New 600GB VelociRaptor

Aztlan

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Aug 3, 2002
Messages
3,057
it seems WD has been working on a 5th Generation Raptor

WDC has decided that it is time for a refresh in order to push its capacity advantage further, and is currently developing its fifth generation Raptor. It will also be a 10k RPM drive, but will utilize advances in areal density to achieve a 600GB capacity with two platters. The new drive will also have "a significantly larger cache", but our source won't specify whether it was 32MB or 64MB. The best part will be the pricing, as it will launch at close to the original launch price of the 300GB VelociRaptor. A new single platter 300GB version will follow later on.

Source
 
Meh... I think 300 GB is plenty for most people. I would rather have a SSD over any size HD.

Just like the real dinosaurs, the Raptor will eventually become extinct.
 
I had 2x74gb raptors raid striped back in 05, 2x300gb velociraptors raid striped in 07. Great speed and responsiveness.
Just as it did with the original raptor the speed of high density 7200rpm drives has become equal to the raptor now so an update is certainly past due.
With 2TB drives pumping out 100-120MBps, SSD drives coming down in cost, and SAS connections becoming available on high end consumer boards WD is really gonna have to carve out a niche here. Personally I think if they are going to push performance hard drives they should go SAS, 15k or both.
 
Personally I think if they are going to push performance hard
drives they should go SAS, 15k or both.

SAS offers increased management/reliability capabilities but performance is still limited by the drive.

15K would help but good luck to WD in making one that doesnt sound like a jet engine. Velociraptor is obsolete as far as I'm concerened. One SSD for OS and apps, one mechanical drive for movies, etc
 
Meh... I think 300 GB is plenty for most people. I would rather have a SSD over any size HD.

Just like the real dinosaurs, the Raptor will eventually become extinct.

300GB isn't NEARLY enough for just my apps and games anymore. But SSDs are the future but the prices need to come down a lot and it would be nice to be able to buy one larger than 250GB. The 512GB and 1TB models that have been launched are still not for sale that I can find.
 
300GB isn't NEARLY enough for just my apps and games anymore. But SSDs are the future but the prices need to come down a lot and it would be nice to be able to buy one larger than 250GB. The 512GB and 1TB models that have been launched are still not for sale that I can find.

Seriously? Wow, I run a lot of stuff and I am using only 50gb or so on my OS partition. Most of which being the OS.

Programs dont take up that much space. I realize games do, but do you need to have every one you own installed at once? :eek:
 
The 512GB and 1TB models that have been launched are still not for sale that I can find.

As of Monday, Newegg had OCZ 500gb and 1TB SSD for sale. If you're crazy enough to spend $1,650 or $3,900 for each then more power to you! :D
 
Rather than a 600gb VR I'd have preferred to see something more innovative. Maybe a hybrid single platter 2.5" 300gb VR with a 20-40gb SSD in there as well.

As a marketing tactic something like this would allow them to migrate the Raptor name fully to SSD's eventually.
 
[LYL]Homer;1035146993 said:
As a marketing tactic something like this would allow them to migrate the Raptor name fully to SSD's eventually.

agreed.
 
Last edited:
I think its good that they are still developing bigger and faster mechanical disks. It will be a long time before SSDs take over the larger storage market and if they are priced right I might be interested in buying a few.
 
15K would help but good luck to WD in making one that doesnt sound like a jet engine. Velociraptor is obsolete as far as I'm concerened. One SSD for OS and apps, one mechanical drive for movies, etc

I agree, compared to regular 7.2K RPM drives (which are easily hitting 100MB/Sec read/write), a VelociRaptor doesn't have a chance from a cost/performance basis. The performance boost isn't large enough (nowhere near SSD) and it's gonna cost significantly more than a regular HD... Yeah it's still cheaper than a high-capacity SSD, but what's the point?
 
Velociraptor is obsolete as far as I'm concerened. One SSD for OS and apps, one mechanical drive for movies, etc

Agreed. Using a high performance drive for storage is just silly. You could easily put together an SSD/HDD combo with better read/write performance and far more storage for less $$$.

I believe SSD/HDD in such a combo will be the mainstream choice in the foreseeable future.
 
I agree, compared to regular 7.2K RPM drives (which are easily hitting 100MB/Sec read/write), a VelociRaptor doesn't have a chance from a cost/performance basis. The performance boost isn't large enough (nowhere near SSD) and it's gonna cost significantly more than a regular HD... Yeah it's still cheaper than a high-capacity SSD, but what's the point?

This is pretty much how I feel. SSD has taken the performance crown from the Raptor, while regular HDDs have gotten almost as fast as a Raptor while being much cheaper. The Raptor is now fairly expensive while still being somewhat slow, compared to other storage offerings. It's just not that impressive anymore.
 
There is a market for drives that are larger than SSDs that have significantly better performance than standard 7.2K. The question is how much faster and how much they will cost, and when larger SSDs are going to be available at a reasonable price.
 
Maybe the performance crown, but for the space, its still cheaper to have a raptor.
As the man said, for an OS drive, you can go with Intel G2 40GB SSD (wish i waited for it, its the perfect size for an OS drive)
but for your games and such, the SSDs are expensive.

So how big is your Steam folder after the recent sale? Yeah i though so.
 
Maybe the performance crown, but for the space, its still cheaper to have a raptor.
As the man said, for an OS drive, you can go with Intel G2 40GB SSD (wish i waited for it, its the perfect size for an OS drive)
but for your games and such, the SSDs are expensive.

So how big is your Steam folder after the recent sale? Yeah i though so.

FTA:
While many of these systems now use SSDs, WDC still believes that the VelociRaptor will continue to hold an important niche between SSDs and magnetic HDDs.
Even WD knows it's a niche product between "cheapest" and "fastest". We'll have to see how much faster these new models are, but compared to the current VRs, a regular WD6401AALS gives the same performance in a lot of tests, while being much larger and much cheaper. The VR is now the "budget extreme" option which isn't really that good at being budget or extreme.

I'm not saying that it's not better than a standard drive, because it is, mostly in access times. However, you're paying a large premium for a relatively small improvement in speed. You can get much faster access times by going to SSD, or you can get much bigger/cheaper drives by going with a regular HDD, which due to higher densities can sometimes be just as fast as a VR.

Especially if you're talking about having your primary files on SSD, using a VR over a regular HDD as your secondary drive probably won't get you much performance relative to how much more you're paying for it. The 6401AALS is only $60-$70. If the 600GB VR ends up being $300 (the current 300GB models seem to be around $200), that's 5 times the cost of a regular Black 640GB. Again, this depends on the final price and specs, but I'd most likely just get the Black and spend the extra $200+ on getting a bigger SSD. That's about the cost of going from an 80GB X25-M to the 160GB version, and that means another 80GB worth of apps getting the SSD boost. I think most people would find it better to have a 160GB SSD and a Black 640GB than an 80GB SSD and a 600GB VelociRaptor.
 
There is a market for drives that are larger than SSDs that have significantly better performance than standard 7.2K. The question is how much faster and how much they will cost, and when larger SSDs are going to be available at a reasonable price.

The problem is the price premium the VelociRaptors command has never corresponded to the (mild) performance advantage they have over regular 7.2K drives... That was fine when they were the only performance upgrade on the HD scene, but these days it's just not gonna cut it. Vast majority of users would rather make do w/several SSD in RAID if they really need extra capacity for their OS/programs.

So how big is your Steam folder after the recent sale? Yeah i though so.

What does it matter? Every game in your Steam folder doesn't need to be on an SSD, some of them will probably not even benefit significantly from it. It's not hard (or even inconvenient) to use hard or symbolic links to only split away the games that you really want on the SSD away from the main Steam folder (or vice versa).

As the above poster points out, there's very little leeway in pricing for a new Velociraptor to really be a reasonable option. If it's higher than $250 you're better off w/a lower capacity SSD for the performance alone (or several of them), even at that price it's 4x the price of a regular 7.2K HD of the same capacity and you're not getting anywhere near 4x the performance (unlike an SSD, where you're actually seeing more than that performance-wise).
 
This is very interesting. There's zero doubt that SSD's are the future, but they still have a ways to go in terms of size/price ratio. Today's 1 TB drives are pretty damn fast already, and come close to the Velociraptor's speed, so they'll really need to do some impressive stunts for the new product. Unless they really have some amazing ideas up their sleeve, I don't know how much farther they can take this.

Looks like nobody cares about WD refresh :)

Wha? There's a lot of posts here and the WD Raptor/Velociraptor products are very popular/well known.

Seriously? Wow, I run a lot of stuff and I am using only 50gb or so on my OS partition. Most of which being the OS.

Programs dont take up that much space. I realize games do, but do you need to have every one you own installed at once? :eek:

50 GB!? Yikes that's tiny. Sure, it'll hold an OS and maybe a game or two, but as soon as you save a picture or something, your OS will freak out from lack of space.
 
Back
Top