Am I surprised by that study?
No.
Is Google+ a ghost town?
No.
Is the study wrong?
Yes and No.
Google+ appeals to the type of person who would LinkedIn rather than Monster to go hunting for jobs. It appeals to the type of person who would prefer Tolkien oven Meyer. It appears to the person who has a job, and not those who hang around in Starbucks.
The problem, if you could call it a problem, is that Google+ does not appeal to the average consumer, the people who say, used Prodigy, then moved to AOL, then moved to Myspace, and then moved to Facebook. So far Google+ has appealed to a more mature audience, the type of person who, well, is turned off the by the immature audience services like Facebook attract.
What a lot of studies don't understand is why Google+ attracts a more mature audience. For many analysts there is a desperate need to "pit" the services of one site against another. There always has to be a competitor. There always has to be a winner. There always has to be a loser. The problem is, Internet Traffic isn't a zero-sum game. Case in point would be this site. Just because I visit HardOCP.com doesn't mean I go out of my way to avoid Arstechnica. Just because I read Sluggy Freelance doesn't mean I ignore Schlock Mercenary. The types of conflict and winner / loser positioning that analysts and their studies try to force corporations like Google and Facebook into are largely unique to those sites. SOMEBODY has an axe to grind, pure and simple. Because most of these studies are approached with a predetermined expectation of what the result will be, and how that result will be achieved, we never see real questions get answered. We never see an exact detailing of "Why" Facebook appeals to a wider crowd than Google+. We just see data saying that Facebook does appeal to a wider crowd.
Now, does the lack of overall traffic to Google+ compared to "other" social services make it a failure?
No. Why would it?
Let me make another example to try and highlight the question here. http://3btech.net/ is given an Alexa rank of :261,092. Newegg.com is given a rank of 336. Does this make 3btech a failure just because they pull far less traffic than Newegg? No. Why would it? What's the association? How does the performance of one site directly impact the performance of another site?
The metric of performance for any particular website that is in the business to make money is based on whether or not that website makes money. If Google+ is returning a positive profit for the work Google puts into it, then it's a success, no matter that anybody else does.
From Google's perspective the addition of Google+ as a social service remains a natural extension of everything Google was already doing. Google already fields a wide range of online applications ranging from email clients to office suites. People who have Google accounts are already using Google Docs like an external hard-drive, using Gmail to chat, and so on and so forth. From Google's perspective it's easier to just simply pull functions that are tangential to one service and focus on a UI or application that better serves that function.
Case in point would be Google Voice. Yes, you can make calls using Google Voice through Gmail... but if you go to the Google Voice web-page you'll be presented with fine detailed information about your phone calls through a dedicated interface.
In this type of application production environment one has to keep in mind that Google+ doesn't have to be wildly successful or have tons of users. It's simply giving a dedicated interface to functions that other aspects of Google were being used for. It's a more traditional type of social networking service compared to previous attempts by Google such as Buzz or Wave, but that traditional approach makes it easier to quantify and for people to identify with.
* * *
Now, having just ripped 90% of the posts in this thread to shreds, I want to point something out to those who say that Google has too much information:
You can delete your information on Google. There are multiple tutorials on how to do so. You are certainly welcome to use the Bing search engine which is run by a Corporation that has been convicted of State, Federal, or National crimes on 5 out of the 7 continents on the world. (I'm unaware of any criminal convictions against Microsoft in Australia or Antarctica)
And now something for those who live in the US:
Your local government probably has more personal information on you than Google.
The Credit Agencies like Equifax do have more personal information than Google..
So, if you want to howl against Google for all of the information that Google gathers?
I expect to see all of the US readers of this thread howling to their Congressional Candidates this year about the even more aggressive collection of personal information by the credit agencies.
No.
Is Google+ a ghost town?
No.
Is the study wrong?
Yes and No.
Google+ appeals to the type of person who would LinkedIn rather than Monster to go hunting for jobs. It appeals to the type of person who would prefer Tolkien oven Meyer. It appears to the person who has a job, and not those who hang around in Starbucks.
The problem, if you could call it a problem, is that Google+ does not appeal to the average consumer, the people who say, used Prodigy, then moved to AOL, then moved to Myspace, and then moved to Facebook. So far Google+ has appealed to a more mature audience, the type of person who, well, is turned off the by the immature audience services like Facebook attract.
What a lot of studies don't understand is why Google+ attracts a more mature audience. For many analysts there is a desperate need to "pit" the services of one site against another. There always has to be a competitor. There always has to be a winner. There always has to be a loser. The problem is, Internet Traffic isn't a zero-sum game. Case in point would be this site. Just because I visit HardOCP.com doesn't mean I go out of my way to avoid Arstechnica. Just because I read Sluggy Freelance doesn't mean I ignore Schlock Mercenary. The types of conflict and winner / loser positioning that analysts and their studies try to force corporations like Google and Facebook into are largely unique to those sites. SOMEBODY has an axe to grind, pure and simple. Because most of these studies are approached with a predetermined expectation of what the result will be, and how that result will be achieved, we never see real questions get answered. We never see an exact detailing of "Why" Facebook appeals to a wider crowd than Google+. We just see data saying that Facebook does appeal to a wider crowd.
Now, does the lack of overall traffic to Google+ compared to "other" social services make it a failure?
No. Why would it?
Let me make another example to try and highlight the question here. http://3btech.net/ is given an Alexa rank of :261,092. Newegg.com is given a rank of 336. Does this make 3btech a failure just because they pull far less traffic than Newegg? No. Why would it? What's the association? How does the performance of one site directly impact the performance of another site?
The metric of performance for any particular website that is in the business to make money is based on whether or not that website makes money. If Google+ is returning a positive profit for the work Google puts into it, then it's a success, no matter that anybody else does.
From Google's perspective the addition of Google+ as a social service remains a natural extension of everything Google was already doing. Google already fields a wide range of online applications ranging from email clients to office suites. People who have Google accounts are already using Google Docs like an external hard-drive, using Gmail to chat, and so on and so forth. From Google's perspective it's easier to just simply pull functions that are tangential to one service and focus on a UI or application that better serves that function.
Case in point would be Google Voice. Yes, you can make calls using Google Voice through Gmail... but if you go to the Google Voice web-page you'll be presented with fine detailed information about your phone calls through a dedicated interface.
In this type of application production environment one has to keep in mind that Google+ doesn't have to be wildly successful or have tons of users. It's simply giving a dedicated interface to functions that other aspects of Google were being used for. It's a more traditional type of social networking service compared to previous attempts by Google such as Buzz or Wave, but that traditional approach makes it easier to quantify and for people to identify with.
* * *
Now, having just ripped 90% of the posts in this thread to shreds, I want to point something out to those who say that Google has too much information:
You can delete your information on Google. There are multiple tutorials on how to do so. You are certainly welcome to use the Bing search engine which is run by a Corporation that has been convicted of State, Federal, or National crimes on 5 out of the 7 continents on the world. (I'm unaware of any criminal convictions against Microsoft in Australia or Antarctica)
And now something for those who live in the US:
Your local government probably has more personal information on you than Google.
The Credit Agencies like Equifax do have more personal information than Google..
So, if you want to howl against Google for all of the information that Google gathers?
I expect to see all of the US readers of this thread howling to their Congressional Candidates this year about the even more aggressive collection of personal information by the credit agencies.