Scientists Re-Create Big Bang in Lab

Status
Not open for further replies.
Incorrect, what is accepted in the scientific community is evolution. My previous post explains why this is this case.

I wasn't talking about the scientific community, but about me personally.

What difference does it make whether you test your hypothesis with evidence you gather from an event that happened in front of you vs one that happened before you got there? Evidence is evidence, whether or not you created it yourself. This is a very silly line of reasoning you're hanging on to.

Evidence is evidence. And we are all to judge it's merits for ourselves. But this has nothing to do with the Scientific method, where one can verify hypothesis by reproducing them. Evolutionary scientists are constantly running with false assumptions that get corrected. While other assumptions are yet to be corrected.

And what creatures are there that look closer to humans than chickens yet have less similar DNA? Not that it matters one way or another if such things exist, but whenever I hear examples like this they usually trace back to creationist websites or Josh McDowell books.


Most mammals look more like humans than chickens. I'm not sure what happened to one of nature.com's articles about humans and chimps. Anyways, I don't care to waste my time belaboring that point tracking down my sources. I'll drop the chicken thing... for now.

What allows you to accept dogs and wolves having a common ancestor while rejecting humans and chimps having a common ancestor? That's like saying you can accept someone being able to count to 100, but not much beyond that. What's the barrier between "micro" and "macro?"

No one knows of a barrier. But no one has proved that "there is no barrier." Its supposed nonexistence is merely an untested conjecture that lacks support from the fossil record.
 
you know, I felt like yesterday really dragged by...it was horrible. Even commented to my wife about it.

You're saying this was the reason? They managed to manipulate space-time? Or just time?

Doesn't matter unless they got that baby up to 88 miles per hour :cool:

 
What? Because it's not bigger than it is? You would do better?
What sound does a joke make when it whizzes over your head?

I didn't see anyone ridiculing your beliefs. In fact, I don't know who you are arguing with? The people operating the LHC are trying to figure out more about the universe, I think they have better things to do than attack your personal creed.
Exactly.
 
I think some of you are getting how old the universe is confused with how big it is. Through physics we know that energy can not be created nor destroyed therefore energy has always existed. We also know that e=mc^2 which which means that as long as energy exist, so does matter. How big the universe is is up for debate.

Ftfm
 
It's enough for something like a change in size, or a modified emphasis on appendage usage, or a change in diet. There are many significant changes that could occur over a few million years.

You speak of things of which you nor I know. There are many significant factors. But you nor I can't accurately state whether they are sufficient.

Don't be stupid. The output of a printer does not affect the behavior of the printer on the next flag.

But the concept of a design that changes over time due to copy errors is a great way to see the ideas behind evolution at work. Language is a very prominent example. Words and symbols can be traced back in time to common roots. Geographic isolation allows branches of a language to evolve into separate new languages. Copying errors occur with the new variety taking hold on occasion, causing further diversity.

The same thing could happen with flags. If two groups of people start off with the same flag, but become isolated from each other, in 1000 years their flags will probably be pretty different.

Your concept of geologic time and environment change is pretty simplistic. Rapid environmental changes occur over hundreds of thousands of years. You have to think in terms of pressures on allele pools from multiple directions that shift slowly, not single events that are responsible for single changes.

Language is intelligently designed. Bad example. And my flag is not about people changing things, but about purely random processes.

"Natural Selection" is harsher than you think. You treat it as some gentle guide.

Again, you're assuming a series of completely random events which is not the case with what I'm talking about. Sure, a single mutation may be competely random and caused by a "printer error" in the genetic machinery of some creature. Usually mutations are bad things, and that particular animal will probably die before its genes are propegated very far. On rare occasions a mutation can actually give an individual an advantage over others of the same species. In this case, that individual would be genetically more fit than those without the mutation. This causes the trait to be selected for in the population, and eventually, over a very long period of time, the trait caused by the mutation becomes the norm. Add in some reproductive isolation and a few hundred million years, and you'll get something that probably looks completely different from it's ancestors.

It's still random, because the flow is always interrupted. Nature will sometimes save the mutated 'inferior' while kill off the mutated 'superior.' There is no such thing as "natural selection only choses the superior." Life and nature are furious and chaotic.

I think some of you are getting how old the universe is with how big it is. Through physics we know that energy can not be created nor destroyed therefore energy has always existed. We also know that e=mc^2 which which means that as long as energy exist, so does matter. How big the universe is is up for debate.

physics only show that WE cannot create energy.

But energy and its manifestations is chain of cause and effect. Is it possible to have an infinite chain of cause and effect? An infinite train of boxcars with no engine pushing?
 
No one knows of a barrier. But no one has proved that "there is no barrier." Its supposed nonexistence is merely an untested conjecture that lacks support from the fossil record.
So... you're happy to tell everyone that there is a difference between micro and macro, while simultaneously saying no one knows of such a distinction. I think that pretty much sums up all of your posts in this thread. Doublethink makes some pretty impressive things possible.

But hey, it's not my place to criticize someone for exhibiting willful ignorance. Earlier today I was explaining that I am willfully ignorant of the amount of money I've spent on my gaming rig. When my wife asks me how much I've spent, I can say the case was $250, the video cards were $350 each, the monitors were $200 each, the power supply was $150, each of the hard drives were $120.... but don't worry honey, those are all small amounts, they can't possibly add up to anything significant.
 
Language is intelligently designed. Bad example. And my flag is not about people changing things, but about purely random processes.
Did you design the language you speak? No, you did not. You copied it. Each of us has a distinct copy of English in our brains with a unique set of errors and omissions.

Was it intelligent design when Christians started using the word "fellowship" as a verb? No. Someone was stupid and used the word incorrectly. But then it caught on because Christians had a use for a shortened version of "to have fellowship."

Was it intelligent design when "gay" and "fag" came to mean homosexual? Nope. Just a series of errors in usage that caught on and caused redefinition of the word.

We could go on and on and on. Changes in language are not designed, they arise out of mistakes (sometimes willfully made) and are inherited.
 
I love that we have reduced ourselves to the point that we think uneducated positions are just as valuable as educated ones. Fail.
 
I never understood why people go back and forth on this
spiritual beliefs are an entirely different realm. You cant prove or disprove it with science or any other thing of this world.
 
I love that we have reduced ourselves to the point that we think uneducated positions are just as valuable as educated ones. Fail.
This bothers me, too. In popular culture it's OK to substitute emotion for logic. When did our culture start encouraging us to stand by our beliefs no matter what? I heard that all the time when I was a kid, and it turns out that it's actually really bad advice.
 
If we and the universe are finite, how can the cause of a finite being be an infinite being if nothing is infinite?

If the big bang was the beginning, what was before the beginning?
Purely nothing? If that is the cause then the result would be purely nothing.
Nothing=Nothing.
What caused the universe to come into being? It had to be SOMETHING.
Since the universe encompasses all we know and it could not have created itself what does that leave? We know the universe is finite because it had a beginning.
This is why people argue what what caused the universe to come in to being is unknowable and we shouldn't even speculate about it.
Isn't that kind of like saying in a booming voice "Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain"
The law of cause and effect tells us for every effect (the universe coming into being) there has to be a cause.
And the cause of this finite universe is something that transcends our worldly understanding. But reason dictates that cause exists.
Now which is more unreasonable? That a being that is not bound by the constraints of time and space brought the universe in to existence. Or it "just happened" and we have not business asking why.

I choose to be curious about things. How about you?
 
wtf is the "law of cause and effect?"

Why does the universe need to have a beginning?
 
If the big bang was the beginning, what was before the beginning?
Purely nothing? If that is the cause then the result would be purely nothing.
Nothing=Nothing.
What caused the universe to come into being? It had to be SOMETHING.
Since the universe encompasses all we know and it could not have created itself what does that leave? We know the universe is finite because it had a beginning.
This is why people argue what what caused the universe to come in to being is unknowable and we shouldn't even speculate about it.
Isn't that kind of like saying in a booming voice "Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain"
The law of cause and effect tells us for every effect (the universe coming into being) there has to be a cause.
And the cause of this finite universe is something that transcends our worldly understanding. But reason dictates that cause exists.
Now which is more unreasonable? That a being that is not bound by the constraints of time and space brought the universe in to existence. Or it "just happened" and we have not business asking why.

I choose to be curious about things. How about you?

Pretty much the whole point of the LHC is because we are curious.
 
So... you're happy to tell everyone that there is a difference between micro and macro, while simultaneously saying no one knows of such a distinction. I think that pretty much sums up all of your posts in this thread. Doublethink makes some pretty impressive things possible.

But hey, it's not my place to criticize someone for exhibiting willful ignorance. Earlier today I was explaining that I am willfully ignorant of the amount of money I've spent on my gaming rig. When my wife asks me how much I've spent, I can say the case was $250, the video cards were $350 each, the monitors were $200 each, the power supply was $150, each of the hard drives were $120.... but don't worry honey, those are all small amounts, they can't possibly add up to anything significant.

Can you tell me the exact barrier at which we exit earth's atmosphere and enter into space? You can only offer an estimate. Just because our limits are not defined does not mean that there is no distinction. It's like saying there is no male and no female, because we have these odd cases where doctors have trouble defining the gender of a person. What's the barrier that defines a gender? Can you give a comprehensive explanation? Or are you only going to cite the extremes? Defining the barrier is an exercise in futility.

You have offered up nothing except to say, "we see small changes, so there must be big changes given time."

Did you design the language you speak? No, you did not. You copied it. Each of us has a distinct copy of English in our brains with a unique set of errors and omissions.

Was it intelligent design when Christians started using the word "fellowship" as a verb? No. Someone was stupid and used the word incorrectly. But then it caught on because Christians had a use for a shortened version of "to have fellowship."

Was it intelligent design when "gay" and "fag" came to mean homosexual? Nope. Just a series of errors in usage that caught on and caused redefinition of the word.

We could go on and on and on. Changes in language are not designed, they arise out of mistakes (sometimes willfully made) and are inherited.

Please. Don't be absurd. Language is made by intelligent beings. No matter how stupid something is, it was created by an intelligent being. Apple's security system is flawed, but it was designed nevertheless. Designs usually have flaws and mistakes.
 
If the big bang was the beginning, what was before the beginning?
Purely nothing? If that is the cause then the result would be purely nothing.
Nothing=Nothing.
What caused the universe to come into being? It had to be SOMETHING.
Since the universe encompasses all we know and it could not have created itself what does that leave? We know the universe is finite because it had a beginning.
This is why people argue what what caused the universe to come in to being is unknowable and we shouldn't even speculate about it.
Isn't that kind of like saying in a booming voice "Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain"
The law of cause and effect tells us for every effect (the universe coming into being) there has to be a cause.
And the cause of this finite universe is something that transcends our worldly understanding. But reason dictates that cause exists.
Now which is more unreasonable? That a being that is not bound by the constraints of time and space brought the universe in to existence. Or it "just happened" and we have not business asking why.

I choose to be curious about things. How about you?

Your ignorance in science does not mean you are "curious".

Asking what was "before" the big bang is a trick question. You are putting linear properties on something that is not linear.

Let me phrase it so you understand: What is before the North Pole? What is more North than the North Pole? There "has" to be something, right? Wrong.

The Big Bang is a reference point in the time/space continuum. It is not a "beginning" because space is curved, and curves--like the sphere of the Earth--don't really have a "beginning". Asking what comes "before" the big bang is pop-science. It really just shows your ignorance in the universe, not your curiosity.
 
wtf is the "law of cause and effect?"

Why does the universe need to have a beginning?

It is a challenge to think about this in logical terms. This is something most of us are dissuaded to do now a days. Most prefer you chant the party line and bow to consensus.
 
If the Big Bang created the universe, where did the big bang come from?

The whole space thing can really screw with your head.

I've given up trying to make sense of Space. It hurts too much to think.
 
Your ignorance in science does not mean you are "curious".
Asking what was "before" the big bang is a trick question. You are putting linear properties on something that is not linear.
In other words time is an illusion.
So are you saying before the big bang was the universe and time is just in "replay" mode eternally?
Let me phrase it so you understand: What is before the North Pole? What is more North than the North Pole? There "has" to be something, right? Wrong.
Here you are comparing apples and oranges. Your point is that the universe always existed. Then what is the point of the big bang theory then? It is because the EVIDENCE that is gathered is that the universe had a beginning. Time is linear and has a beginning.
And for all purposes that was the nanosecond the big bang happened.

The Big Bang is a reference point in the time/space continuum. It is not a "beginning" because space is curved, and curves--like the sphere of the Earth--don't really have a "beginning". Asking what comes "before" the big bang is pop-science. It really just shows your ignorance in the universe, not your curiosity.

Again you are saying it always existed and didn't have beginning.
All scientific investigation produced a theory that says it did. What is scientific about your point of view hmm?
 
I would respond to the nonsensical arguments against evolution, but it is off topic, so GTFO.

I would instead point out that "cause and effect" is a laughable concept when you're talking about experiments seeking to reconcile Quantum Mechanics and Relativity. People are stuck on a linear train of thought when they should be looking at time as just a dimension (if anything).

Vacuum Energy, Hawking Radiation--these things rely on the spontaneous appearance and annihilation of particles and anti-particles. No cause and effect there.

Theories? Sure. And therefore experimentally testable.
 
Can you tell me the exact barrier at which we exit earth's atmosphere and enter into space? You can only offer an estimate. Just because our limits are not defined does not mean that there is no distinction.
This is a great example that serves my point. You and I would agree that both space and the earth's atmosphere exist. We also would agree that the boundary between atmosphere and space is subjective, because the concepts of space and atmosphere are invented by humans. There is hydrogen all over the universe, so one could easily say the entire universe is earth's atmosphere. But that's not useful, so we assign a dividing point that serves whatever conversation it's a part of.

When it comes to micro and macro evolution, my beliefs are the same. The difference between micro and macro has no concrete definition, it's a subjective line placed somewhere in the evolution continuum. Both macro and micro evolution exist (oh how I hate those terms), so the dividing line we place between serves only ourselves.

You, however, believe that on one side of the line evolution exists, but on the other it does not. Since your micro/macro actually defines what is and isn't real, and isn't just a subjective descriptor, it has to have a true, repeatable definition. In your world, the placement of the dividing line between micro and macro matters very much, because on one side of the line lives fantasy, while on the other, reality.

So what is the definition? How do you locate the line between what is possible and what is impossible?

It's like saying there is no male and no female, because we have these odd cases where doctors have trouble defining the gender of a person. What's the barrier that defines a gender? Can you give a comprehensive explanation? Or are you only going to cite the extremes? Defining the barrier is an exercise in futility.
Like the separation between atmosphere and space, the separating line between male and female is subjective. But people on both ends of the spectrum do exist, so the line we draw between genders only serves whatever discussion it's a part of. This is not the same thing as declaring that a person can be too male to exist, which is what you're trying to do.

So where is the line between micro and macro? How different can a dog get from a wolf before Mother Nature steps in and says the limit has been reached? What are the limiting mechanics?

How can you be so sure a dividing line between micro and macro evolution exists when you yourself say no one knows that it does?

Please. Don't be absurd. Language is made by intelligent beings. No matter how stupid something is, it was created by an intelligent being. Apple's security system is flawed, but it was designed nevertheless. Designs usually have flaws and mistakes.
You're completely missing the point. We're not talking about the design of the language, we're talking about the process of copying language from person to person. It is the process of copying where modification occurs. You copy another piece of language when you learn a word (which may result in an error). You copy your genetics when you make a baby (which may result in an error). But don't hurt yourself thinking about this. It's not that important in the scope of the discussion.
 
So where is the line between micro and macro? How different can a dog get from a wolf before Mother Nature steps in and says the limit has been reached? What are the limiting mechanics?

If you can't think of some limiting mechanisms for your Evolution, you've got some 'splainin' to do. It is the norm of the fossil record for species to remain essentially unchanged for vast periods, supposedly even hundreds of millions of years. Save your pleading excuses, this is off topic.

Why can't some people stay even halfway sober when it comes to science (yeah, I'm talking about those people who think the government is part of the scientific method)? How ridiculous is it to call something like this a recreation of the Big Bang. Did he create a magical expansion space-time? Nooo... Just a hot spot.
 
Good Grief.

The Big Bang is a theory.
Nothing more.
Just because it is the theory that most people hang their hat on does not change the fact it is a theory; a GUESS.
The same with evolution and the rest of the theories people pick and chose from to complete the portfolio that makes up what they believe.
And to ridicule people that believe God had something to do with it is being rather hypocritical since it is a matter if faith to believe in a theory.

WRONG, in science a theory is not a guess.
http://www.evolution.mbdojo.com/theory.html
 
If you can't think of some limiting mechanisms for your Evolution, you've got some 'splainin' to do. It is the norm of the fossil record for species to remain essentially unchanged for vast periods, supposedly even hundreds of millions of years. Save your pleading excuses, this is off topic.
I admit that I can't think of any natural mechanic that would allow a certain amount of evolution to happen, but then stop completely. Can you? You make it seem like it's something everyone should know, so I'm sure you won't explaining it to us.

And there's no rule I'm aware of that says allele frequencies change at a steady pace. In fact, I think the opposite is what has been observed, as some of you have pointed out.
 
Again you are saying it always existed and didn't have beginning.
All scientific investigation produced a theory that says it did. What is scientific about your point of view hmm?

The big bang theory is not how the universe is created, but more of why is the universe the way it is. What was before the big bang can not be researched for the fact there is no "reminiscence" of the time before the big bang. One of the theories of the big bang is that it will expand to a point, then contract to a single point like the beginning. I wonder if this is a cycle, and if so, is the big bang and the universe an endless cycle therefore infinite.
 
If you can't think of some limiting mechanisms for your Evolution, you've got some 'splainin' to do. It is the norm of the fossil record for species to remain essentially unchanged for vast periods, supposedly even hundreds of millions of years. Save your pleading excuses, this is off topic.

Why can't some people stay even halfway sober when it comes to science (yeah, I'm talking about those people who think the government is part of the scientific method)? How ridiculous is it to call something like this a recreation of the Big Bang. Did he create a magical expansion space-time? Nooo... Just a hot spot.

Invention is the mother of necessity. Same goes for evolution is the mother of environment. If an animal is adapted to their surroundings for say a million years and that environment does not change... is evolution necessary for that animal to survive?
 
I wonder if this is a cycle, and if so, is the big bang and the universe an endless cycle therefore infinite.

"All of this has happened before; all of this will happen again."

My God/Gods/Universal Creator, the Cylons were right!
 
Good Grief.

The Big Bang is a theory.
Nothing more.
Just because it is the theory that most people hang their hat on does not change the fact it is a theory; a GUESS.
The same with evolution and the rest of the theories people pick and chose from to complete the portfolio that makes up what they believe.
And to ridicule people that believe God had something to do with it is being rather hypocritical since it is a matter if faith to believe in a theory.

Oh wow. Judging by the 6 pages in the thread, you've probably been told numerous times already, but I'll add into it. A theory is NOT a guess, period. The classical definition of a theory is basically a concept that can withstand scientific testing and scrutiny and haven't been conclusively disproved. Are you to dismiss the atomic theory as well?

And you are not required to BELIEVE in anything about science. It's all about being convinced by the evidence put forth in front of you.
 
This is a great example that serves my point. You and I would agree that both space and the earth's atmosphere exist. We also would agree that the boundary between atmosphere and space is subjective, because the concepts of space and atmosphere are invented by humans. There is hydrogen all over the universe, so one could easily say the entire universe is earth's atmosphere. But that's not useful, so we assign a dividing point that serves whatever conversation it's a part of.

When it comes to micro and macro evolution, my beliefs are the same. The difference between micro and macro has no concrete definition, it's a subjective line placed somewhere in the evolution continuum. Both macro and micro evolution exist (oh how I hate those terms), so the dividing line we place between serves only ourselves.

You, however, believe that on one side of the line evolution exists, but on the other it does not. Since your micro/macro actually defines what is and isn't real, and isn't just a subjective descriptor, it has to have a true, repeatable definition. In your world, the placement of the dividing line between micro and macro matters very much, because on one side of the line lives fantasy, while on the other, reality.

So what is the definition? How do you locate the line between what is possible and what is impossible?


Like the separation between atmosphere and space, the separating line between male and female is subjective. But people on both ends of the spectrum do exist, so the line we draw between genders only serves whatever discussion it's a part of. This is not the same thing as declaring that a person can be too male to exist, which is what you're trying to do.

So where is the line between micro and macro? How different can a dog get from a wolf before Mother Nature steps in and says the limit has been reached? What are the limiting mechanics?

How can you be so sure a dividing line between micro and macro evolution exists when you yourself say no one knows that it does?

As you and I would agree space and atmosphere is not subjective. But we can't say that the boundary is a subjective non-existing thing, but that it's just too complicated for you or me to define. We might say, the barrier is the last atom to bounce up and down from the earth's atmosphere. That definition might be good or bad (and you can call it subjective), but nevertheless a real objective separation exists. The only possible subjective thing is an attempt to define a middle. The endpoints are not subjective. All this serves to explain that there is a distinction between macro and micro. (Nothing to do with such merits of the existing of macroevolution). All I am saying that an extraordinary change from ape to human would be on the macro scale, something that would supposedly take millions of years and not observable. On the other hand, records in ancient Egyptian breeding can tell us about dogs.

Our other argument was about the merits of macroevolution.

You're completely missing the point. We're not talking about the design of the language, we're talking about the process of copying language from person to person. It is the process of copying where modification occurs. You copy another piece of language when you learn a word (which may result in an error). You copy your genetics when you make a baby (which may result in an error). But don't hurt yourself thinking about this. It's not that important in the scope of the discussion.

Copying is not part of the evolution of language. That's the part when it doesn't evolve. Mistakes are a small portion of language evolution. Most of the time, someone discovers something new and gives it a sound. And they usually base the sounds upon something they previously understand.
 
If the universe is infinite (not known) than the observable universe might only constitute a tiny fraction of it. Why do we generalize the observable expansion of galaxies to apply to the entire universe, perhaps largely unseen, which for all we know could contain multiple big bangs/contractions spaced apart? When you talk about an infinite universe, I start to not be able to comprehend it. :confused:
 
If the universe is infinite (not known) than the observable universe might only constitute a tiny fraction of it. Why do we generalize the observable expansion of galaxies to apply to the entire universe, perhaps largely unseen, which for all we know could contain multiple big bangs/contractions spaced apart? When you talk about an infinite universe, I start to not be able to comprehend it. :confused:

The only thing that would suggest multiple big bangs/contractions is if we can observe evidence of it. Other than that, it truly would be a guess or a curious thought.
 
As you and I would agree space and atmosphere is not subjective.
No, we would not agree on that. Remember when I said that in one line of thinking all of the universe could be considered atmosphere?

But we can't say that the boundary is a subjective non-existing thing, but that it's just too complicated for you or me to define. We might say, the barrier is the last atom to bounce up and down from the earth's atmosphere. That definition might be good or bad (and you can call it subjective), but nevertheless a real objective separation exists.
But no such point exists. Space is not empty of atoms. There are hydrogen atoms scattered from here to any point in the galaxy. And even if we arrive at an objective definition, both the atmosphere and space still exist. Our objective definition, that we created ourselves, does not define what exists and what does not, it defines what words we use to describe each place. Nature doesn't care about what we choose to call atmosphere and what we choose to call space.

All I am saying that an extraordinary change from ape to human would be on the macro scale, something that would supposedly take millions of years and not observable. On the other hand, records in ancient Egyptian breeding can tell us about dogs.
And where between those two events is the line? The line that you say exists defines what is real and what is not. The implications of this line are far greater than what words we use to describe things. Your line is based on the difference between reality and imagination, and is completely independent of our knowledge of it.

Putting your micro/macro line on the atmosphere example means that whatever's in the atmosphere exists, and whatever is beyond it does not exist; that the edge of the universe is on the edge of the atmosphere.

Putting your micro/macro line on the gender example means that anyone who is female exists, and anyone beyond the male line does not exist, except in the imaginations of females.

You believe very strongly that this line exists, yet have no evidence whatsoever, and even declare that no person can know. How can you know so much about something yet declare that no one can know anything about it? How can you have so much faith in the existence of this line while dismissing the millions of research hours put into shaping the modern theory of evolution?

What is the difference between micro and macro evolution? It seems like a pretty simple question that you should be able to answer objectively.

How much different can a dog get from a wolf before nature puts on the brakes?

What natural mechanism enforces the division between micro and macro evolution?
 
Darwin came up with the theory of evolution a long time ago based on the evidence available at the time. Since then, we have acquired so much more knowledge...all supporting the theory of evolution and its predictions. Amazing the entire field of genetics, which didn't exist at all during Darwin's time, completely supports evolution and the relatedness of all life.
 
WRONG, in science a theory is not a guess.
http://www.evolution.mbdojo.com/theory.html

From dictionary.com

the·o·ry 
–noun, plural -ries.
1. a coherent group of general propositions used as principles of explanation for a class of phenomena: Einstein's theory of relativity. [proposition=guess]
2. a proposed explanation whose status is still conjectural, in contrast to well-established propositions that are regarded as reporting matters of actual fact. [proposed=guess]
3. Mathematics . a body of principles, theorems, or the like, belonging to one subject: number theory. [not applicable]
4. the branch of a science or art that deals with its principles or methods, as distinguished from its practice: music theory. [wikipedia, music theory is "any statement, belief, or conception of or about music"= guess].
5. a particular conception or view of something to be done or of the method of doing it; a system of rules or principles. [conception=guess]
6. contemplation or speculation. [speculation=guess]
7. guess or conjecture. [guess=guess]

A theory is an educated guess. Nothing more. Any claim to the contrary is ignorance or lies.
 
wow some close minded people here thinking that religion and science can't get along. This probably stems from some who believe that creation was ex-nihilo which is completely bogus imho. God who is omniscient works within laws he just knows them a lot better, things were created from something.
 
From dictionary.com

the·o·ry 
–noun, plural -ries.
1. a coherent group of general propositions used as principles of explanation for a class of phenomena: Einstein's theory of relativity. [proposition=guess]
2. a proposed explanation whose status is still conjectural, in contrast to well-established propositions that are regarded as reporting matters of actual fact. [proposed=guess]
3. Mathematics . a body of principles, theorems, or the like, belonging to one subject: number theory. [not applicable]
4. the branch of a science or art that deals with its principles or methods, as distinguished from its practice: music theory. [wikipedia, music theory is "any statement, belief, or conception of or about music"= guess].
5. a particular conception or view of something to be done or of the method of doing it; a system of rules or principles. [conception=guess]
6. contemplation or speculation. [speculation=guess]
7. guess or conjecture. [guess=guess]

A theory is an educated guess. Nothing more. Any claim to the contrary is ignorance or lies.

You can't be serious. In science, "theory" is a different word with a different meaning. Why is this so hard to understand? Stop breathing through your mouth for a minute and try looking up the correct phrase.

A scientific theory, by definition, is a collection of ideas that explain all observable phenomena and is falsifiable. Scientific theories are constantly tested until they are disproved. Until they are disproved, they are considered the best available explanation for the set of phenomena they address.

Origin of Species was written 151 years ago. It is not a small deal for Darwin's explanation for biological diversity to remain in place as the most commonly accepted answer for 150 years. It is not "just a theory" when all of the work in biology, zoology, and genetics continue to confirm it.

http://onelook.com/?w=scientific+theory&ls=a

- a theory that explains scientific observations; "scientific theories must be falsifiable"
- In the sciences, a scientific theory comprises a collection of concepts, including abstractions of observable phenomena expressed as quantifiable properties, together with rules (called scientific laws) that express relationships between observations of such concepts. A scientific theory is constructed to conform to available empirical data about such observations, and is put forth as a principle or body of principles for explaining a class of phenomena.
- a theory that explains scientific observations
- a statement that postulates ordered relationships among natural phenomena
- a logically closely interconnected set of scientific laws
-
 
From dictionary.com

the·o·ry 
–noun, plural -ries.
1. a coherent group of general propositions used as principles of explanation for a class of phenomena: Einstein's theory of relativity. [proposition=guess]
2. a proposed explanation whose status is still conjectural, in contrast to well-established propositions that are regarded as reporting matters of actual fact. [proposed=guess]
3. Mathematics . a body of principles, theorems, or the like, belonging to one subject: number theory. [not applicable]
4. the branch of a science or art that deals with its principles or methods, as distinguished from its practice: music theory. [wikipedia, music theory is "any statement, belief, or conception of or about music"= guess].
5. a particular conception or view of something to be done or of the method of doing it; a system of rules or principles. [conception=guess]
6. contemplation or speculation. [speculation=guess]
7. guess or conjecture. [guess=guess]

A theory is an educated guess. Nothing more. Any claim to the contrary is ignorance or lies.

If you wanna play that game, lets define a "guess" (from dictionary.com)

–verb (used with object)
1. to arrive at or commit oneself to an opinion about (something) without having sufficient evidence to support the opinion fully: to guess a person's weight.
2. to estimate or conjecture about correctly: to guess what a word means.
3. to think, believe, or suppose: I guess I can get there in time.

–verb (used without object)
4. to form an estimate or conjecture (often fol. by at or about): We guessed at the weight of the package.
5. to estimate or conjecture correctly.

–noun
6. an opinion that one reaches or to which one commits oneself [/U][/B] or in the absence of any evidence whatever.
7. the act of forming such an opinion: to take a guess at someone's weight.

A guess by these definitions pretty much have nothing to do with proposed scientific theories. If you don't believe that these scientific theories are sufficiently supported, then stop believing and start reading the real stuff.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top