The Mounting Minuses at Google+

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Raise your hand if you are surprised by this news. How many of you guys use Google+, how much and how often?

It turns out Google+ is a virtual ghost town compared with the site of rival Facebook Inc., which is preparing for a massive initial public offering. New data from research firm comScore Inc. shows that Google+ users are signing up—but then not doing much there. Visitors using personal computers spent an average of about three minutes a month on Google+ between September and January, versus six to seven hours on Facebook each month over the same period.
 
I signed up for it during beta and haven't been on it since.
 
I signed up for it during beta and haven't been on it since.

Same here. Most of my friends don't bother with it so neither do I.

Sorry Google, but you have a flop.
 
I wish more people would use google+. It makes it a lot easier for me to keep things sorted between: Friends, close friends, work "friends", colleagues, the boss + co, customers.

Facebook's groups are so cryptic I have a fake account that I shove around between groups just to test, and some stuff still gets shown.
 
I wish more people would use google+. It makes it a lot easier for me to keep things sorted between: Friends, close friends, work "friends", colleagues, the boss + co, customers.

Facebook's groups are so cryptic I have a fake account that I shove around between groups just to test, and some stuff still gets shown.

Sadly, the best answer is to watch what you post.
 
I do like the circle mechanism for controlling contacts and access to things like photos. I just wish they'd done it sooner. Many of the people in my contacts are not willing to sign up for Google+.


pinterest implemented a much better google+ idea

I tried Pinterest for a bit, but I don't really "get" it.

Their terms of service don't exactly give me warm fuzzies, either:

You agree to defend, indemnify, and hold Cold Brew Labs, its officers, directors, employees and agents, harmless from and against any claims, liabilities, damages, losses, and expenses, including, without limitation, reasonable legal and accounting fees, arising out of or in any way connected with (i) your access to or use of the Site, Application, Services or Site Content, (ii) your Member Content, or (iii) your violation of these Terms.

The way I read it, if you post copyrighted material and they get sued, you could be on the hook for any costs they incur.
 
I have 36 friends on Facebook and I unsubscribed from everyone of them. I really cant stand reading peoples emo crap. I use it now just to keep tabs on some of my favorite watering holes and Breweries for new beer releases.

Google+ does back up my photos from my phone and that's the only thing I use it for.
 
Google really flubbed the launch for G+. People were interested in it when it first came out, but it was a "closed" by invite only beta, so they soon lost interest. Once Google opened it up to everyone, they had already lost all their buzz and nobody was interested in using it anymore. They really missed their opportunity to get a critical mass of users actually using it.

It's like they didn't get the fact that for a social network to catch on, you have to have a lot of people actually using it, especially when trying to go up against an already well-established competitor...
 
I can't wait for the social network craze to just go away already.

I honestly just don't get it. Why would you want to put your life out there for random strangers to look at? And why would you want to follow random peoples lives, that you really don't know or care about, instead of living your own? The only thing that social networking has brought into my life was drama.
 
I never bothered creating one.

I only reluctantly have a Facebook page. I have one because that's where most people I know have an account and communicate/send party invites/etc./etc.

For me, the only thing that could make me change services is if a competing service somehow magically wound up with the majority of users and that type of activity suddenly happened there.

Until that happens, I really have no interest in Google+.
 
I liked Jon Stewart's take on Google+: "Or as GMail users know it, what the fuck is that up in the corner? Can I turn that off?" :D

I love Google's other services but have no desire to be a part of their social network or anyone else's. It all seems like a worthless timesink to me.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038436106 said:
I never bothered creating one.

I only reluctantly have a Facebook page. I have one because that's where most people I know have an account and communicate/send party invites/etc./etc.

For me, the only thing that could make me change services is if a competing service somehow magically wound up with the majority of users and that type of activity suddenly happened there.

Until that happens, I really have no interest in Google+.

Oh, and the fact that Google disallowed fake names really peeved me, and made me not want to join either. I don't want my real name out on the Internet.
 
I use Google+ in a different way then Facebook. Facebook is more about what friends have done and Google+ is more about what topics interest me. Most of whats on Facebook I could careless. I get some of that in + but at least right now i get more useful info out of +.
 
I never really had a reason to flee Facebook and I already had my FB contacts divided into different groups.
Google never gave us a reason to switch other than "it's new."
I'm not going to re-find my friends and the hundreds of businesses I follow daily on FB for no reason.
Google was counting on the FB to go the way of MySpace when the new privacy rules came out and it didn't happen.
 
I dont use G+ because no one I know figured out how to actually use it.. So by default Im just kind of right back to using facebook..

I wouldnt even really call it "using" either.. I blocked every app, blocked most all feeds except for about 5 people who dont constantly spam crap..
 
I stayed the hell away from it because I don't want to loose access to my gmail and google docs accounts because of a violation of badly defined and murky terms of service. Until google can guarantee me they won't boot me from those accounts on the basis of some arbitrarily enforced rule, I won't touch google + with a ten foot pole.
 
.... I feel suicidal for being a part of a statistic like this!! :p
 
I signed up during the beta and deleted the account when Google updated the privacy policy.
 
I tried it for a bit....... I really did not like the format. Keep it simple.... should have just cloned facebook but with much higher privacy controls.
 
Sadly, the best answer is to watch what you post.

Yup. Like Ben Franklin said, three can keep a secret if two of them are dead. Anything you put out there is going to get somewhere you didn't want one way or another.
 
Google has simply lost its way. They are engaged in a continual process of changing familiar, entirely functional interface elements for absolutely no reason other than to change things. This has been going on for a while -- it is no surprise that the incompetence extends into other areas of the business.

This is what happens when things become too large for a single person, or close-knit group of individuals, to manage. Or when that group simply cashes out, and ceases to exist.
 
I tried it for a bit....... I really did not like the format. Keep it simple.... should have just cloned facebook but with much higher privacy controls.

Google / Face Book and privacy are mutually exclusive terms
 
I signed up and never us it as well.

I think it's just not that much better. Facebook uses the KISS theory, so don't have to think about it at all. i can be a social Zombie, and a hard core techy.
 
Here are some things I can give you off my finger tips.
Quicky and dirty: Its buggy, its lame (not to slang way but it is) it lacks features and has no leg up on the competition


1. There is the issue of its annoying: I don't have 10 friends? TELL ME ALL THE TIME! I know I don't have 10 friends, and I don't want to, but there is a huge banner prodding me to round out the list every time I log in.
They are constantly pushing this: "Whats hot" Feature, I can care less about celebrities.
2. More like 1a, Things that did work don't work anymore: I had G+ back in the beta and one thing I wanted to do was to use a trick I saw that uses your Facebook secrete send to post address. Add that email as a friend and send them stuff and its auto posted on FB. I wanted to do this for my friends bachelor party. Nope! You can do this on the page if you click a special box every time but NOT from the phone.
They use to have a nice feed, think of it as a group and you can see groups on their own. This feed was called incoming, someone added you and you don't feel like adding them, their posts that you can see end up in the incoming bin. They got rid of this, why I don't know, but now you can see "whats hot on your phone!!!" :|
3. Things are broken, Its been a few months now and more than a handfull of updates and STILL posting in landscape mode via a mobile device will deactivate spell check. Have they fixed it? No, Do they care? I have no clue.

Lets move on to some other things, They added youtube so that you can watch videos while you use G+ ... okay maybe nice for someone. They moved the hang out, chat shout session whatever of the various names they call it, to a seperate program... okay... This one may be me, I side load this to my Kindle fire, and perhaps since the apk comes from my phone, but it doesn't seem to have any concept of later icons, buttons etc, on a larger screen.

I could go on, yes I do actually still have things to rant about, but you get the gist. The thing is at first you were going to have to come to the table with something other's didn't, they did not do that. Second you need to have a stand up product - they do not.

With all the storage Google touts they give, the innovation that goes through their veins they could do a lot more. They could take the livejornal voice post feature and give it away for free. They sure could use an interface makeover, and over, and over... There is zero creativity and personality there.
 
Facebook seems way more childish and unprofessional, where G+ is more professional and adult oriented. Facebook is all games, "like this post if you want to go out with me" type of posts, and stupid women bitching about life.

I use G+ a LOT more than I do Facebook. FB is very rarely used. Haven't logged in to that POS for around a month or two... Christmas time, anyway. Google+ has been my main hangout since.... :)
 
Google really flubbed the launch for G+. People were interested in it when it first came out, but it was a "closed" by invite only beta, so they soon lost interest. Once Google opened it up to everyone, they had already lost all their buzz and nobody was interested in using it anymore. They really missed their opportunity to get a critical mass of users actually using it.

It's like they didn't get the fact that for a social network to catch on, you have to have a lot of people actually using it, especially when trying to go up against an already well-established competitor...

I came here to say this. Google used the same invite-only launch method they used for Gmail. It worked great for Gmail because Gmail was so much better than any other free email provider at the time - the exclusivity of this amazing email service really enticed people. And because email does not require a critical mass of users to be useful - whether your email provider has 10 users or 10 million it's not really going to affect your experience. For Google+ this strategy was horrible though. For one thing Google+ is playing catch-up with Facebook, when you're the clear underdog keeping your product difficult to access isn't going to help you any. And for another thing social networks require lots of users to be useful. All the people that were able to sign up got bored when none of their friends could sign up and stopped using it.

Google+ had loads of initial buzz, lots of celebrities were making pages at the beginning. However I tried to make an account probably 5 times during the first month or so and was denied each time. Eventually I got frustrated and gave up, when they finally got around to opening it up to everyone it was too late. They should have opened it to the masses immediately. If their service was not prepared for that kind of load that's their fault for not preparing ahead of time. By not planning on having a blockbuster with loads of users they were not prepared when the opportunity presented itself.
 
I don't use facebook due to their privacy policies and generally I don't care for social networking. Since most everyone I know are using gmail, I started using g+ as sort of replacement for funny / interesting links that used to be sent via chain email or email list. Much less intrusive since it doesn't clog up my email box and I can check it when I want.

I was worried about google's recent privacy policy changes and I do encourage anyone using g+ to look into them and make their own decision before continuing use of the service.
 
The updated privacy policy isn't helping much either.

Or, more accurately, all the fear mongering articles about a total non-issue isn't helping. The privacy policy itself is fine - it's actually really good - but fear drives more traffic, so that's what the articles are.

That said I use Google+, but I don't spend much time on it. Which to be honest is how I use almost all Google properties. I hop on, do whatever I want quickly, and move on.
 
Google+ has much less noise to me.

I follow a lot of tech stuff too, and every bloke in Silicon Valley seems to use it, so why not? Besides, it's easier to follow tech trends without the lack of noise and crap coming up.

As for IRL friends... most of them never use it except for hangouts. I can see the prebundling with ICS + photo backups to Picasa as a way to draw in mobile users though.
 
Registering for G+ gives a significant free upgrade to picassa web albums on the same Google account.
That is the extent of my experience with G+

To be fair, I don't use FB any more either, the only reason I still have a page is so my Fiancé can log in as me from time to time and respond to her Castleville requests. :rolleyes:
 
I don't use facebook due to their privacy policies and generally I don't care for social networking. Since most everyone I know are using gmail, I started using g+ as sort of replacement for funny / interesting links that used to be sent via chain email or email list. Much less intrusive since it doesn't clog up my email box and I can check it when I want.

I was worried about google's recent privacy policy changes and I do encourage anyone using g+ to look into them and make their own decision before continuing use of the service.

I've had it not just with Google, but with all the popular data mining operations that people participate in. I'm sick of giving random companies permission to spy on me, the right to use what I put up, etc.

DuckDuckGo replaces Google. Tonido replaces Dropbox. My own ~$3.80/month domain name's email replaces Gmail. I still have more work to do, but it feels good to be in better control of my personal information.
 
Back
Top