Randy Pitchford Bemoans Multiplayer Obsession

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Gearbox's head honcho (and all around nice guy) Randy Pitchford explains why we see multiplayer forced into games that shouldn't have it. If you guessed "corporate bean counters" as a reason, give yourself a cookie. :D

Gearbox’s upcoming Duke Nukem Forever, a fast-paced FPS, naturally suits competitive multiplayer, but Pitchford points to the likes of Dead Space 2 as evidence that decisions are often motivated by the desire to tick boxes on a feature list, rather than for the good of the game itself.
 
I'm a disagreeuerment. All games and or should have co-op

i'll edit that for you to MOST games should. I <3 coop, but there are some that i can see it not working right.


that aside he's pretty much on the ball. many of us gamers bemoan how games "used" to be...and rightly so, once the shareholders have you by the nuts its more or less game over... how many of those suits are actually gamers? some i'm sure, but to have the bank to have a say in a companies future, they are most likely previous gen money with kids that play video games.
 
I agree. Co-Op is cool and I'd like to have seen Dead Space games offer some form of it, however, the adding multiplayer to it seemed ridiculous to me. It's time the developer could have spent elsewhere on the game.
 
The problem isn't multiplayer being used in games where it shouldn't be, its devs using multiplayer to be the game and neglecting the single player game. Bad Company 2 for example.
 
I agree. Co-Op is cool and I'd like to have seen Dead Space games offer some form of it, however, the adding multiplayer to it seemed ridiculous to me. It's time the developer could have spent elsewhere on the game.
Same for Bioshock 2.
 
The problem isn't multiplayer being used in games where it shouldn't be, its devs using multiplayer to be the game and neglecting the single player game. Bad Company 2 for example.
+1. I think the trend is to get away from the SP campaign as much as possible to keep the production costs down. That why they have become very short and the stories are weak and uninteresting.
 
In a perfect world, I wish a lot of these games would have a dedicated crew of people for JUST the single player component and then another dedicated crew for any potential MP and/or at least co-op component so neither would come at the expense of the other.
 
Absolutely spot on. Randy's been in the business long enough to know the score. I enjoyed Borderlands, but I only really bought it because I could co-op it with my friends; never played anything but co-op and was very impressed with how it was implemented: rather like popping in a quarter and hammering away with your friends at the arcade, relative to the RPG nature of the game anyway. Gearbox is rebuilding its cred nicely after the whole 007 Nightfire thing.
 
Dynamic gaming is the future, whether through co-op, multiplayer, or incorporation of online data into the single player experience. It's also the only form of DRM that requires nothing on the clients computer, and it works.

If you are not supportive of online functionality, you are of an antiquated mindset, and it's time either to get out, or re-educate.
 
+1. I think the trend is to get away from the SP campaign as much as possible to keep the production costs down. That why they have become very short and the stories are weak and uninteresting.

this++;

I'm so sick of potentially good single player games being truncated to 5 hours so they can feature n^nth multiplayer variations.

I'm not opposed to having a great MP battle, but for crying out loud, enough of making 10% single player and 90% MP games. Co-Op is fine in either category, but I can live with or without it...
 
I'm so sick of potentially good single player games being truncated to 5 hours so they can feature n^nth multiplayer variations.
Oh, like both Modern Warfares? Sorry, not paying basically $12/hour for a game with no replayability that's not only multiplayer. I guess that's why MW2 is still $60 a year and a half later.
 
On the other hand, I haven't bought an Elder Scrolls game since Daggerfall because I can't play it with my friends, not even on a very small scale basic on a home lan.

So yeah, make games that are designed for multiplayer in the first place, and we won't have this problem.
 
I agree with this guy. These days the type of multiplayer I value the most (by far) is co-op. Versus can be fun, but co-op capabilities give a game way more value (i.e. Borderlands, ArmA2, etc.)
 
randy is beating a dead horse we all know some games should not ship with multiplayer... hell some games should not ship with a descent singleplayer yet they do...
 
Dynamic gaming is the future, whether through co-op, multiplayer, or incorporation of online data into the single player experience. It's also the only form of DRM that requires nothing on the clients computer, and it works.

If you are not supportive of online functionality, you are of an antiquated mindset, and it's time either to get out, or re-educate.

Many games just suck for competitive MP play. Many games could work well with some form of co-op. Unfortunately, there are fewer games that have true co-op, than there are SP games that have a half assed attempt at competitive MP tacked on.

Perhaps we are not antiquated, perhaps it is you who is ahead of their time in this matter. ;)
 
Bioshock 2 had shitty multiplayer and shitty single player, it was definitely a forgettable experience.

If there is ANY one game I'd like to see have co-op, it's an Elder Scrolls game.

Doesn't have to be massively multiplayer, just give me one other person to hook up with.
 
Bioshock 2 had shitty multiplayer and shitty single player, it was definitely a forgettable experience.

If there is ANY one game I'd like to see have co-op, it's an Elder Scrolls game.

Doesn't have to be massively multiplayer, just give me one other person to hook up with.

Amen!

I dream of the day I will be able to use my "heal other" spell on anything but stupid NPCs and my horse.
 
If there is ANY one game I'd like to see have co-op, it's an Elder Scrolls game.

Doesn't have to be massively multiplayer, just give me one other person to hook up with.

Sweet jesus yes.
 
On the other hand, I haven't bought an Elder Scrolls game since Daggerfall because I can't play it with my friends, not even on a very small scale basic on a home lan.

So yeah, make games that are designed for multiplayer in the first place, and we won't have this problem.

Well that sucks for you. You missed out on easily the best game of the Elder Scrolls series in Morrowind.
 
Dynamic gaming is the future, whether through co-op, multiplayer, or incorporation of online data into the single player experience. It's also the only form of DRM that requires nothing on the clients computer, and it works.

If you are not supportive of online functionality, you are of an antiquated mindset, and it's time either to get out, or re-educate.

this +++ I couldn't agree more
 
Nah. He didn't miss anyhting. Morrowind was yet another buggy crashy Bioware game that would have been worth playing with cooperative multiplayer.
 
To paraphrase Ken Levine "If you are just making multiplayer to put it as a tic mark on the back of the box why the fuck are you doing it?"

One of these days I need to find the exact quote so I'm not paraphrasing it.
 
Nah. He didn't miss anyhting. Morrowind was yet another buggy crashy Bioware game that would have been worth playing with cooperative multiplayer.

No, consider that a laconic stoic rebuttal
 
Bioshock 2 had shitty multiplayer and shitty single player, it was definitely a forgettable experience.

If there is ANY one game I'd like to see have co-op, it's an Elder Scrolls game.

Doesn't have to be massively multiplayer, just give me one other person to hook up with.

If an Elderscrolls ever had co-op I would cream my jeans. I do remember a project that was being worked on to do just that for oblivion but im not sure what happened to it.
 
Unfortunately Bethseda has said repeatedly that they are not looking to make Elder Scrolls a co-op experience, they want to focus on making the best single player games that they can, which is all fine and good.

Anyone who says Morrowind wasn't a good game is wrong on so many levels it's not even funny.
 
Unfortunately Bethseda has said repeatedly that they are not looking to make Elder Scrolls a co-op experience, they want to focus on making the best single player games that they can, which is all fine and good.

Anyone who says Morrowind wasn't a good game is wrong on so many levels it's not even funny.

I'm really surprised the mod community never created any kind of co-op mod for the games.
 
I'd imagine the logistics would be difficult. It's not so simple as "modding" it as far as a regular mod goes, you have to develop the network scripts and a client/server tool from the ground up, I'd imagine that's an undertaking beyond the reach of most average modders, I'd think it would take a dedicated team to make it happen.
 
I'd imagine the logistics would be difficult. It's not so simple as "modding" it as far as a regular mod goes, you have to develop the network scripts and a client/server tool from the ground up, I'd imagine that's an undertaking beyond the reach of most average modders, I'd think it would take a dedicated team to make it happen.

Kinda like the San Andreas multiplayer mod, right?
 
To paraphrase Ken Levine "If you are just making multiplayer to put it as a tic mark on the back of the box why the fuck are you doing it?"

One of these days I need to find the exact quote so I'm not paraphrasing it.

I think that's the bottom line...I'm not opposed to multiplayer being included in every game, but I hate it when it's just an afterthought. Why not just spend the time to make the single player better instead of making some shitty multiplayer that no one will remember 6 months down the road?

And as for all the games now that require you to log in to some server in order to play the game, regardless of whether it's SP or MP, it depends on the game. If I need to launch Half Life 2 from Steam....OK, fine. But for competitive games, Starcraft 2 for example, there NEEDS to be LAN support.
 
I agree that potentially good games get screwed up by an emphasis on non co-op multiplayer. I'm also irritated that really good maps like the MP maps in Black OPS (not the zombie maps) aren't available for co-op.

I still regularly play UT3 with friends in co-op. It's nice to play against both AI and real people to keep it interesting. At least you get the chance to kill something between fraggings.

Of course if you neglect the single player then I guess there's not enough development for co-op play. I still think Modern Warfare 2 hit it out of the park with the co-op missions. I'd like to see more of that.

:cool:
 
Back
Top