Man Given $7 Per Track Fine

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I'm not sure how "lucky" it is to be hauled into court over 44 songs but this $7 per track fine is way better than the $1.5M fines we've seen handed out.

In a case that is likely to set guidelines for the punishment of file-sharers in the future, a 26 year-old man from Sweden has escaped his court hearing with little more than a tap on the wrist. After being tracked by the IFPI and accused of making available 44 music tracks on the Internet, the man was taken to court last week. His punishment was a 2000 kronor fine – just $311.
 
That still seems ridiculous considering a CD tops is $15, which contains multiple tracks.
 
That still seems ridiculous considering a CD tops is $15, which contains multiple tracks.

Well the fine should be more than the actual value, providing an incentive to not STEAL.

If they fined people $1 a song, well if you get caught who cares it is a wash.

I think the punishment was pretty fair.
 
There is a reason he was only fined $7 per track.

I am pretty sure Sweden has in a place a penalty system that fines you based off your income.

See this: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-10960230

"Under Swiss law, the level of fine is determined by the wealth of the driver and the speed recorded."

Yes, I understand this is speeding but I believe the law is transparent in both regards.
 
Considering that all music is shite nowadays. .07 cents per song would be more than enough... Oh, wait, .07 cents is the going rate for artists per song sold.. How we gon' fix dat?
 
Wow. That's really reasonable...

However if someone pirated 50,000 songs... Um. Yikes.
 
A much more reasonable fine than what is levied against file sharers in the U.S.

If an under 18, still in school, no job kid of wealthy parents got caught sharing files, would the judgement be based on the kid's income or the parents?
 
Wow. That's really reasonable...

However if someone pirated 50,000 songs... Um. Yikes.

Who has 50,000 songs? That's like 200,000 minutes of music. That's 138 days of music listening. Who has that music time to listen to each track?
 
I have way over 50,000 songs, though I own all of them legally (buy used CDs!).
I agree that $7/track is more in line with what the fine should be.
 
There is a reason he was only fined $7 per track.

I am pretty sure Sweden has in a place a penalty system that fines you based off your income.

See this: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-10960230

"Under Swiss law, the level of fine is determined by the wealth of the driver and the speed recorded."

Yes, I understand this is speeding but I believe the law is transparent in both regards.
Swede != Swiss. You're citing a Swedish driver getting fined in Switzerland.
 
You ever hear of digital hoarding?

You have Steam?

Yea, but only games I intend to play. I haven't bought games that I never played. Well, actually there was a 10 used games for 10 dollars at the game store, and I swear I haven't played any of them. This was for PS2, but I do intend to pick them up and play them.
 
Yea, but only games I intend to play. I haven't bought games that I never played. Well, actually there was a 10 used games for 10 dollars at the game store, and I swear I haven't played any of them. This was for PS2, but I do intend to pick them up and play them.

Even when they have huge savings on huge packs?

This is definitely a reasonable fine. Sad that America is full of corruption now. So full of fail...
 
completely fair fine IMO. (coming from a guy who has rarely ever paid for music)

The song costs $1, so $7 is being avenged sevenfold. Fair to God, fair to me.
 
Seems like people are missing the point. He wasn't punished for downloading songs he was punished for making them available, who knows how many times those were downloaded. If we are speaking of value of "merchandise" and many other users received the pirated items then he may well have gotten off very lightly.
 
Seems like people are missing the point. He wasn't punished for downloading songs he was punished for making them available, who knows how many times those were downloaded. If we are speaking of value of "merchandise" and many other users received the pirated items then he may well have gotten off very lightly.

Then fine the people who downloaded them $3.50 a song?
 
Seems like people are missing the point. He wasn't punished for downloading songs he was punished for making them available, who knows how many times those were downloaded. If we are speaking of value of "merchandise" and many other users received the pirated items then he may well have gotten off very lightly.

Then find out how many copies of the songs he transmitted and punish him based on that. If there is no proof of the number, there should be no case, just like every other area of law except our RIAA lobbyist written bullshit.
 
Who has 50,000 songs? That's like 200,000 minutes of music. That's 138 days of music listening. Who has that music time to listen to each track?

That's not that much. I also know people with more than that. You don't listen to each track. Its called having the whole album as a digital copy. ;)
 
Then find out how many copies of the songs he transmitted and punish him based on that. If there is no proof of the number, there should be no case, just like every other area of law except our RIAA lobbyist written bullshit.

So assuming nobody downloaded the songs there is no wrongdoing here? Even though the original copy may be legal, the fact he made it available for illegal copy/transmission is the case here. At that point it becomes a question of intent, did he intend to make illegal copies available? Apparently this court thinks so.

The question is what did the record company really lose in terms of revenue from this case. That's a question for discussion I'm not saying that it's a legal argument since an argument can be made for punitive damages as well as compensatory.
 
So assuming nobody downloaded the songs there is no wrongdoing here? Even though the original copy may be legal, the fact he made it available for illegal copy/transmission is the case here. At that point it becomes a question of intent, did he intend to make illegal copies available? Apparently this court thinks so.

The question is what did the record company really lose in terms of revenue from this case. That's a question for discussion I'm not saying that it's a legal argument since an argument can be made for punitive damages as well as compensatory.

In other areas of law damages are only awarded when they are actually suffered. Try to steal a crate of CDs from Walmart and get caught, and they cannot sue you civilly for conversion damages because cause none were incurred. Instead, the criminal law system handles the "attempt" crime.

The entire underlying foundation of US statutory damages being as high as they are is that each file is downloaded from the uploader thousands of times, and then in turn thousands more times from the new downloaders. Without this assumption, the ratio of statutory to actual damages would be unconstitutional. Yet this assumption removes from the plaintiff all burden of proving the damages element of his case, and in effect makes the defendant guilty until proven innocent on damages. Yet he cannot even prove himself innocent, because even if his torrent ratio showed he only uploaded half a song, the law provides for automatic damages based on the assumption that thousands of copies were uploaded.
 
its not just 2000sek. the source says plus lawyer fees too. as far as i know, that's not going to be cheap at all.
 
Seven times the retail value is more than fair. Imagine getting a $140,000 fine for stealing an actual $20,000 car, that isn't even digital and you've deprived the owner of the ability to use it. That would never happen in a court, but just for some perspective...
 
I think the courts are maturing but it is a slow process and the US is behind in that regard.
 
I think the fine instituates a monitoring system for the accused after court as he was probably a potential in the file sharing network of waking systems already put to rest by courts ?
 
$7 a pop is what I consider a fair fine. It is still 700% more than retail price of the approx $1 per song.If I were on the jury I would feel comfortable passing that kind of a punishment. Unlike here in the US I would have to ask to be dismissed from the case cause I couldn't in good conscience award any penalty larger than about $10-$15/song.
 
Sigh. Nobody ever seems to understand that it has nothing to do with downloading. It would be "wash" at 1$ per song if that was actually the "crime". The "crime" isn't downloading, as that would be nearly impossible to prove intent. What if he already had all those songs on CD and he didn't know how to RIP them himself? Is that a "crime" -- no (at least not in the US -- maybe it is over there). He was sued because he was SHARING the music with people on the internet. A "wash" at 7$ means only 7 people downloaded each track, which is probably UNDER the amount of uploading that actually took place. While the fines in the US are exorbitant, I think it should stop being a case of a "per" song vanilla fine. Did you share or not share music, if so, what kind of totals are we talking about. Do we know how many people actually downloaded it?

Don't be an idiot, don't "SHARE" your music. If you download it illegally, don't share it, not that downloading illegally is OK, it isn't. You're just not going to get sued for that unless they are absolutely sure you don't already own the music.
 
completely fair fine IMO. (coming from a guy who has rarely ever paid for music)

The song costs $1, so $7 is being avenged sevenfold. Fair to God, fair to me.

And the Avenged Sevenfold songs he downloaded? $49 a track.
 
Sigh. Nobody ever seems to understand that it has nothing to do with downloading. It would be "wash" at 1$ per song if that was actually the "crime". The "crime" isn't downloading, as that would be nearly impossible to prove intent. What if he already had all those songs on CD and he didn't know how to RIP them himself? Is that a "crime" -- no (at least not in the US -- maybe it is over there). He was sued because he was SHARING the music with people on the internet. A "wash" at 7$ means only 7 people downloaded each track, which is probably UNDER the amount of uploading that actually took place. While the fines in the US are exorbitant, I think it should stop being a case of a "per" song vanilla fine. Did you share or not share music, if so, what kind of totals are we talking about. Do we know how many people actually downloaded it?

Don't be an idiot, don't "SHARE" your music. If you download it illegally, don't share it, not that downloading illegally is OK, it isn't. You're just not going to get sued for that unless they are absolutely sure you don't already own the music.

It's not illegal to download it if you already own it over here.
Allthough, We are not allowed to play music in hair saloons, cause they have to pay royalties to play the music to a larger audience than the one person.
oookey ?
But radio works... riiight, But however, schools seems to be allowed to download as they will, to show students.......

Don't ask me... I just use spotify and am happy with that.
 
Back
Top