Violent Video Games Alter Brain Function in Young Men

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A study of 22 adult males, over a one week period, proves that violent video games have a long-term effect on brain functioning. If you played violent video games for more than one week, it is already too late...you are a homicidal maniac. :( Thanks to Edward C. for the link.

For the study, 22 healthy adult males, age 18 to 29, with low past exposure to violent video games were randomly assigned to two groups of 11. Members of the first group were instructed to play a shooting video game for 10 hours at home for one week and refrain from playing the following week. The second group did not play a violent video game at all during the two-week period.
 
first post. hummm, well have been playing video games since i could type in dos commands, now im 26 and in a wonderful marriage and enrolled in college for public health with an emphasis in epidemiology and still haven't had the urge to kill thousands of helpless innocents. interesting, perhaps i can find someone who will pay me many thousands of dollars to do a study on happy successful video gamers?
 
Wow, they were desensitized... Big surprise... Bet you would get the same results from violent movies and books. I wish I could get paid to study the obvious...
 
22 Men? Wow, that's a pretty impressive focus group they had there.

22 Adult Men proves nothing, especially compared to the other 100 Million who also play games.
 
Fuck...i've been playing games more violent than those stated before I was 10...

Would have helped to use a test group larger than 11...the testing methods sound like nonsense too... More likely to press a violent word in a test isn't really the same as more like to start hacking someone to death...

But anyway... So apparently "violent" videogames cause the lumps on the head to change shape? :eek:
 
I'm sure the same bullshit could be said if the test subjects watched 10 hours of horror movies. Hmm, I wonder what would happen of 20 year old men watched 10 hours of chick flicks for a week? I bet that would induce more violence than anything, lol.
 
first post. hummm, well have been playing video games since i could type in dos commands, now im 26 and in a wonderful marriage and enrolled in college for public health with an emphasis in epidemiology and still haven't had the urge to kill thousands of helpless innocents. interesting, perhaps i can find someone who will pay me many thousands of dollars to do a study on happy successful video gamers?
Funny how an article citing decreased activation in brain regions normally responsible for "controlling emotion and aggressive behavior" is instantly editorialized into "Video games turn people into brain-damaged killers!"

I wonder what other changes in activity could be observed in groups exposed to other new activities.
 
As everyone said, very small study group for a very short period of time makes the results pretty much worthless.

It's also funded by the "Center for Successful Parenting" so there obviously isn't any bias in the testing methodology that could taint the results. I'm sure they were completely taken by surprise when they got the conclusion they were paying... err I mean looking for. :rolleyes:
 
lizzier2.jpg
 
It's a well known fact that watching televisions, playing sports, shouting, sleeping and drinking coffee makes you violent. Seriously, stop it. Violence is part of our lives. If there's a burglar ransacking your house, you'll appreciate Scorpion's moves in Mortal Kombat. FATALITY!!!
 
"These findings indicate that violent video game play has a long-term effect on brain functioning," Dr. Wang said.
Which way? Oops...doesn't say anything about what it does other than hinders function in those areas. Common sense, while not always accurate, dictates that one assumes that since these regions of the brain reduce in activity the result is sort of a numbing effect. Respondents act neither more or less violently after playing games. Furthermore this study does NOT indicate what is "long term"? What is long term to these people? Hours? Days? Weeks? Note they did not indicate these changes as permanent.

In short I will summarize of those that funded this study...
They are all assholes. :p
 
This study is just making generalizations. ...not sure what the purpose of it is without reading the whole thing.

There are a lot of things that they're missing though. One of the major things that I can say from personal experience as an airborne infantryman is that the brain utilizes long-term potentiation to adapt such things as shooting skills to be reflexive. It's the brain's way of honing the survival instint. If you have to think of defensive/ofensive behavior, you'd die before you reacted.

Another thing that I don't see is these students exposure to violence in their past. Being so near to an urban environment, there's a decent change that these guys were exposed to some sort of violence before playing a video game.
 
Odd.

Considering the fact that many of the most violent people I know are those that either can't or don't play video games, I'm going to have to take this conclusion with a grain of salt.

Sure you're desensitized to violent behavior. But that doesn't mean I'm more likely to go and hack someone to bits.

On the other hand, my brother and I have been playing violent video games for as long as I can remember (born in 91, earliest VG memories are of Mortal Kombat and Street Fighter), and I am FAR from violent. I so anti-confrontational it is almost a character flaw!
 
After learning of this study I decided to take up knitting instead of gaming. But then I started thinking.....if I do that, will I eventually become a ball of yarn? Are there any scientists here that could do a study on that for me?
 
After learning of this study I decided to take up knitting instead of gaming. But then I started thinking.....if I do that, will I eventually become a ball of yarn? Are there any scientists here that could do a study on that for me?

You'll become a cat.
 
PS: If I breathe too much will I become air? Looking for a study on that one too.
 
Which way? Oops...doesn't say anything about what it does other than hinders function in those areas. Common sense, while not always accurate, dictates that one assumes that since these regions of the brain reduce in activity the result is sort of a numbing effect. Respondents act neither more or less violently after playing games. Furthermore this study does NOT indicate what is "long term"? What is long term to these people? Hours? Days? Weeks? Note they did not indicate these changes as permanent.

In short I will summarize of those that funded this study...
They are all assholes. :p

To be fair, they did state that after time passed, the response moved more toward "normal".

By the same token, what real impact did the game have? Were these people on the edge of turning into homicidal maniacs? Or did they just suffer a little less if they decided to go deer hunting for example?
 
PS: If I breathe too much will I become air? Looking for a study on that one too.

Breathing causes severe addiction to oxygen, you should stop now while you still have the chance!!! ;)
 
To be fair, they did state that after time passed, the response moved more toward "normal".

By the same token, what real impact did the game have? Were these people on the edge of turning into homicidal maniacs? Or did they just suffer a little less if they decided to go deer hunting for example?


You mean *gasp* people use GUNS ... to shoot LIVING CREATURES? And it's not illegal/immoral/satanic? (Well, perhaps not politically correct ... but who gives a flying f**k.)

I think a lot of this comes from folks who have zero exposure/total aversion to guns/fighting in any context. Being desensitized to violence is a good thing if you're about to go into actual combat.

How do we know they weren't just desensitized to violence in visual media (videogames, movies etc.) and not actual violence ... do they suddenly think hitting/shooting people is OK? Enough with this bullshit, seriously ...
 
To be fair, they did state that after time passed, the response moved more toward "normal".

I find it amazing that they juxtaposed these two sentences next to each other:

After the second week without game play, the changes to the executive regions of the brain were diminished.

"These findings indicate that violent video game play has a long-term effect on brain
functioning," Dr. Wang said.

This must be a joke.

Actually, even reading this far gives them too much credit. There are at least 20 million males between the ages 20 and 29 in the United States (2000 census). A sample size of 22 [at any significance level statistically meaningful] isn't going to represent that population... in the least.
 
Inconclusive.

Right or wrong, When I was studying for my degree, our lecturer told us once that a 'survey' or 'study' or whatever you want to call it would only be accurate if thousands , if not tens of thousands took part.

To this day I still believe in what he said, I hate 'our product is preferred by 80% of women/men' and then at the end it says 'we asked 14 people'

Complete shit.
 
They forgot the "most kids these days are violent period" variable. Did you know that 9 out of 10 kids that listen to (c)rap will get violent when I take away their (c)rap music and make them listen to something other then n this n that!? :p
 

lol, you didnt post the name, but I was guessing Lizzie Borden, famous video game player of the 1800's.

Agree with all of those who said 'WTF is the meaning of the findings?" Perhaps the game players needed less active brains to accomplish the same task as their lazy un-exercised bretheran?
 
first post. hummm, well have been playing video games since i could type in dos commands, now im 26 and in a wonderful marriage and enrolled in college for public health with an emphasis in epidemiology and still haven't had the urge to kill thousands of helpless innocents. interesting, perhaps i can find someone who will pay me many thousands of dollars to do a study on happy successful video gamers?

+1

These guys have to find new ways to get their grant money from somewhere though! :D
 
Inconclusive.

Right or wrong, When I was studying for my degree, our lecturer told us once that a 'survey' or 'study' or whatever you want to call it would only be accurate if thousands , if not tens of thousands took part.

To this day I still believe in what he said, I hate 'our product is preferred by 80% of women/men' and then at the end it says 'we asked 14 people'

Complete shit.

For large populations, certainly, but your professor would be wrong if he tried to apply that to every statistic; not every population is going to be in the thousands, or even hundreds.

Your sample size is a function of population you wish to infer upon and confidence level (i.e. how repeatable the results are). If your population is the number of middle-aged men who drive Daewoo's, the number of kids at a day care, or the number of blonde women at your workplace, then you can easily come up with a satisfactory sample size that needn't be in the thousands to be accurate.
 
I think it's a destructive vanity of our time that we imagine humans as not inherently violent.

My world view is that given the right circumstances, every human is capable of killing.
 
luckily mixing violent vid games with pron in 15 minute breaks helps keep the brain ticking. i wonder if watching fox news for 10 hours has the same effect?
 
not every human double tap. many people lay their lives down before taking someone elses, especially in asian religious cultural groups. thousands died by communists in china during the "cultural revolution" for not obeying commands to kill their monk, priest, parents etc.

capable, in a sense yes, doesnt mean they will. "every" is a big term.
 
As everyone said, very small study group for a very short period of time makes the results pretty much worthless.

It's also funded by the "Center for Successful Parenting" so there obviously isn't any bias in the testing methodology that could taint the results. I'm sure they were completely taken by surprise when they got the conclusion they were paying... err I mean looking for. :rolleyes:

Heh heh heh he said taint
 
Oh yeah playing Mortal Kombat when I was 14 has turned into such a menacing person, that I got married, and adopt pretty much any cat that shows up to my doorstep.

Besides Duke Forever (I know they didn't name the game) will make anyone dumber and not so emotional.
 
Lmao... Well than according to this artical I should snap and kill hundreds of innocents in oh... Any minute now...

... Guess that's not gonna happen.... I remember playing DOOM when It was out for the PSX. I have yet to run around and kill anyone.
 
Games do not make you want to kill people. PEOPLE makes me want to hurt them, but not kill them. The only time I want to kill someone is when the bastards blew up my buddies and were shooting at me. Then, and only then I want to pull the trigger until the barrel glow red hot. Fuckers...
.
.
.
.
.
damn... time for my PTSD pills now...
.
If any thing, shootem up games like COD4 help me calm down...
 
Juicy bits summary:

"The results showed that after one week of violent game play, the video game group members showed less activation in the left inferior frontal lobe during the emotional task and less activation in the anterior cingulate cortex during the counting task, compared to their baseline results and the results of the control group after one week. After the second week without game play, the changes to the executive regions of the brain were diminished." - Article

"The anterior cingulate cortex is involved in error and conflict detection processes, such as in the go/no-go task." - Wikipedia

Couldn't find anything concrete on the left interior frontal lobe.

The article didn't mention any heightened activity and didn't really elaborate on the findings. I find this annoying. >_>
 
Here I thought people I know with violent issues was due to their drug abuse and child abuse in their upbringing's history. now i know since they played atari in 1982 its due to asteroids.
 
Back
Top