Military Asserts Right to Return Cyber Attacks

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Go ahead and launch a cyberattack against the U.S. military…see what happens. Something tells me the term “returning fire in cyberspace” is code for “we will kick your ass.”

He added that while "this right has not been specifically established by legal precedent to apply to attacks in cyberspace, it is reasonable to assume that returning fire in cyberspace, as long as it complied with law of war principles ... would be lawful."
 
We're already being attacked by the Chinese, or so I hear. Are they sure they can retaliate with any skill?
 
So what, are they gonna fire off DDOS attacks? Try and use your internets now, North Korea!
 
That's right, we fight internets.... with internets.
 
There are hardlines that run from continent to continent right? Time to use the world's largest pair of scissors and cut the one going to eastern asia....hell, at least China will be happy :)
 
On one hand, this is a good thing. On the other hand, the article made it sound like to people giving the commands were a little too overconfident. I hope they don't overestimate our resources. we may be superior militarilly, but in cyberspace I think we might get a run for our money . . .
 
Previous posters seems to have missed the point.
The incoming attacks are initiated from one or a few extremely hard to find locations, but carried out from computers worldwide (inside US borders as well). These are precision "surgical" strikes with a minimum of collateral damage.
Retaliating directly against the initiators is virtually impossible, so the only way to retaliate is to strike back on all attacking computers, owned by innocent bystanders, which means that by principle all damage will be collateral. The only damage to the attacker is a lost or crippled botnet.

Any such form of retaliation attack will of course have severe problems trying to "... conform to international law and guiding military principles."
If I'm attacked by a sniper hiding somewhere in a fully populated city I can't use "self defence" as a justification for retaliating with a strategical nuke...

Cheers
Olle
 
Previous posters seems to have missed the point.
The incoming attacks are initiated from one or a few extremely hard to find locations, but carried out from computers worldwide (inside US borders as well). These are precision "surgical" strikes with a minimum of collateral damage.
Retaliating directly against the initiators is virtually impossible, so the only way to retaliate is to strike back on all attacking computers, owned by innocent bystanders, which means that by principle all damage will be collateral. The only damage to the attacker is a lost or crippled botnet.

Any such form of retaliation attack will of course have severe problems trying to "... conform to international law and guiding military principles."
If I'm attacked by a sniper hiding somewhere in a fully populated city I can't use "self defence" as a justification for retaliating with a strategical nuke...

Cheers
Olle

Good point (bad analogy though)...but fuck 'em. If somebody has let their PC get owned and used for attacks they deserve to have it burned. May finally wake up many to the importance of keeping a secure PC and network. The asshole politicians can get on TV and tell us all that "Not using Anti-Virus Software means the terrorists win!!11" or some such garbage and we'll sell more security products than ever. Considering that upside, I am kinda surprised it hasn't happened already. Capitalism at it's finest. ;)
 
Chinese gov. is already practicing on us. I would think we need our "troops" to acquire some experience as well.

Previous posters seems to have missed the point.
The incoming attacks are initiated from one or a few extremely hard to find locations, but carried out from computers worldwide (inside US borders as well). These are precision "surgical" strikes with a minimum of collateral damage.
Retaliating directly against the initiators is virtually impossible, so the only way to retaliate is to strike back on all attacking computers, owned by innocent bystanders, which means that by principle all damage will be collateral. The only damage to the attacker is a lost or crippled botnet.

Any such form of retaliation attack will of course have severe problems trying to "... conform to international law and guiding military principles."
If I'm attacked by a sniper hiding somewhere in a fully populated city I can't use "self defence" as a justification for retaliating with a strategical nuke...

Cheers
Olle

Wow, I bet the military didn't think of that. They aren't sophisticated enough to realize that they are only going to harm the by-standards. And of course there is no possibility that they would have better capabilities then we estimate. You better hurry and stop them before they unwittingly push the red button! They will NEVER find the originating source!
:p
 
We're already being attacked by the Chinese, or so I hear. Are they sure they can retaliate with any skill?

Yeah all the hackers that have been caught in the US, have been given the choice of prison or the Military cyber defence specialist position.;)
 
I can picture one day a couple hundred machines going poof in homes around the world as zombie machines are counter attacked by the USAF, or better yet Predator strike. The new Cold War, knocking down internet in a community near you.
 
You HaX0red me. I'll HaX0r you. All your base are belong to us.
 
Chinese gov. is already practicing on us. I would think we need our "troops" to acquire some experience as well.



Wow, I bet the military didn't think of that. They aren't sophisticated enough to realize that they are only going to harm the by-standards. And of course there is no possibility that they would have better capabilities then we estimate. You better hurry and stop them before they unwittingly push the red button! They will NEVER find the originating source!
:p

Do you honestly think that people on internet forums like this one are the only ones that know about bot nets, and zombie machines to launch attacks? Or is my sarcasm detector on the fritz?
 
So is this going to be like the "War on Drugs" or the "War on Terror" where there is no result from all the "actions"?
 
I'm finding it funny to think that military cyber attacks might actually contain the subject line "Make your peen larger!"
 
So is this going to be like the "War on Drugs" or the "War on Terror" where there is no result from all the "actions"?

Yep just like that, you won't hear anything after the initial offense defense starts, and there won't be any HMD's (Hacks of Mass Disruption) found.
 
Do you honestly think that people on internet forums like this one are the only ones that know about bot nets, and zombie machines to launch attacks? Or is my sarcasm detector on the fritz?

I've been mistaken for sarcasm before. I thought the :p smilie might have helped. ;)

So is this going to be like the "War on Drugs" or the "War on Terror" where there is no result from all the "actions"?

Ideally, the results will be no (known) result at all. Our systems work fine and we don't get hacked during war. "nothing happening" is a good thing.
 
I"f I'm attacked by a sniper hiding somewhere in a fully populated city I can't use "self defence" as a justification for retaliating with a strategical nuke"

That's a terrible comparison, it's only valid if the sniper is somehow getting the civilians to shoot at you. In which case, game on. A better real life comparison might be inciting a riot. I think the military might start using virtual tear gas on botnets.
 
If somebody has let their PC get owned and used for attacks they deserve to have it burned. ... Considering that upside, I am kinda surprised it hasn't happened already. Capitalism at it's finest. ;)
You didn't see this report, did you?
Burn 88% of the Fortune 500 and the terrorists win!

Cheers
Olle
 
Reports like that are extremely misleading. While I have no doubt that many companies, including large and powerful ones, have been touched by this botnet to some degree, I highly doubt they would come crumbling down at the loss of the infected machines. For smaller companies that may not be the case but unfortunately some lessons are only learned the hard way.
 
Back
Top