Violent Video Games Are Protected Speech

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The National Coalition Against Censorship says violent video games are protected speech. Seriously, this all seems like common sense stuff here, doesn’t it?

Scores of appellate judges and the 82 scientists and media scholars who filed a brief in this case say there's no evidence that children are actually at risk of harm from playing video games. The brief notes that the Federal Communications Commission found that 85 percent of parents are involved in the decision to purchase a video game, and that video game hardware includes controls that are 100 percent effective in blocking access to rated material.
 
Isn't there a reason why there is a committee for assigning ratings to games like movies? And then, isn't it then up to the parent's responsibilities to raise their children in the way that they should go, or allow their children to be raised by themselves, their school teachers, and the world?
 
Isn't there a reason why there is a committee for assigning ratings to games like movies? And then, isn't it then up to the parent's responsibilities to raise their children in the way that they should go, or allow their children to be raised by themselves, their school teachers, and the world?

Parents being responsible for thier own children? That's crazy talk!
 
Isn't there a reason why there is a committee for assigning ratings to games like movies?

A major point of disagreement is whether or not the ESRB is doing a good enough job. They've definitely made questionable decisions in my opinion. (On the side of censorship usually I think, like in the TES: Oblivion "M" rating debacle.)

They're not a government agency. They can legally give ratings based on whatever criteria they come up with. If you read up on some of their evaluating procedures, you can see they're pretty stupid.

There are reputable reviewers that put out game and movie reviews geared at parents, and I think reading those reviews is better thing for parents to do than blindly going by the ESRB or MPAA ratings. But then that requires parents that actually give a damn.
 
A major point of disagreement is whether or not the ESRB is doing a good enough job. They've definitely made questionable decisions in my opinion. (On the side of censorship usually I think, like in the TES: Oblivion "M" rating debacle.)

They're not a government agency. They can legally give ratings based on whatever criteria they come up with. If you read up on some of their evaluating procedures, you can see they're pretty stupid.

There are reputable reviewers that put out game and movie reviews geared at parents, and I think reading those reviews is better thing for parents to do than blindly going by the ESRB or MPAA ratings. But then that requires parents that actually give a damn.

Lots or truth here.
 
I feel like your post is some sort of Mind*uck and I'm supposed to stare at it until I see the dinosaur.

you mean you dont see it? It's right next to the sailt boat.

Parent's responsibility is a truelly shocking concept, lets patent it before steve jobs does. We all know that if kids grow up wrong, it the president's failed school program, or a bad school or a bad teacher's fault, but never the parents......:confused::eek::rolleyes:

Why does this idea never connect to the parents who complain about these things.
 
The newest Supreme Court justice appointed by Obama, Elena Kagan is as anti-free speech as you can get when it comes to sexual content. I wouldn't doubt she harbors the same anti first Amendment views when it comes to violence.

What Obama has said about video games, has been rather negative. He seems to have a disdain for video games, yet spent more time playing golf in his first year than Bush did in eight years.
 
They will defeat it. If they don't then Hollywood and the rest of print/visual media will be affected as well and we all know that isn't going to happen.
 
Most retail chains already have this as policy. ESRB is not mandatory but if you want to sell it at best buy you should have it rated or if you want it reviewed etc. Those stores already don't tell games rated at M to persons under 17 so a law like this would do little to change bad parenting, when their parent buys manhunt 2 for their 12 year old so they will just shut up and go to their room.
 
Speaking of parent's responsibilities.....when can I stop putting in my fucking to go to a game's site?!
 
Maybe I am getting too old. For some reason "age" was not typed in. I blame the keyboard and the damn parents.
 
Meh.

I agree that violent video games are not as harmful as some of these groups purport they are - at least when age ratings are followed - but protected speech seems to be going a bit far for me.
 
The big problem with much of this that you can't legislate intelligent parenting (or even mediocre parenting, or by-God actual present-for-at-least-2%-of-the-child's-waking-day-so-they'll-know-who-you-are parenting). I don't agree with legislation that take away my rights as a consumer. We do need to find a way (preferably also without legislation) to stop the absentee mouthbreahter parents from skunking up the works for the rest of us.
 
Can't they just bring out children licences or something? You need one to own a gun or a car and things, but not to make more humans? Youd need to do an exam, and a test run. Then you get your ovaries/man eggs returned.
 
Can't they just bring out children licences or something? You need one to own a gun or a car and things, but not to make more humans? Youd need to do an exam, and a test run. Then you get your ovaries/man eggs returned.

We'd have a lot of orphanages.
 
So far as I know, there is no law banning the sale of the Saw movies to minors. There is no law banning the sale of the graphic novel "300" to minors. But there is a law banning the sale of Halo (or some other more-mild violent game).

Of course games are free speech. While I don't think it's an infringement on speech to limit the sales of certain goods to minors (porn) I suggest we think hard on where this sort of legislation takes us.
 
The big problem with much of this that you can't legislate intelligent parenting (or even mediocre parenting, or by-God actual present-for-at-least-2%-of-the-child's-waking-day-so-they'll-know-who-you-are parenting). I don't agree with legislation that take away my rights as a consumer. We do need to find a way (preferably also without legislation) to stop the absentee mouthbreahter parents from skunking up the works for the rest of us.

Sure you can, just like hate crimes are somehow different than regular crimes...:rolleyes:
 
Back
Top