For gaming: E8500 or Q6600?

Thanks for all your help guys, I can always turn to [H] for sound advice and a few fanboy laughs. Thanks to the troll for taking over the thread. On [H]ardOCP of all places, he recommends the Intel stock cooler. Thanks, idea rejected.

Q6600 it is, and yeah, it is going to probably be with me for the next 2-3 years as that's my general upgrade cycle.

I've lived with Shuttle G5 systems for the better part of 4 years. While it's nice to have a computer that's the size of a lunchbox, I need to get out of that prison where I have absolutely no choices in upgrades or cooling at all.

Mr. Pedantic, I'm exactly the kind of guy who had an HTPC/SFF for years and would kill to be able to modify my cooling in any way. Don't have any friends who really game on PC or lan anymore, so there's no more need for portability, time for full ATX!

Pyroja, thanks for your sound advice. I hope I get results as decent as yours. I'm looking at the P5Q and the EP45-UD3P but I might have to settle for another hand-me down motherboard for the moment but it should be a decent Gigabyte 965P-DQ6...if I can manage to get the bios flashed properly. What fan are you using on your TrueBlack?
 
I'd get at least a P35 board instead of a 965. They shouldn't be dramatically more expensive than a 965 and will almost certainly be a better OCer if you decide to OC it.
 
This is the [H]ardForum fuck face. Size matter not, cooling matter most. Go troll somewhere that has like minded idiots that don't overclock or use the best cooling for the price possible. This is not the forum for you.

Oh, and even if some of those games, or any new game out, uses only 2 cores? You'd rather have your dual core maxed out so you can't tab between apps smoothly? That makes no sense. Maybe you should write Intel about your hypothesis.
 
In left 4 dead i had better performance with my e8400 at 4.2ghz than on my q6600 at 3.6ghz but i went with the quad anyway because i need it for work.
 
Well, I'm gonna share my experience hear. My current system was orginally equiped with a e8400 which I ran 24/7 at 3883mhz/1.38 volts. After having that CPU for about a year, I traded it and $20 for a xeon 3220(q6600 equivalent). I'll be perfectly honest, even at 3600 mhz, the quad didnt feel as fast as the dual. The quad did everything I asked of it(just like the e8400 did), but my system didn't feel as "quick" as it did with the e8400 and it's 6mb cache. At that point, I was actually dissapointed with the quad. Since then, I've replaced the xeon with a q9650, and what do you know. My system had it's quickness back. So, going by that, I would not recommend a q6600 over a e8*00 dual core. If you really want a intel quad, look for a q9*50 CPU or go I7.

My current system specs-

Processor: C2Q Q9650 OC'ed to 3825mhz@1.38 volts
Motherboard: EVGA 750i FTW
Cooling: GIGABYTE G-power 2 Pro cooler
Memory: Ballistix 6gigs (2*2gig/2*1gig)DDR2 800/4.4.4.12 @ 850/4,4,4,12
Video Card: two GTX 280 in SLI
Harddisk: 500gig Seagate Barracuda 7200.12
CD/DVD Drive: Maddog 16x DVDRW
CRT/LCD Model: SOYO TOPAZ S 24-Inch Widescreen LCD Monitor
Case: Lian Li V1200b Plus II w/ metallic paint job
Sound Card: Realtek High Definition Audio
PSU: Coolermaster Real Power Pro 750 watt
Software: Windows 7 RC 64 bit
 
Last edited:
The list is longer than that, and any game coming out will take FULL advantage of quad-core CPU's. And besides, Windows Vista/7 has EXCELLENT load balancing. The more cores you have the better things run.

Troll be gone, you know nothing. Stop spreading FUD. 6mb total cache versus 8mb total cache and 2 more cores, there's no comparison.

This guy ftw. :D However I'm not sure about Oblivion taking advantage of quad's. It ran great on my 2.66p4, so i don't think there would be a difference between a quad..but w/e nothing to gripe about! :)

I'd get the Q6600. Both are good CPU's, but I think long term, you'd be better off with the quad.

Yea, get the Q6600. Dual's are defiantly a no go in the desktop market. All the recent releases of processors are quad's, and then there's the upcoming i9 which is 6 cores. Only exception is the i5 dual core with HT. So even then it's slightly more then a normal dual core.

A little off topic but, I can't wait for DA! Get that quad before Tuesday!...assuming that you pre-ordered it (I did :cool:).

GL
 
What are you referring to when you say "quickness"? Your post is a bit vague.

I mean with the xeon, my system's response time didn't seem as fast as it did with the e8400 or it does with the q9650(yeah I know, comparing a q6600 to a q9650 is not really fair, but that don't change the fact that my system felt more responsive with the e8400 than it did with the xeon 3220)
 
get the quad no reason to get a dual core now.u will be much better off with the q6600
 
What your NOT considering is this is shared cache dude. So 8MB total shared between 4 cores is in fact 2MB per core vs. 6MB total cache shared between 2 cores is in fact 3MB per core which means more cache per core and seeing as there is 2 cores being utilized in 98% of todays games having 6MB is better geez...

roflmao no.

The Q6600 is 8MB cache in the form of two 4MB blocks shared among each pair of cores. So two cores share one 4MB block and the other two share another 4MB block.

That means that if you running a game that only takes advantage of two cores on a quad, each core will potentially have a full 4MB block of dedicated cache to work with vs. always sharing a single 6MB block on a dual-core.

This brings up another point. Here is a pic of youe true120:

75229d1213128992-how-install-true120-dsc04607.jpg


Seriously look at the size of this thing! Who wants that big @ss bulky thing in there case that not only looks like crap but forces you to never have a chance at using anything less then a full tower. I can only amagine how loud that POS is as well. Now compare this to a nice and simple stock air cooler from Intel that dosen't need a football field of real esate and dosen't sound like a 747 in your living room.You get the idea...

So is that your excuse for running a wolfdale at STOCK clocks on a P45? Talk about fail :rolleyes:
 
Originally Posted by Spare-Flair
Well basically the guy I'm getting them from has both of these processors in his basement and I can have them for cheap.

Do you know this person? If so, why not see if you could try one out for acouple days, then try the other and keep the one you prefer.
 
Pyroja, thanks for your sound advice. I hope I get results as decent as yours. I'm looking at the P5Q and the EP45-UD3P but I might have to settle for another hand-me down motherboard for the moment but it should be a decent Gigabyte 965P-DQ6...if I can manage to get the bios flashed properly. What fan are you using on your TrueBlack?

I have thr normal TRUE, not the Black. Essentially the same, though ;)

Anyhow, as I mentioned, I have two Scythe Ultra Kaze 3000rpm fans on my TRUE. Probably overkill, but I lived with a constantly overheating Athlon X2 before it, so I wanted to be sure I could push air through that thing if I needed to.

Of course, I never run them at max speed. In fact, I have them running pretty much as slow as I can get them before they stop turning. Same with all of my fans. Everything runs nice and cool, and essentially silent. It is, however, kind of funny to crank everything up full-tilt and listen to what sounds like a vacuum cleaner in my room :p

As for boards, I have the P5Q and it's performed remarkably well. I'd recommend it, but as always, research your choices. I wish you luck with your new setup!
 
As that toms multi core co0mparison link shows, everyone who runs more than 1 app at a time will benefit from more cores. Quad core cpu's are affordable enough that everyone should be using them, so just get it and be done with it.

A dual core may be faster at a game if you kill every other app running, but why not use a quad core and leave your browser/mp3 player/torrent clients running and not worry about them hurting your performance.

And aside from games, even just OS performance at the most basic level, you will see an improvement using a quad over a dual. Just go quad.
 
As that toms multi core co0mparison link shows, everyone who runs more than 1 app at a time will benefit from more cores. Quad core cpu's are affordable enough that everyone should be using them, so just get it and be done with it.

A dual core may be faster at a game if you kill every other app running, but why not use a quad core and leave your browser/mp3 player/torrent clients running and not worry about them hurting your performance.

Just dosen't make sense. Not only do you need more cores but more ram as well. Why bother?
 
"So is that your excuse for running a wolfdale at STOCK clocks on a P45? Talk about fail"

Not a fail by any stretch! I can OC to 3.8GHz on stock Intel cooling no problem but I see no need to. I run my hardware stock, no big ass fans blowing like crazy, no loud fan noises coming out of my case. I have a antec 4480B mini tower and unless your actualy trying to hear the fans in my PC you can't. Makes me laugh looking at you guys with your 10 pound coolers with full server cases that sound like a small plane in your living rooms LOL!
 
"So is that your excuse for running a wolfdale at STOCK clocks on a P45? Talk about fail"

Not a fail by any stretch! I can OC to 3.8GHz on stock Intel cooling no problem but I see no need to. I run my hardware stock, no big ass fans blowing like crazy, no loud fan noises coming out of my case. I have a antec 4480B mini tower and unless your actualy trying to hear the fans in my PC you can't. Makes me laugh looking at you guys with your 10 pound coolers with full server cases that sound like a small plane in your living rooms LOL!

What? Intel stock cooling is LOUDER than aftermarket solutions with a 120mm volt controlled fan. I didn't plan on OCing my 860 so quickly but the damn stock fan was so loud I went out and got one. Much much quieter now. Damn 4890 is the noise maker now.
 
Eh, Q6600 will scale better with future games and obviously does better in heavily threaded situations. E8500 is better for current games 75% of the time.

http://www.anandtech.com/bench/default.aspx?p=53&p2=55

this "noobie" hit the nail on the head. Plus an e8500 will probably hit very close to 4ghz or possibly even higher.

I have a Q9550 and would probably choose the e8500 over a q6600, mhz and cache are important and the extra cores are nice but they don't negate those two huge pluses.
 
Not a fail by any stretch! I can OC to 3.8GHz on stock Intel cooling no problem but I see no need to. I run my hardware stock, no big ass fans blowing like crazy, no loud fan noises coming out of my case. I have a antec 4480B mini tower and unless your actualy trying to hear the fans in my PC you can't. Makes me laugh looking at you guys with your 10 pound coolers with full server cases that sound like a small plane in your living rooms LOL!

A good quality high end cooler is much quieter and much more efficient than the Intel stock cooler.

that's not a fact that can be refuted.

While they may be heavier, unless your moving your system around all the time its never a problem.

They do tend to weigh a lot so moving the system often is really not advised , as you run the risk of putting too much stress on the board...
however,most come with bolt thru mounting hardware and are very secure.

if your case limited,or run your chip stock, then a stock cooler is a good choice, but if you have the room and plan on overclocking your system, using the stock cooler is not the best way to go.
 
Q6600 at 3.2GHz is easy, it is fast enough for single threaded games and better than a higher clocked dual cores in multi threaded games.
 
this "noobie" hit the nail on the head. Plus an e8500 will probably hit very close to 4ghz or possibly even higher.

I have a Q9550 and would probably choose the e8500 over a q6600, mhz and cache are important and the extra cores are nice but they don't negate those two huge pluses.

You know what though, that said 75% of current games. That number gets smaller all the time. In the next 2 years, the Quad will be a better gaming option than the Dual, and will still be a relevant CPU.
 
get the Quad Core... i made the decision 2 years ago to get a dual vs Quad...... i regretted it ever since...

i now am the owner of a Q9550 OCed....... with the most demanding games on the market now, a Quad Core helps alot in terms of minimum frames at maximum settings.... especially in crysis... E6550 at 3.5GHz was outpumped by a Phenom 9750 way back when in crysis and the Q9550 at 3.6GHz feels even better....

whenever getting a new processor, get the most cores you can afford and just OC it if you are comfortable with overclocking... you can boost the performance of a core but you cannot turn 2 cores into 4......

unless you have AMD but thats a different discussion altogether :D
 
Just to update this thread and to thank those who recommended the Q6600, I am now running the 6600 @ 3.6GHz (400x9) but unfortunately it's a B3 stepping so it requires a bit more juice to be Prime95 stable. A whopping 1.6v. Is that safe as long as the CPU is under 60° C?
 
1.6 V is too high, I think. You run the risk of killing the chip even if temps are OK.
 
You can probably run 3.2-3.4 with a lot less voltage. I'd just go with that as it's not going to feel all that much slower.
 
A lot of chips have some breakpoint that they get too with minor voltage increases and then past that you have to start seriously pumping it up for minor gains. Find that point if it exists and stay there.
 
Just to update this thread and to thank those who recommended the Q6600, I am now running the 6600 @ 3.6GHz (400x9) but unfortunately it's a B3 stepping so it requires a bit more juice to be Prime95 stable. A whopping 1.6v. Is that safe as long as the CPU is under 60° C?

Your Q6600 stays under 60C during Prime95 at 1.6volts?

My Q6600 took 1.5v with LLC enabled on my Asus board to hit 3.6 but Prime95 temps would be upwards of 80C+.

What program are you using for Temperature Measurement?
 
I can only amagine how loud that POS is as well. Now compare this to a nice and simple stock air cooler from Intel that dosen't need a football field of real esate and dosen't sound like a 747 in your living room.You get the idea...

This post should get you perma-banned, I will forward it to the mods.

You are on the [H]ardforum telling users that the true120 is a POS and advising to use an Intel stock cooler...

The true has remained for several years in the top five air coolers available on the market. Fans generate noise, not the metal cooler itself...

GTFO troll
 
Well we all know better so leave it alone.

Besides the AC7 and one other I cant think of the name/number atm provide excellent improvement in cooling compared to the stock HS for less than $35 if one of the large towers is not desired.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, even the people that think the movie 2012 is real.

OP. Noooo! 1.6 is way too high for long term reliability. Intel Data sheet specifies the Absolute Max Vcore at 1.55 volts and if you factor in the allowed 50mV of cpu regulator overshoot 1.5 is pushing it hard. I have run mine (a crappy OCer despite the GO stepping) up to 1.475 for short periods to see what increased voltage would do, helps some, but even 1.425 makes me nervous for long term use and I keep my stuff forever. Your situation may be different.

I recommend you turn it down to 3.4 ish and see where the voltage goes, as someone mentioned there is usually a point where adding voltage results in diminishing returns and just before that happens is a good sweet spot. It is my experience that once you are past 3.2 with a Q6600 there are no great improvements in the "feel" of the machine. Every game is different, every application is different, but for 200MHz I would not chance drastically reducing the life of the CPU no matter how good a deal you got on it. On the other hand if you plan on replacing it in the near future, who cares.
 
Your Q6600 stays under 60C during Prime95 at 1.6volts?

My Q6600 took 1.5v with LLC enabled on my Asus board to hit 3.6 but Prime95 temps would be upwards of 80C+.

What program are you using for Temperature Measurement?

Good point, I was going by a physical thermistor I had placed right beside the core that I calibrated according to what the motherboard CPU temperature readout was in the bios.

When I use something like Everest, etc. however, the temperatures are a lot higher than what is reported in bios. I wonder why that is. I've gone back down to 1.4v and 3.4GHz due to the recommendations in this thread.

What is LLC?
 
With LLC I was able to stabilize at 3.60GHz my old QX6850 and my current CPU at its current speed, a pity that I can't reach 4.0GHz...
 
Back
Top