Valve's Newell Calls Xbox 360 Patching Process a "Train Wreck"

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Gabe Newell is not a happy camper these days, according to an interview with PC Gamer. The concerns stem from the difference in Microsoft’s support of PC game versions versus that of the Xbox 360 post-launch patches. Thanks and a tip of the hat to Oldie for the link.

Gabe refers to the fact that issuing updates to Xbox 360 games after release cost the developer money and significant changes, requiring large amounts of new content to be downloaded cannot be offered for free, in most cases. This is why much of the content PC gamers get for free is available as paid DLC on the Xbox 360.
 
Bull, we pay $60 for a game that works, if they need to "patch" it for some reason, its their fault.

I dont give a S**T if you as a company need to shell out money to fix the game, we paid for a game that works, if you cannot do that, you fail as a company.
 
Bull, we pay $60 for a game that works, if they need to "patch" it for some reason, its their fault.

I dont give a S**T if you as a company need to shell out money to fix the game, we paid for a game that works, if you cannot do that, you fail as a company.
He's referring to the continuous free updates and content patches that TF2 gets on the PC.
:rolleyes:

Think before you post.
 
And I call the episode 3 development process a trainwreck.

Stop worrying about xbox live and go make your damn games.
 
PC gamers, don't bite the hand that feeds you. To be honest, I am glad the process is a train wreck... More props for us.
 
Bull, we pay $60 for a game that works, if they need to "patch" it for some reason, its their fault.

I dont give a S**T if you as a company need to shell out money to fix the game, we paid for a game that works, if you cannot do that, you fail as a company.

I think you misunderstand. Gabe is referring to the DLC content Valve provides. Valve is perfectly happy giving it for free on the PC but is forced to charge on Xbox because of MS policies.
 
PC gamers, don't bite the hand that feeds you. To be honest, I am glad the process is a train wreck... More props for us.

Personally...I don't give a fuk about "toys R us" consoles. Just sayin'... ;)
 
Bull, we pay $60 for a game that works, if they need to "patch" it for some reason, its their fault.

I dont give a S**T if you as a company need to shell out money to fix the game, we paid for a game that works, if you cannot do that, you fail as a company.

You are an idiot, and if it was any other company but valve they would have made eleventy billion dollars off of TF2 dlc alone. There was so much free content for that game it shames all devs.
 
From what I've heard in regards to 360 patching, the first one is free, but for every one after that MS charges $25k per. Haven't heard about Sony's policy.

MS STILL doesn't have its shit fully together in regards to XBL and its direction. They've changed the gamerscore system (I'm referring to caps and limits for retail and Marketplace titles) so many times since 360 launch (and have been seriously inconsistent for just as long), not to mention the whole pricing scheme...it's a fucking joke.
 
From what I've heard in regards to 360 patching, the first one is free, but for every one after that MS charges $25k per. Haven't heard about Sony's policy.

MS STILL doesn't have its shit fully together in regards to XBL and its direction. They've changed the gamerscore system (I'm referring to caps and limits for retail and Marketplace titles) so many times since 360 launch (and have been seriously inconsistent for just as long), not to mention the whole pricing scheme...it's a fucking joke.

MS charging the devs for releasing patches is stupid... do they make the patches be hosted on an MS server or what?

Why not do it the same way a PC does it?
 
MS charging the devs for releasing patches is stupid... do they make the patches be hosted on an MS server or what?

Pretty much. AFAIK, the only company with semi-independent servers are EA, due to MS having to bend over and take it back in 2005 to get EA sports games on the Xbox platform. From what I've heard, there was a huge concession to EA for that. Ultimately, though, it all goes back to MS.
 
Regular updates, mods, and community maps, are why people are still playing TF2 on the PC.
 
Consoles by nature are closed. It will be interesting to see how closed the next gen consoles are.
 
Bull, we pay $60 for a game that works, if they need to "patch" it for some reason, its their fault.

I dont give a S**T if you as a company need to shell out money to fix the game, we paid for a game that works, if you cannot do that, you fail as a company.

How much did you pay for your operating system on your computer that requires constant security patches and updates? Automobiles routinely get recalls due to design flaws, and they cost THOUSANDS, and you're worried about patch for a freaking game? You're already a dumb ass if you paid $60 for a game. Developers almost ALWAYS release patches for free, and what everyone else has said about Valve releasing free content for TF2 pretty much kicks your ignorance in the chops here. It costs Valve NOTHING to release patches on the PC. It's Micro$haft's money grubbing scheme for the XBox-360 that's the problem here.

I really think PC game developers should just quit making console ports if the console makers are going to make it that hard on the devs. Put some pressure on the console manufacturers.
 
Consoles by nature are closed. It will be interesting to see how closed the next gen consoles are.



Not quite. The whole big hubub about Gabe Newell showing up at the Playstation E3 keynote was that PS3 getting Valve Steamworks and the ability to push patches just like PC. I wouldnt be surprised to see KB/Mouse support too ( i just wouldnt bet on it).
 
The biggest piece of irony here is Gabe Newell calling another piece of software a "train wreck"
 
Are you saying its offered as paid DLC on Xbox because MS requires it to be paid? Because after I pay a developer for a finished game, I should not be required to pay for patches, or updates that are crucial to the game running properly. Notice I said "updates" or "Patches that are critical to the game".

I dont mind paying for the addition of content to my games (such as maps) on Xbox. Proceeds of those payments are going towards the stability and upkeep of the Xbox network. On PC, P2P sharing makes the distribution of user and developer created content a breeze, im guessing no one here (including myself) knows really how much more work needs to be done to upload and distribute that content on the Live network vs on the PC platform.

This dumbass at Valve needs to shut his fat mouth, and stop bitching about money. Im sure hes not hurting for dough in the long run. Maybe his fatass should take a little break in his pay if hes so worried about paying MS money to get his shitty content on the network?
 
it is not about anything other ms getting a byte out of the DLC pie that causes developers to have to charge for DLC on the MS network. My only question is if the cost is network traffic why can't they simply point to a different server for the dlc, which suggests that it is only about the money MS can make.
 
Are you saying its offered as paid DLC on Xbox because MS requires it to be paid? Because after I pay a developer for a finished game, I should not be required to pay for patches, or updates that are crucial to the game running properly. Notice I said "updates" or "Patches that are critical to the game".

I dont mind paying for the addition of content to my games (such as maps) on Xbox. Proceeds of those payments are going towards the stability and upkeep of the Xbox network. On PC, P2P sharing makes the distribution of user and developer created content a breeze, im guessing no one here (including myself) knows really how much more work needs to be done to upload and distribute that content on the Live network vs on the PC platform.

This dumbass at Valve needs to shut his fat mouth, and stop bitching about money. Im sure hes not hurting for dough in the long run. Maybe his fatass should take a little break in his pay if hes so worried about paying MS money to get his shitty content on the network?


Why don't you first explain what MS's policy is exactly on "updates" or "Patches that are critical to the game" or new content. I don't know exactly but it sounds like you do, please explain in clear paragraphs, otherwise you sound like an everyday angsty teen.
 
Why don't you first explain what MS's policy is exactly on "updates" or "Patches that are critical to the game" or new content. I don't know exactly but it sounds like you do, please explain in clear paragraphs, otherwise you sound like an everyday angsty teen.

I cant, but its obviously more difficult/expensive than on PC if that fatass Gabe is whining about it.

Bottom line: If you dont like how MS does it, dont publish your games on that platform, oh but then Valve would lose money? Kind of a catch 22 huh? :rolleyes:

I would be more than happy to play Valve games on PC strictly.
 
I can see both sides. On the one hand, MS wants to encourage people not to put out patches all the time. Most gamers don't like it. They wanna buy something and have it done from the get go. For sure I've played more than a couple PC games where the attitude seemed to be "Just launch it now, we'll fix the issues with a few patches down the road." So it makes sense that they want to encourage people to not patch their stuff. Ship the version you want people to see on the disc.

On the other hand, I understand the wish to do free updates for games. Shooties in particular do real well with that kind of thing. Maybe tweak the balance a bit, add a new map, add a new weapon, that kind of thing. Keeps the game fun, and makes people want to buy your next game. All the shooties I've liked, like TF2, Bad Company 2 and so on have worked like that. They release updates that enhance the game, at no charge.

Well that is nice, but you can't really ask a game company to want to eat a patch charge for that. After all they are already putting developer and designer time in to it.

On the other other hand :)D) I can understand MS doesn't want to do things for free too much. It does cost them money to put out an update, and there is much less space for all that on consoles than PCs. An update on a PC doesn't matter, you have everything on your hard disk already and PC HDs are use. The 360, not so much.

Personally I think Gabe shouldn't whine about it, it just means Valve should focus on PCs. Say "Because of the update differences, our top flight versions of games will be for Steam. We'll be porting games to the consoles, but if you have a choice, get the PC one. It will be higher quality." As a practical matter they make more money per PC copy sold since there's no license fees.
 
I cant, but its obviously more difficult/expensive than on PC if that fatass Gabe is whining about it.

Bottom line: If you dont like how MS does it, dont publish your games on that platform, oh but then Valve would lose money? Kind of a catch 22 huh? :rolleyes:

I would be more than happy to play Valve games on PC strictly.

What's your beef?
 
Its funny, Gabe will whine bitch and moan about the extra time and money his team needs to put into Xbox games, yet hes not man enough to pull his games from that platform.

Why you ask? Simple, because even with the extra effort, time and money, his company is still making a huge PROFIT off of the extra game sales! Bingo!

@Bravo: This sort of issue really boils my blood. We have a rich fatty complaining about simple (for the professionals that get paid big $ to work at valve) coding and fees, when his company is turning out TONS of money in profit from the extra sales. Bite the hands that feed you much?
 
@Bravo: This sort of issue really boils my blood. We have a rich fatty complaining about simple (for the professionals that get paid big $ to work at valve) coding and fees, when his company is turning out TONS of money in profit from the extra sales. Bite the hands that feed you much?

Gabe is more about the experience. He complains about all the extra content that could have been released for free, but because of XBL, it is not. That is what this is about. He is standing up for the consumer having to pay for updates.
 
Its funny, Gabe will whine bitch and moan about the extra time and money his team needs to put into Xbox games, yet hes not man enough to pull his games from that platform.

Why you ask? Simple, because even with the extra effort, time and money, his company is still making a huge PROFIT off of the extra game sales! Bingo!

@Bravo: This sort of issue really boils my blood. We have a rich fatty complaining about simple (for the professionals that get paid big $ to work at valve) coding and fees, when his company is turning out TONS of money in profit from the extra sales. Bite the hands that feed you much?

why is he not entitled to say that the consoles have a shit process for updates? sometimes they churn out a tiny little patch for a game with 1 change. there is no set release for their stuff, sometimes you'll end up with multiple updates in a day. trivial over steam, a big problem on the consoles where the stuff probably has to go through all kinds of microsoft hoops just to get released at all. it's not like they just press a button and like magic, everything is distributed and they pay a little money.

do you think they don't want people to enjoy their games? they've just added ps3 support themselves so people don't have to worry about bad ports.
 
Gabe is more about the experience. He complains about all the extra content that could have been released for free, but because of XBL, it is not. That is what this is about. He is standing up for the consumer having to pay for updates.

He may just be wanting things to be how they always were in the past. He has a history of hating change. He was extremely whiny about the move to multi-core on PCs and consoles claiming it didn't work for games and so on. He's a convert now, but when it first happened he raised a stink. Likewise he hated on the PS3 when it came out and said it was shit. Now he says he quite likes it.

More or less he is like many programmers that don't like change. So when something is different, he's inclined to whine about it. that may be the real source of his complaint with the 360, not consumer protection.

I mean if he really cared about consumers, he'd make it so Steamworks wasn't tied to Steam (more like Impulse :: Reactor). As it stands if a company chooses to use Steamworks to protect their game it is only available on Steam and Retail. It can't go on Impulse or Direct2Drive since it requires Steam to run. So you can get Civ 4 on other platforms, but Civ 5 is going ot be Steam only.

That setup isn't best for consumers, who are best served by competition and choice, it is best for Valve. That's fine, they are in business to make money, but let's not pretend like they are 100% altruistic. It could be done differently, Reactor is an example of a company's DRM that is NOT tired to their service (if you use reactor you have to let them sell the game on Impulse, but it can go on other services and never requires Impulse to be installed).
 
Its funny, Gabe will whine bitch and moan about the extra time and money his team needs to put into Xbox games, yet hes not man enough to pull his games from that platform.

Why you ask? Simple, because even with the extra effort, time and money, his company is still making a huge PROFIT off of the extra game sales! Bingo!

Why shouldn't they port games to the console? I guess you would rather eliminate another choice of where you can play their games, and give 360 fanboys more fodder to complain about. :rolleyes:

MS controls Live. Valve thought by now, maybe MS would have loosened the reigns a little bit. Shacknews dropped the ball on the article; a better one to read is: Valve owns up to its 'failures' with PS3 and 360
Valve's Erik Johnson lamented the way the company has dealt with the PS3, and also referred to the lack of Team Fortress 2 updates on the Xbox 360 as "a total failure." Johnson noted that these failures are worse than internal failures, saying, "If you fix a bug before it ever ships, it's pretty cheap. If you ship it and then fix it, it's really expensive." Gabe Newell added that the company is "really happy with the current situation with the PS3."

Concerning the lack of TF2 updates on Xbox, Newell admits that Valve built the game assuming that Microsoft would eventually change some of its Xbox Live rules (thought he didn't elaborate on the nature of said rules). "We thought that there would be something that would emerge," said Newell, "because we figured it was a sort of untenable." He added that Valve understood Microsoft's rules when it made TF2, but they were "such a train wreck" that the company assumed they would "have to change" eventually.

This is yet another reason why I'm no longer paying for Xbox Live once my subscription is up. It's bad enough they charge for it, but it's ridiculous that they (MS) lock it down to the point where developers are not allowed to price their own stuff if they want it to be free. Bizarre Creations wanted to make Geometry Wars a free title on the 360, and Microsoft wouldn't let them - they told them they had to charge something for it. So BC picked 400pts because that was the lowest price they could choose. This isn't the first time this has happened, and it certainly won't be the last time.

The funny thing is - where'd they end up with more future plans? Ps3. The one system Gabe has consistently ripped on for several years now. Why did they go that route? Because Sony isn't forcing them to charge for the stuff they want to add - that's why Steamworks integration and the other stuff announced for Portal 2 Ps3 is on the way.

360 is getting left in the dust where Valve is concerned - frankly, I don't blame them. :rolleyes:
 
Bull, we pay $60 for a game that works, if they need to "patch" it for some reason, its their fault.

I dont give a S**T if you as a company need to shell out money to fix the game, we paid for a game that works, if you cannot do that, you fail as a company.

Troll ...... added to ignore list....
 
This is yet another reason why I'm no longer paying for Xbox Live once my subscription is up. It's bad enough they charge for it, but it's ridiculous that they (MS) lock it down to the point where developers are not allowed to price their own stuff if they want it to be free. Bizarre Creations wanted to make Geometry Wars a free title on the 360, and Microsoft wouldn't let them - they told them they had to charge something for it. So BC picked 400pts because that was the lowest price they could choose. This isn't the first time this has happened, and it certainly won't be the last time.
Microsoft no doubt pays a crapload of money and bandwidth to host things on its servers. Hosting things for free doesn't make anyone money
 
Microsoft no doubt pays a crapload of money and bandwidth to host things on its servers. Hosting things for free doesn't make anyone money
I'm sure Valve would be willing to host their patches themselves given their own infrastructure, but they aren't allowed to do that either.
 
I'm sure Valve would be willing to host their patches themselves given their own infrastructure, but they aren't allowed to do that either.
The entire reason XBL is the best online console service is because it's run and hosted by a singular consistent entity. Trying to use EA's services is an exercise in pain and frustration. Opening the door to letting third parties run services degrades the service as a whole. No doubt Microsoft has learned their lesson from areas like Windows, where third parties' poorly written software and drivers reflect poorly on the operating system as a whole. Why should they want to give away control and degrade their product?
 
The entire reason XBL is the best online console service is because it's run and hosted by a singular consistent entity. Trying to use EA's services is an exercise in pain and frustration. Opening the door to letting third parties run services degrades the service as a whole. No doubt Microsoft has learned their lesson from areas like Windows, where third parties' poorly written software and drivers reflect poorly on the operating system as a whole. Why should they want to give away control and degrade their product?

All they have to do is let us download from a server, doesn't sound like a big deal except Microsoft is deathly afraid of poisoning their cash cow with awesome free content.

Gabe may as well just sell the gimp version of his games to xbox retards and let the rest of us play games the way they were meant to be played. It's just free money, and he'll never have to support the console version.
 
I'm sure Valve would be willing to host their patches themselves given their own infrastructure, but they aren't allowed to do that either.

iirc, MS leases datacenters from Level (3), which aren't cheap in any way. Since Level (3) has backbone access, XBL will have lower latencies (in theory - this works out well for me, I dunno about others).

I don't know what Sony does, nor what Valve does.
 
MS also probably has to verify each patch, which is more likely why they want money. On consoles, you can't just release anything. The company that controls the console licenses each game. Part of that is they usually verify it for compatibility and security and so on.

Wouldn't surprise me if MS wanted to re-verify each patch.

MS charges a fee for each driver version you want WHQL testes ($250 per version of Windows you want it verified on), can't see this'd be any different.
 
This is yet another reason why I'm no longer paying for Xbox Live once my subscription is up. It's bad enough they charge for it, but it's ridiculous that they (MS) lock it down to the point where developers are not allowed to price their own stuff if they want it to be free. Bizarre Creations wanted to make Geometry Wars a free title on the 360, and Microsoft wouldn't let them - they told them they had to charge something for it. So BC picked 400pts because that was the lowest price they could choose. This isn't the first time this has happened, and it certainly won't be the last time.

The funny thing is - where'd they end up with more future plans? Ps3. The one system Gabe has consistently ripped on for several years now. Why did they go that route? Because Sony isn't forcing them to charge for the stuff they want to add - that's why Steamworks integration and the other stuff announced for Portal 2 Ps3 is on the way.

360 is getting left in the dust where Valve is concerned - frankly, I don't blame them. :rolleyes:

I feel the same way. I think MS is completely out of the loop as far as their consumer is concerned. Live isn't doing anything that much different to Apple's App Store which has tons of free apps.

As an aside, I think I was one of the last holdouts boycotting Live Gold. I'd gone without a gold account since 2006 when I finally cracked a couple of months ago to play MW2 online. After four years of hearing how vastly superior it was to PSN, I just felt embarrassed for those people. Multiplayer is no better than I've seen on PSN and, to make things worse, half the stuff they claim brings value to the subscription is region locked.

Reading Gabe's comment just furthers my sentiment (and, frankly, resent) about Live. For a company that collects almost a billion dollars a year in subscription fees, they don't seem to like giving much back.
 
In one way MS is rightly afraid of a free for all. They do not want game patching to fix issues to become the norm.
This what we have now on the PC. As many games ship with game breaking bugs as not anymore. That your new game will have to be patched is almost assumed. The console games are now at the point where they can be patched, and often need to be. This is part of the reason that process has been made difficult. As a lesson to devs to make sure their games work prior to release. I would guess it is prolly not the main reason though.

The main one, is that the additional content patches cost money to push out and can reduce revenues. MS, Sony, and many devs desperately want to move to the paid DLC and micro transaction model. They want to get you for $100 to $150 per game. The 3 maps for $15 and selling special guns or clothes or whatever in game is how they want to go about it. Even if you sell the game later, they can then sell DLC and other crap to a second person.
Companies that want to give away free map packs and/or updates add a game mode makes the ones that charge for it look bad, and may reduce the money one can eek out of micro transactions. In fact, it may cause people to migrate away from the fee based ass rape games to the ones that have free updates.
 
The entire reason XBL is the best online console service is because it's run and hosted by a singular consistent entity. Trying to use EA's services is an exercise in pain and frustration. Opening the door to letting third parties run services degrades the service as a whole. No doubt Microsoft has learned their lesson from areas like Windows, where third parties' poorly written software and drivers reflect poorly on the operating system as a whole. Why should they want to give away control and degrade their product?

Yea totally, valve's content delivery system really sucks. :rolleyes:

If xbox players had access to steam then I wonder how many would use that wonder xbl product you claim they are protecting from being degraded.
 
Back
Top