How Long Before The Kickstarter Bubble Bursts?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
While many people believe that Kickstarter is the wave of the future, others are wondering when the Kickstarter bubble will burst.

I think we have about six months left of that period. Towards the end of this year, some Kickstarter projects are going to start slipping. Some will see their teams collapse amidst bicker recriminations. Some pledgers are going to start getting very angry.
 
It will always work for some well established devs. It's not likely to help many people new to the industry, at least for gaming. The article is fairly poorly written and only really cites worst case examples, especially when talking about "rewards".

On the other hand, some companies are doing this very same thing internally, rather than using a 3rd party like Kickstarter. Path of Exile has earned quite a bit of donation money during their current Beta.
 
To add, excitement will die down during the long development process of some of these projects, but when/if great finished products are released, people will hop back into it.
 
I'm the project manager/director of Herocraft Development - I believe we will go with kickstarter in the future - however the way path of exile has it setup is very nice indeed!
 
I'm assuming my project is one they are implying "will never be funded". While things are a little slow, we still have 3+ weeks left and are very soon going to release a lot of new content which will address a lot of concerns some people have raised. We have been working for a long time on our code and assets (well over $100k out-of-pocket on dev tools, art assets, animations, custom music etc.) and countless thousands of man-hours on a previous project but got screwed around by several publishers and other potential private investors.

Here is some info on our project:

http://www.indiedb.com/games/realm-explorer
http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/realmsource/realm-explorer

If we can meet our funding level we can definitely finish our game with all of the featurers we want to add, as we have most of the core functionality complete. Having $10k+ worth of prizes on a $30k budget is a bit unbalanced -- our budget reflects what it will realistically take for us to have a full-time dedicated programming team (all of our founding members are programmers so we are not contracting that out) and the work required to get all of our art assets up and running in the game engine we switched to.
 
As long as it's not being artificially propped up then the market will take care of it. That is to say the market will help the idea flourish or it will burn to the ground.
 
I'm not sure what all the furor is about.

Like any venture, if you can't afford to loose your investment, don't invest.

I go into any venture investment expecting nothing, and surprised if I get something back in the end.:D
 
I'm not sure what all the furor is about.

Like any venture, if you can't afford to loose your investment, don't invest.

I go into any venture investment expecting nothing, and surprised if I get something back in the end.:D

That's pretty much all of it, boiled down to the point where it can be easily ingested.
 
Penny Arcade has a good editorial on what to look for in a kickstarter project, as well as some of the pitfalls, here: The ugly side of Kickstarter

And my feeling is, once you get outside of game development, the level of risk falls off dramatically. A $2,000 Kickstarter for a Graphic Design Philosophy Posters project that will be done in a month or two is a much safer bet than a video game project that doesn't have even an alpha to show off.
 
I'm not sure what all the furor is about.

Like any venture, if you can't afford to loose your investment, don't invest.

I go into any venture investment expecting nothing, and surprised if I get something back in the end.:D

Nicely worded in layman terms :D
 
I'm not sure what all the furor is about.

Like any venture, if you can't afford to loose your investment, don't invest.

I go into any venture investment expecting nothing, and surprised if I get something back in the end.:D
The thing is; Your Kickstarter contributions are not investments, they are donations. BIG difference.
 
The thing is; Your Kickstarter contributions are not investments, they are donations. BIG difference.

No, they are not. You give money (they call it "pledges" or "funding") with the expectation of a return or product (they call them "rewards"). Nowhere on the site does it mention the word "donation".
 
Articles like this are what causes it.

"Oh shit the 'bubbles' gonna burst soon! better rush this project and get it up soon!"

cue flood of shitty kickstarter projects. self-fulfilling prophecy.
 

I stumbled upon your project last week after reading a few articles on existing projects, and I was legitimately interested. I must say that simply FINDING your project was not intuitive at all (not your fault). Browsing kickstarter is like browsing the ios store or google store...you can narrow it to a category, but that does little to truly filter your search. With the growing popularity of kickstarter, I fear that will be the biggest downfall of people/projects like yourself.

I wish you good luck on your project, you got my $15 after I saw:
Pyromaneyakk 2[H]4U, 11.7 Years
 
The thing is; Your Kickstarter contributions are not investments, they are donations. BIG difference.

No, they are not. You give money (they call it "pledges" or "funding") with the expectation of a return or product (they call them "rewards"). Nowhere on the site does it mention the word "donation".

Indeed.

With your investment, you receive something, whether it's something almost insignificant like a thank you card or mention on the website for a small contribution, a pre-order of the project for an appropriately sized (depending on the project) contribution, and I think I've seen stock/a stake in the company being offered for some projects as a reward for larger contributions.
 
Just because they don't call them donations doesn't mean that they aren't donations. Fine, if you have issues with the word donation then you can call it gambling, or online begging or any other number of things. You can even call them pledges.

It doesn't matter what label you attach to it, the fact remains that those who fund Kickstarter projects give money away to people who were not able to raise money by conventional means because their idea is not commercially viable.

You are essentially funding someone's hobby, or their childhood dream, or whatever you want to call it, something other than a legit business operation. As long as you realize that this is what you are doing, and you are OK with it, then there's no problem. It's difficult to understand how anyone could see the money they hand out to Kickstarter projects as an investment (unless they obtain partial ownership of the company but that too is just crazy to begin with).
 
Whether or not you use the word "investment" or "gamble" depends on how secure you figure it to be, which in terms of Kickstarter is a completely subjective thing. However, people who have game development experience in the industry starting a Kickstarter, to me, represents a pretty good chance of success, or at least the chance of a finished product making it to market.

In any case, it is still not a donation, because you are expecting a return. Whether or not you get the return is irrelevant, because a donation implies you are knowingly giving money for no return whatsoever.
 
because their idea is not commercially viable.

Well, not commercially viable in the minds of publishers / investment firms. However, if all you need is $X to finish a game and Kickstarter raises that amount for you, then you're golden :)
 
Well, not commercially viable in the minds of publishers / investment firms. However, if all you need is $X to finish a game and Kickstarter raises that amount for you, then you're golden :)
yes but the most the people who provide the funding will see is a product coming to fruition. that's not an "investment" by any stretch of the imagination. when one invests one at least expects a return larger than the principle amount.

to use fractional costs of future software as a form of investment would lead to considering pre-orders "investments" which simply put is silly.
 
yes but the most the people who provide the funding will see is a product coming to fruition. that's not an "investment" by any stretch of the imagination. when one invests one at least expects a return larger than the principle amount.

to use fractional costs of future software as a form of investment would lead to considering pre-orders "investments" which simply put is silly.

In many cases, you would be getting a ~$60 retail title for $15 or so on Kickstarter. I'd say that's a "larger return than the principle amount".
 
honestly i don't know if kickstarter will last or not but i hope it does. its a great way for small developers, artists, authors, etc. to get their products out and make some money at the same time while getting around the big publishers *cough*EA*cough*
 
In the case of games, a developer puts their name & career "on the line" for interest free project funding.

The better the developer reputation, the more funding is possible.

Sounds like a fair tradeoff. You are not buying a finished product , you are funding the development of a product, and instead of interest on the money you "loaned" you get recognition, or something tangible.

Sounds good to me.
 
On the other hand, some companies are doing this very same thing internally, rather than using a 3rd party like Kickstarter. Path of Exile has earned quite a bit of donation money during their current Beta.

Large game companies have been doing the paid beta for years, you just have to stroll down to the local retail store and pickup a copy off the shelf...
 
It's gambling. If you win, your investment gets you a game you like (wich has some personal value north of your donation.) If you lose, your investment may get you a sub-value game, or nothing at all.
 
Just because they don't call them donations doesn't mean that they aren't donations. Fine, if you have issues with the word donation then you can call it gambling, or online begging or any other number of things. You can even call them pledges.

It doesn't matter what label you attach to it, the fact remains that those who fund Kickstarter projects give money away to people who were not able to raise money by conventional means because their idea is not commercially viable.

You are essentially funding someone's hobby, or their childhood dream, or whatever you want to call it, something other than a legit business operation. As long as you realize that this is what you are doing, and you are OK with it, then there's no problem. It's difficult to understand how anyone could see the money they hand out to Kickstarter projects as an investment (unless they obtain partial ownership of the company but that too is just crazy to begin with).

lot of good stuff funded by kickstarter that contradicts your opinion. Kickstart is more like Ebay than anything else, if enough people bid, everyone wins. :p

sure, there are a lot of goofy ass projects that would or should never see the light of day, but when you take good projects that need proof of concept, i. e. people willing to buy it, it is a life saver. Order of the stick and the Luna-tik Ipod nano bracelet are good examples.

The Ebay analogy is one reason I don't see a "bubble" bursting, I see kickstarter as more of a enabling tool that should always have a place, now that the idea has taken root.
 
lot of good stuff funded by kickstarter that contradicts your opinion. Kickstart is more like Ebay than anything else, if enough people bid, everyone wins. :p

sure, there are a lot of goofy ass projects that would or should never see the light of day, but when you take good projects that need proof of concept, i. e. people willing to buy it, it is a life saver. Order of the stick and the Luna-tik Ipod nano bracelet are good examples.

The Ebay analogy is one reason I don't see a "bubble" bursting, I see kickstarter as more of a enabling tool that should always have a place, now that the idea has taken root.
he's not arguing with the impact or effect but rather the use of the concept "investment" to describe the process.

ebay purchases are not "investments", neither are pre-sale purchases nor *any* purchases for that matter. In fact, even fronting money without collateral, a behavior many might consider investment, is properly called "speculation."

unless one places collateral for a loan, a loan that is expected to be repaid, the process is not an "investment."

investment is not loaning someone money and receiving a good; one does not loan 10,000 dollars to someone and expect to be repaid in fruit baskets or vehicle tires--unless one were participating in a co-op/collective ownership structure.

if one were to receive shares from the company *that* would be the rare exception that one could conclude was an investment.
 
he's not arguing with the impact or effect but rather the use of the concept "investment" to describe the process.

ebay purchases are not "investments", neither are pre-sale purchases nor *any* purchases for that matter. In fact, even fronting money without collateral, a behavior many might consider investment, is properly called "speculation."

unless one places collateral for a loan, a loan that is expected to be repaid, the process is not an "investment."

investment is not loaning someone money and receiving a good; one does not loan 10,000 dollars to someone and expect to be repaid in fruit baskets or vehicle tires--unless one were participating in a co-op/collective ownership structure.

if one were to receive shares from the company *that* would be the rare exception that one could conclude was an investment.

But, they are not really donations either. you give a donation with no expectation of a reward or a return on your money.

you do pledge money into kickstarter with the expectation of a product resulting from it, unless the project fails to garner enough support, in that case, you lose no money. there is the risk of a successful project failing to supply the end product, whatever that may be, and in that regard it does resemble an investment. You have no way of knowing if an investment in an IPO will succeed when you give them money. you have the expectation of a return, but no guarantee.
 
I agree they aren't donations. But neither are they investments and should not be equated to stock purchases for the reasons noted above.

They most closely resemble collectives. Co-ops or co-ownership and this opinion seems to be supported by the inclusion of credits to pledgers. When there is a collective buy-in for an end product that will be distributed among the contributors then you have a co-ownership model in action.


If one uses that template to understand the kickstarter phenomenon then I believe it strengthens the sustainability of the model. Investment models would dwindle over time as "investors" or speculators lose out in the long run.

But in so far as people desire to be part of a collective expression and/or ownership of an idea they believe in then this is no bubble at all. It's simply an expression of what people value in terms of forms of content creation.

That's a powerful statement, I think. The impetus is on the giving, the outcome is less relevant to some extent. To an investor, the outcome is all. To a pledger the outcome matters less in so far as I deem my expression to be focused on support of the creation and fruition is a hoped for and exciting outcome yet not necessarily fundamental to my reasoning for support. that might be why he saw it as a donation--because people generally donate out of goodness of will without much regard to how the gift is put to use (provided it's not blatantly misused like money for food going to money for beer). Some people might even disagree with that last point of mine in that to some the very act of giving fulfills the desire. Once a gift is given whatever happens is irrelevant to the giver. It's not longer the giver's money but rather the receiver.

But that's a more philosophical position. I don't know if people want to pursue that inquiry but it's certainly interesting when discussing the sustainability of alternative business models.
 
Well, it seems like several people against using the term "investment" don't actually understand the definition:

Wikipedia said:
Investment has different meanings in finance and economics. Finance investment is putting money into something with the expectation of gain, that upon thorough analysis, has a high degree of security for the principal amount, as well as security of return, within an expected period of time.[1] In contrast putting money into something with an expectation of gain without thorough analysis, without security of principal, and without security of return is speculation or gambling.

There is no implication of stock trading or any other practice like that in order to make something an "investment". People buy antiques or collectibles and call it an "investment" because they later hope to sell them for more money. In the same way, Kickstarter can be considered an investment because you are putting money in with the expectation of an equal or greater return. Whether or not you consider it "secure", again, is completely subjective.
 
security is not subjective. it has a literal meaning in finance.

I suggest you look it up before asserting that people using it correctly are misunderstanding the issues.
 
The Kickstarter site describes itself as:
Kickstarter is a new form of commerce and patronage, not a place for investment or lending.
In the FAQ it talks about pledging not investing, which I think is a legal fig leaf so no one tries to sue Kickstarter when some backed project fails to produce anything.
 
How long will it last? Until too many scams are propped up that have no intention of making a product and every intention of just walking away with "free" money. Once that happens, things will settle down. They could probably learn a lot from eBay in that regard.
 
investment vs donations: I think this will be a matter of what you are legally bound to. If you pledge $100 to a project on Kickstarter, do you have an ability to sue if you do not get what was promised to you? Can you run to the BBB of the project's home state and have a case? You might be able to argue contract law, but I'm not sure...

Having backed over 35 projects, to me this really is a donation with the hope that I get something back in return, like a good bartering system. For the project's themselves, from their point of view this is an investment you're making in them, but without the exchange of ownership (VC) or large debt.

Kickstarter definitely needs to continue to make it clear that this is not Amazon, nor a real investment for the pledgors. I have several projects that are several years old that are not yet fulfilled, while others send product in weeks of closing.
 
It doesn't matter what label you attach to it, the fact remains that those who fund Kickstarter projects give money away to people who were not able to raise money by conventional means because their idea is not commercially viable.

You are essentially funding someone's hobby, or their childhood dream, or whatever you want to call it, something other than a legit business operation. As long as you realize that this is what you are doing, and you are OK with it, then there's no problem. It's difficult to understand how anyone could see the money they hand out to Kickstarter projects as an investment (unless they obtain partial ownership of the company but that too is just crazy to begin with).

I suggest talking with some entrepreneurs or small business owners about how to fund their ideas. Just because they don't have VC money or want to fund their business on debt doesn't mean their idea isn't viable. Kickstarter, indeed "crowdsourcing," is a fresh, new way to get an idea of yours off the ground without selling ownership or putting yourself under the fuse of debt.

I think many people are just misusing the term "investment" for something like that. It sort of is like helping someone by investing in their company, but it's not technically accurate.

There are plenty of actual business ideas and/or products in Kickstarter. They're not just all hobbies. In fact, some of them are established businesses looking for a new way to fund expansion or their next product.
 
In many cases, you would be getting a ~$60 retail title for $15 or so on Kickstarter. I'd say that's a "larger return than the principle amount".

What indie/small publisher game has EVER gone for $60?

And if it did, how long did it take before the price quickly dropped?

Prediction: no one will EVER get a $60 game for $15 from Kickstarter.
 
Just like mainstream video games, there will always be the good ones and the bad ones.

There are many people who got burned by pre-ordering a game which turns out to be utter turd too, but that didn't stop people from pre-ordering future games.;)
 
Depends on the quality of the first batch and the games that come after it. There still hasn't been a return from any of the larger projects. If they are crappy then the whole thing will sink, if a few of them are good and theres a stream of good ones that follow, then game making kickstarters could be sustained for years, unless the bad/scam projects end it prematurely.
 
Back
Top