Publishers Must Stop Pass-Locking Multiplayer Modes

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Whether or not you are against the recent trend of game companies requiring online passes for multiplayer, I think you'll find this editorial rather interesting.

And while I'm here, allow me to challenge the notion that publishers pass-lock content for anything other than commercial gain, as opposed to guarding against financial loss. EA now typically online pass-protects multiplayer modes in projected hits (Battlefield 3, Mass Effect 3), so don't think they opened up Syndicate in an altruistic display of heroism. No, they're re-launching a dormant franchise from the '90s, and they don't want to hobble its chances by selling half a game. Same goes for SSX...its online pass doesn't block an entire mode, but will affect how fast you unlock gear.
 
One thing that has always bothered me is how we are mad at the publishers / developers that do this but not the people that caused this by making a business out of giving people $10 trade-in on a $60 game that they resell for $49.99.
 
Agreed.

They should just focus on getting rid of the "used game". Then it becomes a supply demand issues. Works for Steam and prices get hella low
 
One thing that has always bothered me is how we are mad at the publishers / developers that do this but not the people that caused this by making a business out of giving people $10 trade-in on a $60 game that they resell for $49.99.

So, in other words, let's be fine with the outrageous greed spreading through the software industry.

You almost make it sound if the publishers / developers did not receive the original price in the first purchase.

Let's tell it like it is, they are not contempt with receiving $50-60, they want a cut of that second $30.

They should just be straight sell it for $90, heck, why not $150? As long as they stop nagging their legal customers and eroding their ownership rights.
 
Whether or not you are against the recent trend of game companies requiring online passes for multiplayer, I think you'll find this editorial rather interesting.

Why in the world would any regular customer be FOR the online pass?

I know your blurbs are mostly story related, but this one made little sense :p

Only a dev who doesn't know any better would be FOR the online passes.
 
Or a bean counter, I guess. Kotick, man, Kotick, he'd be for this. That man is a one-man exploitation wizard, constantly trying to invent new ways to exploit games and find new revenue streams, whether popular or not.
 
One thing that has always bothered me is how we are mad at the publishers / developers that do this but not the people that caused this by making a business out of giving people $10 trade-in on a $60 game that they resell for $49.99.

i agree. before christmas i saw demon's soul, among other old games, for 40 euros 2nd hand in some store similar to game stop. i asked if that was a new copy, already guessing the answer. nope. dude, i can get a new game cheaper from amazon... but kids don't go to amazon. they're happy about any cash they get for five games just to get one new one. it's a ripoff.

i also wish people would just stop buying games that have these kind of "features" like loads of trivial (day1) DLC or stupid drm. what's the point of complaining if there's no loss in sales anyway so it just confirms that they can go on with this. yes, one can live without mass effect. since i don't like the DLC ripoff, i always wait for the "complete edition" with all DLC with a few exceptions like skyrim, serious sam 3, mortal kombat... but these are not titles that thrive on the DLC craze.
 
Once consoles go to a digital distribution method for their games this will be a non-issue. You will not be able to sell your used games unless you sell the account they are associated with.
 
I've been protesting this shit with my wallet for years.
Simply put, I DON'T spend money on any game that has overly restrictive DRM, and that has one-time use multiplayer codes.
That way the publisher can live with the fact that they themselves caused a lost sale. I found plenty of games that suit my needs without having to buy in to this bullshit. I'd buy a whole lot more games if this crap didn't happen.

One day I hope the execs at game studios realize that they lose an awful lot of money by pissing off their customers and treating them like criminals.
 
One thing that has always bothered me is how we are mad at the publishers / developers that do this but not the people that caused this by making a business out of giving people $10 trade-in on a $60 game that they resell for $49.99.

With or without Gamestop, these large publishers will still do everything they can to prevent 2nd hand usage

If they could restrict each game to be used only by a single DNA carrier, they would. If they could make you pay for the access to a game for each of your kids at home, they would.

There is no end to their greed. Its up to us consumers to vote with our wallet to keep them honest the best we can.
 
This on-line pass bullshit for console games really ticks me off as a primarily PC gamer that only rarely plays console games by renting them, ala. GameFly.

I don't want to pay for instance $10 a month to rent a game and then another $10 just to play the online portion of that game for a few days before returning it!

I wonder how companies like Gamestop and GameFly will fight against the industry on this as it will really deal a huge blow to them.
 
One thing that has always bothered me is how we are mad at the publishers / developers that do this but not the people that caused this by making a business out of giving people $10 trade-in on a $60 game that they resell for $49.99.

Last I check, this has been going on forever. 8-bit Nintendo had used games. Got used games for my Sega Genesis. Why is it now suddenly a concern if people buy used games?

Also, I just heard it's legal to sell your copy of an mp3 song. We are perfectly within our rights to sell our products. Everyone loses out on used product sales. Why do we accept this system put in place by these companies to punish people for used game sales?
 
One thing that has always bothered me is how we are mad at the publishers / developers that do this but not the people that caused this by making a business out of giving people $10 trade-in on a $60 game that they resell for $49.99.

We aren't mad at the stores that rip off people on trade-ins because we have the choice to avoid them. Don't want to get $10 trade in for your brand new game, don't do it. Don't want to overpay for a used copy, buy new.
What we can't avoid is online passes, DRM or any of the other crap publishers are putting into their game unless we don't play it. Problem is we really want to because we love games. That's why the hate is directed towards publishers / developers, they toy with our emotions by sprinkling our delicious cake with shit flakes then saying eat it.
 
Sounds like a console problem....that will affects PCs at some point. Derrrr....

Trouble in that logic is, none of the game stores trade second hand PC titles since they started using unique install codes, so if anyone is to blame it's the cheapskates that buy second hand console titles.
 
I know how 98% of people in this forum will respond.

publisher are greedy... blah blah blah

Funny Steve may be the only one here besides me who has any common sense.

YES, publishers are in it for the money and they do whatever increases their sales and they have the right to do it. Don't like it? Then don't buy them. But since this is the hard forum, I have to clarify that statement. Don't buy it doesn't mean steal it.
 
Why don't game publishers buy back games for credit toward future games?

Example: sell back fallout 3 for $20 and get a credit toward Skyrim
 
One thing that has always bothered me is how we are mad at the publishers / developers that do this but not the people that caused this by making a business out of giving people $10 trade-in on a $60 game that they resell for $49.99.

:confused:

I dunno about you, but I've always been mad about that.
 
you're treating customers like criminals. Good luck finding a business model where that turned out well.

I like this line from the article best. Apply it to DRM of any kind in general.
 
I have always believed that this was a waste of time. If people could not afford the new game, why would they pay the new game price for used when all was said and done? I know my kid does not pay new prices for her 360 games, ever. Used or bargain bin only. And she does not buy games that require a fee after the fact to "unlock" the whole game.
End game question: While the publisher may have reduced used sales with this unlock system, did they actually increase new sales at the full retail price? Or did they just increase sales at the bargain bin level where they may have made a dollar or two on the game when all was said and done? Or did they not increase new sales at all? A lot of what the devs and pubs do when it comes to DRM and this sort of thing, seems more about spending their own money to spite GS and the gamers rather than make money.


I know how 98% of people in this forum will respond.

publisher are greedy... blah blah blah

Funny Steve may be the only one here besides me who has any common sense.

YES, publishers are in it for the money and they do whatever increases their sales and they have the right to do it. Don't like it? Then don't buy them. But since this is the hard forum, I have to clarify that statement. Don't buy it doesn't mean steal it.

Publishers ARE greedy, but so is Gamestop. I do not, and likely will not ever spend a dime in that location.

I already don't buy stuff like this.

If you are attempting to call copyright infringement, stealing, you are incorrect according to the law, and common sense. The people that continue to call copyright infringement, stealing, typically are willfully doing so knowing they are wrong. Though sometimes they are just people that have disconnected their rational minds, because of some emotion or another, usually greed, or outrage caused by greed.

P.S. I firmly believe pirating a game is wrong. If you don't want to pay, or can't pay, or can't borrow, you should not play it. Games are a LUXURY item. They are not required for survival.
 
I also have been boycotting games with excessive DRM. Anything EA or have games for windows crap like red faction guerilla...i avoid like the plague.

I bought that game on steam (which i think is a cool game) but after logging into steam, i launch the game, then have to login to windows games to save my game or play online. I have to jump through so many unnecessary hoops. Its so bad, that it can take hours to even find 4 people on the entire internet willing to play multiplayer.
 
I boycott fuckers all the time, and I stick to it.

I've been fed up with the RIAA & MPAA for so long I haven't bought a any music since 2004 (I listen to the radio), I haven't seen a movie in a theater since 2005 (I have Hbo, Showtime, Cinemax, etc).

I boycotted EA when they put advertising in 2142 and haven't bought an EA game since.

I boycott local brick & mortar establishments also.
If a place has employees to staff a cash register and there is a big line with only 1 register running, I boycott them.

Our local Gander mountain keeps reels locked up behind a counter, good luck finding someone to let you touch them, then if you do they won't even give it to you, they walk it up to the register like it is made of gold or something and the customer is a criminal.
Gotta wait around forever for them to get around to getting you some bait, I hate these fucking people...

Basically any company that treats their customers like they don't matter, I boycott.
 
Why in the world would any regular customer be FOR the online pass?

I know your blurbs are mostly story related, but this one made little sense :p

Only a dev who doesn't know any better would be FOR the online passes.

*shrugs* i'm a regular customer, and i'm FOR online pass ... only because I hate the resell racketeering and want to see the entire industry built around it burn in hell.
 
I've been fed up with the RIAA & MPAA for so long I haven't bought a any music since 2004 (I listen to the radio), I haven't seen a movie in a theater since 2005 (I have Hbo, Showtime, Cinemax, etc).
Where do you believe radio stations go to secure the rights to play commercial music? How do you think HBO, Showtime and Cinemax secure the rights to show movies?
 
Where do you believe radio stations go to secure the rights to play commercial music? How do you think HBO, Showtime and Cinemax secure the rights to show movies?

Yeah, I was thinking the same thing but I didn't want to pop his bubble of self righteousness. :D
 
I personally think the online passes are ridiculous, but I got rid of my console years ago so really don't care.
 
I don't see why people are so upset about used games going for so much. I mean, if piracy is stealing, as in stealing a real physical object, then people should be to sell and buy used games just like anything else. This is just greed and jealousy on the part of the publishers, pure and simple.
 
I couldn't care less about the used game market but they are actively preventing me from borrowing games off friends and lending in return.

For that they get zero sympathy from me.
 
So, used games trading is the new same as stealing now?...
...

People can trade used games, but companies like GameStop have created multi-million dollar business from it.
Like Steve said, the devs and pubs want a piece of that or stop it all together. Unfortunately, the consumer will get caught in the cross fire.
 
One thing that has always bothered me is how we are mad at the publishers / developers that do this but not the people that caused this by making a business out of giving people $10 trade-in on a $60 game that they resell for $49.99.

Steve, everything I've seen says that stores make little to no money on AAA game releases. Stores pay the full price for the game up-front, and at the retail price they maybe make a few bucks per-sale And they often have to have launch parties to get enough gamers excited enough to shell-out for that price (more money out-of-pocket).

Unlike some other industries (say, books), publishers in the game industry won't buyback extra product so if you bought more games than will sell for $60, it sits in your inventory while they drop the price until it sells. Any losses are incurred by you, the reseller.

Console sales are also very low-profit (this is the same reason places like Best Buy will hound you for accessory and plan sales,, and sometimes refuse to sell without them). Accessories are a big help with that at Gamestop, but people are less likely to buy these in a game store with very limited selection, so the only thing that keeps Gamestop breathing is used game sales.
 
Trouble in that logic is, none of the game stores trade second hand PC titles since they started using unique install codes, so if anyone is to blame it's the cheapskates that buy second hand console titles.

It affects PC gamers because DRM like Steam and Origin are being used as a requirement to play games.
Ubisoft, the worst offender, tries to punish PC gamers by any means necessary. They aren't shy about let the customer know they don't own the game.

Anything we buy digitally in the near future, could be exclusively tied to a certain DRM platform.
Yes....that is consolization on the PC. Then things like subscription based multiplayer models are being considered(FPS, TPS, Sports, Racing etc.), not much different than an online pass.

Once both consoles and PC are all digital, the pubs will have full control over our game libraries.
All games are going to be required to launch a DRM client at some point, unless you resort to other means or only buy indie games.
 
Back
Top