AT&T Going After Unauthorized Tethering

A stock clean desire or nexus one would have that option too.

I know. I waited for the official Froyo release for my phone. When it finally came out about 6 months late, Tethering didn't work without a contract. So I just went custom. I really hate phone companies...
 
Fake edit: I also get HSDPA wireless now. ATT has it enabled in a lot of areas but most phones don't pick it up with stock firmware.
 
I thought that was the whole purpose behind WiFi enabled phones?!

Pretty soon they're gonna start charging for premium content if you download a video that is new.
 
If you don't like getting charged extra for it switch carriers. Go to another carrier that does not charge extra for less bandwidth. If they don't have an iPhone guess what pick another phone! They have a right to charge any idiot any amount that's dumb enough to pay for the product.
 
Yeah,I have Sprint, and just got an Android LG Optimus S. The service requires an additional $10 surcharge because it's a "smartphone". I already had unlimited web/data before, so why is this any different? It is a really cool phone though, upgrading from a flip phone!! :eek:

$40/mo flat rate. LG Optimus V (same thing) on Virgin Mobile. Unlimited text and data and 1200 minutes. Sprint runs Virgin Mobile. Same network, same service.

http://www.phonescoop.com/phones/phone.php?p=2833

http://www.virginmobileusa.com/cell-phones/lg-optimus-v-phone.jsp

There's no reason to be on contract plans anymore. For the same phone and same service, you're paying about $1200 extra over 2 years.

If you're still within your 30 days, you could cancel out if you wanted.
 
If you don't like getting charged extra for it switch carriers. Go to another carrier that does not charge extra for less bandwidth
Maybe it works that way in your country, but not in America.

In the U.S., you switch to a competing network, still get screwed on overpriced phone and data plans, plus you sign a two year contract.

And long before that two year contract is up, Carrier A will go "well carrier B got away with this. We should do it too!".
 
Hello, first time post but I've been lurking for a decade now, lol.

To all the people complaining that data is data and/or I paid for this I should get to use it how I see fit; you all signed a contract and expressly agreed not to use said data anywhere but your phone, plain and simple.

Everyone here has only themselves to blame, and any argument against the matter is moot, because you signed on the dotted line.

We can debate what should or shouldn't be allowed all we want, but when you're arguing do's and don'ts, then you're nothing but a criminal/pirate who's lying to themselves to remove any guilt they might feel by breaking their contract.
 
you all signed a contract and expressly agreed not to use said data anywhere but your phone, plain and simple.

Everyone here has only themselves to blame, and any argument against the matter is moot, because you signed on the dotted line.
Achievement Unlocked: Thread Derailed!
 
Not sure why anyone thinks this is a surprise. Whatever device you were using to connect throughout your iPhone has an IP address. Just like the file sharing people trying to hide their IP 's.....you can't.
 
Achievement Unlocked: Thread Derailed!

How is my post not relevant to the topic at hand?

"AT&T Going After Unauthorized Tethering", unauthorized tethering clause is in everyone's contract, which my post was about. Or perhaps you don't understand the topic of this thread?

Not sure why anyone thinks this is a surprise. Whatever device you were using to connect throughout your iPhone has an IP address. Just like the file sharing people trying to hide their IP 's.....you can't.

What do internal IP's have to do with External IP's? The only one the network see's is the external IP, the internal IP is used for the two devices to communicate to each other.

In any case, I agree with you about it not being a surprise, the only surprise is how long it took them to start cracking down on this.
 
How is my post not relevant to the topic at hand?
Never said it was off-topic.

The bit about "AT&T can write whatever the fuck they want into the contract, even if it grossly unreasonable and unfair to one of the parties" has been proven wrong time and time again on this forum. Unreasonable contract clauses get beat down in court like clockwork.
 
Never said it was off-topic.

The bit about "AT&T can write whatever the fuck they want into the contract, even if it grossly unreasonable and unfair to one of the parties" has been proven wrong time and time again on this forum. Unreasonable contract clauses get beat down in court like clockwork.

Then we have a difference of opinion, as I believe that it's unreasonable for any person to pay for data for their phone and expect to use said data on any device they feel like; in any case I still don't see how that's derailing to this thread.

I will however agree that the prices are flat out highway robbery on damn near every service they offer. Minutes, data and texts are incredibly overpriced and are starting to be cost prohibitive to a lot of users.
 
Maybe it works that way in your country, but not in America.

In the U.S., you switch to a competing network, still get screwed on overpriced phone and data plans, plus you sign a two year contract.

And long before that two year contract is up, Carrier A will go "well carrier B got away with this. We should do it too!".

I'm in the good ol' USA. I pay for the best deal for me. I don't complain that I'm getting robbed then continue to go to the same person I think is robbing me. Each carrier is different if you actually shop around you will see. I can tether with my BB phone without extra cost, I'm with Sprint. If enough people think prices are to high and drop the service they would have no choice but drop the price. But no they just want to complain like a cell phone is a right. It's not ditch it and get a land line if it's too much for you!
 
"AT&T Going After Unauthorized Tethering", unauthorized tethering clause is in everyone's contract, which my post was about. Or perhaps you don't understand the topic of this thread?

The contract I agreed to does not mention in any way, shape, or form the manner in which I am allowed to use my data.

I have never signed or clicked to accept a newer agreement than that one.
 
To a small extent, I can see where AT&T is coming from. On page 1 of this thread, someone mentions one of the thethering users, using the unlimited plan as his main internet connection and transfering 156GB of data in a single month.

Consider that the avg user, subtracting the high bandwidth users is perhaps 1-2GB of data a month. AT&T can potentially use that same 156GB of bandwidth to supply an additional 75-150 customers at $20.00 a month with bandwidth. That's $1500 to $3000 more they could make per month with no network upgrades required at all. Simply by getting rid of the one hog and tell him to buy a fios connection or buy a isp-company name here connection.

It's awful but from a business standpoint it makes sense. If this 156GB of data per month at least paid the tethering fee, they wouldn't be losing as much potential profitability though.
 
To a small extent, I can see where AT&T is coming from. On page 1 of this thread, someone mentions one of the thethering users, using the unlimited plan as his main internet connection and transfering 156GB of data in a single month.

Consider that the avg user, subtracting the high bandwidth users is perhaps 1-2GB of data a month. AT&T can potentially use that same 156GB of bandwidth to supply an additional 75-150 customers at $20.00 a month with bandwidth. That's $1500 to $3000 more they could make per month with no network upgrades required at all. Simply by getting rid of the one hog and tell him to buy a fios connection or buy a isp-company name here connection.

It's awful but from a business standpoint it makes sense. If this 156GB of data per month at least paid the tethering fee, they wouldn't be losing as much potential profitability though.
If I ran AT&T, I'd upgrade my infrastructure ASAP and continue allowing tethering.

Then I could steal customers away from Comcast, Verizon, Qwest, Time Warner, and others. Easy market penetration, and a lot cheaper than having to lay lines.
 
The contract I agreed to does not mention in any way, shape, or form the manner in which I am allowed to use my data.

I have never signed or clicked to accept a newer agreement than that one.

Hahaha. You wish they didn't. I read the first two paragraphs and found this as reasons for them terminating your contract: "or if we have reasonable cause to believe that your Device is being used for an unlawful purpose".

What's that? You downloaded an mp3, torrent or anything you didn't have copyright permission for using your phone or via tethering? You downloaded 156GB of data in one month? I'm sure that there probably wasn't one copyright violation in there at all. :p.

They have the right to terminate your contract 'if they have reasonable cause' and reasonable cause is conveniently not defined.

Of course, they could specifically add to the service agreement at anytime a paragraph explaining how you are allowed to your data. If they do, you automatically agree to the changes as per the paragraph "CHANGES TO TERMS AND RATES" in which it states:

We may change any terms, conditions, rates, fees, expenses, or charges regarding your service at any time
 
If I ran AT&T, I'd upgrade my infrastructure ASAP and continue allowing tethering.

Then I could steal customers away from Comcast, Verizon, Qwest, Time Warner, and others. Easy market penetration, and a lot cheaper than having to lay lines.

Really? You'd choose to invest a few hundred milloin dollars in infrastructure rather than disconnect your top 1% of bandwidth hogs for the same gain in amount of bandwidth? I wonder which one is economically cheaper to do and provides more profitability?
 
Of course, they could specifically add to the service agreement at anytime a paragraph explaining how you are allowed to your data. If they do, you automatically agree to the changes as per the paragraph "CHANGES TO TERMS AND RATES" in which it states:

We may change any terms, conditions, rates, fees, expenses, or charges regarding your service at any time

Which is illegal. It's called bait and switch.

You advertise a rate that comes attached to the contract, they must honor the rate or allow you to nullify the contract without penalty. They must also allow people to KEEP that rate for as long as they opt to continue that contract via renewals. Hence "grandfather clauses."

They advertised it, now they have to honor it.

http://www.theipadguide.com/content...ction-lawsuit-over-ipad-3g-data-plans/7174685
 
Really? You'd choose to invest a few hundred milloin dollars in infrastructure rather than disconnect your top 1% of bandwidth hogs for the same gain in amount of bandwidth? I wonder which one is economically cheaper to do and provides more profitability?
I would not invest a few hundred million, I assure you (and neither would AT&T). I'd just start with the metro areas where they have no presence as an ISP. If it was a success, I'd spread out. If it was a failure, well darn it! Some of my customers are going to have to endure having better service and my stockholders are going to have to take a penny less per share that quarter.
 
I know businesses are just in it for themselves. No surprise there. But AT&T is satan's cellular network. Just sayin'. I've heard the arguments that "It's AT&T's network. You violate the EULA at your own risk!! You agree to their terms when you sign up!!"

Whatever. AT&T is the devil.
 
I'd like to see data and REAL numbers before jumping to conclusions, the common perception seems to be that its a small % of users abusing the majority of the bandwidth?... from a practical sense using your phone as a modem to transfer 150GB a data a month does seem rather abusive. :eek: And your kinda doing it wrong if the phone is your only internet connection for activities like that.. :-/ I would say allow free tethering for 1 - 2 GB and then charge up the wall for anything over that...who really needs to tether crap loads of data on a consistent basis? :confused:
 
Who does this anyway and where are you living that you have such great speeds to make it even bearable or practical?...living in NYC due to the ridiculous network congestion there's no way in hell I think I'm ever gonna see my 3G/HSPA/4G speed go above 1 Mb or anything even remotely close to it on a consistent basis so I don't even bother trying to download more than a webpage or two a month... let em charge the stupid neck beards up the ass for abusing the network. :mad:
 
Who does this anyway and where are you living that you have such great speeds to make it even bearable or practical?...living in NYC due to the ridiculous network congestion there's no way in hell I think I'm ever gonna see my 3G/HSPA/4G speed go above 1 Mb or anything even remotely close to it on a consistent basis so I don't even bother trying to download more than a webpage or two a month... let em charge the stupid neck beards up the ass for abusing the network. :mad:

:rolleyes: Uhuh
 
I'd like to see data and REAL numbers before jumping to conclusions, the common perception seems to be that its a small % of users abusing the majority of the bandwidth?... from a practical sense using your phone as a modem to transfer 150GB a data a month does seem rather abusive. :eek: And your kinda doing it wrong if the phone is your only internet connection for activities like that.. :-/ I would say allow free tethering for 1 - 2 GB and then charge up the wall for anything over that...who really needs to tether crap loads of data on a consistent basis? :confused:

I can agree with this, but it still irks me that they sell something as "unlimited*" with an asterix. It should be illegal to use the term unlimited if that's not what it really means.

Using your cellphone as your only internet service while tethering to a computer and downloading tens if not hundreds of gigs a month is definitely abuse. There must be some way of curbing this behavior without hitting those who use tethering like a temporary tool while on the road in addition to their land-based broadband, not instead of it.

Personally I do have a jailbroken iPhone, and I do tether using it occasionally. It's pretty rare, and I usually only do it when I happen to have my laptop with me and need to do something that is either inconvenient or impossible to do from the iPhone browser. (stranded at airport, waiting for something else, etc.) I also used it once for a road trip to get computer access in the car (not for me, the driver) while driving.

This is what my data usage looks like with tethering included:

5579359623_2cb5b0035f_o.jpg


Even with my rare periodic tethering included my data usage is probably lower than many who don't tether at all, and I do have unlimited data. Why should they care how I use my data? Tethered data is no different than handset data of the same amount.


I feel there should be laws that restrict ISP's and wireless providers to strictly being service providers. They should have no knowledge of or ability to change their service based on how end users use their product. If they don't want people using more than 2 GB a month, only sell a 2GB plan, but they should be prevented from seeing or placing restrictions on HOW end users use that 2GB, on what handset they use it, what features that handset has or does not have, and whether or not they tether.

Wireless providers should be relegated to being just that. Wireless providers, who all they do is provide voice minutes and bandwidth and are agnostic to how it is used and on what it is used.
 
Who does this anyway and where are you living that you have such great speeds to make it even bearable or practical?...living in NYC due to the ridiculous network congestion there's no way in hell I think I'm ever gonna see my 3G/HSPA/4G speed go above 1 Mb or anything even remotely close to it on a consistent basis so I don't even bother trying to download more than a webpage or two a month... let em charge the stupid neck beards up the ass for abusing the network. :mad:

4756513306_6ffc5e7bcf_o.png


AT&T 3G in Boston.

This is faster than I usually test, but most of the time with good reception, I'm getting over a Gbit. The ping is for shit, so you can't play games on it, but the bandwidth is sufficient unless you are into heavy downloading :p

A friend of mine has an HTC Thunderbolt (4G LTE on Verizon) and he tethers with a 55ping, 20+Gbit down and 6+gbit up, almost everywhere...

199697_955650336992_9103289_48833188_2188972_n.jpg



New York is a pretty crappy market for wireless bandwidth because of the congestion of people, but many other places bandwidths are actually usable...
 
So what just happens if you tell them to fuck off? I don't see why you need to pay them for the privilege of using a hardware feature of the phone you bought and paid for, on a network connection you are paying for.
 
So what just happens if you tell them to fuck off? I don't see why you need to pay them for the privilege of using a hardware feature of the phone you bought and paid for, on a network connection you are paying for.

i imagine that would be where an early termination fee comes in or they will just disconnect your service if you refuse to pay the tethering charge they added...
 
Really? You'd choose to invest a few hundred milloin dollars in infrastructure rather than disconnect your top 1% of bandwidth hogs for the same gain in amount of bandwidth? I wonder which one is economically cheaper to do and provides more profitability?

Having given this more thought, there's a fundamental problem with this line of logic. You're expecting short term gains to be more worthwhile than long term profitability.

The problem is that AT&T is trying to treat data as if it were a limited resource, like gas and power. The difference is that when you use more natural gas, the gas company has to buy more natural gas. When you use more electricity, the power company has to put more coal in their furnaces. When you use more bandwidth, unless the network was already at 100% capacity, it costs the ISP nothing and the capacity you would consume would otherwise go to waste. If the network is at 100% capacity then it needs to be expanded whether there is metered billing or not. That is, unless you set the metered rate so high that it will materially suppress usage -- also known as "destroying innovation" -- in which case everyone will get less service for more money since you're now paying extra usage fees but the ISP no longer needs to expand capacity because metered billing is suppressing usage, so all the extra money goes to profit.

Metered billing is the model of perpetual stagnation. It gives the ISP an incentive to never upgrade because the more scarcity there is, the more they can charge for it. Why on Earth would they make a capital investment to alleviate a supply shortfall, the result of which would be lower prices to customers? They certainly have no real competition to make them do it.
 
Zarathustra[H];1037062240 said:
here's mine:

1232270086.png
my modem is over 4 years old is a dociss 2.1 and according to my providers web page no longer supported... And the techs have a really low opinion of them...
 
my modem is over 4 years old is a dociss 2.1 and according to my providers web page no longer supported... And the techs have a really low opinion of them...

Sounds like they're trying to get you to rent a "new" modem from them instead. The provided modem I got with Comcast was already 2 years old when I got it and was more than 6 years old by the time it was decommissioned. It was able to support Dociss 3.0.

That said, Comcast tried to claim that my modem would not work on their system despite already having scheduled an appointment for installation using that modem. I was able to get the Comcast new customer signup page to show when the tech ran the connection to my apartment... but the phone rep said she could not find my modem to activate it for service so I'd have to use one of theirs. I told her that I wanted to cancel and would just have RCN give me the service instead just moments before she "magically" found my modem and whitelisted it.
 
Having given this more thought, there's a fundamental problem with this line of logic. You're expecting short term gains to be more worthwhile than long term profitability.

The problem is that AT&T is trying to treat data as if it were a limited resource, like gas and power. The difference is that when you use more natural gas, the gas company has to buy more natural gas. When you use more electricity, the power company has to put more coal in their furnaces. When you use more bandwidth, unless the network was already at 100% capacity, it costs the ISP nothing and the capacity you would consume would otherwise go to waste. If the network is at 100% capacity then it needs to be expanded whether there is metered billing or not. That is, unless you set the metered rate so high that it will materially suppress usage -- also known as "destroying innovation" -- in which case everyone will get less service for more money since you're now paying extra usage fees but the ISP no longer needs to expand capacity because metered billing is suppressing usage, so all the extra money goes to profit.

Metered billing is the model of perpetual stagnation. It gives the ISP an incentive to never upgrade because the more scarcity there is, the more they can charge for it. Why on Earth would they make a capital investment to alleviate a supply shortfall, the result of which would be lower prices to customers? They certainly have no real competition to make them do it.

This is spot on, and exactly why I say that AT&T is one of the worst, most evil companies we have to deal with that is large enough for everyone to know about. Microsoft, with big money and revenue and cash reserves produced Vista. Whether Vista was bad or not, there was a substantial public outcry against it, and they listened to extensive feedback and complaints from developers to the average layperson. In the face of pressure from consumers, shareholders, and competitors, what did Microsoft do? THEY COMPETED. They worked their butts of to release Windows 7 quickly. In order to make more money and keep their vast majority of market share where they wanted, THEY MADE A BETTER PRODUCT. You know as well as I do that Vista was a necessary step to getting us there, and brought great advancements like more idiot proof security, more 64-bit capabilities, prefetching, and improved plug and play support, among other things. But they made Windows 7, to the best of their ability, to be the product that would sell the best and ultimately make the most customers happy.

In addition, there are customers that want cheaper Windows and Office prices, especially if they're students or own multiple machines, or don't need/want Outlook. So what did MS do? They provided a 3 pack of Office for $100-150, depending on sales prices. They provided disc free copies, which I don't really like, but they're a bit cheaper for folks that are pinching pennies. They sell a Windows 7 Upgrade family pack from time to time. This is an incredible value at $50 a PC, especially when minor upgrades on a few year old machine will make it more than Windows 7 capable. This also gave folks who bought a couple of Vista PCs a bit of a price break when upgrading their machines to the latest OS. Student copies are cheap and easy to get - all you need is a functioning .edu email address.

Do I work for microsoft? No, and they make plenty of blunders here and there that I openly criticize. But compare that to what AT&T does when faced with competition or customer outcry. Overall, Microsoft will compete, improve, and develop.

AT&T just BUYS the damned competition. Why the hell did the government have to step in and actually break them apart back in the day??

AT&T is the devil. I HATE them. I hate them for buying T-Mobile. I hope something happens to stop them. A GSM provider monopoly in the states is BAD BAD BAD for consumers and competition in more ways than I can fathom. The one company that stands to benefit the most from this merger actually is speaking out against it - Sprint. Believe it or not, they will be the go-to for people that see their beloved more budget friendly plans start disappearing. It may take a while for the T-Mobile contracts to finally expire, but when faced with nearly equally priced service from Verizon and AT&T-Mo, the only" budget" national carrier left will be Sprint.

I have actually lost sleep over this, and I even have Verizon. I see VZ's unlimited data disappearing. I see them putting more aggressive caps. I see them possibly following AT&T's example and going after unauthorized tetherers. I see them being less competitive like AT&T. I don't want that to happen. Someday I was hoping to to switch to T-Mobile, just to have the more unlocked and world-friendly GSM android phones, and I was hoping to get good phones like the SGS2 or LG Optimus Black on T-Mobile instead of Verizon's fat, ugly, hot, bulky, and for me unnecessary and still young LTE phones.

I pray that someone or something stops this merger.
 
One thing that bugs me about AT&T is that they are going after 4G/LTE. With AT&T's current infrastructure 4G/LTE is a complete waste. The underlying infrastructure can't even support their 3G/HSPA implementation which supports up to 14mbit and 5.8Mbit up...

Its obvious to me that 3G is not the current bottleneck. Its the bandwidth of the wired infrastructure that connects to the 3G access antennas that is the problem. Upgrading the handsets and the antennas to 4G/LTE won't make squat of difference. It will still perform at the same speed.

It's sort of like upgrading from a Geforce 9800GTX to a Geforce GTX580 when your processor is still a Pentium 3... It's not going to do a whole lot of good... Other than marketing purposes..


Now they can chant "WE HAVE 4G", but it will still be just as slow as their 3G implementation if not slower as the user base continues to grow and taxes the existing infrastructure even more...
 
Back
Top