NYTimes: Government Should Regulate Google's Search Algorithm

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The New York Times suggests that the government should regulate Google’s search algorithm…you know…because the government doesn’t have stuff like the economy, jobs and housing to fix first.:rolleyes:

Still, the potential impact of Google’s algorithm on the Internet economy is such that it is worth exploring ways to ensure that the editorial policy guiding Google’s tweaks is solely intended to improve the quality of the results and not to help Google’s other businesses. Some early suggestions for how to accomplish this include having Google explain with some specified level of detail the editorial policy that guides its tweaks. Another would be to give some government commission the power to look at those tweaks.
 
When you can't compete because your business model sucks/is outdated, cry to Big Daddy Government. Seems to work for the MafRIAA and MPAA. And when you're just jealous of success, cry to Big Daddy Government.
 
Google should regulate the Governments Search Habits.

Also teach the government how to properly run a business. An give them a class on business ethics.
 
The New York Times suggests that the government should regulate Google’s search algorithm…you know…because the government doesn’t have stuff like the economy, jobs and housing to fix first.:rolleyes:

But your comment is just as bad.. Government fixing the economy, housing and jobs is not their responsibility. That's why the WORLD is in such a bad shape (actually it's in bad shape due to lack of Godliness). Government is not the solution.. More government = more bad.
 
But your comment is just as bad.. Government fixing the economy, housing and jobs is not their responsibility. That's why the WORLD is in such a bad shape (actually it's in bad shape due to lack of Godliness). Government is not the solution.. More government = more bad.

actually Income tax / Federal reserve was founded under the guise of maintaining a stable economy......They just never specified for whom.
 
But your comment is just as bad.. Government fixing the economy, housing and jobs is not their responsibility. That's why the WORLD is in such a bad shape (actually it's in bad shape due to lack of Godliness). Government is not the solution.. More government = more bad.

Neither is more Godliness.
 
Government beaurocrazy isn't the answer. Don't like how Google's search results pan out? Use another search engine or make your own.

We need to be willing to fix our own problems. When did we turn into the land of the sheep and the home of the crazed?
 
because the government doesn’t have stuff like the economy, jobs and housing to fix first.

Even this is not a responsibility of our (USA) government, yet they felt the need to get seriously involved over the last century, and even more so as each day passes. Note our economy has gotten worse the more our government has gotten involved...

Free markets trump government interference every time.
 
Government beaurocrazy isn't the answer. Don't like how Google's search results pan out? Use another search engine or make your own.

We need to be willing to fix our own problems. When did we turn into the land of the sheep and the home of the crazed?

When government entitlements became a reality.

The "government housing" here in Huntsville AL has a rule that you are eligible for subsidized housing (really cheap rent on government housing) unless you make over
$100,000 a year....

The USA is becoming the United States of Entitlement.

Rememebr hearing about a lot of certain people thinking that they were going to get money from "Obama's stash"???

What about all the people who use food stamps to buy food and then use their money to buy grocery carts full of alchohol and cigarettes? I have seen it multiple times.

Hence why the libs are the looters, and a huge amount of their supporters are the moochers.

As long as the moochers get their entitlements, they will keep voting for the looters.
 
More government = more bad.

+100

This is exactly the problem, and why everything this administration has done for the last year and a half has ended up making things worse.

The main cause of the housing bubble was fanny mae and freddy mac. The new 2000+ page financial bill does NOTHING to fix the problem with these "government" run companies, but insteads burdens banks and small business with tons of new regulations. It's typical government over-reaction that lets the politically connected guilty go free, and punishes everyone else so they can pretend they are doing something about the problem.

Now Greenspan is saying to let the Bush tax cuts expire.
This is the current 800 pound gorilla that is going to kill the economy. I'm far from "rich", as my income is below the average for where I live, but if the Bush tax cuts are allowed to expire, my federal taxes will increase by at least $3000 (that's over 50%) This is based on the base rate going from 10% to 15%, and the $500 per child credit going away.

Meanwhile, someone making over $250,000 (Obama's definition of the rich) will see thier rate go up from 34% to 39%. The total dollars might be more for the rich, but the percentage is MUCH higher on the middle class.

It's almost worth letting them expire, to finally put to rest the "tax cuts for the rich" lie. I'd love to see these people who voted for Obama, compaining about thier taxes doubling.
 
Political debates suck.

One asshole will have their own idea and another asshole will have his. Then the two assholes will get together and argue over why the other asshole is wrong.

Can you think of *any* political discussion where asshole A convinced asshole B that his ideas were wrong?

Just end it here, for the love of God (unless you're an atheist or agnostic or an asshole).

/thread :D
 
An interesting point. For many people, "google" is synonymous with "internet". If a single business entity has that much influence over the entire internet economy, is it in the public's best interest for it to be left under "private" control?

Obviously letting the "government" regulate is probably a bad idea, but the underlying idea (that Google might indeed be becoming "more" then just a business) is interesting.
 
What about all the people who use food stamps to buy food and then use their money to buy grocery carts full of alchohol and cigarettes? I have seen it multiple times.
.

I have seen people in $75,000 cars use foodstamps, i have seen couples use foodstamps to pay for a wedding cake at publix before. You hit that nail right on the head my friend
 
Political debates suck.

One asshole will have their own idea and another asshole will have his. Then the two assholes will get together and argue over why the other asshole is wrong.

Can you think of *any* political discussion where asshole A convinced asshole B that his ideas were wrong?

Just end it here, for the love of God (unless you're an atheist or agnostic or an asshole).

/thread :D

Amen, brother ...
 
So much troll bait...

Anyway, the NY times needs to STFU. Google is not mandatory or even remotely restrictive. You can always go to any other search engine for no additional cost and you could even start your *own* search engine without having to fight your way through some monopoly control of the resources.
 
Really, I think the government should regulate The New York Times.. Oh Wait...
 
But your comment is just as bad.. Government fixing the economy, housing and jobs is not their responsibility. That's why the WORLD is in such a bad shape (actually it's in bad shape due to lack of Godliness). Government is not the solution.. More government = more bad.
LOL. Religion is one of the bigger sources of the world's problems, not the solution. Wake up.
 
Did I wake up in China?

Here's a tip NY Times, if you don't like Google, Go elsewhere....
 
No, no, no, no, no.
No.
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
Nooooooooo.
No.
No one gets the Google... but Google. F-off NYT.
 
The only thing God and Goverment have taught me is that they're bad at math.

Heaven help us if Google search results do fall under US regulation: All the millions of search results we don't click on will somehow add to the deficit.
 
LOL. Religion is one of the bigger sources of the world's problems, not the solution. Wake up.

It's not religion that's the problem, it's all the power hungry polititians and others that use religion for thier own personal gain.
 
Political debates suck.

One asshole will have their own idea and another asshole will have his. Then the two assholes will get together and argue over why the other asshole is wrong.

Can you think of *any* political discussion where asshole A convinced asshole B that his ideas were wrong?

/thread :D

So you think that a massive tax increase will HELP the economy?

If you actually study history (not the biased junk they teach in most schools nowdays) you'll see that these same mistakes have been made before. It's amazing how poeple who are suppose to be so smart, are so ignorant of history.
 
Political debates suck.

One asshole will have their own idea and another asshole will have his. Then the two assholes will get together and argue over why the other asshole is wrong.

Can you think of *any* political discussion where asshole A convinced asshole B that his ideas were wrong?

Just end it here, for the love of God (unless you're an atheist or agnostic or an asshole).

/thread :D

thank you!
 
So the article is about the NYT questioning whether or not the US government should regulate google. Does every single article that mentions the US government have to offer at least 3 pages of "taxes R bad" tripe in the comments section?
 
So you think that a massive tax increase will HELP the economy?

If you actually study history (not the biased junk they teach in most schools nowdays) you'll see that these same mistakes have been made before. It's amazing how poeple who are suppose to be so smart, are so ignorant of history.

You didn't even read the thread you quoted did you? Be honest...

Did I say anywhere in my thread about my specific views on *this* political debate? Sigh... this is what I am talking about.

You, my friend, are Asshole A. ;)
 
+100

This is exactly the problem, and why everything this administration has done for the last year and a half has ended up making things worse.

The main cause of the housing bubble was fanny mae and freddy mac. The new 2000+ page financial bill does NOTHING to fix the problem with these "government" run companies, but insteads burdens banks and small business with tons of new regulations. It's typical government over-reaction that lets the politically connected guilty go free, and punishes everyone else so they can pretend they are doing something about the problem.

Now Greenspan is saying to let the Bush tax cuts expire.
This is the current 800 pound gorilla that is going to kill the economy. I'm far from "rich", as my income is below the average for where I live, but if the Bush tax cuts are allowed to expire, my federal taxes will increase by at least $3000 (that's over 50%) This is based on the base rate going from 10% to 15%, and the $500 per child credit going away.

Meanwhile, someone making over $250,000 (Obama's definition of the rich) will see thier rate go up from 34% to 39%. The total dollars might be more for the rich, but the percentage is MUCH higher on the middle class.

It's almost worth letting them expire, to finally put to rest the "tax cuts for the rich" lie. I'd love to see these people who voted for Obama, compaining about thier taxes doubling.

Err..... $3000 increase in tax also being 50% increase? Either you have tons of kids or don't understand tax brackets it sounds like. The 10% bracket away will only increase taxes by $400 or so. So you got 5 kids?
 
An interesting point. For many people, "google" is synonymous with "internet". If a single business entity has that much influence over the entire internet economy, is it in the public's best interest for it to be left under "private" control?
Yes. You'd rather trust it to the organization which brought you the train wreck of the Katrina aftermath and creates business cycles with the help of its central bank?
 
Look at how great atheist leaders have been Mao, Stalin, and Pol Pot.

I love how when religion is brought up people always point to the 'demon' atheists to try and prove a point. How about Warren Buffett, Bill Gates and Linus Torvalds? Three atheists (or at least agnostics) who people on these boards would recognize?

Your religion, no matter which one, does not instantly turn you into an angel or a demon. It is your own actions that do that.
 
An interesting point. For many people, "google" is synonymous with "internet". If a single business entity has that much influence over the entire internet economy, is it in the public's best interest for it to be left under "private" control?

Obviously letting the "government" regulate is probably a bad idea, but the underlying idea (that Google might indeed be becoming "more" then just a business) is interesting.

I don't see a problem with google taking advantage of the marketing power of the internet? Before it was AOL? And every nub called the internets, "AOL".

Despite the large profit Google could make and control over the net they could gain over this, it is still better off than the alternatives.

People seem to think that when the government gets involved, the company loses power? Then in the same breath, they complain about lobbyists controlling our regulation, laws, rules, and tax dollars.

What I would suspect would happen, based upon everything else in this country... is if the government started regulating search engines, google would lobby for regulation that would benefit itself under these same regulations. This would reduce competition, increase their market share, favor them over the long term. Then the people who think regulations solve everything would blame lobbyists and capitalism rather than the government which shouldn't be involved to begin with to even have lobbyists approach them.

I suspect there are possible consequences long term if Google got even more in bed with the government, that search results would end up being biased in a way that would promote government agenda. Much like other forms of media all throughout history in just about every country including our own.

Ultimately, I guess what I'm getting at, is I don't see any moral high ground on having the government regulate Google's attempt to push it's agenda over the government pushing it's agenda, and Google's agenda?

Josh
 
I find it amusing that the same people that had a problem with Microsoft determining who they would and wouldn't do business with regarding OS pre-installs now have no issue whatsoever with Google being the de-facto standard of internet searches. Companies and ideas live and die by how easy they are to find on a Google search.

Not that there should be any governmental regulations regarding what Google does with their search algorithms. But I think people are getting WAY too caught up in the "gub'mint good, gub'mint bad" pointlessness when they should be discussing the far more interesting and important topic of how much power one company has over the internet as we know it.
 
LOL. Religion is one of the bigger sources of the world's problems, not the solution. Wake up.

+1

But the poster who posted what you quoted was not speaking of religion.

Even Jesus spoke out against religion.

Godliness is not the same thing as religion... far from it.

Who was rebuked constantly by Jesus when he was here? The self-righteous religious priks.. that's who!
 
I find it amusing that the same people that had a problem with Microsoft determining who they would and wouldn't do business with regarding OS pre-installs now have no issue whatsoever with Google being the de-facto standard of internet searches. Companies and ideas live and die by how easy they are to find on a Google search.

Not that there should be any governmental regulations regarding what Google does with their search algorithms. But I think people are getting WAY too caught up in the "gub'mint good, gub'mint bad" pointlessness when they should be discussing the far more interesting and important topic of how much power one company has over the internet as we know it.

Excellent points, and most of the time people will complain about gub'mint until they are in need of help. The crux of the problem is that event horizon of government involvement. At what point does it tip from being beneficial to the public and become wasteful over-regulation. Where do you draw the fine line and how do you determine whether getting involved in the first place is warranted by the possible outcomes.
 
I want Obama Bucks for my crappy house price, but alias I don't qualify, but have to be one of the stupid people who bought to much house. We are becoming a socialist country.

And Google should be able to do whatever the Fook they want. You don't like them, use Yahoo or someone else. or is the government going to shut down all the other search providers?

That way they can regulate it better.

What a sack of Doo Doo.
 
Excellent points, and most of the time people will complain about gub'mint until they are in need of help. The crux of the problem is that event horizon of government involvement. At what point does it tip from being beneficial to the public and become wasteful over-regulation.
As soon as it does comes into being.
 
Back
Top