes' are different. If you 're happy with it...

I have dual 4284 Opterons hence why it might be hard to believe. I'm encoding 1080 not 720. I don't think you asked me what settings I ran. Again, you would do well to ask before you assume.

Since I encode 2 at a time and they both finish around the same time I'm not losing anything. If I did 1 file at a time and let's just say at 100% utilization it could be done in 1 1/2 hours. Well if I encode 2 files and both finish in 3 then I'm right where I should be.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top