New Socket to Replace LGA1366 in 2011

You'll be saying that forever the way technology is. i7 is a great processor and will be for awhile. ;)

Exactly. 1366 is very affordable right now. I can't see why someone would wait to pay a higher cost for something that may not give a significant performance increase when it's released, along with a very high early adoption cost. Not to mention that it's not going to be released until late 2011. I can't see how a person can wait until then unless they like to watch grass grow. Buy 1366 now and wait how this new socket performs.

If I could pickup a 980x in Q2 2011 for around $500 bucks I would jump on it. Plus 12GB's of ram I think the X58 chipset would useful for quite sometime.

This is my plan also. I can't see how I will need any more power than a 980x in the next 2-3 years. Unless all X68 chips are 20-28nm 6-core CPUs, I can't see the initial advantage over 1366 besides a native 3.0 USB/SATA controller for ICH11R.

I was looking at either LGA1366 or 1156, as 2011 falls within my 3 year upgrade plan. Time to watch and see what happens now.

Yep. Especially if you purchased the 1366 socket back in 2008. Three years is a good amount of time to have one CPU.
 
The problem with changing sockets too fast shows up when your board dies and you need a replacement but nobody makes a compatible replacement anymore. With $500 to $1000 CPU's on the market I'd be awfully upset if after a year I could no longer get an equivalent board because of Intel's greed.

Maybe not now but think about having an 1156 board on a 6 month old PC and it's spring 2011. Even with a warranty if something goes wrong you're going to get a refurb board. Asus is sending out refurbish for warranty replacement on nearly new boards right now!

I've seen this happen with my clients more than once and it's irritating when a fix that would have taken 15 minutes turns into a rebuild because you had to use a new board and CPU. Let's not even mention the cost involved.

If the whole physical architecture is going to change every year then stop selling PC components with the promise of "upgradability" normal people don't upgrade their hardware every 6 months.
 
unless my i7 920 is devastatingly inadequate (unlikely) or the new socket is called 1337, i doubt ill be upgrading for at least a year after it comes out.
 
Intel needs to be like AMD, pick a socket and stick to it.

Errrr what? AMD has had a ton of sockets. Within the time frame of Intel's 775 socket alone, AMD went through 5 sockets. Ranging as far back as Socket A to the AM2. As for change in the 775. It only saw two revisions. That of the Pentium 4 era & that of the C2D era. It's still less than AMD's 5 sockets during that time frame.
 
wow, didn't think of that.. Intel really missed the boat if 1337 isn't a new socket in the near future.
 
I don't like how that article states there is going to be 4 DIMM slots only if its quad channel... I mean, WTF? Whats wrong with adding 8 slots? If this is true, not impressed.
 
The problem with changing sockets too fast shows up when your board dies and you need a replacement but nobody makes a compatible replacement anymore. With $500 to $1000 CPU's on the market I'd be awfully upset if after a year I could no longer get an equivalent board because of Intel's greed.

http://www.google.com/products?q=socket+478+motherboard&hl=en&aq=f
Socket 478 boards, many of them from 845 to 965 chipset. Those are from 2004 or earlier, 6yrs plus old. How freaking long do you want obsolete computer parts to remain available? That's almost getting absurd. Beyond that, there is eBay.

Second, you use the word "greed" as if it has a negative connotation to it. When it is really only describing the nature that all people have in order to survive, especially businesses. Their entire motive is to turn a profit. If they don't turn a profit, and aren't successful in the market then the ten's of thousands of employees they support would not be able to provide food/shelter/etc for their families.

The cheap, economical thing to do, is to reuse parts as much as possible. Minimize SKU's, get reduced cost through large scale production. It costs Intel a lot to change platforms, sockets. There is a lot of engineering R&D, tooling costs, testing, etc etc. that goes into developing a new socket/platform. They change sockets when there is a specific engineering design/strategic need in order to further performance and thus maintain competitive in the market.

Maybe not now but think about having an 1156 board on a 6 month old PC and it's spring 2011. Even with a warranty if something goes wrong you're going to get a refurb board. Asus is sending out refurbish for warranty replacement on nearly new boards right now!

I've seen this happen with my clients more than once and it's irritating when a fix that would have taken 15 minutes turns into a rebuild because you had to use a new board and CPU. Let's not even mention the cost involved.

If the whole physical architecture is going to change every year then stop selling PC components with the promise of "upgradability" normal people don't upgrade their hardware every 6 months.
What is wrong with a refurb? Refurb is a very grey area with no clear defintion. It could be parts that just never made it into retail packaging, were returned due to buyers remorse, were sent in for repair by ASUS's technicians. More than likely an ASUS trained technician tested and verified the board as good. Why is this a problem?

PC components are marketed toward different kinds of people simultaneously. Board makers don't know if it's casual or enthusiast users who are reading, they have to answer to both. A computer that is over 6 years old is about ready to be put to pasture anyway. It has so many other legacy components, outdated USB, SATA interfaces, expansion ports, it's more than likely time for a serious system overhaul.
 
I don't like how that article states there is going to be 4 DIMM slots only if its quad channel... I mean, WTF? Whats wrong with adding 8 slots? If this is true, not impressed.
Board real-estate for the physical sockets and for the traces. The additional PCB layers to support that many slots is likely cost prohibitive even in the enthusiast market. Look at server boards that have that many and look at the prices.
 
Errrr what? AMD has had a ton of sockets. Within the time frame of Intel's 775 socket alone, AMD went through 5 sockets. Ranging as far back as Socket A to the AM2. As for change in the 775. It only saw two revisions. That of the Pentium 4 era & that of the C2D era. It's still less than AMD's 5 sockets during that time frame.
Don't forget to mention to him that even as Intel evolved the chipsets that used the 775, they all maintained backwards compatibility. Even the latest and last P45 chipset would support old Pentium 4's.
 
I always upgrade my board and ram whenever I get a CPU anyway. Speeds have gotten to a point that I don't know how long I will wait until I upgrade from my i7 860. With the memory controller (and sometimes PCI-E lanes) on board the CPU, Intel will have to change the socket every time they make a change to the memory configuration. (and PCI-E Lanes)

I'd rather have to deal with the sockets changing that deal with stagnant technology.

The only thing that annoys me is the changes with the HSF mounting holes when they don't seem necessary. For example I think they should have made the holes the same for 1366 and 1156.
 
Don't forget to mention to him that even as Intel evolved the chipsets that used the 775, they all maintained backwards compatibility. Even the latest and last P45 chipset would support old Pentium 4's.

Most motherboards with a p41 and up chipset don't support the P4's, just core based processors.

Intel G45
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813121355

processor support list
http://processormatch.intel.com/CompDB/SearchResult.aspx?BoardName=DG45ID
 
Most motherboards with a p41 and up chipset don't support the P4's, just core based processors.

Intel G45
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813121355

processor support list
http://processormatch.intel.com/CompDB/SearchResult.aspx?BoardName=DG45ID
Weird, must be a odd matrix of support. I mostly deal with the enthusiast line P35/P45 etc line such as ASUS's P5Q P45 chipset series such as this which does support the old stuff.
http://support.asus.com/cpusupport/cpusupport.aspx?SLanguage=en-us&model=P5Q
 
Most motherboards with a p41 and up chipset don't support the P4's, just core based processors.

Intel G45
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813121355

processor support list
http://processormatch.intel.com/CompDB/SearchResult.aspx?BoardName=DG45ID
Further looking, ASUS and other parties support Pentium 4 on even your G45 chipset. This is a bios limitation for that specific motherboard. The chipset and socket are still potentially backwards compatible if the bios is setup to support it, as in ASUS's case.
http://www.asus.com/product.aspx?P_ID=jR7eO7eY08cBntsR&templete=2
 
I understand that. I was pointing out even though the chipset supports it, some MFG's don't have a bios for it.
 
http://www.google.com/products?q=socket+478+motherboard&hl=en&aq=f
Socket 478 boards, many of them from 845 to 965 chipset. Those are from 2004 or earlier, 6yrs plus old. How freaking long do you want obsolete computer parts to remain available? That's almost getting absurd. Beyond that, there is eBay.

Second, you use the word "greed" as if it has a negative connotation to it. When it is really only describing the nature that all people have in order to survive, especially businesses. Their entire motive is to turn a profit. If they don't turn a profit, and aren't successful in the market then the ten's of thousands of employees they support would not be able to provide food/shelter/etc for their families.

The cheap, economical thing to do, is to reuse parts as much as possible. Minimize SKU's, get reduced cost through large scale production. It costs Intel a lot to change platforms, sockets. There is a lot of engineering R&D, tooling costs, testing, etc etc. that goes into developing a new socket/platform. They change sockets when there is a specific engineering design/strategic need in order to further performance and thus maintain competitive in the market.

What is wrong with a refurb? Refurb is a very grey area with no clear defintion. It could be parts that just never made it into retail packaging, were returned due to buyers remorse, were sent in for repair by ASUS's technicians. More than likely an ASUS trained technician tested and verified the board as good. Why is this a problem?

PC components are marketed toward different kinds of people simultaneously. Board makers don't know if it's casual or enthusiast users who are reading, they have to answer to both. A computer that is over 6 years old is about ready to be put to pasture anyway. It has so many other legacy components, outdated USB, SATA interfaces, expansion ports, it's more than likely time for a serious system overhaul.

More often than not refurb means returned or repaired. If I buy a brand new board and it's a dud I want another brand new board not some questionable stand in.

Yeah, greed is bad unless you're still living in 1985. Greed is why the economy is in the crapper. So yeah, I don't like greed. Profit and greed aren't the same thing. Profit is what's left over after a business pays all it's bills. Greed is specifically trying to screw everyone from the supply chain to the end consumer to get more money for yourself. That's just bad Karma dude...

I also don't agree with the R&D argument. If what you profess were so the P4 and the Core 2 Quad would never have worked in the same 775 socket. I've got a Gigabyte board right now that can support everything from a P4 to a core 2 quad right now as a matter of fact.

I'm also not saying that socket 478 or equivalent should still be considered current what I'm saying is turning over physical architectures (meaning sockets and the like) has been more about forcing premature upgrades than for any engineering purpose.

Oh yeah, and I disagree with your whole premise too.

:cool:
 
I was thinking about upgrading to i7, but I guess I may wait until this new socket comes out. To be honest, my current system has yet to let me down.
 
Back
Top