External Raid Enclosure for video capture and editing

Vcize

n00b
Joined
Apr 4, 2010
Messages
14
I do a lot of work with game (as in videogame) promos. I capture most of the video using this: http://www.amazon.com/Hauppauge-1212-Definition-Personal-Recorder/dp/B0018LX0DY

Currently for my workflow I have an Intel X25 SSD for my OS install where I have all my video editing software installed. Then I just have a separate internal hard drive that I capture the video on and edit it from.

I do get some frame drops and whatnot when recording, so I'm looking to upgrade and set up a raid array for my capture and to edit from.

I'd like to be able to hold a lot of footage so I'm thinking Raid-5 with 2tb drives. I'm looking for a good Raid-5 enclosure that can hold three to five drives at least and give me decent recording ability without dropping frames, and will be fast to edit from.

Also, I'm still a bit confused on how this all works. Do I need the enclosure and then also a Raid card, and does the Raid card go in the computer? My motherboard has an eSata port on it, but is that only for software raid?
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
The frame drops are most likely due to your processor/RAM/capture card not being fast enough.

What processor/ram do you have?
 
The frame drops are most likely due to your processor/RAM/capture card not being fast enough.

What processor/ram do you have?

Q9450 processor with 4gb ram.

Your cheapest solution would be to buy a RAID card like this:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16816118105&cm_re=9260-8i-_-16-118-105-_-Product

and these hitachis:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822145298

and make the RAID inside your existing case.

Unfortunately space and power are both going to be issues in my current case, so an external enclosure would probably be ideal.
 
Also, I'm still a bit confused on how this all works. Do I need the enclosure and then also a Raid card, and does the Raid card go in the computer? My motherboard has an eSata port on it, but is that only for software raid?

Most RAID Enclosures come with an add-on card that you install into the PC that allows you to use and set-up the RAID array/enclosure. However do note that most of those RAID enclosures pretty much uses software RAID to create and maintain the RAID array. So rather than help, it might hurt as CPU cycles from your PC is being used for parity calculations.
 
why will it cause headaches? I am thinking of getting the LSI MegaRaid 9280-8e, but I am not sure now after seeing what you said.
I owned that card and promptly returned it. The management software was such a POS that I couldn't even get an array up and running. You can ask nitrobass24 about it. I brought it over to his place and showed him when I was troubleshooting stuff. :p
 
I owned that card and promptly returned it. The management software was such a POS that I couldn't even get an array up and running. You can ask nitrobass24 about it. I brought it over to his place and showed him when I was troubleshooting stuff. :p


Ok. Thanks. That's good to know. But it seems that the LSI cards are generally faster than the Areca. Most Areca still use pci-express 1.0, while the LSI are using 2.0 .
 
Ok. Thanks. That's good to know. But it seems that the LSI cards are generally faster than the Areca. Most Areca still use pci-express 1.0, while the LSI are using 2.0 .
Areca's new cards should be out within a month. The fact that they use PCIe 1.0 doesn't affect them (since they are still processor limited).
 
Most RAID Enclosures come with an add-on card that you install into the PC that allows you to use and set-up the RAID array/enclosure. However do note that most of those RAID enclosures pretty much uses software RAID to create and maintain the RAID array. So rather than help, it might hurt as CPU cycles from your PC is being used for parity calculations.

Thanks.

Would buying a separate hardware raid card get past this (just take the crappy card they gave me with the enclosure and toss it out, and then just plug that enclosure into a hardware raid card that I purchased separately)?
 
You might try this:
http://www.frys.com/product/6139609?site=sr:SEARCH:MAIN_RSLT_PG

I've got 5 of the older AMS T5s...these are strickley eSata with Port Multiplier. so I have no idea how well this version works..however, the new version is has a hardware raid controller (I'm sure not very powerful) built right into the case.

Given that you already have an eSata port, this would seem like an extremely cost efficient way to go...given the price of this is just north of $200.
 
Ok. Thanks. That's good to know. But it seems that the LSI cards are generally faster than the Areca. Most Areca still use pci-express 1.0, while the LSI are using 2.0 .

PCIe 2.0 has nothing to do with it. The bottle neck is the IOP, and SAS1

SAS2 and the new ROC on these newer cards raises your throughput but it will only be realized on setups that have 10+ disks or SSDs
 
x2 on the capture card. You have enough RAM that your capture card should have somewhere to put it's output at all times, should never have to scrap any frames. But if your capture card can't encode fast enough then there's no output from it to need a place for. This thing says bitrates up to 21Mbit per second. That's like 2.3MB a second or something. Nothing of consequence for even a crappy storage system. It also seems like the host PCs CPU does alot of heavy lifting during capture. Check your CPU usage during capture, if it's pegged then storage definetly isn't your problem.

Dustin
 
I do a lot of work with game (as in videogame) promos. I capture most of the video using this: http://www.amazon.com/Hauppauge-1212-Definition-Personal-Recorder/dp/B0018LX0DY

Currently for my workflow I have an Intel X25 SSD for my OS install where I have all my video editing software installed. Then I just have a separate internal hard drive that I capture the video on and edit it from.

I do get some frame drops and whatnot when recording, so I'm looking to upgrade and set up a raid array for my capture and to edit from.

I'd like to be able to hold a lot of footage so I'm thinking Raid-5 with 2tb drives. I'm looking for a good Raid-5 enclosure that can hold three to five drives at least and give me decent recording ability without dropping frames, and will be fast to edit from.

Also, I'm still a bit confused on how this all works. Do I need the enclosure and then also a Raid card, and does the Raid card go in the computer? My motherboard has an eSata port on it, but is that only for software raid?


What is your video source? Are you capturing HD videos or just standard definition? What bitrate do you use?
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top