Do We Need a 'Do Not Track' List

Do you support a "Do Not Track" list?

  • YES

    Votes: 54 64.3%
  • NO

    Votes: 5 6.0%
  • Who cares, the Do Not Call list doesn't work either!

    Votes: 25 29.8%

  • Total voters
    84

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
How many of you would support a national “Do Not Track” list? Hopefully it would work better than the Do Not Call list but, at this point, I think anything would be better than nothing.

The so-called Do Not Track list is now under investigation, and a report on its feasibility is said to be due in the fall. The idea would be to limit Web users’ trackability through cookies and other mechanisms, thus preventing online marketers from discovering users' browsing and e-shopping habits.
 
I don't like people following me, but if people are paying other people to get this information (and keeping the thing free/cheaper for me), then go ahead, do it.

If Youtube and Google were completely free of AdSense and all the data it collects about user's habits, someone (us) is going to have to pay for it (either through more intrusive ways like playing commercials before youtube videos, or paying out of pocket for material), instead of the companies that are willing to pay to advertise or receive that information.

So, I don't know. I chose Yes, as I like being clean, but if it makes the net a better place (in both price and the way it functions, but also the results we receive), then go ahead, track us.
 
^ Yeah, not that I understand the advertising model, exactly, but they are going to get our money somehow. I doubt another "Will Not Work" list is ideal but I would still prefer to have the option, especially for my kids.
 
The problem with a "Do Not Track" list is that companies will do it through other methods. Lets say by September there's a way to sign up, but will companies stop trying to collect personal information?

They'll just have more products with "sign up for a chance to win an iPod", or they'll force you to register your product, otherwise it won't work.

Either way, they'll get what they want. I'd like to see the FBI or something step in and put some definite rules to stop corporations from knowing personal information. Like, why the hell do some places need to know the last 4 digits of my social?
 
<tin foil hat>Wouldn't that be a convenient list for the government to use to identify weirdos and other undesirables who are secluded in their basements, writing manifestos about the end of the world in 2012?</tin foil hat>
 
I don't have any problems with the do not call list. I have my number on both the national and state levels and i don't get any sales calls.
 
I've had really good results with the do not call list. I used to get 10-15 calls PER DAY at all hours. It was so bad I had to unplug my phone and only used it for outgoing calls. A few months after putting myself on the list I get maybe a call every month or two.
 
I do not care if they know about my shopping habits. I pick and choose what I fight for on my freedoms and privacy, lest people roll their eyes and go "oh, just another activist". Because activists can be idiots like that because they get outraged at the tiniest things.

This is too trivial to be worth any government involvement. You know what I'd rather have? A do not spam list for my snail mail box. I want my bills and whatever I ordered...nothing more.
 
I would much rather use the ad supported internet than the pay for every service with a monthly fee internet.

Ban these people from all ad supported content and let them be "un-tracked" by advertising companies. See how long that lasts. Murdoch will be so proud of you.

There's no free lunch. Someone has to pay for your mooching. And yes, blocking ads is stealing. These writers / bloggers / whatever you want to call them aren't doing this for free. If you aren't paying a monthly fee and you're blocking ads, you're stealing money from your favorite blogs / publications.

If a website is being too greedy, throwing out pop-ups and other excessively irritating moving advertisements or ads that require click-throughs, blocking ads as a way of protesting is justifyable. But most sites don't resort to that bullshit anymore. Look at [H], Anand, Slickdeals and most other websites you visit. They have have ads in the margins. They don't have audio. They aren't flashing and hardly consume any resources. There is really no excuse for turning them off.

If you're researching new cars, furniture or computer hardware on Google, is it so horrible that Google shows you ads relevant to things you've been searching for? Is that too practical for you? Would you rather they show you dick enlarging drug ads instead, since they pay the biggest advertising bucks?
 
blocking ads is stealing. These writers / bloggers / whatever you want to call them aren't doing this for free. If you aren't paying a monthly fee and you're blocking ads, you're stealing money from your favorite blogs / publications.

Look at [H]. They have have ads in the margins. They aren't flashing and hardly consume any resources. There is really no excuse for turning them off.

I've had [H] Flash ads peg my CPU at 100% on several occasions... E7400@3.8Ghz, all going to some Newegg ad for a 10-port USB hub!

Solution? Firefox 3.6.6.

Now Flash crashes within milliseconds. FF recovers, and [H]'s nice ads are just gray notices that "Flash has crashed. Refresh to crash again."

I haven't seen an ad in weeks!
 
I think we have way too many intrusions into our privacy these days,but it's reached the point where I don't know if it can be stopped now.Big business and government have become so intertwined it's hard to tell one from the other.
 
If a website is being too greedy, throwing out pop-ups and other excessively irritating moving advertisements or ads that require click-throughs, blocking ads as a way of protesting is justifyable.


It is not justified.

You set your own standards and soon everyone has their own different standard. You want to look at a website, you sit there and stare at their ads, no matter how much they move or pop. You sound like a common street thief to me.

Remember, someone has to pay for the content and that someone is YOU!
 
It is not justified.

You set your own standards and soon everyone has their own different standard. You want to look at a website, you sit there and stare at their ads, no matter how much they move or pop. You sound like a common street thief to me.

Remember, someone has to pay for the content and that someone is YOU!

Pop up ads were extremely infamous years ago, and now every web browser has a built in pop up blocker. Nobody complained, cause it got so bad that even shows like "Aqua Teen Hunger Force" had episodes that mocked them.

Now the ads are built into the web page, and I'm sure it's just as profitable as when pop ups existed. It's also just as annoying too. Ads ranging from animated Gifs to flash ads, to ads that take up the whole screen until you click X.

Oh, and that content that you're talking about, it's regurgitated. Tech news travels very fast, and it's not a surprise to see the same news story on 10+ different sites. Some journalism.

Has anyone wondered why every tech website shows up with benchmarks for a product at the same day? It's cause the NDA gets lifted, but doesn't that mean those websites have to give good reviews. Red vs Blue PSA #2 said it best.

http://redvsblue.com/archive/?id=1340

"Scores 1-6 are completely irrelevant, cause nobody ever gets them. So, that means a game that gets a 7 is terrible. So 7 is the new 0. 8 is also a terrible game, but a terrible game that advertised on thew review site. Still very legal. 9.1 is a lousy game as well. 9.2 through 9.4 are good. 9.5 is great, and there's nothing about 5, except for 10 which is a perfect score, and 9.9 which is also a good game but the reviewer doesn't like the developer because he said something mean to him at a party or something."
 
It would be nice, but I don't think it would work, especially with the internet being so inherently international, and things that are banned in one country, cna so easily be done in another.

That, and just like with the do not call list, the biggest offenders (politicians and non-profits) would probably be excluded. :rolleyes:

Washington is corrupt.
 
I'd bet they'd just use the list to specifically track those who are on it. Using their reasoning, why would you not want to be tracked if you aren't doing anything wrong?
 
I would much rather use the ad supported internet than the pay for every service with a monthly fee internet.

Ban these people from all ad supported content and let them be "un-tracked" by advertising companies. See how long that lasts. Murdoch will be so proud of you.

There's no free lunch. Someone has to pay for your mooching. And yes, blocking ads is stealing. These writers / bloggers / whatever you want to call them aren't doing this for free. If you aren't paying a monthly fee and you're blocking ads, you're stealing money from your favorite blogs / publications.
...

Speaking of ads... Kyle banned me from the forums 7 or 8 years ago when I mentioned I never had problems with forum ads because our office used ad-blocking software. I think his comment was "You block my ads, I block you."

Now here we are years later and I have a business that partly relies on internet advertising. I'm glad Kyle set me straight.
 
It is not justified.

You set your own standards and soon everyone has their own different standard. You want to look at a website, you sit there and stare at their ads, no matter how much they move or pop. You sound like a common street thief to me.

Remember, someone has to pay for the content and that someone is YOU!

Or is it the website operators who are the thieves, stealing our bandwidth by forcing us to view content we don't wish to see? :p

Agree with it or disagree with it, but there has long been an expectation that everything and anything on the internet should be free, probably due to the internet and the first usenet forums, and webpages being designed by geeky hobbyists.

With no offense intended to Kyle, Steve, Anand, Gizmodo, or anyone else who runs a website as their livelihood, there really is no need for professional webpages. ( Seriousyly, send me all the latest hardware and I'll build, review and host the articles for for free :p )

I kinda liked how tech and webpages used to be things for hobbyists, and am a little bit disappointed that everyone wants to make money off of it now.

I know the early internet utopia is mostly gone these days, but I still have fond memories of it.
 
Speaking of ads... Kyle banned me from the forums 7 or 8 years ago when I mentioned I never had problems with forum ads because our office used ad-blocking software. I think his comment was "You block my ads, I block you."

Now here we are years later and I have a business that partly relies on internet advertising. I'm glad Kyle set me straight.

That doesn't seem fair though. It's not as if it was your choice to block the ads (or was it?)

I agree that ads serve an important role in financing many internet sites I have come to appreciate. I just wish they could be displayed in less obtrusive ways so they don't have negative impacts on the user experience.

Ad sense is pretty good like this. uses little to no bandwidth and integrates with what you are trying to do.

Straight up banners aren't bad usually, (as long as they arent too large in file size, or physical size, aren't animated, and don't have too wild colors)

Animated banners, faux popups that block the site until you dismiss them, and anything java or flash based drive me up a wall however.
 
Zarathustra[H];1036014771 said:
Or is it the website operators who are the thieves, stealing our bandwidth by forcing us to view content we don't wish to see? :p.

I mentioned this as a joke, but come to think of it, it's not that far off. For most desktop users its not a big deal, but some mobile plans are rather limited. I wonder how much cumulative bandwidth all ads a internet powe user downloads ad up to in a month. I wonder how much money in monthly overage charges could be avoided for mobile broadband users if they weren't there?
 
Do Not Call works for me. Yes, please.

It depends on the type of call. It works for me by not being bothered from the major national corporations and companies, but it doesnt work for say.. the local sheriffs office asking me to give them money. I truely don't understand that aspect of it, but suffice to say, it is fun to go off on callers once in awhile. and the DNCL has pretty much eliminated 99%, but gives you that 1% once every like 6 months to practice your expression techniques :D
 
I don't think it will work. How do you enforce it? Doesn't that require you giving your personal information to a government agency? That kind of defeats the purpose, does it not?
 
I don't think it will work. How do you enforce it? Doesn't that require you giving your personal information to a government agency? That kind of defeats the purpose, does it not?

And how would the website issuing a tracking cookie, even know who the person was?

Do you register your public IP? Well for most people public IP addresses are dynamic...

It just seems very convoluted to make work.
 
Back
Top