Nightline Goes Inside Foxconn

Has anyone considered that Foxconn executives LIED to Apple about the working conditions there? It's not like Apple travels to China to inspect the factories daily.

They order product to be built, and it shows up in shipping containers. If it's right, they received what they paid for.

Apple should be commended for taking action, where it had no real legal position to do so, and investigate.

More often then you think. They have paid apple personal living in China that are their to make sure everything is in order and QC is happening.
 
I'm boycotting Samsung, Sony, Intel, etc... until they stop using foxconn. Those scumbag companies don't deserve my money! I wonder how much Motorola payed ABC for this.

not srs
 
Some bigwigs at ABC probably have mega shares of Apple stock and probably arranged for this.

ABC is owned by Disney.

Disney's CEO is on the board of Apple.

Steve Jobs was the largest shareholder of Disney. (now it's the Jobs family)

You decide how impartial this report is.

That being said, it doesn't really matter what network went there. There is no way their Chinese escorts would ever have let them see any of the bad stuff. If anything the ABC tour of the factory gave the workers there one day (or at least a few hours) of relief before everything returned to normal.

Remember the forced Foxconn dormitories?

article-1285980-09FFBFAD000005DC-122_636x456.jpg


Workers are not permitted to live "off campus". In many cases if they even ever leave leave the campus, they are fired. They work something like 17 hours a day too.
 
Apple doesn't own Foxconn, and so they can't do anything. If there were factories in the US that can support what Apple and the other companies need they probably would take their business to them.

If you want to break this all out that is fine. I never said Apple owns Foxconn, but if you think Apple has no sway at all over what Foxconn does you are seriously deluding yourself. They can do an awful lot if they really chose to, but they do not choose to. That is why they are getting picked on.

It's China's problem, not ours. The Chinese people can demand the rights they want, the only thing we can do is support them.

Since China is quickly becoming the largest economic power in the world, it is all of our problems.


Beautiful, a profound and well thought out argument. :rolleyes: (Since logic seems to evade you; that was sarcasm.)

Thank you! This is the point all along.

Logic seems to be minimal here, and shame on Steve for encouraging this.

Yes let's keep supporting the everyone jump off the bridge scenario and if you buy it, surely that is the same as supporting it. Also let us just assume that everyone that dislikes Apple has to be mindless hypocrites... Because of course that argument is logical...

Exactly, Apple seems to be the only company that has done ANYTHING to promote well being towards the people they do business with.

This uses the same exact faulty logic that you apply when saying people shouldn't just criticize Apple. Just because you see a lot of press about what Apple is doing or not doing, does not mean that other companies are not also trying to affect change. Your logic is completely flawed throughout your whole post here with no actual factual information except spreading more disinformation and illogical support for Apple.
 
I'm sure if she said what was really on her mind, she would turn up in a Chinese jail somewhere.

Between apple and the Chinese government? I would be surprised if she wasn't already punished (physically beaten) or in jail already. This stuff seriously ticks me off, and they didn't even go into the bad stuff.
 
The only people that I see claiming that Foxconn's working conditions are wrong are the people on here that hate Apple with a passion (and whatever, to each their own).

The people that committed suicide, were blown-up, maimed, tortured and sexually assaulted would probably beg to differ with your assessment.

This isn't "NEW," we've been reporting on this now for two straight years.

Unless all these Foxconn defenders are claiming EVERY. STORY. IS. FAKE. just to make Foxconn look bad. :rolleyes:
 
People crying about picking on Apple....I say it is the opposite. The ONLY reason anyone defends this type of situation is BECAUSE it is Apple. How many Dell/Microsoft/Sony/Nintendo fans do you see in here defending Foxconn? Zero.

The sad part is, were aren't even talking about Apple, we are talking about Foxconn.

Seriously, if this was General Motors, would ANY of you defend them like you are defending Foxconn?


News: There was an explosion at GM's Camaro facility killing 4 and hospitalizing 70. Improper working conditions lead to the deadly explosion, the second in a week, after repeated warnings from outside agencies went ignored.

This, just days after installing suicide nets around the assembly plant following dozens of suicides in the last three weeks.
GM was forced into the spotlight after inhumane work conditions were discovered, underage workers were beaten and several allegation of sexual assaults had been filed against the company. As we speak, there are 300 people on a roof threatening to jump unless they are given a raise.


Fruitcakes: YUO ARE PICKING ON GM!!! ITS STILL LOWAR THAN TEH NATIONAL AVERIDGE!!!!!


Wow. Seriously...wow.
 

News: There was an explosion at GM's Camaro facility killing 4 and hospitalizing 70. Improper working conditions lead to the deadly explosion, the second in a week, after repeated warnings from outside agencies went ignored.

This, just days after installing suicide nets around the assembly plant following dozens of suicides in the last three weeks.
GM was forced into the spotlight after inhumane work conditions were discovered, underage workers were beaten and several allegation of sexual assaults had been filed against the company. As we speak, there are 300 people on a roof threatening to jump unless they are given a raise.


Actually, sounds sortof like GM's Freemont facility back in the 70s :p
 
The people that committed suicide, were blown-up, maimed, tortured and sexually assaulted would probably beg to differ with your assessment.

This isn't "NEW," we've been reporting on this now for two straight years.

Unless all these Foxconn defenders are claiming EVERY. STORY. IS. FAKE. just to make Foxconn look bad. :rolleyes:

I never said that... you took my quote out of context or completely misunderstood me. It was in response to this:

As for the Apple defenders,sure,other companies do this,but since when does two wrongs make it right.

I haven't seen the 'defenders' crying foul or claiming that two wrongs make a right... only the people that time and time again love attacking Apple seem to be bringing it up (and like I said... who cares... everyone is entitled to spend their money how they want). People like playing 'gotcha' and I'm just pointing out what wasn't said.

I'm not saying that Foxconn hasn't had it's share of problems or that it's even a great place to work.

I'm sure some folks do genuinely care about the situation over there, but the majority of the people (here at least) love hopping on the moral superiority bandwagon when they're doing the exact same thing they claim to oppose when it's obvious they're ONLY using it to rationalize their irrational prejudices. It's based on emotion, not logic (dishonest).

I can't help but think of a single mid-30's divorcee driving a hummer while preaching about saving the environment every time I see someone post "and THIS is why I h8 appole" when a story about Foxconn comes up and then glance down at their signature.

Bash 'em all you want, but don't hide behind some imaginary moral soapbox trying to justify it because it makes you (not you, just people in general) lose credibility and integrity. It's very phoney.
 
whoops!


My bad, I apologize...I misinterpreted what you meant. :)

lol it's all good. I probably could of used better words to convey my message, re-reading it, I can see why you drew that conclusion.
 
Damn, here in America, they won't even let prisoners live in those kind of quarters :eek:
 
I think this blog sums up how I feel about the whole Foxconn thing.

I agree with most of that sentiment. The problem is, Apple used to manufacture most everything in the US and then turned to China to apparentlly compete with other companies. Only they still kept their high prices and pocketed huge profits. So people basically kept paying the premium for manufacturing in America, while Apple raked in huge profits from manufacturing overseas off of quasi slave labor. If Apple were to bring back manufacturing to the United States and kept prices relatively close to their current ones, then I might serious consider buying Apple products.

I will when given a choice, buy products from America or another country over those made in China. And I would pay a small price premium on occasion to buy a product manufactured mostly in America.
 
I like how everyone thinks Foxconn factory workers are treated the worst. Something makes me think there are PLENTY of factories with MAGNITUDES worse working conditions.

But just because a company is well known and successful...instantly makes them a terrible company and forced to "raise" these levels in a country where they have always been extremely low.

This reminds me of that clothing/shoe sweatshop crap earlier in the decade... this stuff has always been there. Crappy working conditions where in the US too before people backlashed and created unions/forced the gov to regulate business.

If you guys (Americans) want your techy gadgets to continue to be cheap like they are now, or for companies to make as much money they do to use creating more cool tech, I'd suggest shut your yappers and let things stay how they have been/were.

</rage>

My hope for the future, although idealic and somewhat crazy, is that in 15-20 years, we might see a bit of a cultural revolution/oddity if we start seeing much more capable human-emulating robots that become capable of doing minimum wage jobs like serving food or assembly line work.

Even if one of these robots cost $20,000.00 akin to the purchase of a car, not having to pay that robot $8.00 an hour and only paying $1.56/hr in electricity plus occasional maintenance cost could have that $20,000.00 paid off in just 3,000 hours. If you worked the robot 24/7 like you could do with a robot but never with an employee, those 3,000 hours reprsents just four months of work(120ish days). You'd be making a profit via the robot four months in.

That's not counting how much you might save not having to provide the robot with a health care plan, dental plan, etc. Probably the maintenance cost for the robot would balance out ok with providing medical + dental. There'd be some savings in HR I imagine too with not having to really advertise your 'hiring', 'interviews' and then 'training' new employees that quit only a x months later from minimum wage paying jobs. Combine that with the benefit of no increase of sick days in the winter or employees calling in sick for work because their car wouldn't start, etc. Hopefully days spent out of operation waiting on parts/repairs for robots would be less than the average number of sick days a minimum wage employee takes over a year.

Weird concept to imagine us being able to get our cheap-consumer goods for cheap + no human rights violations + an oddity where there are no more minimum wage/service jobs and only second-tier/jobs requiring some education/training/specialization, isn't it?
 
People crying about picking on Apple....I say it is the opposite. The ONLY reason anyone defends this type of situation is BECAUSE it is Apple. How many Dell/Microsoft/Sony/Nintendo fans do you see in here defending Foxconn? Zero.

The sad part is, were aren't even talking about Apple, we are talking about Foxconn.

Seriously, if this was General Motors, would ANY of you defend them like you are defending Foxconn?


News: There was an explosion at GM's Camaro facility killing 4 and hospitalizing 70. Improper working conditions lead to the deadly explosion, the second in a week, after repeated warnings from outside agencies went ignored.

This, just days after installing suicide nets around the assembly plant following dozens of suicides in the last three weeks.
GM was forced into the spotlight after inhumane work conditions were discovered, underage workers were beaten and several allegation of sexual assaults had been filed against the company. As we speak, there are 300 people on a roof threatening to jump unless they are given a raise.


Fruitcakes: YUO ARE PICKING ON GM!!! ITS STILL LOWAR THAN TEH NATIONAL AVERIDGE!!!!!


Wow. Seriously...wow.

That'd be news if it was the US. But it's not. I have no love for Apple, and in fact own exactly ZERO Apple products. My whole issue with this is that Foxconn is being singled out because it's Apple. This is China we're talking about. Safety standards and employees rights are at least a century behind the United States. This sort of shit happens at every huge Chinese employer.

This one just happens to make toys for rich, entitled, and self-righteous Americans who feel a little less self-righteous when the conditions that make their toys affordable get rubbed in their face.

Anyone who has a serious problem here and talks about boycotting Foxconn, or Apple, really needs to go through their house and find anything made in China and destroy it right now, because this type of thing is happening all over that country.

What? You don't want to? It's too inconvenient to apply your outrage to ALL Chinese-made products? Okay then.
 
That'd be news if it was the US. But it's not. I have no love for Apple, and in fact own exactly ZERO Apple products. My whole issue with this is that Foxconn is being singled out because it's Apple. This is China we're talking about. Safety standards and employees rights are at least a century behind the United States. This sort of shit happens at every huge Chinese employer.

This one just happens to make toys for rich, entitled, and self-righteous Americans who feel a little less self-righteous when the conditions that make their toys affordable get rubbed in their face.

Anyone who has a serious problem here and talks about boycotting Foxconn, or Apple, really needs to go through their house and find anything made in China and destroy it right now, because this type of thing is happening all over that country.

What? You don't want to? It's too inconvenient to apply your outrage to ALL Chinese-made products? Okay then.

And exactly what is destroying those products going to do? Boycotting makes sense if you are truly committed to the process. Going around and destroying already purchased products makes absolutely zero sense.

And you can't sit there and talk about every single employer, you make an example of the biggest, richest companies, because they are the ones that should be setting an example. In this case it is the paired combo of Foxconn and Apple. I have absolutely zero problems with singling out Foxconn. They are the largest manufacturer by an incredible margin in China. The only business in China that makes more money than Foxconn is the Chinese government. If you dilute your message across many companies nothing gets done. If you assault one company continuously and affect their profit margin, they will eventually cave and make changes. That is the way things generally work.

And if you want American companies to act more responsibly, you have to do the same thing. Unfortunately they don't normally listen to polite discourse, you have to drag their name through the mud by publicly showing what they are doing and what they are responsible for. Even if they are not the only ones responsible. In the fallout maybe you get Foxconn to contnually improve worker conditions, maybe you get Apple to decide to manufacture elsewhere. At least you make them reconsider their current strategies. By having other people in the world with more say and more power, this also might help encourage Chinese workers to feel like they are not alone, like more people are fighting for them. That might be part of the courage they need to break out of the circumstances they are in. This is the same kind of thing that enabled other industrialized nations to break out of their slave labor type of operations.
 
NoOther and the rest of the [H]ating apple hipsters are getting fucking owned on this thread...

It is allsome! Hypocrisy at its finest.
 
NoOther and the rest of the [H]ating apple hipsters are getting fucking owned on this thread...

It is allsome! Hypocrisy at its finest.

Wow, thank you for calling me a hipster, I never knew I was one. I also didn't know I was specifically an Apple Hater. All this time I thought I was just calling out a company for talking out of two sides of its mouth.

I would also like to know what hipocrisy I have spoken or done? I am sure there are several things I am hippocritical of, but I don't remember owning a mega corporation that does it manufacturing in China.... I wish I did, I would have mad cash and wouldn't be sitting here reading this or posting, I would be lighting fat cuban cigars with 100s and making it rain on all the biatches in the Carribean.
 
Back
Top