Apple Snow Leopard – What’s Coming?

The fact that the "upgrade" is $29.99 means they understand it's not some new OS.
I'd agree with that. But Apple is not marketing this as a service pack. If they were to call it "Leopard Second Edition" or something (ala XP SP2), I'd be more inclined to believe that argument.



Can you give some sort of comparison as to what's new and worth paying the $129 and up for in Windows 7 versus the $29.99 that Snow Leopard will cost? I don't quite see anything in either that justify the price.
$50 upgrade, not $130.
Sure, for $30, it'd probably be enough, if I still owned Macs... To upgrade. However, like I said, there's no way in hell I'm paying ANYTHING for a patch/tweaking service pack.
 
What does Windows 7 offer over Windows Vista that is so remarkable?
Spoken as someone who hasn't used Windows 7.

What justifies the $219 upgrade price for 7 Ultimate (a whopping $190 more than the Snow Leopard upgrade)?

Nobody needs Ultimate. Especially since they've ported the Media stuff into the Professional edition now... Only reason most people around here run it is that it's paid for.

Thus, for those who wanted Windows 7, they hopped on and got the $50 upgrade.

So again, $50 for Windows 7 or $30 for Snow Leopard? Which is the better value???
Even at $120 I'd pay for Windows 7. It's simply the BEST Windows OS ever created.
 
Or what Microsoft might call "Windows 7". (And charge you handsomely for it, too)

And you'll be buying two or three more upgrades during the life of Windows 7. And you could have gotten 7 for $50. So your post is incorrect.
 
I'd agree with that. But Apple is not marketing this as a service pack. If they were to call it "Leopard Second Edition" or something (ala XP SP2), I'd be more inclined to believe that argument.

Well, they do call it "Snow Leopard", a straight homage to the name of the OS that it REALLY is, just with some extra "snow" (if you will) on top. ;). Windows 7 is a brand new name, basically.

$50 upgrade, not $130.
Sure, for $30, it'd probably be enough, if I still owned Macs... To upgrade. However, like I said, there's no way in hell I'm paying ANYTHING for a patch/tweaking service pack.

Nice try, but $50 was that limited-time pre-order price. So I say again - $129. ;)
 
Well, they do call it "Snow Leopard", a straight homage to the name of the OS that it REALLY is, just with some extra "snow" (if you will) on top. ;). Windows 7 is a brand new name, basically.



Nice try, but $50 was that limited-time pre-order price. So I say again - $129. ;)

Doesn't change the fact that you could have gotten for $50. Plus Windows 7 isn't even out yet. There will be more specials.

And what's really cool is that Windows 7 is probably ALREADY more widely deployed before its offcial launch than Snow Leopard will ever be. So hey, if people are willing to pay what's so bad about that? Apple gouges everytime than can so giving people a break on a minor upgrade is the least they can do.
 
Doesn't change the fact that you could have gotten for $50. Plus Windows 7 isn't even out yet. There will be more specials.

And what's really cool is that Windows 7 is probably ALREADY more widely deployed before its offcial launch than Snow Leopard will ever be. So hey, if people are willing to pay what's so bad about that? Apple gouges everytime than can so giving people a break on a minor upgrade is the least they can do.

The bold text: Dude, I'm all for Windows 7. I've had the beta installed on a machine and I still have the RC on a partition. I was one of the many that dropped $50 for the pre-order special. But look - when you say something like "Doesn't change the fact that you could have gotten for $50.", you had better be comparing it to something more expensive than Snow Leopard - which will only be $29, no matter WHEN you buy it. ;)

For the rest: No argument on the point about W7 deployment. That's a total given. In all honesty, though, saying how Apple gouges, etc is a pretty big dramatization . Their OS's, however frequent they are released, are ALWAYS much less expensive than a new Windows release. Of course, that doesn't stop me or the countless others who buy Windows instead of OSX, but that's beside my point.
 
10.1 was a free upgrade, it had to be because 10.0 was basically a beta version of the OS running in parallel with OS 9.


I've seen some people argue that Mac users have to buy every copy of OS X from 10.0 through 10.6, which brings cost of ownership to over $800. It is a ridiculous and completely false argument coming from someone that has been on the platform since 2002. It just doesn't work that way in the real world, I'm sorry.

I just went back and looked it up. 10.1 was "free" with a 19.95 shipping and handling charge. I was off by 10 bucks......

As for the second part I refer you back to my original text which you quoted.

In what 8 years we had 7 releases of the operating system? All of them paid upgrades which is a little unfair as most people would have gotten a few of them with new machines as they upgraded.

Yea most people wouldn't have bought every version. I will say that I ended up paying for 10, 10.1, got 10.2 with a new mac I think, 10.3, 10.4, and got 10.5 with another new mac.

One last thing I forgot to mention is that I also owned Macbooks at the same time period (G4 Powerbook from 2003-2008, Macbook Pro from 2008 till now). Those same OS X upgrades do not carry CD-keys, so I was able to upgrade both my desktop and my notebook for the same price.

So after OS 10.6 drops next month, that will be $290 to upgrade multiple machines over the course of seven years. You cannot do that with Windows, unfortunately. Again, I get my Windows licenses for super cheap, if not then I'd have a real problem with their pricing.

So you either paid extra for the family pack or pirated it on the second machine. Whats your point? If you did the later you could have done that with windows as well. If not you still paid for the upgrade although I will admit it is cheaper.
 
You have to remember that when you buy snow leopard that apple already has you for the cost of the machine you are going to be upgrading. When you buy a copy of windows microsoft only makes money on that copy of windows.
 
And you'll be buying two or three more upgrades during the life of Windows 7.

Not true at all. I've had Macs for seven years and every version of OS X from 10.2 through 10.5. Since then I have only bought two upgrades, 10.3 and 10.4 on the G4 I had for five years from 2002-2007. My copies of 10.2 and 10.5 came with new machines. Next month will be my third upgrade with 10.6.

On top of that I was able to install those upgrades on my notebook as well as my desktop. So over seven years of Mac ownership I have spent $260 total on OS upgrades for two computers. Add another $30 to that after next month.

Real world situations makes your argument incorrect, between the purchasing of new machines, the average upgrade release schedule (two years for a majority of the time I've used OS X), and there being no CD keys.
 
Spoken as someone who hasn't used Windows 7.


*ahem*

You were saying...?

Nobody needs Ultimate. Especially since they've ported the Media stuff into the Professional edition now...
Hey, I was just comparing the high-end to the high-end. What's a more valid comparison, in your opinion? The $29 upgrade version of Snow Leopard is the most feature-packed version (as well as the only version).

Thus, for those who wanted Windows 7, they hopped on and got the $50 upgrade.
The vast majority of Windows 7 users will not have paid $50 for it. The majority will be paying the retail upgrade prices, with a small number paying the obscene full version prices. Thankfully Microsoft was nice enough to offer a family pack at a reasonable value for those who need multiple licenses.

It's simply the BEST Windows OS ever created.
Sure thing, Tina.

And you'll be buying two or three more upgrades during the life of Windows 7. And you could have gotten 7 for $50.
Will I? You have insider information on Apple's OS roadmap that I don't?

Sure, I could have gotten 7 for $50. But at that point, I hadn't used 7. You're suggesting that I should have paid Microsoft for an OS I've never used? I'm sorry, but I don't take such grand leaps of faith when it comes to Microsoft's products. I exercise much more caution and self-restraint, and it's served me pretty well so far.
 
Not true at all. I've had Macs for seven years and every version of OS X from 10.2 through 10.5. Since then I have only bought two upgrades, 10.3 and 10.4 on the G4 I had for five years from 2002-2007. My copies of 10.2 and 10.5 came with new machines. Next month will be my third upgrade with 10.6.

On top of that I was able to install those upgrades on my notebook as well as my desktop. So over seven years of Mac ownership I have spent $260 total on OS upgrades for two computers. Add another $30 to that after next month.

Real world situations makes your argument incorrect, between the purchasing of new machines, the average upgrade release schedule (two years for a majority of the time I've used OS X), and there being no CD keys.

So you skipped upgrades. Fair enough. But I was comparing all AVAILABLE upgrades for both systems. People can skip 7 as well and pay $0.

But in honesty it difficult to do an apples to apples comparison (sorry for the pun) between the real price of upgrades per user. In the real world Windows 7 upgrades can cost nothing, both leagally and not so much, to a lot. I get MSDN though my work and have for the past 5 years so my cost TO me to run Windows has been $0. Yes, I know about the MSDN EULA and all as I've had it for 13 but in the real world, my cost to run Windows is zero, nada, zip. It's as free to me as any *NIX distro at least for now.

But even more intresting is that there are probably more people running FREE versions of Winodws, both legal and not, than the entire OS X base. So Windows pricing is a matter of perspective. For OS X its costs X dollars for pretty much everyone.
 
So you either paid extra for the family pack or pirated it on the second machine. Whats your point? If you did the later you could have done that with windows as well. If not you still paid for the upgrade although I will admit it is cheaper.

Yeah, the honor system method that Apple uses for their OSes gets into sketchy territory for me.

Spend a little bit extra for a five machine "family pack" or buy a standard upgrade, neither of which have CD-keys. The lack of CD-keys, which means I don't have to actively crack anything, sure doesn't make it feel like piracy when I install it on only two machines. Because of that I've been fine just buying a regular OS X upgrade. Its different with Windows since everything they sell has a CD-key on it. I wouldn't dream of actively cracking authentication or anything like that. Every copy of Windows and Office I own is legit.

Posts like this sure do put the guilt trip on re: my OS X upgrades though, especially since I don't actively pirate anything (movies, music, applications). :)
 
So you skipped upgrades. Fair enough. But I was comparing all AVAILABLE upgrades for both systems. People can skip 7 as well and pay $0.

Yes, I did, and I've had every single version at some point. Do you expect anybody in the real world to have a Mac from all the way back in 2000 that has gone through every single upgrade version of OS X on the same machine? Hell, there are machines from back then that can't even run 10.5, forget about the fact that a computer that old would likely have been discarded ages ago.

The majority of people will get OS X pre-installed on a new machine and then go through one, maybe two upgrades. I had a Mac for five years during the early 10.2-10.4 period when upgrades were actually annual, and I only had two total upgrades on it.

Practically speaking, the argument that people will buy nothing but OS X upgrades holds absolutely zero water with me. I've owned Macs for seven years and about half of the versions I've run are ones that came with new machines. This is even more important since on average I hold onto my Macs much longer than my PCs; five years versus two with my Windows PCs. This is mainly because my Windows machines are performance boxes for gaming, while my Macs are for everything else and work.
 
Yeah, the honor system method that Apple uses for their OSes gets into sketchy territory for me.

Spend a little bit extra for a five machine "family pack" or buy a standard upgrade, neither of which have CD-keys. The lack of CD-keys, which means I don't have to actively crack anything, sure doesn't make it feel like piracy when I install it on only two machines. Because of that I've been fine just buying a regular OS X upgrade. Its different with Windows since everything they sell has a CD-key on it. I wouldn't dream of actively cracking authentication or anything like that. Every copy of Windows and Office I own is legit.

Posts like this sure do put the guilt trip on re: my OS X upgrades though, especially since I don't actively pirate anything (movies, music, applications). :)

So you are still actively pirating the OS on the second machine. Hell you could do the same with windows. It would just be a phone call to reactivate it on a second machine. If you wait 120 days you wouldn't even need to do that. For the same thing you could just get a friend to burn you a copy of the os because it comes down to the same thing.

Not a good way to defend yourself by using piracy as a reason for why something is better.
 
Yes, I did, and I've had every single version at some point. Do you expect anybody in the real world to have a Mac from all the way back in 2000 that has gone through every single upgrade version of OS X on the same machine? Hell, there are machines from back then that can't even run 10.5, forget about the fact that a computer that old would likely have been discarded ages ago.

The majority of people will get OS X pre-installed on a new machine and then go through one, maybe two upgrades. I had a Mac for five years during the early 10.2-10.4 period when upgrades were actually annual, and I only had two total upgrades on it.

Practically speaking, the argument that people will buy nothing but OS X upgrades holds absolutely zero water with me. I've owned Macs for seven years and about half of the versions I've run are ones that came with new machines. This is even more important since on average I hold onto my Macs much longer than my PCs; five years versus two with my Windows PCs. This is mainly because my Windows machines are performance boxes for gaming, while my Macs are for everything else and work.

Most people don't buy windows in the same respect. They get it with their pre-built machines.
 
damn, im usually *not* on the apple side of the aisle... but holy crap, the mac guys kicked the crap outta the windows guys arguement-wise....

seriously, the question goes unanswered... what is in windows 7 that is so profound and worth paying for that makes snow leopard "just a service pack"???

and other than windows xp SP2, when has a windows service pack ever really given so many new things as an OSX point release??

seriously guys, i hate on apple as much as anyone else... but dont choke too hard on the Microsoft cock you have in your mouths..... Windows 7 is one of the smallest upgrades in windows history.... ranks right up there with the Windows 2000 ---> Windows XP one
 
But in honesty it difficult to do an apples to apples comparison (sorry for the pun) between the real price of upgrades per user. In the real world Windows 7 upgrades can cost nothing, both leagally and not so much, to a lot. I get MSDN though my work and have for the past 5 years so my cost TO me to run Windows has been $0. Yes, I know about the MSDN EULA and all as I've had it for 13 but in the real world, my cost to run Windows is zero, nada, zip. It's as free to me as any *NIX distro at least for now.

And yeah, this argument means nothing to me. Since 2001 I've bought every single copy of Windows and Office through a friend of mine that works at Microsoft. My full non-upgrade copies of Vista Ultimate were roughly $30 each. It isn't free but it sure is far from retail pricing.

Either way, I wouldn't dream of using my own personal example in this argument. It is about as irrelevant to the conversation as you using MSDN in yours.
 
So you are still actively pirating the OS on the second machine. Hell you could do the same with windows. It would just be a phone call to reactivate it on a second machine. If you wait 120 days you wouldn't even need to do that. For the same thing you could just get a friend to burn you a copy of the os because it comes down to the same thing.

Not a good way to defend yourself by using piracy as a reason for why something is better.

And yet Apple is a-ok with this. Its been going on for a very long time and they really don't care. If they did then they'd have CD-keys on OS X upgrades like they do with Final Cut Studio and iWork.

All that said, I'd feel compelled to pay the little extra for a Family Pack license if I was installing it on more than two computers. As it stands, they don't mind, and I don't mind not paying for five whole licenses when I'm only installing it on a desktop and a laptop that I almost never use at the same time.
 
damn, im usually *not* on the apple side of the aisle... but holy crap, the mac guys kicked the crap outta the windows guys arguement-wise....

seriously, the question goes unanswered... what is in windows 7 that is so profound and worth paying for that makes snow leopard "just a service pack"???

and other than windows xp SP2, when has a windows service pack ever really given so many new things as an OSX point release??

seriously guys, i hate on apple as much as anyone else... but dont choke too hard on the Microsoft cock you have in your mouths..... Windows 7 is one of the smallest upgrades in windows history.... ranks right up there with the Windows 2000 ---> Windows XP one

And honestly, the XP SP2 example is laughable. It was a big upgrade as far as Windows service packs go (much needed from a security standpoint), but it is nothing compared to even the relatively small 10.6 upgrade.

And compared to 10.4 or 10.5, holy fucking LOL, only the biggest kool-aid drinking fanboy would believe that any Windows service pack is anywhere close in terms of adding features or functionality, it is flat out delusional.

BTW, this isn't a slag on service packs! Reality just seems to fly over the heads of some people here because of some weird irrational fanboy mentality.
 
All I know is I don't know shit compared to some of you guys. Thanks for the education though.
:D
 
Doesn't change the fact that you could have gotten for $50. Plus Windows 7 isn't even out yet. There will be more specials.

And what's really cool is that Windows 7 is probably ALREADY more widely deployed before its offcial launch than Snow Leopard will ever be. So hey, if people are willing to pay what's so bad about that? Apple gouges everytime than can so giving people a break on a minor upgrade is the least they can do.
Here's the deal. 10 MILLION people tested Windows 7, folks. Sorry, but Apple couldn't get that large of an initial install base if they wanted to, much less just TESTING it out. Windows 7 is simply the most in-demand OS Microsoft has ever came out with (DOS wasn't even in as much demand I don't think).

Their OS's, however frequent they are released, are ALWAYS much less expensive than a new Windows release. Of course, that doesn't stop me or the countless others who buy Windows instead of OSX, but that's beside my point.
Real-world example time.
I buy XP in 2001. Let's assume I pay full-blown retail of $300 (Again- paying full sticker price is VERY rare). I get 3 SPs up to 2006 (Vista) for free (And there will be 4 total...).
Let's also assume I buy OS 10.0, Cheetah. $130 for that.

Now let's assume I want to buy the latest upgrades, updates, and etc that I can.

Windows XP, 3 free SPs.
OS 10, you have 10.1, 10.2, 10.3, 10.4, 10.5 up to 2006. A grand total of 6 versions.

6*130 = 780 OSX
1*300 = 300 Windows

It doesn't take rocket science to see that OS X is costing you more money. Period.

The vast majority of Windows 7 users will not have paid $50 for it. The majority will be paying the retail upgrade prices, with a small number paying the obscene full version prices.
Really?
Who do you know that upgrades their OS?
99% of people upgrading their OS are the technically savvy. 99% of people that are technically savvy know about the $50 deal. 99% of people that knew about the $50 deal knew they wanted Windows 7. 99% of those people bought at $50 versus $130.
 
Real-world example time.
I buy XP in 2001. Let's assume I pay full-blown retail of $300 (Again- paying full sticker price is VERY rare). I get 3 SPs up to 2006 (Vista) for free (And there will be 4 total...).
Let's also assume I buy OS 10.0, Cheetah. $130 for that.

Now let's assume I want to buy the latest upgrades, updates, and etc that I can.

Windows XP, 3 free SPs.
OS 10, you have 10.1, 10.2, 10.3, 10.4, 10.5 up to 2006. A grand total of 6 versions.

6*130 = 780 OSX
1*300 = 300 Windows

It doesn't take rocket science to see that OS X is costing you more money. Period.

Your chickenshit "iggy list" is going to keep you in a state of ignorance (well, you're well beyond help, but that's another thread...).

First off, 10.1 was $20 for the CD and shipping, not $130.

Second, 10.5 launched in October of 2007, not 2006. Again you invent facts for your broken arguments.

Finally, a Mac bought in 2000 would likely not be able to run OS 10.5 since minimum spec requirements had gone up by then, you'd be able to run 10.4 at best. Furthermore, it definitely would not be able to run 10.6 since PPC support is being dropped.

If you did what I did and bought a Mac with OS 10.2 installed in 2002, held onto it for five years (a LONG time imo) and then bought a new Mac in 2007 with 10.5 installed, your grand total for upgrades is $260, not the $520 that your broken line of thinking would lead you to believe.

Throw in another $30 for keeping that same 2007 machine and installing 10.6, that brings seven years of Mac ownership to a grand total of $290 in OS X upgrades. Consider that I install my single-user license on two computers (a Mac desktop and laptop that do not get used at the same time) and your cost argument diminishes further. Hell, its diminished even if you take the Family Pack pricing into account (five licenses for $200, or $50 for 10.6).

This is before we get to the fact that these OS X improvements had long since left Windows XP in the dust by the time 10.4 launched. They are well worth the price considering the improvement in performance (my 2002 Mac ran better than new by the time I retired it it in 2007) and the UI. Again, comparing them to Windows Service Packs are a joke.

The argument that people buy your claimed number of OS X upgrades (aside from getting 10.1 price and 10.5 release date wrong) completely ignores the fact that Macs come with OS X pre-installed, and that people will generally buy new computers every two to four years (I keep my Macs for five).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I am loving the arguments over cost when in reality 90% of windows users will not buy a retail copy of windows. They will buy a new computer with the new version pre installed. So if you really want to factor out the costs to own each you should take a PC and a mac with similar performance take that cost, then add in how much you will spend over the life of each in upgrades.
 
Who do you know that upgrades their OS?
Actually, most of the people I know upgrade their OS, but I'm not certain what the people I know have to do with this discussion. Can you explain the pertinence?

99% of people that are technically savvy know about the $50 deal.
Correction: knew. The deal's over and has been for some time, and that was only for Home Premium (Pro was $99, and there was no such deal for Ultimate). If you're going to make up statistics, you may as make sure they are at least fabricated upon the vaguest foundation of fact.

I'm still intensely curious as to whether or not you intend to answer my question regarding what makes Windows 7 so much better than Vista, when my experience has been that it's a welcome set of tweaks, minor additions (I like the taskbar) and bloat reduction (which shouldn't have existed in Vista in the first place) and little else. Then again, I've never used 7, as you claim, so what do I know?
 
You know one thing that strikes me funny about the whole "apple is charging for a service pack" argument, is the fact that Windows "7" is actually Windows NT 6.1 with Vista being NT 6.0

Also, as for the XP service pack argument...what was really included in the service packs? (Below is from wikipedia for convenience)

SP1

Service Pack 1 (SP1) for Windows XP was released on September 9, 2002. It contains post-RTM security fixes and hot-fixes, compatibility updates, optional .NET Framework support, enabling technologies for new devices such as Tablet PCs, and a new Windows Messenger 4.7 version. The most notable new features were USB 2.0 support and a Set Program Access and Defaults utility that aimed at hiding various middleware products.

SP2

Service Pack 2 (SP2) (codenamed "Springboard") was released on August 6, 2004 after several delays, with an emphasis on security.[42] Unlike the previous service pack, SP2 added new functionality to Windows XP, including a firewall, improved Wi-Fi support, such as WPA encryption compatibility, with a wizard utility, a pop-up ad blocker for Internet Explorer 6, and Bluetooth support.

Service Pack 2 also added new security enhancements, which included a major revision to the included firewall that was renamed to Windows Firewall and is enabled by default, Data Execution Prevention, which can be weakly emulated, gains hardware support in the NX bit that can stop some forms of buffer overflow attacks.

SP3

* Turns black hole router detection on by default [57]
* Network Access Protection client
* Credentials Security Service Provider [58]
* Descriptive Security options in Group Policy/Local Security Policy user interface
* An updated version of the Microsoft Enhanced Cryptographic Provider Module (RSAENH) that is FIPS 140-2 certified (SHA-256, SHA-384 and SHA-512 algorithms) [57]
* Installing without requiring a product key during setup for retail and OEM versions


So, take out the security fixes and really what did you get? No, Microsoft did not charge, but I don't think they ever could have either.
I've been a pc guy since day one, but all this apple bashing is absurd. I picked up a new little macbook pro and love it...i think apple nailed it for the notebook sector, not even close. I'm getting SL for $10 when it comes out, through Apple's UpToDate program.



BTW
Here's the deal. 10 MILLION people tested Windows 7, folks. Sorry, but Apple couldn't get that large of an initial install base if they wanted to, much less just TESTING it out. Windows 7 is simply the most in-demand OS Microsoft has ever came out with (DOS wasn't even in as much demand I don't think).

Unless you normalize to the pc user base at each release, your statement of "most in-demand" is based on false logic (which I assume is raw number of beta/rc downloads)
 
I am loving the arguments over cost when in reality 90% of windows users will not buy a retail copy of windows. They will buy a new computer with the new version pre installed. So if you really want to factor out the costs to own each you should take a PC and a mac with similar performance take that cost, then add in how much you will spend over the life of each in upgrades.

Holy crap, logic!

A Mac bought in 2007 with 10.5 installed upgraded to 10.6 = $30
A Dell/HP/etc bought in 2007 with Vista installed upgraded to Windows 7 Professional = $200 or Ultimate for $220

If we're not going doing an apples to apples (no pun intended) comparison with the full featured versions of these operating systems, then the same Vista installation upgraded to Windows 7 Home Premium is $120. The best deal by far if we're going down that route is the currently unavailable Family Pack: three Home Premium upgrade licenses for $150. A five-pack "honor system" license (since there are no CD-keys) for a fully-featured OS 10.6 is $50.

Either way you cut it, the Windows 7 pricing structure and list of editions is very favorable compared to how it was with Vista. The omission of certain features from Home Premium when spending more for the Vista Business edition was a mistake that did more than anything else to drive Ultimate sales. Now Windows 7 Ultimate is mostly irrelevant, IMO a good thing since most people that want that extra functionality are just going to want what's in W7 Pro.

The mistake that TechieSooner and several others here are making is that most people are getting copies of Windows or OS X included with their machines and then make upgrades later. You don't count the initial OS purchase unless you're building your own PC (the majority of readers here) or are doing a Hackintosh. Five years of owning a 2002 Mac resulted in $260 in upgrades, 10.3 and 10.4, the latter of which was gargantuan. Another two years of Mac ownership is about to result in one more $30 upgrade, otherwise I got 10.2 and 10.5 preinstalled.
 
So, take out the security fixes and really what did you get? No, Microsoft did not charge, but I don't think they ever could have either.

Pretty much. I've lived through the major modern upgrade cycles on both and I can safely say that OS X upgrades have at the very least amounted to significantly greater than a SP, and at most (ie - the leap from 10.3 to 10.4) represented a leap in performance, features, UI improvements, and functionality, that was larger than the move from XP to Vista or the move from Vista to Windows 7.

Unless you normalize to the pc user base at each release, your statement of "most in-demand" is based on false logic (which I assume is raw number of beta/rc downloads)

False logic and twisting facts is TechieSooner's MO, ditto switching around the subject when it is more than clear that he is losing an argument.
 
Your chickenshit "iggy list" is going to keep you in a state of ignorance (well, you're well beyond help, but that's another thread...).

First off, 10.1 was $20 for the CD and shipping, not $130.

Second, 10.5 launched in October of 2007, not 2006. Again you invent facts for your broken arguments.

Finally, a Mac bought in 2000 would likely not be able to run OS 10.5 since minimum spec requirements had gone up by then, you'd be able to run 10.4 at best. Furthermore, it definitely would not be able to run 10.6 since PPC support is being dropped.

If you did what I did and bought a Mac with OS 10.2 installed in 2002, held onto it for five years (a LONG time imo) and then bought a new Mac in 2007 with 10.5 installed, your grand total for upgrades is $260, not the $520 that your broken line of thinking would lead you to believe.

Throw in another $30 for keeping that same 2007 machine and installing 10.6, that brings seven years of Mac ownership to a grand total of $290 in OS X upgrades. Consider that I install my single-user license on two computers (a Mac desktop and laptop that do not get used at the same time) and your cost argument diminishes further. Hell, its diminished even if you take the Family Pack pricing into account (five licenses for $200, or $50 for 10.6).

This is before we get to the fact that these OS X improvements had long since left Windows XP in the dust by the time 10.4 launched. They are well worth the price considering the improvement in performance (my 2002 Mac ran better than new by the time I retired it it in 2007) and the UI. Again, comparing them to Windows Service Packs are a joke.

The argument that people buy your claimed number of OS X upgrades (aside from getting 10.1 price and 10.5 release date wrong) completely ignores the fact that Macs come with OS X pre-installed, and that people will generally buy new computers every two to four years (I keep my Macs for five).

Yet another massive post of failure from the brainwashed IT drone in Oklahoma, take a bow. :rolleyes:

*claps*

This.

Seriously, I love Windows, I use it exclusively, and feel strongly that Serpico wins this argument. He's brought nothing but pure facts to the table. He doesn't bring speculative material, and never tries to turn it into a Mac vs. PC issue, much unlike TechieSonner, who likes to talk about how many more copies of Windows are sold than OSX. :rolleyes:
 
Care to point out which Windows service pack reduced OS footprint by 6GB and rewrote the entire Windows Explorer? Just curious, I think I missed that one and would love to download it. :rolleyes:

Sure Apple decreased its foot print, not by coding it better, just by compressing their OS. Compression is nothing new, but Apple would like to charge you for it.
 
*claps*

This.

Seriously, I love Windows, I use it exclusively, and feel strongly that Serpico wins this argument. He's brought nothing but pure facts to the table. He doesn't bring speculative material, and never tries to turn it into a Mac vs. PC issue, much unlike TechieSonner, who likes to talk about how many more copies of Windows are sold than OSX. :rolleyes:

yup, pretty much this.

probably time for an /thread, or at least /argument, havent seen such a bad forum beatdown in a while, heh
 
*claps*

This.

Seriously, I love Windows, I use it exclusively, and feel strongly that Serpico wins this argument. He's brought nothing but pure facts to the table. He doesn't bring speculative material, and never tries to turn it into a Mac vs. PC issue, much unlike TechieSonner, who likes to talk about how many more copies of Windows are sold than OSX. :rolleyes:

Thank you. I use both OSes daily and any complaint or praise I have for either platform are legitimate ones based on lots of experience, not fanboy rah-rah cheerleading. Every company has good and bad products, good and bad policies, and they should all be judged individually. It is ridiculous to have complete blind fanboy allegiance like that to any multi-billion dollar corporation, all that matter are the products.

randomdean100 made one of my favorite posts this thread (I responded here: http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1034492760&postcount=66). It goes into how we shouldn't be basing arguments on OSes bought with new machines, but purely on upgrades and how long we keep them. Everything else is pretty much irrelevant.
 
from all the reading and valid points on both sides to me it is almost

Windows 7 is to Vista, what Snow Leopard is to Leopard, but alot cheaper :)

Windows 7 and Snow Leopard are both OS that should of been what they are replacing, should of been originally released as, both sides saw mistakes made and their solution for fixing it is to jump ship and start from new!
 
Someone asked about a complete Windows Explorer rewrite. Rewrites are irrelevant unless they improve performance, security, or functionality. On the other hand, I make extensive use of network folders databases and will be taking full advantage of Windows 7's Libraries and Federated Search.

As others have stated, loss of support for technology is in no way an improvement. Congratulations for putting full support behind Intel x64 at the expense of the installed base. As for the reduced installation footprint, 6GB = $0.70 on my WD6401AALS. I think that much got freed up when I installed Vista SP2. Supersized my combo that night, I can tell you!

I *expect* both Snow Leopard and Win 7 to have improved SSD support. I only know for a fact that it is in Win 7. This may have me jumping on the SSD bandwagon come Sept.

The CNET article cites the following Snow Leopard "performance" improvements: "faster boot times, quicker shut down, a speedier process when joining wireless networks, and faster backups to Time Machine." Booting up and shutting down are irrelevant performance improvements. Every OS upgrade pledges these things (MS or Mac). I'll take them if they come. Faster connection to wireless? *Yawn*. But yay, my unattended backups will be faster!

Out-of-the-box integration with Exchange Server 2007 is pretty cool. I have an Outlook license that worked in XP and Vista, and will work again in Win 7. Next.

In the same vein as OS 10.6 text enhancement features -- since when does replacing TM with a superscripted version need to be an OS upgrade? -- Win 7 has its own "it's-about-time" features. E.g. I hope Win 7's improved file format support puts my Vista/XP codec issues to rest.

Is it just me, or will the following OS X features be available for free to anyone with a pulse?

  • Safari 4 and Quicktime 10 will eventually be ported to Windows and then ignored after the usual flurry of trying to figure out how to uninstall the inglorious basterds.
  • Open CL is... open. That Apple invented it is as relevant as the fact that Netscape invented JavaScript. The big difference seems to be that Mac users require the OS to support it while the rest of the world just needs the right graphics drivers.

Seems to me the problem is that MS just gives too much away independently of OS (IE updates, USB/Bluetooth/etc. support) such that major OS upgrades never seem so major. Either that or software installation (drivers, Office) come with the features that need to be included in Mac OS's.
 
As others have stated, loss of support for technology is in no way an improvement. Congratulations for putting full support behind Intel x64 at the expense of the installed base.

You're right.

Darn it, OS X should still support 68k, and Win 7 better run on the 286. If they don't, I don't care what improvements they make, they're screwing the installed base, and that's not progress at all.
 
so does apple offer a "free ugrade" to people that are currently buying macs? I know MS is offering free upgrade to windows 7 for a while now for people that have vista machines
 
Your chickenshit "iggy list" is going to keep you in a state of ignorance (well, you're well beyond help, but that's another thread...).

First off, 10.1 was $20 for the CD and shipping, not $130.

Second, 10.5 launched in October of 2007, not 2006. Again you invent facts for your broken arguments.

Finally, a Mac bought in 2000 would likely not be able to run OS 10.5 since minimum spec requirements had gone up by then, you'd be able to run 10.4 at best. Furthermore, it definitely would not be able to run 10.6 since PPC support is being dropped.

If you did what I did and bought a Mac with OS 10.2 installed in 2002, held onto it for five years (a LONG time imo) and then bought a new Mac in 2007 with 10.5 installed, your grand total for upgrades is $260, not the $520 that your broken line of thinking would lead you to believe.

Throw in another $30 for keeping that same 2007 machine and installing 10.6, that brings seven years of Mac ownership to a grand total of $290 in OS X upgrades. Consider that I install my single-user license on two computers (a Mac desktop and laptop that do not get used at the same time) and your cost argument diminishes further. Hell, its diminished even if you take the Family Pack pricing into account (five licenses for $200, or $50 for 10.6).

This is before we get to the fact that these OS X improvements had long since left Windows XP in the dust by the time 10.4 launched. They are well worth the price considering the improvement in performance (my 2002 Mac ran better than new by the time I retired it it in 2007) and the UI. Again, comparing them to Windows Service Packs are a joke.

The argument that people buy your claimed number of OS X upgrades (aside from getting 10.1 price and 10.5 release date wrong) completely ignores the fact that Macs come with OS X pre-installed, and that people will generally buy new computers every two to four years (I keep my Macs for five).

Yet another massive post of failure from the brainwashed IT drone in Oklahoma, take a bow. :rolleyes:



lol for what they charge for hardware, you have no savings when you factor it all together.
 
You're right.

Darn it, OS X should still support 68k, and Win 7 better run on the 286. If they don't, I don't care what improvements they make, they're screwing the installed base, and that's not progress at all.

Ha! No kidding, right? Seriously, I think it's a great move on Apple's part. It's inevitable that some customers who have declined to upgrade eventually lose support, so the consequences of this move are to be expected. Honestly, though, it's about damn time all these OEM machines from Dell/HP/etc are being shipped with 64-bit processors and 64-bit versions of Windows. It's great for the future. A nice stepping stone. I wouldn't be surprised if MS announces that Windows8 will be 64-bit only. It'll be a good move, IMO.
 
Yay another PC vs Mac. I like Leopard, I am sure I will like Snow Leopard. I buy what I like. /thead
 
Ha! No kidding, right? Seriously, I think it's a great move on Apple's part. It's inevitable that some customers who have declined to upgrade eventually lose support, so the consequences of this move are to be expected. Honestly, though, it's about damn time all these OEM machines from Dell/HP/etc are being shipped with 64-bit processors and 64-bit versions of Windows. It's great for the future. A nice stepping stone. I wouldn't be surprised if MS announces that Windows8 will be 64-bit only. It'll be a good move, IMO.

Windows 7 should be x64 only
 
No, it shouldn't, because if it was x64 only the entire industry for Netbooks would come to a screeching halt till Intel and VIA started cranking out CPUs capable of 64 bit support which of course is coming but not here just yet.

The benefits of 64 bit computing simply do not translate to Netbooks or even laptops for the most part. While there is an incredibly minuscule number of people out there that have legitimate uses for truly monster laptops and serious power requirements (like crunching some serious scientific applications, etc), the overwhelming majority of folk simply have no need for such beasts.

Windows Server 2008 R2 coming in x64 only makes perfect sense: you don't run a server OS on a Netbook or anything simplistic - you run it on heavy iron because that's what's necessary in this day and age, and that means accessing RAM in the double and sometimes triple digit amounts so, that's the primary hook for a 64 bit operating system.
 
Back
Top