Windows 8: 7 Things We Know For Sure

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Recently leaked builds show that Windows 8 will be a very different OS from its forebearer, from the kernel to the cloud. ARM processor support, mobile-device optimization, and system-wide menu tweaks abound. There are still a lot of things we don't know about the next OS from Microsoft, but the number of things we can say for sure is growing.
 
You know, innovation is a good thing.

But one thing they never seem to fix: window focus! Windows has terrible window focus behavior. It seems like if anything happens its enough to switch window focus on me, whether the window is idle (reading), or even if I'm in the middle of typing.

Whenever I'm annoyed by my OS, it's the window focus. Rarely is something actually wrong or irritating with 7.
 
WHy don't they just make a touch screen tablet edition and leave the desktop version without giant buttons (or have a simple skin based system).
I'm still not seeing anything new...
 
I should have checked before clicking that link first.

I just accidentally gave Gizmodo an extra page hit.
 
Based on the leaked info. Does anyone actually plan on upgrading from Win7?
 
I should have checked before clicking that link first.

I just accidentally gave Gizmodo an extra page hit.

Yea I was definitely unhappy about this too :(

So far it seems nice, but nothing to move me to upgrade so far. Unless of course I get another great deal (ie free or less than $30) like I have with Vista and 7
 
Based on the leaked info. Does anyone actually plan on upgrading from Win7?

I wouldn't say I planned on not doing. To be honest I had very little cause to move from XP to 7. Vista was very easy to resist but the geek in me only lasted out a year from 7's release to finally moving over.

The DWM and 64bit support have made it a worthwhile upgrade but I honestly can't think what features 8 will be able to bring that will really matter.
 
Nice. Win8 looks to be great. Let's see how Android and iOS do when Win8 comes rolling in on tablets and crushes them like the half assed OSes they are.
 
Fucking ribbons. I tolerate it in Office, I deplored it in AutoCAD and now they wanna put it in Windows Explorer? Thankfully, they were smart enough to have a revert option to non-ribbon.
 
You know, innovation is a good thing.

But one thing they never seem to fix: window focus! Windows has terrible window focus behavior. It seems like if anything happens its enough to switch window focus on me, whether the window is idle (reading), or even if I'm in the middle of typing.

Whenever I'm annoyed by my OS, it's the window focus. Rarely is something actually wrong or irritating with 7.

WTF u coming from fvwm :p
 
Fucking ribbons. I tolerate it in Office, I deplored it in AutoCAD and now they wanna put it in Windows Explorer? Thankfully, they were smart enough to have a revert option to non-ribbon.

I saw the screen shot of that and /facepalmed
 
Ribbons are better in every way. And guess what, you can minimize them to! There is absolutely no argument to be made for the old way of doing things, except that people are resistant to change.
 
The Portable Workspace Clone looks nice :D Very very nice indeed! :D
 
I saw the screen shot of that and /facepalmed

You mean the odd looking menu area, correct?

Personal I would like the file edit view options back like from xp, So i can have a box pop up for folder options. Lame I know but I like it.
 
Ribbons are better in every way. And guess what, you can minimize them to! There is absolutely no argument to be made for the old way of doing things, except that people are resistant to change.

What about the folks the think the layout is better without ribbons.
Personally I like my office the same as open office. Which i am sure others do too. So that is an argument.
 
How do you mean? Do you have a screen shot?

I found it. Truthfully never looked in the organize and layout option.
That makes me feel this small
screenymymistake.jpg
[/URL] Uploaded with ImageShack.us[/IMG]
 
I have nothing against optimizing an OS for portable apps, as long as it does not reduce its functionality on the Desktop.

If Widows 8 does this, it will be the worst thing they have released since Bob.
 
Oh and also...


Die ribbon interface. Please die faster than anything has ever died before.
 
I actually really liked the ribbon interface in Microsoft Office. It made more features be known and more user friendly IMO. Now having a ribbon in Explorer, not so good.
 
I actually really liked the ribbon interface in Microsoft Office. It made more features be known and more user friendly IMO. Now having a ribbon in Explorer, not so good.

I think the ribbon interface made Office utterly unusable.

I'm still on Office 2003 at home and will be until there is a newer version without the ribbon.

We are also still on 2003 at work (and have been at my last three jobs) and if they force is to update to 2007 or 2010 I will throw a fucking fit.
 
Zarathustra[H];1037192591 said:
I think the ribbon interface made Office utterly unusable.

I'm still on Office 2003 at home and will be until there is a newer version without the ribbon.

We are also still on 2003 at work (and have been at my last three jobs) and if they force is to update to 2007 or 2010 I will throw a fucking fit.

Does it have full compatibility with .docx?
 
Ribbons are better in every way. And guess what, you can minimize them to! There is absolutely no argument to be made for the old way of doing things, except that people are resistant to change.

Pretty much this. Ribbons are superior to the old menu system in nearly every way.

the problem is, ribbons for the most part are going to be rendered moot as far as windows explorer. I don't ever use the explorer in win 7 as it is..the instant search feature just works too good.

That said, I haven't seen anything that interests me for Win 8 yet. Win 7 is fantastic and does everything I currently need. I will consider it in the event that it has some major improvement, but I can't think of many. Most of the features in that 7 things list are utterly worthless to me currently. I would jump if there was a $30 upgrade for my Win 7 ultimate to Win 8 ultimate though.
 
Does it have full compatibility with .docx?

The compatibility pack seems to work fine.

Either way, I usually admonish anyone who sends me one of those new 2007+ file formats. They are simply not standard accepted formats like .doc, .xls and .ppt are.
 
Pretty much this. Ribbons are superior to the old menu system in nearly every way.

Bullshit.

Everything is disorganized and difficult to use. Besides, no need for icons. IMHO the icons are a huge negative. They use more screen real estate and are much more difficult to use than a neat, clean and organized column of text, like in a traditional menu. The only reason to use icons is to appeal to those who cant read. Everyone using word should be able to read...

Office 2007 is a fucking train wreck due to the ribbon interface. I haven't used 2010 yet, but I am assuming it's the same.

I think there is a reason that not as single business I have interacted with has updated to 2007 or 2010 in the 4 years since release...

Traditional menus are a quick clean interface, use minimal screen real estate and are organized intelligently. Very usable. The ribbon interface is a convoluted messed up jumbled mess of pictures and text and makes no sense at all.
 
Count me in as another person that despises the Ribbon. I gave a good-faith effort to use the Ribbon for a year when Office 2007 came out. I even went so far as to uninstall Office 2003 for the time so I wouldn't be tempted to "run home to momma" when the Ribbon frustrated me.

Now I've gotten good with the Ribbon. That doesn't mean it's any better. I often find myself having to make extra clicks to accomplish the same thing that I did pre-Ribbon. I can, of course, equal my old productivity by creating a custom Ribbon with only the functions that I want on it, but that's not an improvement over what I was able to do pre-Ribbon, which then begs the question of why the Ribbon was invented to begin with.

The only reason I now use Office 2010 is because a few (stupid) people I know keep on insisting sending me documents in .docx format, even though I've showed them multiple times how to send something in .doc. They're not using any slick features that justify using .docx, so it's doubly frustrating.

I can only hope that businesses and large enterprises resist moving over to 2007/2010, and/or give MS lots of hateful feedback about the Ribbon, and cause it to be relegated to the dustbin of stupid computer ideas like Clippy and DIVX, the self-destructing DVD.

The thought that the Ribbon is going to appear in Windows 8 is annoying me to no end. Though I'm sure some smart guy will come up with "Classic Shell" or whatever that will enable the previous XP/Vista/7 behavior, which is cleaner and takes up less vertical screen space.
 
Now I've gotten good with the Ribbon. That doesn't mean it's any better. I often find myself having to make extra clicks to accomplish the same thing that I did pre-Ribbon. I can, of course, equal my old productivity by creating a custom Ribbon with only the functions that I want on it, but that's not an improvement over what I was able to do pre-Ribbon, which then begs the question of why the Ribbon was invented to begin with.

The Ribbon was created for several important reasons, one of the bigger ones being discoverabilty of features in function-rich applications like Office. Another being that it is a FAR much touch friendly UI metaphor than classic menus.

I work a lot with Office users and almost without fail its old time Office users that don't like it and noobies that love it. In that situation the noobies generally win.
The Ribbon is here to stay. I'd say that you're not getting your wish with resistance to Office 2010, apparently uptake of it is very solid according to Microsoft's last profit statement. As a heavy Tablet PC user I love the ribbon metaphor as it can be made to work well with traditional KBM interfaces as well as touch and pen devices and it's so awesome having the same app with the same features and capabilities running on my desktops, laptops and tablets. This is CRITICAL to the success of Windows 8 and Microsoft's ability to penetrate into slates and tablets.
 
Its 2011 people, .docx is a much superior to .doc, the files are significantly smaller. Telling people they can't send you .docx files they must first convert to .doc is retarded.

What exactly are you guys doing that it takes sooooooooo many clicks with a ribbon that did not using the old interface? If you are really that much of a power user of Office, how have you not learned the keyboard shortcuts, it would make your life about a million times easier.
 
I chuckle at the ribbon haters. Menu's are garbage and always have been.

It was a little rough in 2007 for certain, but in 2010 it is vastly improved. The problem with "Text" menus is at a certain point it becomes a wall of text and unusable to anyone. I have been using word and office since 1997 and frankly every version was complete shit until 2007. Office 2003 was particularly awful, I lump it in with XP in that it was a terrible version that people have become attached too for unknown reasons.

Does the ribbon have room to improve? yep it does. It however is only 2 product generations old where the menu system had honestly hit its limit of capability.

That all said, I only find it useful in office and I think that it is a worthless addition to windows explorer. Like I said the instant search feature renders it almost pointless.
 
Zarathustra[H];1037192812 said:
Bullshit.

Everything is disorganized and difficult to use. Besides, no need for icons. IMHO the icons are a huge negative. They use more screen real estate and are much more difficult to use than a neat, clean and organized column of text, like in a traditional menu. The only reason to use icons is to appeal to those who cant read. Everyone using word should be able to read...

Office 2007 is a fucking train wreck due to the ribbon interface. I haven't used 2010 yet, but I am assuming it's the same.

Many would say the menus in Office 2003 Are a trait wreck and Office 2010 is superb, its selling quite well right now.
 
Back
Top