Viacom Blocks Google TV

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Viacom has joined the other major networks that are currently blocking Google TV. How pissed would you be if you bought a Google TV device only to have all the content you want to watch end up being blocked?

Comedy Central, MTV, VH1, and Nickelodeon are just a few of the Viacom owned networks that bring up the dreaded “sorry, this content is unavailable for your device” when attempting to stream a full episode from their websites.
 
The satellite board I visit already has people crying about this thing. I will never understand why people buy things with flaws and then complain about it. If I've learned anything, it is this... If you buy the first version of a product, be willing to accept it's flaws.

On the upside, Google will work out deals and the functionality will come. In a couple of years, when I buy a new TV, I will probably get one with it built in.
 
It isn't about a flawed product, just an identifiable product with a big, exploitable name. TV companies are trying to kill it before it becomes popular and they lose ad revenue, whereas HTPCs are a niche techie thing.

I have a Logitech Revue (googleTV device). Its mostly used for Netflix, some Youtube. Never tried to watch a normal TV show on it besides .
 
It isn't about a flawed product, just an identifiable product with a big, exploitable name. TV companies are trying to kill it before it becomes popular and they lose ad revenue, whereas HTPCs are a niche techie thing.

I have a Logitech Revue (googleTV device). Its mostly used for Netflix, some Youtube. Never tried to watch a normal TV show on it besides .

Why didn't you just get a Blu-ray player then? Most of them does Netflix and YouTube streaming these days.
 
NEWFLASH: Content providers do not want you to consume their content. Even if they publish the content for display on the web, they don't want you to see it. As far as they're concerned, it's $40/season for every show you watch or nothing.

Bullshit like this justifies piracy. It is hard to imagine a victim less deserving of sympathy.
 
Google could fix this instantly.

Just insert a fake browser identification string. Something like this :p

Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 7.0; Windows NT 5.1)

Nothing like telling the web server you are IE7 running on Windows XP :p
 
NEWFLASH: Content providers do not want you to consume their content. Even if they publish the content for display on the web, they don't want you to see it. As far as they're concerned, it's $40/season for every show you watch or nothing.

Bullshit like this justifies piracy. It is hard to imagine a victim less deserving of sympathy.

I sympathise completely with this line of thought.

Once you put it out there, it should be up to the users how to use it. Limiting and restricting use just ticks people off.

Viewing stuff like this on your TV over the web is going to be mainstream in the future whether they like it or not.
 
i don't understand why... is google TV stripping the streaming ads somehow?

for some reason i'm thinking the networks are just seeing $$$ when they see the name "Google"
 
Zarathustra[H];1036464771 said:
Google could fix this instantly.

Just insert a fake browser identification string. Something like this :p

Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 7.0; Windows NT 5.1)

Nothing like telling the web server you are IE7 running on Windows XP :p

Won't do anything, because everyone is now checking flash id. They all got wise to that weeks ago.
 
NEWFLASH: Content providers do not want you to consume their content. Even if they publish the content for display on the web, they don't want you to see it. As far as they're concerned, it's $40/season for every show you watch or nothing.

Bullshit like this justifies piracy. It is hard to imagine a victim less deserving of sympathy.

This has nothing to do with piracy or not wanting you to consume their content. They just don't want you using it as your primary viewing source and cutting out the cable and satellite companies who pay the networks a LOT of money to broadcast their content.

If Google TV and services like it catch on, you'll see households all accross Amercia droping their cable service in favor of 'free' internet TV which, in turn, will drasticlly cut the networks revenue. I somehow doubt that the Ad revenue generated by streaming shows online is a drop in the bucket compared to what they generate from primetime TV ad's.

For this to legitimatly catch on, they'll need to increase the amount and frequency of Ad's (assuming it doesn't violate any existing contracts that they have with other networks and/or service providers) on their streaming content and possibly some sort of subscription, depending on how many customers they lose from traditional cable companies. This isn't about 'screwing the consumer', they're just looking out of their best interests while still throwing their viewers a bone (being able to watch shows online)
 
Google should ban any searching or redirecting from their site and affiliates, to anything Viacom.
 
Google should just introduce a site specific user agent patch.

Unless they are compiling their own version of flash I cant see Google being able to do anything, unless they convince Adobe to allow id modifications on the fly.
 
Won't do anything, because everyone is now checking flash id. They all got wise to that weeks ago.

Ahh, well they should be able to tweak this so it looks like one of thoe most common computer configurations out there as well :p

If it comes to a competition between Google and the TV content providers in finding crafty workarounds, my money is going to be on Google every time.

That is, until the content providers bring in the lawyers. Noone is better at misusing the civil courts than large studios.
 
HTPC, avoid all of that crap, plus I can stip out the ads entirely with software.
 
Unless they are compiling their own version of flash I cant see Google being able to do anything, unless they convince Adobe to allow id modifications on the fly.

They could probably run some kind of virtual layer between Adobe's flash plugin and the shared content, passinng on all instruction, except the ID string.
 
Zarathustra[H];1036465022 said:
They could probably run some kind of virtual layer between Adobe's flash plugin and the shared content, passinng on all instruction, except the ID string.

Yep, Greasemonkey plugin for Firefox is an example of such layer.
 
So I just looked up google TV, and it seems like some way of watching the internet on your TV. I currently have my PC hooked to my TV, so this isn't new to me.

What does google TV allow me to watch that I couldn't do anyway with my cable or internet?
 
So I just looked up google TV, and it seems like some way of watching the internet on your TV. I currently have my PC hooked to my TV, so this isn't new to me.

What does google TV allow me to watch that I couldn't do anyway with my cable or internet?

As with HD Homerun and Boxee and AppleTV and other pre-built media center devices, this was basically built for those who don't know that computers can also be a media center, especially on your television.
 
If it's streaming off their servers, you're still watching the ads right?

Anyways, I have noticed this that companies want to keep watching TV on your computer and watching TV on your TV separate for some reason. It all started when Netflix/Hulu started streaming. You can't stream to your TV enabled device but you can to your tiny monitor!
 
Shouldn't the FTC or BBB get involved? Aren't these anti-competitive business practices. It's like a city prohibiting FedEx and UPS truck from using it's road while letting DHL use them. That doesn't seem legal.
 
These cable providers fear innovation and competition. and whether that new innovation is legitimate or not, they will do everything in their power to prevent it from catching on. They seek to maintain the status quo.
 
These cable providers fear innovation and competition. and whether that new innovation is legitimate or not, they will do everything in their power to prevent it from catching on. They seek to maintain the status quo.

This isn't about the cable providers, it's the actual network that's blocking it (viacom)
 
If it's streaming off their servers, you're still watching the ads right?

As I understand it its not just streaming the channel over the web. It's essentially an interface that streams specific episodes, as if they were on demand directly on your TV.

Apparently they make less on the online ads than the traditional ones on TV, and as such they want to keep the masses from using it, limiting it to only a few people who stream on their computers....

They will fail in the long run. It may take a while, but they will.

When a technology is more convenient to people it usually wins out long term.
 
Ok posting this from my Revue. Daily SHow (Viacom) open in another tab. It says "sorry this isnt supported by your device."

Change the useragent to something other than the default, reboot the revue, and it works.

Side note, figured out how to enable double-tap mouse clicks on this thing like most laptops have nowadays. You have to do a shift+control+FN+Pageup to enable it. Yeah wtf. Whatever, once you do that it works fine.
 
NEWFLASH: Content providers do not want you to consume their content. Even if they publish the content for display on the web, they don't want you to see it. As far as they're concerned, it's $40/season for every show you watch or nothing.

Bullshit like this justifies piracy. It is hard to imagine a victim less deserving of sympathy.

1st off.... Viacom should easily be able to be sued because of this.... no? If I had google TV and they blocked it I would certainly get free service, or a free disconnection of service w/o penalty. That's just BS again from Viacrap.

2nd..... Content providers DO want you to watch their stuff. I was talking to comcast last week and the chat rep asked, in between questions, if I would use fancast for watching TV shows. It was kind of odd. Why would comcast want me to use their bandwidth up and not Hulu's, for example?
 
Ok posting this from my Revue. Daily SHow (Viacom) open in another tab. It says "sorry this isnt supported by your device."

Change the useragent to something other than the default, reboot the revue, and it works.

Side note, figured out how to enable double-tap mouse clicks on this thing like most laptops have nowadays. You have to do a shift+control+FN+Pageup to enable it. Yeah wtf. Whatever, once you do that it works fine.

Ah swweeettt.... they are too stupid to catch the easy workarounds as usual.

smart man!
 
1st off.... Viacom should easily be able to be sued because of this.... no? If I had google TV and they blocked it I would certainly get free service, or a free disconnection of service w/o penalty. That's just BS again from Viacrap.

2nd..... Content providers DO want you to watch their stuff. I was talking to comcast last week and the chat rep asked, in between questions, if I would use fancast for watching TV shows. It was kind of odd. Why would comcast want me to use their bandwidth up and not Hulu's, for example?

Google does not host content. Viacom does. It's Viacom's content, and it's therefore their rules. Watching CSI or whatever is not a privilege, but a right. If you don't agree with the terms, go elsewhere.

And the industry, as a whole, knows that streaming is the future. There's too much money in the middle (broadcast companies, for example: Rogers Canada losing 20% of their cable subscribers last year, over year) to turn a blind eye until some sort of consensus is developed on a proper streaming model. Current ones simply don't generate the revenue that television did... Revenue that supports the quality of programming you are all used to...
 
So I just looked up google TV, and it seems like some way of watching the internet on your TV. I currently have my PC hooked to my TV, so this isn't new to me.

What does google TV allow me to watch that I couldn't do anyway with my cable or internet?

Nothing at all really. Infact, your PC hooked up to your tv can do more such as play ___insert game here that requires a DX9, 10, or 11 video card____ or open documents using Microsoft Office on your pc, or run utorrent, etc etc.

The difference really is that googletv costs: ???? - It's nearly impossible to tell since its built into the cost of a tv such as a Sony HDTV starting at $599.99 and going upwards or for $399.99 built into a blu-ray player. It's hard to distinguish how much of that cost is related to your blu-ray player cost and how much of it is related to the hdtv cost. It's probably built into the price to the tune of around $150.00 - $200.00.

Ideally, your HTPC costs more than $150.00 - $200.00 if you've gotten a decent video card and you've gotten a decent cpu/psu/case/cable-card reader or capture card. So really, its a cheaper HTPC that's not as fully-featured as a PC hooked up to your home theatre system, such as being unable to play games, but...hey...it's cheap and its got a semi-cool looking user-interface. GoogleTV might make for a far less invasive HTPC for the bedroom for example where your wife won't let you put a full-sized pc without 3 week of manditory sleeping on the touch time.
 
Let's ban the sale of any radio that allows recording to a cassette tape as well. Cause no one will ever listen to radio anymore...
 
The networks are bleeding blood and sharks like Google, Hulu and Netflix are circling. If you could find an unbiased upper-management employee to share his opinion of one of these networks, they would probably say how stupid this kind of move is, which is just trying to delay the inevitable instead of embracing it.

Plus, it's bad PR for them, NOT Google. The devices can obviously do it, even common people know it's not Google's fault, which means they place the blame elsewhere...with the cable provider and the networks!

On a separate note, ad income is such a waste of time. I hate advertising to begin with. Any of it. I prefer to do my own research after hearing about a product, but it is *never* from television that I hear about said products, always word of month or the internet. Maybe if these big networks trimmed up a little and dropped all their dead weight, they would make more profits. That's also coming, sooner or later they will understand....
 
Ah swweeettt.... they are too stupid to catch the easy workarounds as usual.

smart man!

They will catch on quick and start doing things like checking flash platform.

While these broadcasting corps. aren't necessarily the smartest fish in the pond, they aren't stupid either.
 
Google does not host content. Viacom does. It's Viacom's content, and it's therefore their rules. Watching CSI or whatever is not a privilege, but a right. If you don't agree with the terms, go elsewhere.

And the industry, as a whole, knows that streaming is the future. There's too much money in the middle (broadcast companies, for example: Rogers Canada losing 20% of their cable subscribers last year, over year) to turn a blind eye until some sort of consensus is developed on a proper streaming model. Current ones simply don't generate the revenue that television did... Revenue that supports the quality of programming you are all used to...

At issue here is that television stations have offered this content online to their viewers, not making it explicitly known that they are only offering it to SOME viewers using CERTAIN hardware.

Then when people go out and buy hardware with watching the content in mind, they turn around and block it, within a short period of time. No matter how you look at this, they are screwing people over.

Sure, there may be some stupid fine print disclaimer that users have to accept that says something like "this service is provided at the sole discretion of the content owner, and may be revoked or modified at any time", but that still doesn't mean that it is right.

Shame on you media companies.
 
On a separate note, ad income is such a waste of time. I hate advertising to begin with. Any of it. I prefer to do my own research after hearing about a product, but it is *never* from television that I hear about said products, always word of month or the internet. Maybe if these big networks trimmed up a little and dropped all their dead weight, they would make more profits. That's also coming, sooner or later they will understand....

Why do you think marketing executives everywhere get all cagey as soon as you ask them to prove their return on investment in advertising?

They know it's all smoke and mirrors, but they ahve to justify their positions somehow, right? :p
 
Back
Top