How Bing is Out-Innovating Google

Every time I see these stories I think back to the one time I used Bing. I searched for something for school and couldn't find what I needed within three pages. After that I went to Google and the first hit was exactly what I wanted.

Bing is just not good. All it is is a re-skinned Live Search. Nothing has changed.
 
Why not? Google isn't perfect. I use Google and Bing, Bing is my default. 95% it gives me what I want sometimes with better results than Google and if I don't get what I want one click later I have Google results. Limiting oneself to one search engine is bizzare around a place where people claim to run eleventy billion different OSes.:confused:

I wouldn't say it's bizarre. I've been using google for years now like most others and am very familiar with how to work the search algorithm.
 
I wouldn't say it's bizarre. I've been using google for years now like most others and am very familiar with how to work the search algorithm.

That a person will deal with a lot of different OSes and only ONE search engine. It's a little strange to me. Maybe it the way I do my searches but Bing will sometimes give me stuff I want better then Goggle. I'm a .Net developer and I seem to have a bit better luck sometimes with Bing for Microsoft tech stuff. But most of the time both engines give the very much the same top links. The more obscure a search is the better Goggle seems to be. The more generic the better Bing seems to be. Just an off the cuff observation with absolutely NO evidence.
 
Call me weird but I think the new Image search is superior in every way. I can't even figure out why anyone would want to use the old image search unless they just hate change that much.

/shrug
 
Call me weird but I think the new Image search is superior in every way. I can't even figure out why anyone would want to use the old image search unless they just hate change that much.

/shrug

In my case its the speed. All I want is an option to use the old one. That would makes us both happy.
 
In my case its the speed. All I want is an option to use the old one. That would makes us both happy.

The option is there; scroll to the bottom and hit basic. Or ctrl f and type basic and it'll take you right to it.
 
Ok, the thing that really made me switch to using bing the most is when that news story about them (google) discriminating pay in favor towards certain life choicers. Plus one can't ignore googles attempts to data mine your information/habits as much as they can.

So all of my machines have been switched to bing as default. I don't miss google at all. I'd probably revert to using google 1 / 100 of the time now.
 
I personally thing Windows Phone 7 will do wonders to the brand, hopefully they can do something with it.


I love Google, I wouldn't imagine using any other email, but gmail, I am using an Android OS phone, and I probably make 50 google search queries a day, but I want there to be competition too...
 
I guess the main thing about Google is, how much stuff we get from them for free. With ad block plus I never even see their ads, I don't see any ads on my phone. The only really thing I pay them with is my data by using them.
 
Ok, the thing that really made me switch to using bing the most is when that news story about them (google) discriminating pay in favor towards certain life choicers.

They aren't paying more just simply because they are Gay. They are compensating them for the extra $1062 they have to pay in taxes to get their partner on their insurance, taxes a heterosexual married company do not have to pay. Google isn't the only company that does this.

If this is a problem, then why not boycott companies who pay their NY workers extra to compensate for garaging their vehicle, or give a bump in pay to compensate for childcare. Not everyone has a child or a car so it's a major disservice that they get more money to bring their pay in line with the people who don't...
 
Bing continues to pick up market share from Google. Not a huge amount, but it has been an impressive trend so far considering how dominant Google is. Also, look how long Bing has been out compared to Google. Give it some time, things might get interesting.

not a 1 to 1 comparison, lots of bings marketshare is from the old msn search.
 
I like Bing. I think it looks nicer. The image search is miles ahead Google's.
 
The few times I've tried bing for an actual search (not just a quick visit for a cash-back link) I've been disappointed. It seems to try and find similar things to what you might be looking for but not what your actually looking for...

Google on the other hand, 99% of the time, works every time.
 
I agree.
Because Google keeps copying off of Bing, therefore Google is saying Bing is ahead of the curve, so therefore Bing is ahead of the curve that Google and Bing have co-created.

Google was better, it was simple, and clean.
Bing was colorful and cluttered.

Google still gives better results, but IMHO if Google continues to copy Bing, I will simply use Bing because Bing is the original.

Google should go back to being awesome, but alas...I think they don't know how.

I hate side bars on my search pages, and I hate their new slow as chunk (Goonies,) cluster fuck image search.
 
The option is there; scroll to the bottom and hit basic. Or ctrl f and type basic and it'll take you right to it.

Again, this only works for the page listing, not for the image preview, which still pops up in a supid "flash/java/dhtml/whatever it is" in the middle of the screen.

I hate that.
 
Plus one can't ignore googles attempts to data mine your information/habits as much as they can.

And you think Microsoft isn't doing this with Bing? Mining data is what search is all about. That's where the money is. That's why companies launch search engines.

If it weren't for mining peoples data to provide personalized ads there would be no search engines at all...
 
They aren't paying more just simply because they are Gay. They are compensating them for the extra $1062 they have to pay in taxes to get their partner on their insurance, taxes a heterosexual married company do not have to pay. Google isn't the only company that does this.

If this is a problem, then why not boycott companies who pay their NY workers extra to compensate for garaging their vehicle, or give a bump in pay to compensate for childcare. Not everyone has a child or a car so it's a major disservice that they get more money to bring their pay in line with the people who don't...

I don't mind the gay compensation. People can't help if they are gay and the company is helping them avoid federal discrimination in the tax laws.

The bump in pay for parking and childcare - however - I would be 100% opposed to. People CHOOSE to have cars and children, and as such they should pay for it themselves, not take it from a salary pool that could be spread evenly among everyone.

Those who choose to not have children or cars should not have to indirectly pay for the people who do.

I feel similarly about taxes. The government should not offer tax discounts for dependents or married people at all. Quite frankly it's none of the governments business. If peope want to have lots of children they should have to PAY for lots of children and not burden the rest of us with higer taxes because of their life choices.
 
I can not tell you the last time I actually went to Googles search page. I just use the search box at the top of Firefox. I have used Bing a few times. For the most part I get the same results. I am used to Googles layout on search results so I will probably just stick with them.
 
That a person will deal with a lot of different OSes and only ONE search engine. It's a little strange to me. Maybe it the way I do my searches but Bing will sometimes give me stuff I want better then Goggle. I'm a .Net developer and I seem to have a bit better luck sometimes with Bing for Microsoft tech stuff. But most of the time both engines give the very much the same top links. The more obscure a search is the better Goggle seems to be. The more generic the better Bing seems to be. Just an off the cuff observation with absolutely NO evidence.

The difference being that Ubuntu and Windows are both *GOOD*, whereas Google is great and bing is meh.

I run Firefox, Chrome, and Opera on a daily basis - but I still don't use IE or Bing, because I don't like them.
 
I don't get the "I searched Google and it came back as the top result, Bing didn't have the result AT ALL" / "Bing had the results I wanted, but Google can't find them and also ate my sandwich" posts. Can anyone cite examples?
 
Zarathustra[H];1036018340 said:
I don't mind the gay compensation. People can't help if they are gay and the company is helping them avoid federal discrimination in the tax laws.

The bump in pay for parking and childcare - however - I would be 100% opposed to. People CHOOSE to have cars and children, and as such they should pay for it themselves, not take it from a salary pool that could be spread evenly among everyone.

Those who choose to not have children or cars should not have to indirectly pay for the people who do.

I feel similarly about taxes. The government should not offer tax discounts for dependents or married people at all. Quite frankly it's none of the governments business. If peope want to have lots of children they should have to PAY for lots of children and not burden the rest of us with higer taxes because of their life choices.

No, they really are the same thing. To make it sure, what I was referring to in terms of automotive and childcare is Transportation reimbursement accounts and backup care. Both are used for work only purposes, are not government subsidized or a handout. It's an incentive for you to work for them.

For instance, where I work, the company will pay for your metrocard, or if your hours cannot make taking the subway feasible they will either provide you a parking space, or pay for it for use during your hours. Backup care is where the company will provide you up to 10 days of care for your child or a elderly family member in case your normal sources are unavailable. Again, its for you to work, you can't just call and say I need a sitter tonight so I can have a night out on the town.

People offer competitive things to get you to work for them, and to keep you there. If I had to pay the $465 a month extra to park my car so I can work the night shift, then I'm going to go work for someone else who provides free parking as the day shift people can take the train, even if it wasn't free they still only pay $89. Get what's going on?

Back on subject. Three areas where bing is superior. Turn by turn directions using their mobile app, the plugins you can use with their mapping service, like cab fare calculator or parking finder. and Twitter/facebook integration is nice as well.
 
Google should stay focused on their strengths - familiarity and simplicity. If they change something too much, they risk experiencing the "New Coke" effect. Given the search engine's market share, what they've been doing so far has clearly been right.

Even if a design change is for the better, it will take time for people to get used to and accept it. For example, the new image search requires me to mouse over images to see the URL and resolution of the image. Why? What if I quickly want to find an image of a certain resolution, or want to avoid a certain site due to known popups, ads or low speed?

When my start page was suddenly change to iGoogle, I was also confused and angered by the change to *my* start page. It felt like Google had gone in and re-arranged all the icons on my desktop. Now that I'm using many of Google's apps, I'm finding it more useful however and have actually switched.
 
So because Microsoft tried two new ideas over how long that Google didn't get to first, they're out-innovating Google? wtf? How many thousands of ideas has Google introduced and then improved on its own without even any competition because they are so far ahead in innovation? CNN has really gone downhill.
 
Back on subject. Three areas where bing is superior. Turn by turn directions using their mobile app,

For what mobile OS? Because Google Maps Navigation on Android is far superior to anything else I've used.
 
For what mobile OS? Because Google Maps Navigation on Android is far superior to anything else I've used.

Windows mobile. Pretty much on par with google maps. arrow and voice notifications on a turn, avoid traffic and/or tolls, map or list. As far as Google maps, it's nice but I've ran into too many times where it was way off the mark on results. Enough that I rather use a real GPS over the android version.
 
Example of a frustration with Google maps. 5865 BUFORD HIGHWAY Atlanta, GA 30340. If you search for where it is, it's right. Plot a route, it will send you 4 miles south. Reported it four months ago, still hasn't been fixed.
 
Example of a frustration with Google maps. 5865 BUFORD HIGHWAY Atlanta, GA 30340. If you search for where it is, it's right. Plot a route, it will send you 4 miles south. Reported it four months ago, still hasn't been fixed.

Yeah, I've had misdirection by a few miles like that a couple of times too.
 
Bing usage has increased as Windows 7 market share has increased, because it's the default search for IE. It's a long-running MS strategy -- tie it in with the OS, make it the default.

Anecdotally, I don't know anyone at all that actually uses Bing instead of Google for search. The only time I've really even heard anyone in my circle of nerds talk about it is in reference to the cash back feature, which is gone now anyway.

Bing is in the same category as Windows Phone 7 -- trying way too late to get into a market with a product that has nothing unique or better than the status quo other than "It's made by Microsoft." What MS fails to understand is that, these days, MOST people consider that a Con, not a Pro.
 
Bing usage has increased as Windows 7 market share has increased, because it's the default search for IE. It's a long-running MS strategy -- tie it in with the OS, make it the default.

Anecdotally, I don't know anyone at all that actually uses Bing instead of Google for search. The only time I've really even heard anyone in my circle of nerds talk about it is in reference to the cash back feature, which is gone now anyway.

Bing is in the same category as Windows Phone 7 -- trying way too late to get into a market with a product that has nothing unique or better than the status quo other than "It's made by Microsoft." What MS fails to understand is that, these days, MOST people consider that a Con, not a Pro.

Well hold on, didn't Firefox have a huge browser market share in the past couple years? Who's their default search engine? Opera and Safari also has Google as their default. People and Google who complains about Internet Explorer making Live, then Bing, the default needs to shut up and quit being hypocrites.
 
Well hold on, didn't Firefox have a huge browser market share in the past couple years? Who's their default search engine? Opera and Safari also has Google as their default. People and Google who complains about Internet Explorer making Live, then Bing, the default needs to shut up and quit being hypocrites.

There might be an ounce of truth in this if Firefox was pre-installed on store-bought PCs, but it isn't. If you go to Best Buy right now, buy a computer, open the default browser and do a search with the default search engine, you're searching Bing with IE (unless you bought a Mac).

On top of that, a user that's savvy enough to go install another browser is almost certainly savvy enough to change their default search engine, so again...
 
Considering that Google has been adopting a lot of Bing's concepts lately, I would say they are.
 
Considering that Google has been adopting a lot of Bing's concepts lately, I would say they are.

Exactly.
And this is going to hurt Google more than anything.
They should undo every Bing-a-size they've done to their shit.

I miss plain and simple google : (
 
I HATE THE NEW GOOGLE IMAGE AS MUCH AS I HATE ALL CAPS.


But google is still better than Bing, lets just hope that google stops trying to help bing out.
 
Weird. I was researching a Lenovo laptop this morning on my IE8 browser and noticed that Google Image is back to the old format, but not so with my Firefox browser (with Basic Version selected).

IE_Google_Image.jpg


Firefox_Google_Image.jpg
 
Weird. I was researching a Lenovo laptop this morning on my IE8 browser and noticed that Google Image is back to the old format, but not so with my Firefox browser (with Basic Version selected).

http://i125.photobucket.com/albums/p53/Azhar1972/IE_Google_Image.jpg

http://i125.photobucket.com/albums/p53/Azhar1972/Firefox_Google_Image.jpg

Interesting. I'm having the same issue with firefox. When I select the basic version the search results come up in the classic format I am used to, but once I click on the results I get the same, new version as you show above. I didn't realize it was actally working properly in IE.
 
Back
Top