The Kinect Is Not Racist

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Consumer Reports have put those rumors that Kinect can’t see darker skin tones to rest. Facial recognition, for all skin tones, is affected by low light conditions but it does not impact game play at all. The testers even played in a room with the lights completely off with no issues. Hit the link for the video.

Those rumors that the Microsoft Kinect has trouble with certain skin tones? No way, says Consumer Reports. Just stop playing in that dark basement rec room, and all will be well.
 
The original eyetoy had this problem.

Plus it barely looks like its controlled by anything. So I don't think it will make a difference.

They should just send it to poland and then everyone will be changed magically (with photoshop) to white...
 
I'm glad this is sorted out, I'll be able to sleep at night again.
 
So are they saying that it's safe for me to come up out of the basement?
 
What's funny is at Fry's during the demo of the Kinect the device register darker skin toned people better than the lighter skinned toned. The device is raciest against white people!
 
What's funny is at Fry's during the demo of the Kinect the device register darker skin toned people better than the lighter skinned toned. The device is raciest against white people!

I don't think it's socially possible to be racist to white people :p
 
Here's a another not racist comment. I also have trouble seeing dark people in the dark...:eek:

Seriously I thought webcams were good in low light situations...
 
UG a follow on to a poor slow news day article . .
How can this be "raciest" or not?!?!?!? (unless the device was specifically designed with this exact GOAL in mind - which it was not)

OMGs a VISUAL device MAY or may not operate differently on people with different color/value of there skin. . . wow that is news worthy?

Does it discriminate VS albinos? or is it some uber conspiracy of albinos for world power because it works "too" well??
Does it work perfectly with a eye patch? Goths? People with spray on tans? "little" people? OMG not the little people . .

Or is the answer So mundane that people have to make shit up for a slow news day . . .
could it be that most devices are designed to work at the current consumer average in order to be effective for as many people as possible . . not all fit that but most do more or less. (chairs for instance)
Also physics and design come into play . . sometimes devices can't be made with a wide range or have problems at one or both extremes. you would need more then one version of the device or a total remake (which may not be possible at this time, or may not make sense in doing)
Would it be MORE or LESS "raciest" to make a "black" persons Kinect that MAY work better for them?? and would that effect the albinos?? or be just a raciest to others? :p
Lame
 
It's no a racist device... except that it does, in fact, discriminate against dark-skinned people. Can we call that a de facto racism?
 
Is anyone going to even buy this fisher price toy? I bet it will end up like PhysX, a nice concept but totally useless in games.
 
It's no a racist device... except that it does, in fact, discriminate against dark-skinned people. Can we call that a de facto racism?

I see what you are saying but .. .look at it this way, the device may be discriminate low contrast people to diminished functionality of the device or not.
this is NOT Racial Discrimination unless construction of the device was modified/planned to discriminate.
Racial Discrimination is a sociological concept and activity. Racial Discrimination is a ACTIVE social process . . People CHOOSE to be raciest and pick arbitrary differences to make the demarcation line that the "OTHERS" are different.

Also I would like to point out "dark" skinned people ARE not the same race nor all light skinned people. (raciest are idiots on more then one level :) )

So If a device can't find the contrast it needs to function on a dark skinned person then it may also not find the contrast it needs on a completely white skinned person (the albino of previous post) etc and for what ever other technical reasons any device made may or may not work for some segment of the populous.
Some ergonomic chairs will not work for larger or smaller people then a set range.
Another spin on this would be the SUN racially discriminating between light skinned and dark skinned people, as light skinned are more effected by intense sunlight.
seems crazy but, I know people that may think that could be as you say "de facto racism", it can't be. No human making a social choice to differentiate groups, not all "dark" skinned people ARE of the same race. and the effect is global the result is not. etc etc ) -
Are Tanning beds are raciest because they are of little use to "dark" skinned people. and it can go on and on and on.
All idiotic . . and outside the context of the real term . . (though people still go there)
 
not everything has to be racism. the more you cry racism over something that isn't, the less convincing you will be when true racism rears its ugly head.
 
What race are they saying had problems with the Kinect?
 
What race are they saying had problems with the Kinect?

look at the article... has a picture

this makes perfect sense, especially is you have two players, each of very different skin color.
the lens is trying to focus and keep track of what is going on, it is going to be set properly for at least one of them, let's say a white person. then for anyone of darker skin, that person will be underexposed, making it harder for the camera to pick up distinct actions from that person.

lesson: dont buy this silly gizmo
 
That's ridiculous! white people should sue the sun for being racist by giving them sunburn quicker. does kinda remind me of the camera with "blink detection" which would've been more aptly named chink detection (it rhymed not trying to be derogatory all you ultra liberal paranoid pc douchebags). "did somebody blink?" hahaha classic!
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Here's a another not racist comment. I also have trouble seeing dark people in the dark...:eek:

Seriously I thought webcams were good in low light situations...

The problem specifically was with the facial recognition. Once it recognizes you and you have your avatar you can turn the lights back down and it will work.
 
What? The guy in the video was barely mocha! They need to get a real Mandingo motherfucker to put this to the real test.
 
I see what you are saying but .. .look at it this way, the device may be discriminate low contrast people to diminished functionality of the device or not.
this is NOT Racial Discrimination unless construction of the device was modified/planned to discriminate.
Racial Discrimination is a sociological concept and activity. Racial Discrimination is a ACTIVE social process . . People CHOOSE to be raciest and pick arbitrary differences to make the demarcation line that the "OTHERS" are different.

Also I would like to point out "dark" skinned people ARE not the same race nor all light skinned people. (raciest are idiots on more then one level :) )

So If a device can't find the contrast it needs to function on a dark skinned person then it may also not find the contrast it needs on a completely white skinned person (the albino of previous post) etc and for what ever other technical reasons any device made may or may not work for some segment of the populous.
Some ergonomic chairs will not work for larger or smaller people then a set range.
Another spin on this would be the SUN racially discriminating between light skinned and dark skinned people, as light skinned are more effected by intense sunlight.
seems crazy but, I know people that may think that could be as you say "de facto racism", it can't be. No human making a social choice to differentiate groups, not all "dark" skinned people ARE of the same race. and the effect is global the result is not. etc etc ) -
Are Tanning beds are raciest because they are of little use to "dark" skinned people. and it can go on and on and on.
All idiotic . . and outside the context of the real term . . (though people still go there)

I don't think it needs to be an "active social process" --as you put it-- to be discrimination. Racism, probably as you say, because it's against the race and not so much the actual color of the skin. But "discrimination" can be from any means of differentiation that results in two distinct groups being treated distinctly differently. Mostly that's just semantics, but what if this facial recognition algorithm was used to grant access at the workplace? Black people would constantly be accosted by security, and sue, with the noisy help of that guy with huge hair.

Regarding actual racism and skin tone though... there are countless examples across the world of darker-skinned people being seen as lesser --- not just in outright racist situations (50s america, south africa, etc), but india, south america, certain Mediterranean countries and so forth where darker skin probably meant laboring under the sun. The tanning machine though .... :) that's a conundrum.
 
Back
Top