How IT Pros Cheat on Certification Exams

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
IT professionals cheating on exams? Is this really some new phenomenon or are we just now talking about it? I'm not even sure I buy into the notion that the bad economy turns honest IT folks into cheaters. Thanks to Bob Brown for the link.

Incidents of cheating on IT certifications are on the rise, a trend that experts say is an outward sign of the desperation felt by out-of-work and under-employed IT professionals.
 
Last edited:
Considering the quality of people that I have interviewed in the past who had a resume full of these certifications, this news is hardly surprising.
 
The issue is really standardized testing in general. It is a system of convenience, not effectiveness. They aren't the most effective way to judge ability, but there is no real practical alternative when you need to screen a large amount of people.
 
Considering the quality of people that I have interviewed in the past who had a resume full of these certifications, this news is hardly surprising.

I used to work IT for a very very large casino group in Las Vegas. Either I was extremely overqualified, or the quality of IT-workers is saddening.

Sometimes it'd be so bad, that my co-worker and I would screw with the newbies they kept sending us ("Yeah, it's probably the flux capacitor, the ones we get from DELL are horrible!"). Quite fun, actually ;)
 
The idiots who cheat on it probably spent more time, effort, and money cheating than just preparing for the test. I studied for my certifications just a few days beforehand and passed no problem.
 
I made some mistakes on my exams but they were just stupid mistakes because I was going so fast, not that I didn't know the material. I had more than a decade of field experience before I went to school so by the time I took all my exams they were pretty easy.

After one of my exams I walked out of the testing booth and the girl at the desk said "what's wrong?" and I said, "well, I'm finished" ...I think it took me ten minutes.
 
The issue is really standardized testing in general. It is a system of convenience, not effectiveness. They aren't the most effective way to judge ability, but there is no real practical alternative when you need to screen a large amount of people.

Whats really the problem is that business are to fucking lazy to properly interview or review candidates. Instead of hiring based on experience, ability, and character they let a computer parse through keywords to pick out potential people. You don't need these certification to know what you are doing, but you do need them just to get in door for interview. Half of the time you get interviewed by some dolt that doesn't even know what the certification means and they assume that because you have it you must know what you are doing.
 
Certifications are absolutely useless in my opinion. I'm terrible at studying for certification tests and I do mediocre if I tried. Then some booksmart "genius" who probably scored anywhere from 95% to 100% goes around gloating how "good" he is at IT compared to the rest of us. When you ask those "geniuses" the simplest problem which you can expect to solve on the spot goes running to find a book to solve the problem. Like the above, sometimes there are absurd questions you make up and they don't apply common sense.

CompTIA I've took in the past and I would fail some of the questions because they're still using outdated technology (Yes can't hurt to know them) that I haven't worked with in more than a decade going "Fuck this shit". Come on, I've seen questions like "What is EGA?" and I'm going "Uhh what? I only know VGA, SVGA, DVI, HDMI, Displayport." Because of Google, it is the #1 solution, not some certification test where you have to study bullshit stuff you will never use.

The best question all IT professionals should be using "If all else fails and you can't figure out a problem, what do you do?" GOOGLE IT.
 
Braindumps have been around since at least the MCSE NT4 days. So this isn't really something new.

What is somewhat alarming is the source of the test questions. One of my instructors gave us the insight on the guidelines for MS testing. Anything in their technet documentation for the product is fair game. What you end up with is question writers with no practical knowledge of the product creating questions with cryptic command line scenarios.
 
Certifications are not *completely* useless. Some of them have actual merit.

However, they should never be accepted as a good measure of skill.

We're all MSPD here because we get MS Gold for it, saving us all money on MSDN subscriptions.
 
Braindumps have been around since at least the MCSE NT4 days. So this isn't really something new.

What is somewhat alarming is the source of the test questions. One of my instructors gave us the insight on the guidelines for MS testing. Anything in their technet documentation for the product is fair game. What you end up with is question writers with no practical knowledge of the product creating questions with cryptic command line scenarios.

What gets me about it is there are at least ten different ways to do the same thing...and depending on items as simple as right clicking network > properties instead of clicking control panel > Network and sharing will fail an exam question.

I truly think certification exams are only indicators that someone is trying to find a job...nothing to do with reality of knowlege and determiing how good the person will actually be when you hire them.

I'll hire someone with two certs and 5 years experience over a person with full certs and 1 year of experience any day of the week.
 
allot of good points here, back in the day, allot of companies never questioned to see your certifications
 
The phenomenon extends to a point to CS degrees in colleges and universities. In majors focused on theory like CS, it is actually possible to finish with a high GPA while doing a minimum amount of programming (or by copying your friends' homework) in many places.

I sometimes perform technical interviews for lower paid, bottom of the barrel programming positions that don't really have an experience requirement but do have a degree requirement. I don't expect much, but a significant percentage of the applicants that actually get to the interview can't write a "Hello World" program in their favorite language.

There are many jobs out there where you can go through the interview by impressing HR interviewers, get hired, then learn what you need to know on the job. Unfortunately, programming positions aren't one of them.
 
As an IT Professional and someone who is in charge of hiring, I can honestly say that all my years of experience have proven almost all the certifications completely worthless anyhow. Honestly anyone who touts them as an accomplishment is likely lacking the actual experience anyone should care about.

That said, If you have to cheat on any of those then you aren't an IT professional. You are just another one of the many crappy wannabe IT people out there giving the rest of us a bad rap because you chose the wrong career. Today was a fantastic example of this. Our office had one of the Ricoh printers go offline. After a bit of troubleshooting I narrowed it down to the nic card on the printer. The Ricoh tech gets out there (Bear in mind I am not a printer guy) and knows less about the printer than I do. He didn't even know the nic card in it could be replaced. :eek: Really? You can imagine the phone call to dispatch and how it went from me.
 
Certifications are on the same level as a college degree. Its just a goddamn piece of paper till you can prove you know anything.

Its a foot in the door, but if you're stupid, that will shine more than your paper will.

With that said, I'll be taking Server + in a few weeks (requirement for Lenovo server work) and going back to my MS studies.

I've never been a traditional learner. I'm probably like most here, just learn it on the fly, and then absorb that + book work = skill. If you're just reading your certification test from paper, you aren't going to retain anything past 2 weeks out from passing the test.
 
I need to past tests to fill vendor quotas. Not to show off my skills. So yeah, for a lot of tests I need to pass spending the time to actual know the material(as opposed to knowing the test) isn't cost or time well spent.

All that said, if I'm interviewing for a job I'm telling the hiring manager straight up which certs do not represent my knowledge.
 
There's nothing wrong with studying a "brain dump" -- of course, if this is your ONLY material, you're doing yourself a disservice. This is a problem with canned tests in general. They wish to keep the specific testing material a secret unless you $$ pay for the specific training. They exist to collect $$.
 
Whats really the problem is that business are to fucking lazy to properly interview or review candidates. Instead of hiring based on experience, ability, and character they let a computer parse through keywords to pick out potential people. You don't need these certification to know what you are doing, but you do need them just to get in door for interview. Half of the time you get interviewed by some dolt that doesn't even know what the certification means and they assume that because you have it you must know what you are doing.

This this this this. So goddamn prevalent in corporate culture it's sad.
 
Whats really the problem is that business are to fucking lazy to properly interview or review candidates. Instead of hiring based on experience, ability, and character they let a computer parse through keywords to pick out potential people. You don't need these certification to know what you are doing, but you do need them just to get in door for interview. Half of the time you get interviewed by some dolt that doesn't even know what the certification means and they assume that because you have it you must know what you are doing.

AMEN brother!

The reliance on certifications to "thin the herd" is a crutch for unqualifed managers to lean on. The proof is in the high turnover of IT jobs and stalled IT projects.

The whole certification system is a self sustaining cash cow designed not to test your abilities but rather to test your test taking skills. I don't care who or what it's for; a certification process that doesn't demand formal training is nothing but a money mill.

Further, that training has to be accessible which is something Cisco for one isn't very good at when you get above entry level certifications. It also has to be affordable; hundreds of dollars to take a test is just plain graft (look it up)

I'm sick of this "hit the ground running" BS I hear in interviews as well. Here's a tip, if you hear that RUN do not WALK out the door, it's a sweat shop and you're interviewing to be the newest scapegoat.

Everyone wants a guarantee (aka: certification) just so they can cover their own ass when things go wrong. They leave the determination of competence to a commercialized testing process.

So my profound hope is that cheating becomes so widespread that it forces a redesign of the whole certification process. Right now It's all about the corporate logos, not the cert candidate. You test auto parts and PC's not people.

:cool:
 
I would have to say some exams are better than others. Microsoft MCP / MCSE exams are somewhat a joke. I can't say that much material that was on the test was used in day to day management of networks. Much of the overall theory was, but not much of the nuts and bolts on the tests. (I have over 10 years network/system administration). Now hands on tests like Cisco seem to be a better indicator of ones capabilities.

I always revert back to the late 90's when I was taking a summer course at a community college, and I heard a couple guys walking down the stairs.. How do you think you did on your MCSE? Oh I think I did ok, I think my mom did too, but she is a little slow at test taking.. Now.. I am not saying that she was or was not qualified after taking a class at community college, and passing some MCSE tests. The issue is that passing those tests gives you just about zero 'real world' experience in managing servers. Shoot you don't even have to setup a server to pass the exam.. I have seen guys hired w/ MCSE's who were asked to build up a supermicro box and add windows 2003 server on it.. And they could not get the scsi drivers installed to save their life...

Fortunately for me, my experience speaks more than my certifications, and I actually don't try to focus on those at all in interviews. I would rather focus on my accomplishments.
 
the fact there is a term for stolen tests, other than "stolen tests" shows how bad the cheating really is.

That said, when I took my GRE I would have loved to have a braindump :D God damn standardized test scam given by one company such bullshit.
 
Fortunately for me, my experience speaks more than my certifications, and I actually don't try to focus on those at all in interviews. I would rather focus on my accomplishments.

Yes,it is fortunate for you. Unfortunately lazy HR types and moron managers aren't hearing anything but the letters behind your name. It's been like that for most of the almost 20 years I've been in the business.

:cool:
 
I failed the second test for comptia A+ exam. It had a bunch of useless questions at the end which were hypothetical situations. A lot of the questions are trash. Nothing that anyone would use in the field. I know i have a lot of experience in computers and electronics. There are people that pass this test that know nothing at all or very little. It all has to do with getting the right book which has all the questions that are going to be asked on test. Schools these days prepare you for the tests, not the real world. Not much we can do. Schools teach you to remember rather than learn/seek. Books in IT field get outdated quick. I remember taking cisco certification. A guy was doing a network administrator for decades for the county. He even had a hard time with some of the tests. The tests just don't teach real world things mostly. Some things just can't really be tested. Talents/abilities can't be really tested by anything. I know some people with bachelor degrees that know barely anything. Like a interviewer can ask you questions but why even ask. Just pull a computer up to him/her and tell him or her to do this or that. Thats the best way. The fastest or best wins. The paper just says you took the classes doesn't mean you actually learned anything. Some people learn a lot but a lot of those people have learned the information on their own time. Nothing is going to be done about it most likely. :)
 
Certs are just one part of being an effective/successful IT professional. Mostly they are just about making money for the company that is providing the tests.

I get certs because they look good on a resume and it helps keep me current on technologies that I wouldn't otherwise be using at work.

I've taken around 30 exams in the last decade and can understand why dumps have always been popular though. Some tests I have taken were simply horrible. Improbable/unrealistic scenarios, crummy grammar/translation, massive amounts of typos, "tricky" questions that focus on minutia rather than subject comprehension, etc, etc...

As long as their are tests... their will be dumps for them...

I remember when CompTIA and MS went through that whole "adaptive testing" crap initially in the early 2000s... nothing today is any different than a decade ago.
 
What gets me about it is there are at least ten different ways to do the same thing...and depending on items as simple as right clicking network > properties instead of clicking control panel > Network and sharing will fail an exam question.

This is completely untrue. Even temp agency exams are sophisticated enough to allow for you to complete questions in the manner you described.

OTOH, this article seemed to me to be more about trying to steer you toward buying the provider's "licensed" study materials than about cheating.
 
VMware finds a way around this. Cheat all you want, buy all the dumps you want, taking the class is still a pre-req. If you pass the test without taking the class they don't give you the cert.


$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
 
VMware finds a way around this. Cheat all you want, buy all the dumps you want, taking the class is still a pre-req. If you pass the test without taking the class they don't give you the cert.


$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Last I checked those classes were like $4k also. A MS test = $125, if you know the crap, you don't need study materials more than a $50 book. If you can't invest $175 in yourself, then why bother with college, where you walk away 20-40-100k in debt before you have any type of income.

90% of what I know I learned on the job, 8% of what I know I was told by someone else (taught) and 2% of what I know, I gained from books. Experience > All. You can't recreate every, most, even a fraction of the scenarios you are going to experience on the job through a testing lab. Because the lab always eliminates the one thing you always have on the job. People skills, the guy pissed his shit don't work breathing down your ass, thats not covered in your manual.

I have mine, I'm glad I worked hard to get them, and I am tuned up to get more. But they aren't my shield, they're my vow to the customer, that I can at least backup my bullshit :D
 
There's nothing wrong with studying a "brain dump" -- of course, if this is your ONLY material, you're doing yourself a disservice.

Agreed. I use brain dumps as a type of pre-test to see if I actually know what I am expected to know for the test. A good example is when I was studying for the BSCI. The version of materials I had did not have very much IPv6 on it at all. Luckily, the brain dump had a TON of it. This caused me to find out I had an old rev of the book and to obtain a new one. Lots of multicast was added as well. Saved me from failing an exam simply because I was unaware the exam had changed.
 
Really, only IT admins in the biz for 3+ years should be talking here.

As 2005 grad starting in IT, I was never able to even enter the field as all the slack IT guys were taking the lowest totem pole job. I could have gotten a $8-12 call center job, but that would have left me in debt still anyways so I ended up making the most on my own.

IT is dead and I have easily applied to 40+ jobs that I actually fit into with my lack of exp (believe me, most IT jobs I rarely can fit into with no professional exp), and now with outsourcing I have given up on anything IT.... employers care more about saving a buck and getting COMPLETE SHIT CUSTOMER SERVICE WITH IT guys in India, then actually hiring a helpful, cheap American IT intern that can actually get the job done right....

I saw a documentary on outsourcing... they fired ONE GUY in American Dell call centers because Dell was "spending too much" --- guess what happen? To take that EXACT JOB over in India, they hired more than 15 people in India to replace just ONE persons salary in America. No joke, no bs.

That is why there are no IT jobs, hands down..... and believe me I know and i have paid (big time) for knowing this information :(
 
I used to work IT for a very very large casino group in Las Vegas. Either I was extremely overqualified, or the quality of IT-workers is saddening.

Sometimes it'd be so bad, that my co-worker and I would screw with the newbies they kept sending us ("Yeah, it's probably the flux capacitor, the ones we get from DELL are horrible!"). Quite fun, actually ;)

Sounds about right, I definitely used to know people who would fall for that.
 
That is why there are no IT jobs, hands down..... and believe me I know and i have paid (big time) for knowing this information

Right. For the record I've switched jobs 3 times in the last 3 years. Each time my job search lasted less than a week. If I wanted to switch jobs right now I have a line of companies recruiting me.

Start going to conferences and talk to people. Network, make yourself known in your area. Things like meetup.com is a good way to do this. Research and read on your own time so you have something to talk about. Get in touch with recruiters. Recruiters are fucking leaches, but they have that network of contacts you don't. They can get you an interview.

IT isn't like accounting, it's not all about college and courses.
 
That is why there are no IT jobs, hands down..... and believe me I know and i have paid (big time) for knowing this information :(

Been in the IT biz for about 4 years now, and I don't know where you have been looking for jobs, but where I am I've never had an issue finding work for good money. In fact in my opinion IT, at least for experienced, competent technitians, is on an upswing.
 
IN my experience most employers are not tking these certs as seriously anymore. I have a 2year associates degree in network admin and a 4 year degree in management of IT and no certs and I got hired over all the people with the certs and more experience.

Now my 2 year degree helped a lot because my tcp/ip teacher was in his 80's and was very very knowledgeable in the subject(was a big wig for tech in china in the 80;'s then came here and was a big wig tech guy in our government then worked for IT at grumman). The college i went to made sure that all the course teacher s knew their subject material and actually worked in the field.

In my experience i learned more going the college route then I did just certs. The college route taught me more then PC stuff. It taught me how IT fits into a business as a whole and how to be a business manager besides an IT guy.
 
Passing an exam does not mean much, especially when it comes to IT however, they are supposed to be challenging so they include a ton of bullshit you will never need to know as material. If they just included the stuff everyone knew already, then everyone would be certified.
 
Back
Top