Nightline Goes Inside Foxconn

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you were expecting a hard hitting expose about the conditions at Foxconn, this isn't it. It is disappointing that Nightline had that kind of access and the only thing new you learned was how much the host loooooves his iDevices. Thanks to everyone that sent this one in.

"Compared with other factories, it's quite good here, because the benefits are good. And because a lot of things happened in the past, it's been improved a lot," said 26-year-old Zhang Ruohua after making printer cartridges for about a year.
 
I'm sure if she said what was really on her mind, she would turn up in a Chinese jail somewhere.
 
Everything is A-Okay. Nothing to see here. Move along. No we will not air these personal interviews. This will support Apple and the amazing, non-donating sack of shit corporation they are.
 
It's not as if ABC is biased at all, right?

What with disney being so tight with Apple, (sharing board members, and the Jobs family being huge shareholders) and the fact that Disney owns ABC... :rolleyes:

Why don't we send the Syrian state run new channel in to investigate whether the Syrian state is committing genocide :rolleyes:
 
Compared to working in a coal mine, factory assembly line work isn't the worst ever. Boring, tedious, low paying? Sure. But beats working in the elements or hacking apart animals etc.

I think Apple should homesource all their manufacturing back to the USA. That might make me respect them a little more. Maybe. I'm still not buying their products. But the iSheep will buy the stuff regardless of price, so who cares if it costs a little extra if it's made in USA?
 
Can't spell Apple butthurt without [H].

Seriously look at yourselves...you are so butthurt over apple all the while playing games on your computer built with mega corporations products or browsing this site on your samsung android phone.
 
Compared to working in a coal mine, factory assembly line work isn't the worst ever. Boring, tedious, low paying? Sure. But beats working in the elements or hacking apart animals etc.

I don't know about that. If I had to choose between hard labor and working in a boring monotonous assembly line, I'd take the labor any day of the week. The repetitive motions would drive me absolutely insane. I landed a job YEARS ago at a local assembly plant/factory and I quit that day... just not the job for me.

I do sort of agree though, I'd still rather do that than risk being caved in on or developing black lung lol
 
Can't spell Apple butthurt without [H].

Seriously look at yourselves...you are so butthurt over apple all the while playing games on your computer built with mega corporations products or browsing this site on your samsung android phone.

LOL, if that isn't the butthurt calling the butthurt...ummm, butthurt. :D

Compared to working in a coal mine, factory assembly line work isn't the worst ever. Boring, tedious, low paying? Sure. But beats working in the elements or hacking apart animals etc.

That's what makes this so wierd...then why aren't there a bunch of suicides in the coal mines etc. etc. etc. Freaky when you think about it. I agree 100% that Apple should build their products in the US or, at the very least, somewhere else.
 
Everything is A-Okay. Nothing to see here. Move along. No we will not air these personal interviews. This will support Apple and the amazing, non-donating sack of shit corporation they are.

You realize that Apple isn't Foxconn's only customer.

There's Dell, HP, Asus, Compaq, Acer, MSI, Motorola, Nokia, LG, Samsung and others.

Apple was the first one to encourage pay raises and launch an investigation of working conditions at Foxconn. Maybe you should petition Dell, HP and the other companies to do the same thing.

Raging on one company (that 90% of everyone on this forum hates) isn't gonna solve anything, especially one that has tried and did make a difference.

Disclaimer: I've used Linux (Ubuntu), Windows XP - 8, and Mac OSX SL - Lion. Don't call me a fan-boy, it doesn't solve anything.
 
Was anyone expecting a different outcome? Even if it's not the whole truth, it's the story ABC could get away with telling. Since there's a lot of public scrutiny, Foxconn and Apple had to make some gesture, even if it was an insincere one.
 
Apple pulled some strings and this fluff piece got done as a counter to the NYT's earlier stories. This sort of thing indicates the contempt Apple has for its US customer base, imo.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038413244 said:
It's not as if ABC is biased at all, right?

What with disney being so tight with Apple, (sharing board members, and the Jobs family being huge shareholders) and the fact that Disney owns ABC... :rolleyes:

Actually, you can watch the first 5 mins on ABC right now. The anchor says upfront everything you just mentioned and claims his reporting is 100% non-biased (not that I believe it lol). I 'think' they're following around a 3rd party auditor as well... but again, it's only a short 5 min segment.

Honestly, from what they showed, it didn't look much different than any other high tech assembly line that I've ever seen. Although, it seems like they don't really talk to one another much. I don't know if they're not allowed to or if it will distract them from their job (ala I love lucy at the chocolate factory). According to ABC, I believe they said that they can churn out 10K ipad cases in a day, so you have to assume that the work is pretty fast paced. While the work looked like it sucked, it seems a far cry from slave labor.

At any rate, I look forward to watching this tonight.
 
That's what makes this so wierd...then why aren't there a bunch of suicides in the coal mines etc. etc. etc. Freaky when you think about it. I agree 100% that Apple should build their products in the US or, at the very least, somewhere else.

The death rate for Chinese miners is high enough nobody has to put effort into suicide. It's basically automated.
 
You can watch the whole thing now at that link.

awesome, thanks for the heads up.

For some reason I thought they weren't showing the episode online until after tonight. You're the man
 
You realize that Apple isn't Foxconn's only customer.

There's Dell, HP, Asus, Compaq, Acer, MSI, Motorola, Nokia, LG, Samsung and others.

Apple was the first one to encourage pay raises and launch an investigation of working conditions at Foxconn. Maybe you should petition Dell, HP and the other companies to do the same thing.

Raging on one company (that 90% of everyone on this forum hates) isn't gonna solve anything, especially one that has tried and did make a difference.

Disclaimer: I've used Linux (Ubuntu), Windows XP - 8, and Mac OSX SL - Lion. Don't call me a fan-boy, it doesn't solve anything.

You do realize that Apple only started investigating because they were called out for lying? They claimed to be humane and green and they were called out for it directly. Only then did they decide to give face value to the issue by having audits. They started the audits in 2006. They suggested things to Foxconn but had no punishment for Foxconn not following the suggestions. Things only got worse, not better. They kept doing audits and things kept getting worse. The last few years have been the worst since they first started auditing.

So yes, they are getting the proper amount of heat for continuing to put up a charade, just like this report. These jobs are highly sought after in a country with very few jobs, but that is also why there are such crappy conditions all over China. You can't keep defending Apple just because other companies do the same thing. Its the age old question, if all your friends jump off a bridge, will you jump off the bridge?

This is about awareness, and Apple is the current whipping boy and they are not doing the proper steps to fix the issue, so no other company will follow suit either.
 
I like how everyone thinks Foxconn factory workers are treated the worst. Something makes me think there are PLENTY of factories with MAGNITUDES worse working conditions.

But just because a company is well known and successful...instantly makes them a terrible company and forced to "raise" these levels in a country where they have always been extremely low.

This reminds me of that clothing/shoe sweatshop crap earlier in the decade... this stuff has always been there. Crappy working conditions where in the US too before people backlashed and created unions/forced the gov to regulate business.

If you guys (Americans) want your techy gadgets to continue to be cheap like they are now, or for companies to make as much money they do to use creating more cool tech, I'd suggest shut your yappers and let things stay how they have been/were.

</rage>
 
Pretty typical of American news media which is all bought and paid for by corporations. ABC is basically Disney, which is really tight with Apple. No surprises that when given the opportunity to do a hard hitting expose on the horrendous working conditions and abuses at Foxconn, we instead get a guy talking about how much he loves Apple products and how the workers don't really have it that bad.
 
I like how everyone thinks Foxconn factory workers are treated the worst. Something makes me think there are PLENTY of factories with MAGNITUDES worse working conditions.

But just because a company is well known and successful...instantly makes them a terrible company and forced to "raise" these levels in a country where they have always been extremely low.

This reminds me of that clothing/shoe sweatshop crap earlier in the decade... this stuff has always been there. Crappy working conditions where in the US too before people backlashed and created unions/forced the gov to regulate business.

If you guys (Americans) want your techy gadgets to continue to be cheap like they are now, or for companies to make as much money they do to use creating more cool tech, I'd suggest shut your yappers and let things stay how they have been/were.

</rage>

So no one should do anything right? We shouldn't care at all or point out any companies then? We shouldn't give a damn how people are treated, or what goes on behind closed doors?

Pathetic, yet another pathetic excuse for apathy. Any pressure on any company is worth it, and it works better when you keep pressure on a company until they finally own up and do the right thing. And since Apple is sooo adamant about saying how much they do the right thing, it is time for them to pony up and pay the piper. They have been caught several times just giving lip service, now its time for them to actually do something about it. Especially since they don't seem to do much else with that huge cash reserve to help anyone other than themselves...
 
Can't spell Apple butthurt without [H].

Seriously look at yourselves...you are so butthurt over apple all the while playing games on your computer built with mega corporations products or browsing this site on your samsung android phone.

Wrong. Motorola
 
That's what makes this so wierd...then why aren't there a bunch of suicides in the coal mines etc. etc. etc. Freaky when you think about it. I agree 100% that Apple should build their products in the US or, at the very least, somewhere else.

You think those coal mining slaves don't suicide? Of course they do. But the coal mines aren't used to make Apple products, so it doesn't make international news.

If you really think Foxconn is any worse than any other Chinese employer, you'll believe anything you read.
 
So no one should do anything right? We shouldn't care at all or point out any companies then? We shouldn't give a damn how people are treated, or what goes on behind closed doors?

Pathetic, yet another pathetic excuse for apathy. Any pressure on any company is worth it, and it works better when you keep pressure on a company until they finally own up and do the right thing. And since Apple is sooo adamant about saying how much they do the right thing, it is time for them to pony up and pay the piper. They have been caught several times just giving lip service, now its time for them to actually do something about it. Especially since they don't seem to do much else with that huge cash reserve to help anyone other than themselves...

Apple is a company run by scumbags that makes products for scumbags.
 
Compared to working in a coal mine, factory assembly line work isn't the worst ever. Boring, tedious, low paying? Sure. But beats working in the elements or hacking apart animals etc.

I think Apple should homesource all their manufacturing back to the USA. That might make me respect them a little more. Maybe. I'm still not buying their products. But the iSheep will buy the stuff regardless of price, so who cares if it costs a little extra if it's made in USA?

You do realize that some of the chemicals used in these factories can be just as bad, if not worse then coal mining right?
 
So it was a staged visit buy Foxconn for Nightline. Lol. I used to work for a place that had surprise visit from upper management. We were always told a week ahead of time so that we could clean up the place before they came. You can bet that Nightline only got shown what Foxconn wanted them to see.
 
LOL, if that isn't the butthurt calling the butthurt...ummm, butthurt. :D



That's what makes this so wierd...then why aren't there a bunch of suicides in the coal mines etc. etc. etc. Freaky when you think about it. I agree 100% that Apple should build their products in the US or, at the very least, somewhere else.

in China, working in coal mines IS suicide, seeing all of those cave-ins they've been having the past many years.
 
So it was a staged visit buy Foxconn for Nightline. Lol. I used to work for a place that had surprise visit from upper management. We were always told a week ahead of time so that we could clean up the place before they came.

SLAVE LABOR!!!!

quick, someone call Nightline :p

I agree though... I'm sure everyone that's ever worked has had to deal with that at some point. I've worked at resturants where we had to clean the place top to bottom, late into the night, for a heath depeartment inspection or visit from the brass the following day.

I'm sure this is no different.

With that said, it (foxconn) still doesn't seem all that bad IMHO... just extremely boring and lonely. It's clean/hygenic, the work is high-tech (opposed to threading nuts on screws all day) and they 'seem' to give decent benefits for China's standards. The news is hard to believe though... ABC is giving a different impression than NYT was, but I'm sure they both have their agendas.
 
It was exactly what I expected,they never would have stepped foot in the country,let alone the factory,if the government didn't know ahead of time they'd treat them with kid gloves. As for the Apple defenders,sure,other companies do this,but since when does two wrongs make it right. Apple is at or near the top of the ladder,are insufferably smug,and act like they're the Chosen Ones,so they're a prime target.
 
Apple pulled some strings and this fluff piece got done as a counter to the NYT's earlier stories. This sort of thing indicates the contempt Apple has for its US customer base, imo.
You think apple will wreck its chance of getting in on the largest cell provider China Mobile, not on your life, the largest provider that doesn't sell iphones, YET. apple still has to figure out whose pocket they have to fill with gold to get that one elusive contract. The guy running China Mobile is probably as cheap and arrogant as the apple head honcho, maybe not , maybe he just won't bend over for apple, because their doing just fine without apple.
 
As for the Apple defenders,sure,other companies do this,but since when does two wrongs make it right. Apple is at or near the top of the ladder,are insufferably smug,and act like they're the Chosen Ones,so they're a prime target.


The only people that I see claiming that Foxconn's working conditions are wrong are the people on here that hate Apple with a passion (and whatever, to each their own). The people defending Apple/Foxconn just seem to be pointing out the obvious.... that Apple is a customer, along with every other electronics manufacturer.

Claiming to hate Apple because of Foxconn is dishonest. When you have a machine in your signature where half the components were made at the same place, it's hypocritical and borderline insane to criticize Apple and it's users while the haters are enjoying their toys & gadgets on the backs on the same Chinese citizens as Apples users.
 
The only people that I see claiming that Foxconn's working conditions are wrong are the people on here that hate Apple with a passion (and whatever, to each their own). The people defending Apple/Foxconn just seem to be pointing out the obvious.... that Apple is a customer, along with every other electronics manufacturer.

Claiming to hate Apple because of Foxconn is dishonest. When you have a machine in your signature where half the components were made at the same place, it's hypocritical and borderline insane to criticize Apple and it's users while the haters are enjoying their toys & gadgets on the backs on the same Chinese citizens as Apples users.

Well said. Unfortuntely, their raging hatred of all things Apple (and apparently anyone who buys an Apple product as evident by the juvinile name calling they toss around), will not let them process your logic. Does not compute!!! Error!
 
Well said. Unfortuntely, their raging hatred of all things Apple (and apparently anyone who buys an Apple product as evident by the juvinile name calling they toss around), will not let them process your logic. Does not compute!!! Error!

You are partially correct.

We SHOULD call out all manufacturers who use their services, or other similar manufacturing services in China.

What has made this particular instance explode involving Apple though, is that Apple was asked about the issues and denied them. This problem might have gone away or never surfaced at all if Apple didn't tout themselves as a green equitable company ahead of the curve in labor relations, and when the issues were pointed out had immediately acknowledged them and divulged their plan to improve.

People react to stories of hypocrisy, cover ups and lies, and that is why the Apple story has exploded where may other electronics companies have been ducking scrutiny (for now).
 
The only people that I see claiming that Foxconn's working conditions are wrong are the people on here that hate Apple with a passion (and whatever, to each their own). The people defending Apple/Foxconn just seem to be pointing out the obvious.... that Apple is a customer, along with every other electronics manufacturer.

Claiming to hate Apple because of Foxconn is dishonest. When you have a machine in your signature where half the components were made at the same place, it's hypocritical and borderline insane to criticize Apple and it's users while the haters are enjoying their toys & gadgets on the backs on the same Chinese citizens as Apples users.

Well put.
 
Has anyone considered that Foxconn executives LIED to Apple about the working conditions there? It's not like Apple travels to China to inspect the factories daily.

They order product to be built, and it shows up in shipping containers. If it's right, they received what they paid for.

Apple should be commended for taking action, where it had no real legal position to do so, and investigate.

Zarathustra[H];1038413924 said:
You are partially correct.

We SHOULD call out all manufacturers who use their services, or other similar manufacturing services in China.

What has made this particular instance explode involving Apple though, is that Apple was asked about the issues and denied them. This problem might have gone away or never surfaced at all if Apple didn't tout themselves as a green equitable company ahead of the curve in labor relations, and when the issues were pointed out had immediately acknowledged them and divulged their plan to improve.

People react to stories of hypocrisy, cover ups and lies, and that is why the Apple story has exploded where may other electronics companies have been ducking scrutiny (for now).
 
The only people that I see claiming that Foxconn's working conditions are wrong are the people on here that hate Apple with a passion (and whatever, to each their own). The people defending Apple/Foxconn just seem to be pointing out the obvious.... that Apple is a customer, along with every other electronics manufacturer.

Claiming to hate Apple because of Foxconn is dishonest. When you have a machine in your signature where half the components were made at the same place, it's hypocritical and borderline insane to criticize Apple and it's users while the haters are enjoying their toys & gadgets on the backs on the same Chinese citizens as Apples users.

yep, I have seen pictures of chinese factories that make other things that make foxconn look like a vacation cruise...

anyway, last laptop that I can recall that was 100% made in the USA (mobo, everything) was in like 1989 and cost $8500... so unless you want to pay 10x as much for your stuff (min) then there need to be people in the world willing to work for just about nothing
 
success is the mother of failure
The correct saying is "failure is the mother of success." Failing by succeeding does not make any sense at all.

"A certain level of the aluminum dust was too high and this accident happened," Woo tells me. "We learned a lot from it, so we have changed a lot of processes
The dangers of dust in manufacturing have been well known for decades.

The company says more than a million line workers have been informed of their rights, 60,000 have taken advantage of free college-level instruction
yet
Apple reports that at least half of workers in over 90 factories exceeded the 60-hours-a-week work limit or worked more than six days a week.
When do they go to these classes and what time do they have to study? This is just like when I worked for XX&X where they give you money to go to college but if you go you will be fired because you aren't available to work 12 hours 7 days a week. Surely this college class luxury only applies to management and not to the average factory grunt. Especially considering that the average factory grunt doesn't even have a high school diploma and can't handle college level courses.

especially for their families back in the village, where most of their paycheck will end up
and
The young men and women range from 16 (the legal working age in the province) to their early 20s,
Sounds like the majority of the adults decide not to work in the factory for good reasons. As poor as they are they know better than to live like that.

I expect to see that in the next year or two, they will become more like a collective bargaining union, and they will be freely elected.
That would be outright illegal and revolutionary for China. It's not going to happen, this is lip service for self centered westerner journalists.
 
You do realize that Apple only started investigating because they were called out for lying? They claimed to be humane and green and they were called out for it directly. Only then did they decide to give face value to the issue by having audits. They started the audits in 2006. They suggested things to Foxconn but had no punishment for Foxconn not following the suggestions. Things only got worse, not better. They kept doing audits and things kept getting worse. The last few years have been the worst since they first started auditing.

So yes, they are getting the proper amount of heat for continuing to put up a charade, just like this report. These jobs are highly sought after in a country with very few jobs, but that is also why there are such crappy conditions all over China. You can't keep defending Apple just because other companies do the same thing. Its the age old question, if all your friends jump off a bridge, will you jump off the bridge?

This is about awareness, and Apple is the current whipping boy and they are not doing the proper steps to fix the issue, so no other company will follow suit either.

Apple doesn't own Foxconn, and so they can't do anything. If there were factories in the US that can support what Apple and the other companies need they probably would take their business to them.

So no one should do anything right? We shouldn't care at all or point out any companies then? We shouldn't give a damn how people are treated, or what goes on behind closed doors?

Pathetic, yet another pathetic excuse for apathy. Any pressure on any company is worth it, and it works better when you keep pressure on a company until they finally own up and do the right thing. And since Apple is sooo adamant about saying how much they do the right thing, it is time for them to pony up and pay the piper. They have been caught several times just giving lip service, now its time for them to actually do something about it. Especially since they don't seem to do much else with that huge cash reserve to help anyone other than themselves...

It's China's problem, not ours. The Chinese people can demand the rights they want, the only thing we can do is support them.

Apple is a company run by scumbags that makes products for scumbags.

Beautiful, a profound and well thought out argument. :rolleyes: (Since logic seems to evade you; that was sarcasm.)

The only people that I see claiming that Foxconn's working conditions are wrong are the people on here that hate Apple with a passion (and whatever, to each their own). The people defending Apple/Foxconn just seem to be pointing out the obvious.... that Apple is a customer, along with every other electronics manufacturer.

Claiming to hate Apple because of Foxconn is dishonest. When you have a machine in your signature where half the components were made at the same place, it's hypocritical and borderline insane to criticize Apple and it's users while the haters are enjoying their toys & gadgets on the backs on the same Chinese citizens as Apples users.

Thank you! This is the point all along.

Well said. Unfortuntely, their raging hatred of all things Apple (and apparently anyone who buys an Apple product as evident by the juvinile name calling they toss around), will not let them process your logic. Does not compute!!! Error!

Logic seems to be minimal here, and shame on Steve for encouraging this.

Has anyone considered that Foxconn executives LIED to Apple about the working conditions there? It's not like Apple travels to China to inspect the factories daily.

They order product to be built, and it shows up in shipping containers. If it's right, they received what they paid for.

Apple should be commended for taking action, where it had no real legal position to do so, and investigate.

Exactly, Apple seems to be the only company that has done ANYTHING to promote well being towards the people they do business with.
 
C'mon, You think Nightline just showed up and said, show us your facility? It's China, they cleaned up shop didn't make it seem AS bad.
 
Back
Top