5850 slower than 8800GT

Qafyg

n00b
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
29
Hey guys,

I just upgraded my 8800gt with an XFX 5850 and to my surprise my FPS dropped drastically in the only game I'm currently playing, COD:MW2. I went from 80-90 steady FPS to 80-90 but with frequent drop to as low as 18 fps in the more demanding maps, like estate. (1680x1050, 0xAA, High details)

I noticed right away the gameplay was jerky/stuttering. I re-installed my 8800gt and fps are back up to 80-90 steady.

Any idea why this could be happening? I'm using the latest catalyst 9.12 drivers and I've tried a bunch of tweaks (vsync on/off, playing around with game settings, AA, etc.) to no avail.

Could there be a problem with the card? Could it be my powersupply not having enough juice? Is there any way to test if the card is physically fine? Any help is greatly appreciated

I'm using Fraps to monitor fps.

----
e8400
P5Q-e
Antec Truepower 2.0 550W
http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16817103932
2x2GB G.skill RAM
2x2 WD640AAKS
1TB Samsung
 
are you using higher settings on the 5850? (basically is anything changing at all?)

try cat 9.10 or 9.11 (I had a very similar issue to you with my 4870X2 and Cat 9.11/12, switching back to 9.10 seemed to fix it)

I'm thinking the card is physically fine if its working, it just sounds like a software configuration issue

also, did you happen to install F@H when you loaded the cat drivers up, and is that running in the background?
and did you un-install the nVidia drivers before loading up the new hardware?
 
You can't just yank out a NV card and expect an AMD card to work perfect (and vice versa)..... Too much clean up would be necessary to ensure you don't have driver issues - the only way do this is to reload windows.
 
Forgot to mention I'm using Windows XP 32bit.

I uninstalled the NVidia drivers from Add/Remove program before installing the ATI card and did the same, uninstalled the catalyst drivers from Add/remove before re-installing my 8800 GT.

Same in-game settings with both cards and I didnt install Folding @ home while installing the drivers. I initially only installed the drivers before noticing the problem, then I installed the whole catalyst suite to troubleshoot.

Man, I wish I had another 5850 and power supply just to rule those out. I'm gonna shoot myself if I re-install my OS and it turns out my 4-5 year old PS wasnt cutting it.
 
Try a different operating system (just as a test). There have been some other posts about lower than normal performance under Windows XP.
 
You can't just yank out a NV card and expect an AMD card to work perfect (and vice versa)..... Too much clean up would be necessary to ensure you don't have driver issues - the only way do this is to reload windows.

I originally was planning on a complete reinstall, but I figured it wouldn't waste too much time to try the lazy way. After a simple uninstall, safe mode driver sweeper, swap of cards, and install of the 9.11 Hotfix drivers went smooth and my performance is right where it should be.

So you don't need to reload Windows. At least, not always.
 
It's your OS. 5800 series wasn't supported initially in the XP drivers. I'm not sure if AMD fixed that with 9.12 but it's something to look into.

Now that 7 is here you ought to think about changing your OS in any case for the added functionality. Support for XP will eventually die as well and you're missing out of DX10 and 11 by sticking with XP.
 
Hey guys,

I just upgraded my 8800gt with an XFX 5850 and to my surprise my FPS dropped drastically in the only game I'm currently playing, COD:MW2. I went from 80-90 steady FPS to 80-90 but with frequent drop to as low as 18 fps in the more demanding maps, like estate. (1680x1050, 0xAA, High details)

I noticed right away the gameplay was jerky/stuttering. I re-installed my 8800gt and fps are back up to 80-90 steady.

Any idea why this could be happening? I'm using the latest catalyst 9.12 drivers and I've tried a bunch of tweaks (vsync on/off, playing around with game settings, AA, etc.) to no avail.

Could there be a problem with the card? Could it be my powersupply not having enough juice? Is there any way to test if the card is physically fine? Any help is greatly appreciated

I'm using Fraps to monitor fps.

----
e8400
P5Q-e
Antec Truepower 2.0 550W
http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?item=N82E16817103932
2x2GB G.skill RAM
2x2 WD640AAKS
1TB Samsung

http://support.amd.com/us/kbarticles/Pages/ATICatalyst912Hotfix.aspx

An OS reload might be needed, the link states it supports XP...
Typo?
o Windows® XP Vista 32-bit Edition

o Windows® XP Vista 64-bit Edition
 
did you max out your setting on 8800 GT?

from what I had on 8800 GTX is nowhere near 80-90 steady fps, lots of place in campaign like snow level I had a extreme stutter and frequently deep down to 20-30fps....
 
Seriously would people stop mentioning power supply issues in these threads, that isn't what happens when your power supply isn't strong enough at all. Stop giving advice when you're full of it.
 
Yeah, a PSU does not affect performance at all. Just stability, reliability, and longevity. While that PSU is well known for its above average failure rate and piss poor caps, it won't affect the performance in games.

Use Driver cleaner to completely clean out all remnants of both drivers and then reinstall the ATI drivers.
 
Its not the PS as others have said.

There is a def incompatibility somewhere. Have you tried uninstalling MW2 and then reinstalling? Game could have a config somewhere that's messing up the ATI card.
 
Alright, I'll re-install the OS on a old HD. I'll try XP first to see if it's working fine on a fresh XP install and then I'll reformat and test it in Win7. I guess that'll rule out the OS or a bad driver removal as a possible culprit.

On a side note, I'm getting steady 80-90 fps on MP maps. Still I've just ran The Gulag intro (AA:0x) and I get Min:47, Max:136, Avg:74 on my 8800GT.

Thanks for your help, I'll post my results.
 
Now don't hate me for asking this, but are you absolutely sure what you're experiencing just isn't lag or being on a bad server? It happens quite a bit in this game due to no dedicated servers. Driver issues generally can cause compatibility problems, not lower fps, but it is possible I suppose.

This does seem strange as I haven't seen this brought up before on this card and this game.
 
You can't just yank out a NV card and expect an AMD card to work perfect (and vice versa)..... Too much clean up would be necessary to ensure you don't have driver issues - the only way do this is to reload windows.

this is total nonsense

you can switch between nVidia, ATi, 3DLabs, 3dfx, Matrox, Intel, etc back and forth as many times as you like, as long as you remove and re-install the drivers

it isn't some "hard set" kernel mode feature that requires the kernel to be re-installed and re-compiled to enable, its a simple device driver

driver cleaner is more than sufficient for what you're doing (add/remove programs works just fine, run ccleaner if you're a bit paranoid)

and the PSU is *not* the problem, if the PSU couldn't handle the load it would either just drop the system, or you'd get arcs and sparks
 
this is total nonsense

you can switch between nVidia, ATi, 3DLabs, 3dfx, Matrox, Intel, etc back and forth as many times as you like, as long as you remove and re-install the drivers

it isn't some "hard set" kernel mode feature that requires the kernel to be re-installed and re-compiled to enable, its a simple device driver

driver cleaner is more than sufficient for what you're doing (add/remove programs works just fine, run ccleaner if you're a bit paranoid)

and the PSU is *not* the problem, if the PSU couldn't handle the load it would either just drop the system, or you'd get arcs and sparks


Agreed, I dont know what is more absurd, the suggestion to reinstall windows for a video card upgrade or the fact that PSU's get blamed for just about every issue around here. Granted a clean install may fix the problem, but that's like killing a cockroach with a stick of dynamite
 
i dont know how this turned into some big quibblefest, but like a few people have mentioned already...OP needs to run driver cleaner before reinstalling the OS, i mean thats a last resort type plan Z scenario
 
2x2GB + 1GB videocard on Windows 32bit?

Isn't there something wrong here....
 
It's your OS. 5800 series wasn't supported initially in the XP drivers. I'm not sure if AMD fixed that with 9.12 but it's something to look into.

Now that 7 is here you ought to think about changing your OS in any case for the added functionality. Support for XP will eventually die as well and you're missing out of DX10 and 11 by sticking with XP.

Nay, I popped my 5850 in my older XP box, 32 bit, and what you say is wrong. Performance in Win7 64bit IS better with a 5850 than on XP 32, but framerates in XP32 will still be alot better than with an 8800gt.

My older system has a pair of 8800gt sli, I pulled one out and the 5850 was getting much better frames. Tried it vs. the pair of 8800's and still the 5850 was doing better, but not by alot.

Though, OP, get win7 64!
 
its about time some of you guys put windows xp to rest. its a great os and all but time to let her go........i know its hard but ......you just got to:D
 
Is that really so bad? Get a bad enough infestation, and 1 stick per, and you have quite the show.

yeah but, you need a house to live in after its done (pun intended)

As far as get W7, thats not looking good for AMD (if they've actually abandoned the last two generations of MS OS' and adopted the LEAST adopted OS MS has out....)

although, it may very well improve things, it shouldn't be required
 
...As far as get W7, thats not looking good for AMD (if they've actually abandoned the last two generations of MS OS' and adopted the LEAST adopted OS MS has out....)...

No, I'm sure Vista support is equally fine. XP is the overgrown child.
 
I'm still experiencing stutter and fps drops using a fresh install of WinXP 32 bit. I've initially tried the Catalyst 9.12 drivers then downgraded to 9.10 but still no go.

I'll reformat and install 7 this afternoon to see if there's any improvements.
 
You can't just yank out a NV card and expect an AMD card to work perfect (and vice versa)..... Too much clean up would be necessary to ensure you don't have driver issues - the only way do this is to reload windows.

This must be a joke. You're yanking his chain right? :D

@OP, make sure your CCC 3D settings are set to "Use Application Settings." Perhaps AA is stuck on, I'd like to think people would notice AA is on if was intended it to be off... but nothing shocks me anymore. Anyhow, dick around with the CCC settings. Try shutting off the catalyst AI while you're in there.
 
Last edited:
I'm still experiencing stutter and fps drops using a fresh install of WinXP 32 bit. I've initially tried the Catalyst 9.12 drivers then downgraded to 9.10 but still no go.

I'll reformat and install 7 this afternoon to see if there's any improvements.

I think you're just experiencing shitty servers or just making this up. My pentium 4 2.8ghz 1gb of ram and 4850 can handle this game fine. You should try other games maybe post some benchmarks for comparison.
 
Problem Solved. It was windows XP. Game is running stellar in Windows 7 32bit. It's night and day. I'm pretty confident to say now that WinXP 32 can't run MW2 with an ATI 5850 given the current drivers. I just wish I knew that upfront. Still, I'm glad my card isnt defective or anything.

Time to upgrade I guess *sigh*. Anyways, thanks to everyone who help out narrowing the problem.
 
I think you're just experiencing shitty servers or just making this up. My pentium 4 2.8ghz 1gb of ram and 4850 can handle this game fine. You should try other games maybe post some benchmarks for comparison.

I've played so much MW2 with and without lag, that I was 100% sure it was not lag related and I've got better things to do than make fake problems up; like installing XP then installing Win7 on my thursday after noon :) Anyways, I understand it's hard to trust people when you're not actually seeing the issue with your own eyes.
 
Seriously would people stop mentioning power supply issues in these threads, that isn't what happens when your power supply isn't strong enough at all. Stop giving advice when you're full of it.

+1

Low power will cause the system to not boot, shut down during intense games, or crash during intense games.
 
I've played so much MW2 with and without lag, that I was 100% sure it was not lag related and I've got better things to do than make fake problems up; like installing XP then installing Win7 on my thursday after noon :) Anyways, I understand it's hard to trust people when you're not actually seeing the issue with your own eyes.

sry for doubting you, I just couldn't imagine my second shitty system running it fine but yours not, glad you got the issue worked out
 
You can't just yank out a NV card and expect an AMD card to work perfect (and vice versa)..... Too much clean up would be necessary to ensure you don't have driver issues - the only way do this is to reload windows.

I just did this and all I needed to do was uninstall the Nv driver packs, do one cleaning, and then pop the ATi card in and load the new drivers.. vista 64.. new card works fine.
 
i dont know how this turned into some big quibblefest, but like a few people have mentioned already...OP needs to run driver cleaner before reinstalling the OS, i mean thats a last resort type plan Z scenario

I think a quibblefest is in order, when completely wrong information is being offered as advice :D
 
Problem Solved. It was windows XP. Game is running stellar in Windows 7 32bit. It's night and day. I'm pretty confident to say now that WinXP 32 can't run MW2 with an ATI 5850 given the current drivers. I just wish I knew that upfront. Still, I'm glad my card isnt defective or anything.

Time to upgrade I guess *sigh*. Anyways, thanks to everyone who help out narrowing the problem.

Glad you got it sorted.

Just for peoples' info, I've happily swapped between nVidia and ATI cards on my PC without formatting or even running driver cleaner and its worked fine on both cards. Just uninstalled one set of drivers and installed the other, no performance decrease after swapping to one card then back to the original (did it to test how much better performance my friend's card would give over mine in my system).
 
Back
Top