Scientists Re-Create Big Bang in Lab

Status
Not open for further replies.
Good Grief.

The Big Bang is a theory.
Nothing more.
Just because it is the theory that most people hang their hat on does not change the fact it is a theory; a GUESS.
The same with evolution and the rest of the theories people pick and chose from to complete the portfolio that makes up what they believe.
And to ridicule people that believe God had something to do with it is being rather hypocritical since it is a matter if faith to believe in a theory.

Of course then, you know that theories are meant to be tested and religions are not. I think you have mistaken the scientific process of testing the big bang theory for "belief" or "faith" in the big bang theory.
 
So now big bang is no longer a theory to the BBC in 2010 (to post-modernists 2010 CE). There is so much to physics that the scientist do not know that they do not know. Sheesh, there are stars in globular clusters that are more than 13.7 billion years old. Scientific group-speak also applies to anthropogenic global warming stories.

Source?
 
Good Grief.

The Big Bang is a theory.
Nothing more.
Just because it is the theory that most people hang their hat on does not change the fact it is a theory; a GUESS.
The same with evolution and the rest of the theories people pick and chose from to complete the portfolio that makes up what they believe.
And to ridicule people that believe God had something to do with it is being rather hypocritical since it is a matter if faith to believe in a theory.

Are you aware that, when originally proposed in the 1920s, physicists did not like the Big Bang theory because they thought it supported creationism?

wikipedia said:
In the 1920s and 1930s almost every major cosmologist preferred an eternal steady state Universe, and several complained that the beginning of time implied by the Big Bang imported religious concepts into physics; this objection was later repeated by supporters of the steady state theory.[70] This perception was enhanced by the fact that the originator of the Big Bang theory, Monsignor Georges Lemaître, was a Roman Catholic priest.[71] Pope Pius XII, declared at the November 22, 1951 opening meeting of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences that the Big Bang theory accorded with the Catholic concept of creation.

(Are you also aware that the Big Bang theory is perhaps the most experimentally-supported theory in existence?)
 
Theory is the belief of cause and effects of multiple variables that can not be proven a hundred percent. To give you an idea of how theory works take electricity for example. Electronics theory is based on the flow and manipulation of electrons, but it can not be proven for the fact no one has ever seen an electron. Even though electricity is basically fact to everyone... it's still a theory.
 
(Are you also aware that the Big Bang theory is perhaps the most experimentally-supported theory in existence?)
That does not mean there are no problems with it. It also does not mean anything significant, since it may be the only experimentally-supported theory in existence; I know of no other theories that have had experiments done with the purpose of confirming or denying details of theories other than the big bang.
 
Theory is the belief of cause and effects of multiple variables that can not be proven a hundred percent. To give you an idea of how theory works take electricity for example. Electronics theory is based on the flow and manipulation of electrons, but it can not be proven for the fact no one has ever seen an electron. Even though electricity is basically fact to everyone... it's still a theory.

And we have a winner :D
 
Nonsense. You don't have to watch something happen in real time to observe it. Genetics has provided abundant evidence to substantiate diversity through inheritance with modification.

That's right you don't have to watch, because that is in the realm of forensic science. Unless we continue observations for millions of years into the future, there is no demonstration of large scale genetic changes. We can only make untested hypotheses'.

Mostly due to the fact that large scale changes generally take a long time to come about. The amount of selective pressure on a particular phenotype that would be required to cause it to become fixated in a population in a short amount of time is pretty huge (as in the phenotype would have to essentially be 100% required for the species to survive). You have to remember that people have been studying the subject for a very short period of time biologically speaking.

Well, the fossil record isn't much help unless you go the punctuated equilibrium route. We haven't seen a working example of time being enough to bring about such enormously underestimated changes.

But the point here is that when you hear someone say, "There is no evolution" it is just as unhelpful to reply with "evolution is seen everywhere." Both people are talking about two different things.
 
I know of no other theories that have had experiments done with the purpose of confirming or denying details of theories other than the big bang.
How about gravity? How about special relativity? How about general relativity? Scientific theories are tested over and over and over and over. That's how science works.
 
That does not mean there are no problems with it. It also does not mean anything significant, since it may be the only experimentally-supported theory in existence; I know of no other theories that have had experiments done with the purpose of confirming or denying details of theories other than the big bang.

Seriously? How about the Special theory of Relativity? Or the General theory of Relativity?
 
That's right you don't have to watch, because that is in the realm of forensic science. Unless we continue observations for millions of years into the future, there is no demonstration of large scale genetic changes. We can only make untested hypotheses'.

What on earth are you talking about?
 
Good Grief.

The Big Bang is a theory.
Nothing more.
Just because it is the theory that most people hang their hat on does not change the fact it is a theory; a GUESS.
The same with evolution and the rest of the theories people pick and chose from to complete the portfolio that makes up what they believe.
And to ridicule people that believe God had something to do with it is being rather hypocritical since it is a matter if faith to believe in a theory.
A theory in science is not the same as a theory in colloquial language. A theory in science has been tested, gravity is only a theory.
 
I really dislike religion dictating what other people should think. He gave us a brain. Don't be afraid to think about how the Universe came about. He's not going to smite you.

Why can't other religious people be like you?
 
Good Grief.

The Big Bang is a theory.
Nothing more.
Just because it is the theory that most people hang their hat on does not change the fact it is a theory; a GUESS.
The same with evolution and the rest of the theories people pick and chose from to complete the portfolio that makes up what they believe.
And to ridicule people that believe God had something to do with it is being rather hypocritical since it is a matter if faith to believe in a theory.

I didn't see anyone ridiculing your beliefs. In fact, I don't know who you are arguing with? The people operating the LHC are trying to figure out more about the universe, I think they have better things to do than attack your personal creed.
 
As for evolution. All we observe are small changes. We have never observed large changes. So in a large scale, evolution has not been observed. Punctuated equilibrium is the best forensic model for evolution, and yet most evolutionists choose to ignore it.

Exactly.
Micro evolution has pretty much been proved (the wide variation of dogs, types of roses, etc.)
However, macro evolution is still just theory. (single cell to fish to mamals, etc).
 
That's right you don't have to watch, because that is in the realm of forensic science. Unless we continue observations for millions of years into the future, there is no demonstration of large scale genetic changes. We can only make untested hypotheses'.
The notion that an experiment needs to be performed by taking data while some kind of event unfolds is scientific n00bery. Shadows of high school physics. Thinking that not being able to watch a species change over time prevents you from testing an evolution related hypothesis is ignorant.

There are millions of years worth of data neatly packaged into the DNA of every living thing. Genes appear in multiple species. The closer two species are to their common ancestor, the more genes they have in common. Comparing DNA is an experiment that is routinely performed and used to test hypotheses. You don't have to literally watch 2 species split from a common ancestor to be able to show with a very high certainty that they're related.
 
Theory. theory theory.....:D The fact is, a theory is a theory and not a fact. A fact is a fact and not a theory or opinion. That said about the originial topic:

pics or it did not happen. :D Probably looked real cool to see it as well.
 
The notion that an experiment needs to be performed by taking data while some kind of event unfolds is scientific n00bery. Shadows of high school physics. Thinking that not being able to watch a species change over time prevents you from testing an evolution related hypothesis is ignorant.

There are millions of years worth of data neatly packaged into the DNA of every living thing. Genes appear in multiple species. The closer two species are to their common ancestor, the more genes they have in common. Comparing DNA is an experiment that is routinely performed and used to test hypotheses. You don't have to literally watch 2 species split from a common ancestor to be able to show with a very high certainty that they're related.

Ayup, like bacteria, it doesn't take bacteria millions of years to evolve.
 
Exactly.
Micro evolution has pretty much been proved (the wide variation of dogs, types of roses, etc.)
However, macro evolution is still just theory. (single cell to fish to mamals, etc).
The distinction between "micro" and "macro" evolutions exists only in the minds of people who want to find a middle ground between accepting evidence and denying a principal that challenges their medieval beliefs.

Again, you don't have to watch fish descend from single cell organisms to know that it happened. There is overwhelming evidence to support biological diversity through descendancy with modification and none of it involves a graduate student with a clipboard watching trilobites hump.
 
If the Big Bang created the universe, where did the big bang come from?

The whole space thing can really screw with your head.

An intelligent question.

The question of what caused the big bang, or what created the universe is rarely asked.
The big bang is an explanation for the universe as we now see it. But what triggered the big bang? What what before it? When the vastness of space was utterly empty and there was nothing.
Many people say it is useless to ask such a question because it is unknowable. This was
Carl Sagan's point of view. But is it? What about basic cause and effect reasoning?
Lets look at this logically. We can know some things for sure. Lets ask a few basic question:

1. Does the universe exist?
Yes. We are part of it, and we exist. The earth exists, the moon, the stars, etc,etc.

2. Have we always existed throughout eternity? In other words is it infinite?
No, we and the universe are finite; material. Entropy is at work.

3. Did the universe created itself?
No. Because if it did, it would have to exist, before it existed. Something cannot exist and not exist at the same time.

Also, the idea that the big bang was the culmination of all the matter int he universe compressing itself into a finite dot and then exploding the known universe does not address the question of being. It is a round about way of saying that the universe (matter) always existed.
Then you must ask where did the matter that caused the big bang to come from?

If anything exist it must have a cause of that brought it into being.
Since nothing can be self caused there must be a cause that is above and beyond our comprehension. A power that can bring a universe into being? Does it make sense?
For every effect, there is a cause. For a finite being; the cause has a infinite being.
 
Somehow I knew this would turn into a religious/scientific debate as usual, but for those talking out of their ass about how there is no scientific evidence evolution is true, and is just a THEORY, not fact, please read this book:

picture1.jpg_full_238.jpg
 
2. Have we always existed throughout eternity? In other words is it infinite?
No, we and the universe are finite; material. Entropy is at work.

If anything exist it must have a cause of that brought it into being.
Since nothing can be self caused there must be a cause that is above and beyond our comprehension. A power that can bring a universe into being? Does it make sense?
For every effect, there is a cause. For a finite being; the cause has a infinite being.

If we and the universe are finite, how can the cause of a finite being be an infinite being if nothing is infinite?
 
Good Grief.

The Big Bang is a theory.
Nothing more.
Just because it is the theory that most people hang their hat on does not change the fact it is a theory; a GUESS.
The same with evolution and the rest of the theories people pick and chose from to complete the portfolio that makes up what they believe.
And to ridicule people that believe God had something to do with it is being rather hypocritical since it is a matter if faith to believe in a theory.

Wth dude? Thread hijack ftw?!

I'm a believer in God and subscribe to the big bang. It makes sense to me that God probably used this method to make the universe. Think about e = mc^2 and the scripture "let there be light"...
 
How about gravity? How about special relativity? How about general relativity? Scientific theories are tested over and over and over and over. That's how science works.
Surely from my context it's kind of obvious I mean theories regarding the history of the universe...
 
The notion that an experiment needs to be performed by taking data while some kind of event unfolds is scientific n00bery. Shadows of high school physics. Thinking that not being able to watch a species change over time prevents you from testing an evolution related hypothesis is ignorant.

There are millions of years worth of data neatly packaged into the DNA of every living thing. Genes appear in multiple species. The closer two species are to their common ancestor, the more genes they have in common. Comparing DNA is an experiment that is routinely performed and used to test hypotheses. You don't have to literally watch 2 species split from a common ancestor to be able to show with a very high certainty that they're related.

You haven't explained how evolution is beyond a hypothesis of forensics. We have more in common with chickens than so many other things that look closer to human.

The distinction between "micro" and "macro" evolutions exists only in the minds of people who want to find a middle ground between accepting evidence and denying a principal that challenges their medieval beliefs.

Again, you don't have to watch fish descend from single cell organisms to know that it happened. There is overwhelming evidence to support biological diversity through descendancy with modification and none of it involves a graduate student with a clipboard watching trilobites hump.

That begs the question. Descendancy proves macro evolution. But descendancy is a product of evolutionary models. I can accept the dog/wolf thing. But not much beyond that.
 
That begs the question. Descendancy proves macro evolution. But descendancy is a product of evolutionary models. I can accept the dog/wolf thing. But not much beyond that.

So evolution only occurs in dogs, and all other beings are crafted by god. Interesting. :rolleyes:
 
What you are calling macroevolution is really nothing more than what you have deemed microevolution taken to the extreme. With enough of your "microevolutionary" changes you get what you have termed "macroevolution."

This is really the core of the concept of evolution. There is not something magical that happens and suddenly a dinosaur turned into a bird overnight. Instead, a series of smalled changes driven by natural selection and reproductive isolation eventually lead to two completely seperate things. Again, this is not overnight process, we're talking about a few million years here.
 
You can accept dog/wolf descendancy as a product of evolution but not human descendancy?

Microevolution is what's accepted. Common descendancy of humans is well within acceptable too. I'm not sure what you're getting at.
 
You haven't explained how evolution is beyond a hypothesis of forensics. We have more in common with chickens than so many other things that look closer to human.
What difference does it make whether you test your hypothesis with evidence you gather from an event that happened in front of you vs one that happened before you got there? Evidence is evidence, whether or not you created it yourself. This is a very silly line of reasoning you're hanging on to.

And what creatures are there that look closer to humans than chickens yet have less similar DNA? Not that it matters one way or another if such things exist, but whenever I hear examples like this they usually trace back to creationist websites or Josh McDowell books.

That begs the question. Descendancy proves macro evolution. But descendancy is a product of evolutionary models. I can accept the dog/wolf thing. But not much beyond that.
What allows you to accept dogs and wolves having a common ancestor while rejecting humans and chimps having a common ancestor? That's like saying you can accept someone being able to count to 100, but not much beyond that. What's the barrier between "micro" and "macro?"
 
Microevolution is what's accepted. Common descendancy of humans is well within acceptable too. I'm not sure what you're getting at.

Incorrect, what is accepted in the scientific community is evolution. My previous post explains why this is this case.
 
What you are calling macroevolution is really nothing more than what you have deemed microevolution taken to the extreme. With enough of your "microevolutionary" changes you get what you have termed "macroevolution."

This is really the core of the concept of evolution. There is not something magical that happens and suddenly a dinosaur turned into a bird overnight. Instead, a series of smalled changes driven by natural selection and reproductive isolation eventually lead to two completely seperate things. Again, this is not overnight process, we're talking about a few million years here.

But the question is, is a few million years enough? The complexity of DNA is far greater than we can currently understand. We haven't seen if it's possible for such drastic changes. And the fossil record has been extremely unhelpful in supporting this theory. The Liberia Flag is very similar to the United States flag. But it would be doubtful to imagine millions of years worth of printer ink errors in a USA flag factory to accidentally produce liberian flag. It's logically possible, but in practice it just doesn't happen.

And natural selection doesn't seem gentle enough to allow for gradual changes, when extinctions come from catastrophic changes, and not from a species' failure to mutate and adapt.
 
The Liberia Flag is very similar to the United States flag. But it would be doubtful to imagine millions of years worth of printer ink errors in a USA flag factory to accidentally produce liberian flag. It's logically possible, but in practice it just doesn't happen.

The selection process in evolution is not random.
 
But the question is, is a few million years enough?
It's enough for something like a change in size, or a modified emphasis on appendage usage, or a change in diet. There are many significant changes that could occur over a few million years.

The Liberia Flag is very similar to the United States flag. But it would be doubtful to imagine millions of years worth of printer ink errors in a USA flag factory to accidentally produce liberian flag. It's logically possible, but in practice it just doesn't happen.
Don't be stupid. The output of a printer does not affect the behavior of the printer on the next flag.

But the concept of a design that changes over time due to copy errors is a great way to see the ideas behind evolution at work. Language is a very prominent example. Words and symbols can be traced back in time to common roots. Geographic isolation allows branches of a language to evolve into separate new languages. Copying errors occur with the new variety taking hold on occasion, causing further diversity.

The same thing could happen with flags. If two groups of people start off with the same flag, but become isolated from each other, in 1000 years their flags will probably be pretty different.

And natural selection doesn't seem gentle enough to allow for gradual changes, when extinctions come from catastrophic changes, and not from a species' failure to mutate and adapt.
Your concept of geologic time and environment change is pretty simplistic. Rapid environmental changes occur over hundreds of thousands of years. You have to think in terms of pressures on allele pools from multiple directions that shift slowly, not single events that are responsible for single changes.
 
But the question is, is a few million years enough? The complexity of DNA is far greater than we can currently understand. We haven't seen if it's possible for such drastic changes. And the fossil record has been extremely unhelpful in supporting this theory. The Liberia Flag is very similar to the United States flag. But it would be doubtful to imagine millions of years worth of printer ink errors in a USA flag factory to accidentally produce liberian flag. It's logically possible, but in practice it just doesn't happen.

And natural selection doesn't seem gentle enough to allow for gradual changes, when extinctions come from catastrophic changes, and not from a species' failure to mutate and adapt.

Again, you're assuming a series of completely random events which is not the case with what I'm talking about. Sure, a single mutation may be competely random and caused by a "printer error" in the genetic machinery of some creature. Usually mutations are bad things, and that particular animal will probably die before its genes are propegated very far. On rare occasions a mutation can actually give an individual an advantage over others of the same species. In this case, that individual would be genetically more fit than those without the mutation. This causes the trait to be selected for in the population, and eventually, over a very long period of time, the trait caused by the mutation becomes the norm. Add in some reproductive isolation and a few hundred million years, and you'll get something that probably looks completely different from it's ancestors.
 
I think some of you are getting how old the universe is with how big it is. Through physics we know that energy can not be created nor destroyed therefore energy has always existed. We also know that e=mc^2 which which means that as long as energy exist, so does matter. How big the universe is is up for debate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top