Windows 8 To Revamp Windows Update

Zarathustra[H];1038024151 said:
What Windows Update really needs is something similar to a Linux package manager where ALL software you have installed is included, not just Windows components.

A system is only as secure as its weakest link, and if you are not updating your browser, plugins etc. you are still leaving yourself open to exploits.

Having one uniform interface through which to remind you about and update all of your software would REALLY help Windows security.

There are 3rd party apps that do this already. Still this is a LOT to manage and coordinate effectively.
 
Do you have any idea how many thousands of software applications run on windows? That's easy to do on Linux but would be crippling on Windows if MS has to do it all.
Android does this, and they do it through an expensive 3G/4G network. Microsoft my have to do this, cause of their app store in Win8.
 
Android does this, and they do it through an expensive 3G/4G network. Microsoft my have to do this, cause of their app store in Win8.

You're talking about mostly small/light applications. I'm talking about productivity/enterprise software. Plus there's the fact that MS might be putting themselves in a legally bad position by pushing/hosting other companies updates. If those updates don't work properly MS might get blamed for it.
 
I never use Windows Update... A SP3 update back when I had XP totally ruined my install. I couldn't recover or repair. I haven't used Windows update since. It's completely useless anyway. Don't want to get a virus? Don't hang out in the bad part of the internet neighborhood.
 
I recommend Microsoft Security Essentials for anti-virus/maleware for win7/XP...it'll be implemented in windows 8 natively I think

The EU would have a heart attack. How dare they add decent things people want that other people offer for money :eek:
 
I never use Windows Update... A SP3 update back when I had XP totally ruined my install. I couldn't recover or repair. I haven't used Windows update since. It's completely useless anyway. Don't want to get a virus? Don't hang out in the bad part of the internet neighborhood.

If only, Chauncey. If only.

You have incurable lung cancer.
 
For the vast majority of computer users I think this is a great idea.

This should be the default, although there ought to be a convenient way to toggle this setting along with other security settings for the users that would prefer to go without security features.
 
Android does this, and they do it through an expensive 3G/4G network. Microsoft my have to do this, cause of their app store in Win8.

For much smaller and less complex software. Windows 8 Metro apps are similar to mobile apps in that regard in that many programs will be of typically small phone app nature though Metro apps can scale well beyond what the typical mobile OS tablet and phone can handle.
 
I never use Windows Update... A SP3 update back when I had XP totally ruined my install. I couldn't recover or repair. I haven't used Windows update since. It's completely useless anyway. Don't want to get a virus? Don't hang out in the bad part of the internet neighborhood.

Thank you, Thank you, Thank you.

Its people like you that give me a nice paycheck weekly. I appreciate your donations to my causes graciously, continue to practice these measures in full. I will continue to clean up your mess when "I was just searching on Google" is your reason.
 
Crazy. And Stupid.

Honestly. You have to either be a troll or simply not understand that drive-by attacks are real (on all platforms, not just Windows). And a compromised machine easily becomes a Botnet Club Card holder in no time at all. If you're not running at least an antivirus, turn in your [H] cred now and replace it with [D] for dumb.

no its not crazy and stupid. There is no better antivirus then your own judgement. An antivirus is for people who make bad judgements one what sites they visit.. or what emails they open. I haven't had a virus in 10+ years.
 
no its not crazy and stupid. There is no better antivirus then your own judgement. An antivirus is for people who make bad judgements one what sites they visit.. or what emails they open. I haven't had a virus in 10+ years.

Then you better get off this forum, Slick. We were hit with a virus about some 4 months ago from this very forum.
 
Wow, I'm seriously surprised at the [H] populous right about now.

If you people would have said Windows Update.. okay, maybe Windows Update is good now and then. Personally, I don't notice a lick of difference, and I know exactly what goes into my computer.

Now, Anti-Virus.. I had one until I realized how unbelievably useless they are.
On two separate machines, one with some complex AV, one with nothing, I can prove to anyone who asks that there won't be a single bit of difference.
And if there is? Who cares! I re-install Windows, slip-streamed with all my software and settings and in 30 minutes, it's like it never happened. Oh, and it's free!

But User Account Control? Wow, that's a new low. UAC is the nanny system of Windows 7.
I don't even have anything to say to people who use it. God bless you.

This is how I see it:
If you truly believe that a bunch of updates are going to save you from viruses.. you're exactly the kind of person needs an AV.
 
no its not crazy and stupid. There is no better antivirus then your own judgement. An antivirus is for people who make bad judgements one what sites they visit.. or what emails they open. I haven't had a virus in 10+ years.

It is stupid when talking about GOOD security. All good security processes are multi-layered, no one single point of failure should completely compromise a system with no other line of defense. Sure good judgment is key and isn't replaced by anti-virus but like anything else, human judgment fails and people make mistakes.

As anti-virus software can't replace judgment, judgment can't replace many of the things that good anti-malware does, like detect when a site or file has been compromised.
 
It is stupid when talking about GOOD security. All good security processes are multi-layered, no one single point of failure should completely compromise a system with no other line of defense. Sure good judgment is key and isn't replaced by anti-virus but like anything else, human judgment fails and people make mistakes.

As anti-virus software can't replace judgment, judgment can't replace many of the things that good anti-malware does, like detect when a site or file has been compromised.

Gosh, you people talk about getting a virus like getting AIDS.

So I went to a site I didn't know, so I got a pop-up, so maybe I got a virus on some slim chance. Does it bother me? If it doesn't, who cares? If it does (and this includes making my computer into a bot), I re-install Windows.

There is just simply no reason I can see to using AV.
 
Gosh, you people talk about getting a virus like getting AIDS.

So I went to a site I didn't know, so I got a pop-up, so maybe I got a virus on some slim chance. Does it bother me? If it doesn't, who cares? If it does (and this includes making my computer into a bot), I re-install Windows.

There is just simply no reason I can see to using AV.

You just described the whole point of using AV, preventing malware, and yet see no point in it, fascinating.

Considering that good and efficient AV software is free these days and impacts little on system resources I can't think of a reason NOT to use AV.
 
You just described the whole point of using AV, preventing malware, and yet see no point in it, fascinating.

I don't see a point in it, because:

A.) I never get malware.
B.) I never notice it (if I do).
C.) If I do notice it, I re-install Windows.

Considering that good and efficient AV software is free these days and impacts little on system resources I can't think of a reason NOT to use AV.

Two reason:

1.) Free AV's are not always effective. Haven't used one a few years, but from what I remember it was more like 50/50.
2.) In my mind.. having a program there, running in the background, taking up resources, bothering me every once in a while...
Sounds a lot like having malware to me. I'm a clean PC advocate. I want to see nothing but the programs I open.
 
Gosh, you people talk about getting a virus like getting AIDS.

So I went to a site I didn't know, so I got a pop-up, so maybe I got a virus on some slim chance. Does it bother me? If it doesn't, who cares? If it does (and this includes making my computer into a bot), I re-install Windows.

There is just simply no reason I can see to using AV.

You obviously haven't worked in a sector where a virus outbreak is taken VERY seriously... Do whatever the hell you want in regards to not running AV, but don't spread that bullshit around.
 
You obviously haven't worked in a sector where a virus outbreak is taken VERY seriously... Do whatever the hell you want in regards to not running AV, but don't spread that bullshit around.

Um.. yeah, this is my opinion, not bullshit.

And I have every right to spread that around.

Thank you very much.
 
But User Account Control? Wow, that's a new low. UAC is the nanny system of Windows 7.
I don't even have anything to say to people who use it. God bless you.

Have you ever actually used Windows 7? You really don't get the prompt that often. It is there for good security. You're probably the same guy who a month down the road will see the headline for "virus runs as admin on Windows PCs!" and say to us "Damn Microsoft and their shitty security." :rolleyes:
 
Have you ever actually used Windows 7? You really don't get the prompt that often. It is there for good security. You're probably the same guy who a month down the road will see the headline for "virus runs as admin on Windows PCs!" and say to us "Damn Microsoft and their shitty security." :rolleyes:

Are you high?

You get it EVERY TIME YOU OPEN A PROGRAM.

And even if it were every full moon.. what am I, a baby?

Look, you've already sunk down to personal insults. I really don't feel like I have anything else to say to you.
 
I don't see a point in it, because:

A.) I never get malware.
B.) I never notice it (if I do).
C.) If I do notice it, I re-install Windows.

See no evil, hear no evil, until it's time to reinstall Windows. Heck if AV can save one session of reinstalling Windows it's done it's job as far as I'm concerned.

Two reason:

1.) Free AV's are not always effective. Haven't used one a few years, but from what I remember it was more like 50/50.
2.) In my mind.. having a program there, running in the background, taking up resources, bothering me every once in a while...
Sounds a lot like having malware to me. I'm a clean PC advocate. I want to see nothing but the programs I open.

Human judgment isn't 100% effective either, again security is a multi-layered process, you don't depend on any one thing for your entire security setup, along with AV you also should have backups, unless reinstalling Windows is your thing.

AV bothering you once in a while is more bothersome than reinstalling Windows? And as for the bothering part, I think I might see MSE pop-up something every blue moon, definitely a whole year's worth of MSE pop-ups is a lot less time than a single Windows install.

Not sure when it was the last time you've tried AV but it looks like it's been a while if you think that almost non-existent pop-ups and unnoticeable resources being used by good AV products are worse than malware with which you have no real tools to prevent or detect other than observation.

If you don't want to run AV that's fine, but PLEASE don't recommend that to anyone, it really is insane not to run AV on a modern Windows machine. Cost vs the benefit for virtually anyone is well worth it.
 
Are you high?

You get it EVERY TIME YOU OPEN A PROGRAM.

And even if it were every full moon.. what am I, a baby?

Look, you've already sunk down to personal insults. I really don't feel like I have anything else to say to you.

I think you're the one that's high, this simply isn't the case with Windows 7 for anything other than 3rd party tools that can alter certain things in Windows like installers, task and computer management tools, etc.
 
This is priceless. You'd rather reinstall Windows than just run a lightweight AV like MSE?
 
This is priceless. You'd rather reinstall Windows than just run a lightweight AV like MSE?
He captures all the packets coming into his network, analyzes them all, and then reinstalls Windows. He is a super computer. :cool:
 
The places that do need the updates are businesses. Most hardcore people that know what they are doing won't get any hijacks or anything if they are smart. The people that really need the updates are noobs, grannies, and gramps. They are good to have but not required for the veterans that know about security.
 
One thing they need to do way with is the need to reboot after every single little change. It's not that hard. Linux has done it, why can't a multi trillion dollar corporation with millions of employees manage it?

Not just talking about Windows update, but any other change such as installing a new program or updating a program.
 
One thing they need to do way with is the need to reboot after every single little change. It's not that hard. Linux has done it, why can't a multi trillion dollar corporation with millions of employees manage it?

Not just talking about Windows update, but any other change such as installing a new program or updating a program.

That's not windows requiring the reboot, it's the program itself. In most cases you don't really need to reboot it's just the programs want to insert their auto-start services and get them running after the reboot.
 
That's not windows requiring the reboot, it's the program itself. In most cases you don't really need to reboot it's just the programs want to insert their auto-start services and get them running after the reboot.

Correct, many applications just force a reboot because...

Honestly, Windows booting and restarting processes have improved tremendously over the years, my UEFI Series 7 Slate boots in 15 seconds to a ready to go desktop, my sig rig generally only needs booting after a video driver change or Patch Tuesday.

The biggest pain in dealing with Windows reboots is during an fresh install, Microsoft doesn't roll it's updates into cumulative packages very often requiring multiple updates to get to the latest version on too many occasions.
 
Correct, many applications just force a reboot because...

Honestly, Windows booting and restarting processes have improved tremendously over the years, my UEFI Series 7 Slate boots in 15 seconds to a ready to go desktop, my sig rig generally only needs booting after a video driver change or Patch Tuesday.

The biggest pain in dealing with Windows reboots is during an fresh install, Microsoft doesn't roll it's updates into cumulative packages very often requiring multiple updates to get to the latest version on too many occasions.

If it's requiring a reboot after a video driver change, please tell me which driver. Video drivers are required by WHQL to not force a reboot except for very special extenuating circumstances. I've only granted one such exception in the past year, though it may not be the only exception that exists. You can read more about it here: A major frustration for Windows end-users is software updates that force the system through a reboot. Graphics drivers formerly required a reboot after an update. With Windows Vista and a WDDM-supporting GPU, users are no longer required to reboot when the graphics driver is updated.


Generally, we try to eliminate reboots where possible, because they're annoying (and we know that!). Patch Tuesday is our only scheduled exception, and, well, there's a lot of backstory there that I don't wnat to get into.
 
The big deal is when your PC reboots itself, especially when you're using it. I don't know if Windows 7 does this anymore, cause I set updates to manual. I rarely run Windows Update, cause there's usually nothing worth a damn to get from it. Plus, I've been burned a few times in the past for running it. Reboot my PC, and some stuff isn't working anymore.

I also hate how it decided to start downloading updates, when I'm using my PC. Couldn't the damn thing wait until the PC was idle?

Linux and Mac OS X have the right idea with updates. Pops up a message for you to install updates, it's up to you if want to. This is by default. Enter a password if you decided to go ahead with it. No auto download, install, and reboot my PC.

You can set windows to do that. There is a setting to download only and ask you to install. That said, if your computer has issues after restarting you might want to fix that as you have problems with it. Any computer regardless of OS and software should be able to be restarted without issue, if not then you are running shitty software or have screwed something up big time.

Its possible to get infected from the ads on top of this website, without ever clicking them. Not saying they are infected (don't ban me Kyle :D ), but many legit websites have had infected advertisements.

Then you better get off this forum, Slick. We were hit with a virus about some 4 months ago from this very forum.

This, I've had a few viruses trying to get into my computer from hardocp in the last year. Sad to say that this is the ONLY site that I've had try to give me a computer virus :(

I would like to be able to keep all the updates locally forever to save me time when doing reinstalls. Just point to the updates on my network. For everything, not just service packs.That is what i would like to see.

WSUS, install that on a machine that supports it, have it download all the updates then just point your computers at that for their updates. That is what most businesses do, they don't have every computer download them on their own from Microsoft.

I never use Windows Update... A SP3 update back when I had XP totally ruined my install. I couldn't recover or repair. I haven't used Windows update since. It's completely useless anyway. Don't want to get a virus? Don't hang out in the bad part of the internet neighborhood.

As people pointed out, even the good side (ie this forum and sites like it) can infect your computer from time to time.

I don't see a point in it, because:

A.) I never get malware.
B.) I never notice it (if I do).
C.) If I do notice it, I re-install Windows.



Two reason:

1.) Free AV's are not always effective. Haven't used one a few years, but from what I remember it was more like 50/50.
2.) In my mind.. having a program there, running in the background, taking up resources, bothering me every once in a while...
Sounds a lot like having malware to me. I'm a clean PC advocate. I want to see nothing but the programs I open.

Yeah because the ONLY thing virus do is that. its not like they would steal your info if you do online banking or anything like that.

Are you high?

You get it EVERY TIME YOU OPEN A PROGRAM.

And even if it were every full moon.. what am I, a baby?

Look, you've already sunk down to personal insults. I really don't feel like I have anything else to say to you.

If you get them every time you open a program you need to fix your computer as you really screwed it up somehow.

The places that do need the updates are businesses. Most hardcore people that know what they are doing won't get any hijacks or anything if they are smart. The people that really need the updates are noobs, grannies, and gramps. They are good to have but not required for the veterans that know about security.

I have to call bull shit on that to a point. doesn't matter how smart or careful you are, you have a risk with any system. Businesses have more risk that is true, but i would have to say if you don't keep your machine patches, don't run anything to monitor for viruses or unwanted program not sure you can exactly call that good security wise or safe for anyone.
 
for those people bitching about updates for windows. I've had Linux and Mac OS require updates also, so it isn't like windows is the only OS to ever want you to restart, will admit it wants it more often, but it is the only one that wants a restart.

When it comes to updates, I've had Linux fuck up more than windows from updates and restarts. latest was a few weeks ago were updates on Centos screwed up LVM for me
 
I am truly amazed by some of the posts in this thread. Security in today's world has almost zero to do with the user, and almost entirely to do with how patched their machine is.

Ad server's get compromised on a regular basis, and serve malicious advertisements, that exploit the software on your machine, and then install a rootkit, so you see NO different behavior. Your machine works like it always has, meanwhile it's spamming all your friends, launching attacks and ddos against websites, stealing your game credentials, etc...

http://www.microsoft.com/security/portal/Threat/Encyclopedia/Entry.aspx?Name=Trojan:DOS/Alureon.A

AV and patches are mandatory in today's always on, connected world. The Russian gangsters are going out of their way to compromise your machine.

I don't name victim's of these compromises, but I will give you an example I analyzed from a compromised server.

Code went something like this:

//Try exploit against quicktime
//Try exploit against IE version blah
//Try exploit against firefox version blah

This file was almost 400k of well commented exploit code. Easiest file I've ever had to sign in a long time. ;)

In all of those exploits, the user had to do nothing but browse a website that got a compromised advertisement.

If you don't believe phishing will ever work against you, I suggest you read Cory Doctorow's article about how he was phished, and he is a very technical person.

AV software is the security guard making sure your valuable's aren't robbed, and patching is making sure that the fence and all entrances are properly secured. Defense in Depth is the way to proper security.

This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights.
 
As far as system restarts are concerned: abso-frickin'-lutely.

yeah right, it hasnt changed at all :rolleyes:

you can now install pretty much all updates in one go - with one agreement and one reboot. XP and older had to split up updates and had multiple prompts

reboots are only needed if files are in use - which is a lot of the time but not ALL updates need a reboot

anyway, any PC on the net needs to be patched. Secuirty essentials is free, takes up f*ck all resources and you'll never see it prompt for anything. it just updates in the background and runs a quick scan every now and then.

in this day and age, there is no need to sit there and try and save a mb or 2 of ram :rolleyes:
 
yeah right, it hasnt changed at all :rolleyes:

you can now install pretty much all updates in one go - with one agreement and one reboot. XP and older had to split up updates and had multiple prompts

reboots are only needed if files are in use - which is a lot of the time but not ALL updates need a reboot

anyway, any PC on the net needs to be patched. Secuirty essentials is free, takes up f*ck all resources and you'll never see it prompt for anything. it just updates in the background and runs a quick scan every now and then.

in this day and age, there is no need to sit there and try and save a mb or 2 of ram :rolleyes:

but but I don't want my machine with 32 GB of ram to be using over 320 MB ;)
 
Back
Top