Building a gaming, coding and architecural design computer - would like some feedback

Which mobo?

  • ASRock 890FX

    Votes: 2 15.4%
  • GIGABYTE GA-990FXA-UD3

    Votes: 9 69.2%
  • MSI 990FXA-GD65

    Votes: 2 15.4%

  • Total voters
    13
Sometimes refurb stuff don't have a warranty. Not to mention that you don't know what the previous owner did. As such, there's a chance that you may end up going through the hassle of sending the part back should there be an issue. A lot of times, open-box/refurbished stuff are missing certain cables and adapters.
 
OK I decided to wait on the video card and I bought the Gigabyte mobo (from the poll, link in my first post this thread) as it was discounted $15.00. So two important things here... I'm doing an AMD build AND I'm getting a video card later. Gonna keep looking for those discounts...

I really think I'll be happier with AMD in the long run. But I want all those who encouraged me to go with an Intel build to know I really have appreciated your feedback and help over this last month or so.
- Deathbliss
 
Really quick question for everyone here... When you order a mobo from NewEgg is the box usually wrapped in some sort of plastic, or is it completely unsealed?
- Deathbliss
 
Really quick question for everyone here... When you order a mobo from NewEgg is the box usually wrapped in some sort of plastic, or is it completely unsealed?
- Deathbliss
No plastic wrap IIRC but it is sealed well via tape or something.
 
Is anything missing? Does it look like it was previously opened? If not, nah.
 
The motherboard will be in an antistatic bag, inside a branded box (ie Gigabyte box) packed inside a Newegg box. In general there will not be a safety seal. Most motherboards aren't sold at retail, or if they are they're usually spider wrapped or kept behind the counter. Just look at the manual -- it should have a list of included parts.
 
Minor updates...

The mobo came with everything the manual says it's suposed to, and an extra set of Sata cables too.

I ordered this 750 GB hard drive:

Western Digital Caviar Black
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136794

That was just too good a buy to pass up.

I've also ordered a Trendnet trw-650mb bridge ($29.99) and two Rosewill Cat 7 3' cables ($5.99 ea) so I can get my new computer online without needing a wireless card, as well as my 360 and PS3. I'll order an additional cat 7 cable if I like the Rosewills and a high speed HDMI cable for the computer.

Waiting for my folks to pay the rest of the money they owe me, then I will buy a processor and a video card.
- Deathbliss
 
I ordered this 750 GB hard drive:

Western Digital Caviar Black
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136794

That was just too good a buy to pass up.
Actually it isn't: The Samsung F3 1TB that I've recommended in this thread is a better deal: It's actually faster than that Western Digital drive and only costs $10 more. 250GB more space + 10% to 15% more performance for only $10 more. Well worth it IMO.
I've also ordered a Trendnet trw-650mb bridge ($29.99) and two Rosewill Cat 7 3' cables ($5.99 ea) so I can get my new computer online without needing a wireless card, as well as my 360 and PS3. I'll order an additional cat 7 cable if I like the Rosewills and a high speed HDMI cable for the computer.
Even for Newegg, those cables are not worth it unless you have a super high-end network (we're talking hundreds to thousands of dollars here). You would have been fine with Cat 5e and Cat 6 cables. In any case, those cables are a bit overpriced considering that you can get two 3ft Cat 6 cables for around $6 to $7.50 shipped from Monoprice.com:
http://www.monoprice.com/products/subdepartment.asp?c_id=102&cp_id=10232

While Monoprice.com may have had security issues in the past, still trustworthy enough for me to use them. Hell even if you wanted to stick with Newegg, you still overpaid for cables considering you could have gotten this cable from Newegg:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16812119196
 
Mu budget for a hard drive, the ideal price I was going for, was $50.00. That drive was $65.00 normally, so I saved $15.00, and not only did I get a brand I trust (Western Digital) but I also got one of their higher priced Black versions. Finally at 6gbs how much more speed do I really need?

I do appreciate your suggestions of the Seagate, but it was out of budget for me, I didn't really want a drive that big (I wanted to stack 500 or 750 gig hard drives - maybe 2 or 3 of the same thing, so if one dies I don't loose everything and have to take a week recovering it all), and I'm not a big fan of Seagate. Finally the WD has a 5 year warranty VS Seagate's 2 year.

I got the higher end cat 7 cables because I wanted no throttling when using the 360 and PS3. Maybe it was overkill, but I won't have any internet speed bottlenecks now will I :p

So that's why I made my purchasing decisions. But as always your suggestions are welcome and appreciated! I need different viewpoints to balance my own.
- Deathbliss
 
Mu budget for a hard drive, the ideal price I was going for, was $50.00. That drive was $65.00 normally, so I saved $15.00, and not only did I get a brand I trust (Western Digital) but I also got one of their higher priced Black versions. Finally at 6gbs how much more speed do I really need?

I do appreciate your suggestions of the Seagate, but it was out of budget for me, I didn't really want a drive that big (I wanted to stack 500 or 750 gig hard drives - maybe 2 or 3 of the same thing, so if one dies I don't loose everything and have to take a week recovering it all), and I'm not a big fan of Seagate. Finally the WD has a 5 year warranty VS Seagate's 2 year.

I got the higher end cat 7 cables because I wanted no throttling when using the 360 and PS3. Maybe it was overkill, but I won't have any internet speed bottlenecks now will I :p

So that's why I made my purchasing decisions. But as always your suggestions are welcome and appreciated! I need different viewpoints to balance my own.
- Deathbliss

6 Gbps refers to the speed of the connection between the hard drive and the system, not how fast the hard drive can actually run (think of it more as a speed limit, and mechanical hard drives being nowhere close to that limit.)

He recommended a Samsung not a Seagate, but whatever.

The Cat7 is overkill. It's designed for 10 Gbps networks. It'll work fine for your SOHO network, don't get me wrong, but you're literally paying for tin foil when you don't need it. Especially considering your 300 Mbps wireless bridge has 10/100 ethernet ports on it. Then there's the fact that gaming is affected much more by latency than bandwidth. It's only $12 so really, not a huge deal. Especially since you went above spec rather than below. But Cat7 cables in over 99% of homes, in 2011, do not provide a benefit over Cat6, and usually Cat5e as well.
 
Mu budget for a hard drive, the ideal price I was going for, was $50.00. That drive was $65.00 normally, so I saved $15.00, and not only did I get a brand I trust (Western Digital) but I also got one of their higher priced Black versions. Finally at 6gbs how much more speed do I really need?
Technically you only saved $10 as you apparently bought that WD drive today or within the last few days. That Samsung has been $60 for the past week at the least. Possibly two weeks. In addition as tonytnnt noted, SATA 6.0Gb/s doesn't mean anything when it comes to actual HDD speed. Note that the Samsung drive I recommended is SATA 3.0Gb/s yet still outperforms that WD drive. So interface doesn't matter nowadays when it comes to regular hard drives.
I do appreciate your suggestions of the Seagate, but it was out of budget for me, I didn't really want a drive that big (I wanted to stack 500 or 750 gig hard drives - maybe 2 or 3 of the same thing, so if one dies I don't loose everything and have to take a week recovering it all), and I'm not a big fan of Seagate. Finally the WD has a 5 year warranty VS Seagate's 2 year.
Funny. I don't remember recomending a Seagate drive:
Pretty much the best bang for the buck hard drive out now:
$65 - Samsung Spinpoint F3 HD103SJ 1TB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive

In any case, if an extra two years (Samsung has three years warranty) of warranty is worth $10 savings over 250GB of extra hard drives space + 10% to 15% performance, good for you.
I got the higher end cat 7 cables because I wanted no throttling when using the 360 and PS3. Maybe it was overkill, but I won't have any internet speed bottlenecks now will I :p
You won't but there's a difference between overkill and sheer stupid overkill. Cat 7 was definitely the latter. But tonytnnt is right that it's only $12.
I need different viewpoints to balance my own.
No comment.
 
I see you're a UT'er. Well... the later games at least.
 
I'd get the 955 Phenom II as it's cheaper and it's unlocked so you set it higher if you wanted.
Mobo wise why not get the next Gigabyte board down? I did and it's a pretty damn good board have to say it's got all you want tweaking wise and supports multiple graphics cards, USB 3 ports and headers..

Why spend more?

One thing I like about Asrock is they bundle a USB 3 fron panel with their board. Other than that I think you'd be better off with a lower priced board.
 
My bad I could have sworn that you said Seagate, not Samsung.

In that case I'm even happier with my pick! Why? Read the feedback on the Samsung. It's simply not a trustworthy drive. I'd rather drive a stock Honda Accord than the latest, fanciest, fasted thing from Italy. When it comes to hard drives, as for me it comes to cars (ironic I know since I sold mine and don't have one anymore), reliability is far more important than speed. I'm building a work computer, not something fit for a NASCAR race :p

@Skillz
I play, map, write tutorials, model, and collect maps for Unreal Tournament, Unreal Tournament 2003-2004, Unreal Tournament 3, Morrowind, Oblivion, Far Cry Instincts Predator (some of my maps are running around the Xbox Live network) and will soon be fooling around with the free CryEngine SDK (just released) and the UDK. Currently you can find me, as Deathbliss, on the Playstation Network dabbling with Wipeout Fury HD. I don't play online very much, can't afford and won't pay for an Xbox Gold or Playstation Plus account. You can see all of my PC work at my website under Files and Maps:
http://deathbliss.hostei.com/retro/main.php

You can also find my stuff at Mapraider and whatever the Elder Scrolls site is called now.

@ Mr Spocko
Thanks for the CPU suggestion. MOBO, hard drive, RAM, Case and PSU are all already bought. Next up are CPU and GPU. Unfortunately I can't afford to get either one of them at this point, so the build has been delayed. Hopefully I'll have been paid back enough to order one or the other next month or later this month.

Later all!
- Deathbliss
 
That Kingwin is an ok PSU:
http://hardocp.com/article/2009/11/04/kingwin_lz1000_1000w_power_supply_review/

But I'd rather go Corsair for the higher quality and excellent customer support.

To the OP, I've had 3 Corsair PSU's, never a problem.

My rule of thumb, build slightly above what you want, which allows
for a real upgrade latter. Get as large a PSU, as you can afford now.

I'm a programmer, and like to do light video work, go for all the ram
you can.

Danny is giving great advice here.
 
My bad I could have sworn that you said Seagate, not Samsung.

In that case I'm even happier with my pick! Why? Read the feedback on the Samsung. It's simply not a trustworthy drive. I'd rather drive a stock Honda Accord than the latest, fanciest, fasted thing from Italy. When it comes to hard drives, as for me it comes to cars (ironic I know since I sold mine and don't have one anymore), reliability is far more important than speed. I'm building a work computer, not something fit for a NASCAR race :p

This is simply absurd. If a drive arrives DOA, there are many factors that influence it, including how it is packed and how it is handled in transit. I have the very drive Danny recommended and it's been running great for almost 2 years.

Danny is pretty much the top dog for PC part recommendations because he keeps up with his research and generally recommends a part that he has full faith in. It was aggravating to watch the back and forth of him recommending really great stuff and you coming back with piss-poor or sub standard parts, as if you don't even want to listen to the suggestions. This may sound harsh, but that's the way I see it.
 
Then I owe both you and Danny an apology. If he, and you, feel the Samsung is a worthy drive then it most likely is. I have had little experience with Samsung drives, and therefore have little to say. I was just going by the feedback at NewEgg for the one he recommended. It was far worse than the Western Digital drive.

UPDATE HERE:
OK I have just compared the detail pages of the two drives, so I must be missing something...

Samsung 32 meg cache < 64 meg cache WD
Samsung 3gbs < 6gbs WD
Samsung 4.17 ms latencey > 4.2 ms latency WD
Samsung 8.9 ms seek ? WD
Samsung 7200 RPM = 7200 RPM WD

Looking for a review here but I'm not seeing how the Samsung is faster... Not trying to argue here, just curious as to what Danny and other experienced users are seeing that I'm not.

I have stuck with Western Digital and Seagate because these are what my uncle always recommended. He had been, might still be for all I know, building computers for many, many years. He built the predecessor to the gaming computer I am trying to build now. I still have the hard drives from that computer. I've been using them in an opened external enclosure for the last few years.. They have held up under less than ideal circumstances for, 5 years or so now? Yeah I think about 5 years.

A few years back I got a Western Digital external hard drive despite the bad feedback and better buys, including Samsung. No problems, and that drive is constantly moved around and stored next to my PS3 where it withstands higher than normal temperatures.

So I beg your indulgence if I stick with a hard drive manufacture that has proven trustworthy to me, my uncle and his sons (my cousins). I must also take some offense that anyone would call a Western Digital hard drive a substandard part. For me that has simply never been true.

Finally I should clarify something here... A trick I learned from my uncle, which I will use in my new build, is hard drive stacking (as I call it). What is that? Simply put I have my operating system and installed programs partitions on one hard drive. On another I place my Data, such as My Documents, and my Downloads. Or perhaps I will have a Data drive and a Download drive. In the event of a recovery I want smaller hard drives because it will take less time to recover all the data on them. This also protects me from viruses which usually infect your operating system, so being able to simply image/backup the OS partition will wipe out any virus. I also want smaller hard drives because I don;t need as much room when I use them like this. Finally I want smaller drives because smaller, slower drives have less a chance of failure than larger, faster, more complex drives (my uncle could explain this better).

I have listened to, and will continue to listen to, any suggestions much more experienced people than myself, like Danny, have taken the time to give. I carefully weigh every decision based on all the facts I can gather and the price range in which I am trying to work. I need, and appreciate having, someone looking over my shoulder as I put this thing together because I am on my own, my uncle will not help me, and this is for the best, because sooner or later I have to put together my own computer.

So once again I apologize for any offenses I have given. I thank all of your for your patience, suggestions, and continuing help.
- Deathbliss
 
Last edited:
You should take the reviews at Newegg, or any online retailer for that matter, with a grain of salt. I too have two Samsung F3 drives in Raid0 running just fine and I bought them nearly a year ago.

Here is a nice review/benchmark of the Samsung F3 hard drive: http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/storage/2009/10/06/samsung-spinpoint-f3-1tb-review/1

As for UT, nice site. I happen to run a community site for the Unreal series called www.ut-files.com. Some of your stuff might be on there, if not then when I get a chance I plan to check and add them if they aren't already. Unless you wish for me not too.
 
Then I owe both you and Danny an apology. If he, and you, feel the Samsung is a worthy drive then it most likely is. I have had little experience with Samsung drives, and therefore have little to say. I was just going by the feedback at NewEgg for the one he recommended. It was far worse than the Western Digital drive.
Look at how many reviews there are for the Samsung VS that of the WD drive you chose: 1604 reviews VS 97 reviews for the WD. Also note the combined 4-5 star percentages: 81% for the Samsung VS 65% for the WD. Looke at the 1 star percentage: 10% for the Samsung VS 22% for the WD. So the feedback isn't far worse than the WD drive based on those factors. Not to mention our own personal experiences here: We've been recommending that Samsung drive in this forum for the last two years or so. We've rarely had a problem.

I'm one to fully admit when I'm wrong to recommend something when there is ample evidence showing so. But this is not the case.
UPDATE HERE:
OK I have just compared the detail pages of the two drives, so I must be missing something...

Samsung 32 meg cache < 64 meg cache WD
Samsung 3gbs < 6gbs WD
Samsung 4.17 ms latencey > 4.2 ms latency WD
Samsung 8.9 ms seek ? WD
Samsung 7200 RPM = 7200 RPM WD

Looking for a review here but I'm not seeing how the Samsung is faster... Not trying to argue here, just curious as to what Danny and other experienced users are seeing that I'm not.
HDD specs don't tell the whole story: Cache doesn't really mean anything unless you're doing a fuck-ton of large file transfers for hours on end. Interface doesn't really matter since current mechanical hard drives are nowhere near the limits of SATA 3.0Gb/s nor do they take advantage of 6.0Gb/s.

You have to find actual reviews of said drives or even HDTune scores for those hard drives. If all elsefails, I'll even use a canned benchmark as a metric like PassMark
I must also take some offense that anyone would call a Western Digital hard drive a substandard part. For me that has simply never been true.
But no one here has said that the WD is a substandard part. What we have said is that it's a poor buy for the money. Those are two very different descriptions. Note my sig: I currently have Seagate, Western Digital drives, and Samsung drives. Does it look like I have anything against Seagate or WD drives if I'm still using them in my main PC and my file server?

Well anyway, good luck with the rest of PC purchases.
 
@ Danny

It appears I was wrong about the feedback on the Samsung VS the WD. I could've sworn I was looking at a larger Samsung which had only 3 eggs worth of feeback. Guess I'm loosing track here. Maybe it was that stupid Hitachi I saw on sale a few weeks back. In any case I take back any bad or negative thing I said or implied about the Samsung and admit I was wrong.

The substandard part bit was directed at Zaxour:
...It was aggravating to watch the back and forth of him recommending really great stuff and you coming back with piss-poor or sub standard parts, as if you don't even want to listen to the suggestions. This may sound harsh, but that's the way I see it.

Of course he/she was probably referring to the other parts I was coming back in here with after you had given your recommendations. Like that Lepa PSU I bough because I thought I was so clever... :rolleyes: I think I will be far happier withe the Corsair, which I believe your originally recommended.

@ Skillz

Feel free to share any of my work at your site. Just leave the archives in tact. I recall the name UT Files so I may actually be a member there from a LONG, long time ago. Maybe tomorrow I'll head over and take a look.

Also I understand that about the feedback at NewEgg. You have to wade through the stuff put up by ignorant, whiny users who don't know what they're doing from the more professional detailed information. But in the case of a hard drive like the Hitachi - most likely what I got confused with the Samsung (I have not verified this) if you have 3 eggs and a few pages of users telling you the drive was DOA or died weeks or even months after they started using it well you have to take that into consideration.

Man I'm tired - later folks!
- Deathbliss
 
Last edited:
Back
Top