Beatles rock band rant(dlc)

arr4ws

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Nov 8, 2005
Messages
6,671
Anyone is tired of DLC getting announced before the game hit the shelves. Beatles rock band features only 45 songs ... but they already announced 3 full DLC album that will be available.

why not release it in one single god damn game.... 45 songs for a rock band game isnt enough ... but having to pay extras to get songs already in the works (my guess is already done) to get the full experience is mindblowing to a point of non-sense...

im sorry but i had to vent.
 
Besides the DLC for Rock Band 2 of buying some songs of the PSN. I've never really jumped at the opportunity for DLC for games. Like LittleBigPlanet are people actually buying costumes for their little doll guy/girl? I guess it makes them money and thats why they do it but I wish they didn't offer less with the original product.

I agree with you, if their intention all along was to put those songs in the game then they should be part of the original purchase. ...but now were getting into moral and ethics issues and at the end of the day the whole point of making the game is to make money.
 
Besides the DLC for Rock Band 2 of buying some songs of the PSN. I've never really jumped at the opportunity for DLC for games. Like LittleBigPlanet are people actually buying costumes for their little doll guy/girl? I guess it makes them money and thats why they do it but I wish they didn't offer less with the original product.

I agree with you, if their intention all along was to put those songs in the game then they should be part of the original purchase. ...but now were getting into moral and ethics issues and at the end of the day the whole point of making the game is to make money.

This games is not even out and they are announcing DLC. The song list is half of what we are use to get in that kind of games and im pretty sure the price will be as high as any other game.....

I really like the beatles , and i wanted to buy the game. But this kind of practice is a trend i dont want to be part of. Its sad , cause im pretty sure the game will be very very good.
 
DLC is really starting to get on my nerves. It is simply a way they can raise the price of the game to $75.00.
 
This games is not even out and they are announcing DLC. The song list is half of what we are use to get in that kind of games and im pretty sure the price will be as high as any other game.....

I really like the beatles , and i wanted to buy the game. But this kind of practice is a trend i dont want to be part of. Its sad , cause im pretty sure the game will be very very good.

price will be higher. Beatles RB ships at 250 dollars US.
 
This is really unforgivable. First, the Beatles rockband kit will be more expensive than the regular one just because its Beatles. Next, if you have the original rockband with tons of DLC for that etc... you can't just download all the Beatles songs as albums. You have to buy the special beatles game for $60 to even get started. Now, they're telling you there are 3 whole albums of DLC announced in addition to the game you've paid $60 for?!!!! What the hell? Its not like this content isn't available and this is a "New" beatles album that came out after the game's release!

DLC is getting worse and worse and affecting all platforms. When those like me first saw the Horse Armor fiasco and complained, we were told to shut up. We were told it would never be pervasive - now every game has some sort of DLC. We were told it would never be expensive - the average cost is around $5 for stupid color swap. We were told it would be NEW content - its often content they had on the disc and took OFF in order to make money etc... the list goes on.

I'm not sure how we can reverse this trend because people are buying, but please, if you can resist supporting companies and games that obviously gut your wallet, do so. If not for the money, its the principle of the thing.
 
Is it possible that licensing fees had something to do with how much they're charging? Then again, it could just be a blatant cash grab.

On a side note, I generally like the way the DLC for Rock Band is being handled. I don't mind paying 2 bucks for a song I really like. And being able to use songs I downloaded for RB1 in RB2 (as well as being able to export most of the RB1 originals) is good too What I hate is how Guitar Hero: Smash Hits was done. I would've been happy to pay 10 or 20 bucks to have some of the songs as DLC for World Tour. Instead, I skipped on it and they didn't get a penny from me.
 
This is why I stopped buying these crap games after GH 2. They clearly are drawing this type of genre out and making way to much money doing it. When GH Metallica was announced I was like sweet a guitar hero with all the Metallica songs.... Until I saw the track list which included half of their titles and it included some other bands songs that I didn't care for. Shouldn't GH Metallica have Metallica songs on it?

That is when I said this is stupid.
 
You're getting the full experience when you purchase the game. There were already full albums promised to the community upon release of RB2. It's really no different in this case. Also the base 45 songs while small in comparison to a compilation game such as RB/GH is a lot from a single band. I imagine the DLC will be reasonably priced and offers those who dislike certain songs to skip out on the purchase. I really don't see the problem. Its the exact same formula they use for Rock Band and that's working out wonderfully for them.
 
DLC is getting out of hand. I think Tiger 10 is charging $7.50 per course add-on. Then there was Capcom releasing an extra game mode via DLC a few weeks after RE5 launched.
 
You would also be getting the "full experience" if it only had ten songs...what's your point?

The OP mentioned having to pay extra, DLC, to get the full experience. This isn't the case however. They crafted the game around those 45 songs as a chronological walk though of the Beatles history. In other words you are getting the "full experience" without having to download the additional songs. If however you want to quick play additional songs then you can chose to download them.
 
The OP mentioned having to pay extra, DLC, to get the full experience. This isn't the case however. They crafted the game around those 45 songs as a chronological walk though of the Beatles history. In other words you are getting the "full experience" without having to download the additional songs. If however you want to quick play additional songs then you can chose to download them.

They chose to brand it as a rock band game. Those games and the GH counterparts have always had a very large track list. For less money. They cut that in half for more money. So I'm not sure you have any point at all other than to just say "well, you can still play the game with less songs so don't complain".
 
They chose to brand it as a rock band game. Those games and the GH counterparts have always had a very large track list. For less money. They cut that in half for more money. So I'm not sure you have any point at all other than to just say "well, you can still play the game with less songs so don't complain".

Guitar Hero: Aerosmith's soundtrack consists of 41 songs, 29 Aerosmith and 12 other bands.
Guitar Hero: Metallica features 49 songs based on master recordings, 28 from Metallica, and the other 21 songs from other bands.
Guitar Hero: Van Halen will include 25 songs from the band Van Halen, other bands to be announced.

You were saying? These games also didn't have a fleshed out story mode that teaches you about the band over the course of history. They also didn't have unique character models or venues based upon the era the band played in. So I fail to see your point.
 
Guitar Hero: Aerosmith's soundtrack consists of 41 songs, 29 Aerosmith and 12 other bands.
Guitar Hero: Metallica features 49 songs based on master recordings, 28 from Metallica, and the other 21 songs from other bands.
Guitar Hero: Van Halen will include 25 songs from the band Van Halen, other bands to be announced.

You were saying? These games also didn't have a fleshed out story mode that teaches you about the band over the course of history. They also didn't have unique character models or venues based upon the era the band played in. So I fail to see your point.

Those were all glorified track pack games, that didn't sell with full instrument sets for 250 dollars, so I don't see your point either. GHVH is being given away for free with purchase of GH5. I can compare an apple to an orange too, but that doesn't make them the same thing.
 
Those were all glorified track pack games, that didn't sell with full instrument sets for 250 dollars, so I don't see your point either. GHVH is being given away for free with purchase of GH5. I can compare an apple to an orange too, but that doesn't make them the same thing.

You just mentioned that RB/GH and the counterparts had a very large track list. You were wrong. I was refuting your point and not comparing apples to oranges. Yes the game comes with it's on instruments if you choose to buy the special addition. The insturments are for the Beatles enthusiasts that are willing to shell out more money for "replica instruments". The rest of us can use our original hardware and pay for the game only.

You're also missing the point of a fleshed out story mode based upon the music. If they crafted venues, extras, and character models around each song then of course its going to be somewhat limited. I imagine the download content will not have its on unique venues or character models.This allows them to get the game out in a reasonable amount of time and offer more songs down the line. If the game shipped with those three full albums it would only be more expensive. This allows you to at least chose what additional content you want to spend money on instead of being forced to buy what would probably be a 100$ or more game simply because it contains the entire Beatles catalog.
 
You just mentioned that RB/GH and the counterparts had a very large track list. .

Really? Rock Band 1 and 2 are full featured SKU's with large tracklists and instruments for a premium price. Their counterparts are Guitar Hero WT and GH5. Beatles RB is in the same mold. Aerosmith, VH, and all of the rest of the non band SKU track packs are not comparable, so you continue to be wrong.

Beatles Rock band is 250 dollars and has half the songs. Just because it tells a "story" in one game mode doesn't make up for the grand shafting of a lesser track list. GH and RB games also have a campaign mode style game...so what? Fact is, RB:B is charging more because it can, but consumers don't have to like it, but some apparently want to justify it for some incomprehensible reason.
 
Really? Rock Band 1 and 2 are full featured SKU's with large tracklists and instruments for a premium price. Their counterparts are Guitar Hero WT and GH5. Beatles RB is in the same mold. Aerosmith, VH, and all of the rest of the non band SKU track packs are not comparable, so you continue to be wrong.

Beatles Rock band is 250 dollars and has half the songs. Just because it tells a "story" in one game mode doesn't make up for the grand shafting of a lesser track list. GH and RB games also have a campaign mode style game...so what? Fact is, RB:B is charging more because it can, but consumers don't have to like it, but some apparently want to justify it for some incomprehensible reason.

It's no different from non band SKU games. You still need instruments to play Aerosmith, VH, or Metallica. Just because they didn't ship with their own band specific instruments doesn't somehow change anything. Rock Band Beatles is a 60$ assuming you already own prior instruments. This is the exact luxury that GH band specific games took. They assumed you already owned previous instruments in the series.

If you're comparing the campaign mode to the extra effort Harmonix put into the story mode in Beatles:RB then you're uninformed. Here is a quote from IGN's recent preview of the game. A link to the full article if you want to take the time and read it.

IGN said:
Harmonix has always had the edge over Activision's past few Guitar Hero titles in terms of presentation, but the production value in The Beatles is above and beyond anything I've seen in any music game to date. It doesn't automatically make this a slam dunk brilliant game, but I'm not going to pretend that the hour-long demo didn't have some breathtaking visuals.
 
It's no different from non band SKU games. You still need instruments to play Aerosmith, VH, or Metallica. Just because they didn't ship with their own band specific instruments doesn't somehow change anything. Rock Band Beatles is a 60$ assuming you already own prior instruments. This is the exact luxury that GH band specific games took. They assumed you already owned previous instruments in the series.

If you're comparing the campaign mode to the extra effort Harmonix put into the story mode in Beatles:RB then you're uninformed. Here is a quote from IGN's recent preview of the game. A link to the full article if you want to take the time and read it.

Most people play rhythm music games for breathtaking visuals, definitely not for track list.

:rolleyes:

You still seem to not understand the reason I'm comparing SKU's. Hint: it's because we were discussing value of comparable units.
 
Anyone is tired of DLC getting announced before the game hit the shelves. Beatles rock band features only 45 songs ... but they already announced 3 full DLC album that will be available.

why not release it in one single god damn game.... 45 songs for a rock band game isnt enough ... but having to pay extras to get songs already in the works (my guess is already done) to get the full experience is mindblowing to a point of non-sense...

im sorry but i had to vent.
EXACTLY my bitch when they first started offering songs to download a few years ago. I KNEW this would eventually happen. It's fucking stupid. Put your money where your mouth is and DO NOT buy this product.
 
Wow. 292 songs in Beatles Catalog and I am not sure that includes live and different versions of the same song. You want to pay for them all up front ? How much do you think the game/update/DL whatever should cost for it all in one shot ? ( - really I have no clue, I don't buy digital music anymore and know nothing about these games but what I have seen walking past a Wal-mart display but is not I-tunes like $1.29 a track now ? )

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_The_Beatles_songs

You don't want to know how much I have invested in Beatles records (yes records - just music - no video - no whatever the hell post production is needed to play along with them) when you could buy an album for $6.99not to mention the cost of the equipment to play them on at High-Fidelity standards. Somehow I think the market for $1000 games is limited but then again, it is the Beatles.

Guess we can expect another post when the Wings and John Lennon solo "add ons" become available for DL.

On the other hand I am glad their music is still so popular and if it makes you feel any better I do not buy any of that stuff.
 
i do not expect 292 songs in the games... but at least 80.

45 isnt enough
 
Beatles Rock band is 250 dollars and has half the songs. Just because it tells a "story" in one game mode doesn't make up for the grand shafting of a lesser track list. GH and RB games also have a campaign mode style game...so what? Fact is, RB:B is charging more because it can, but consumers don't have to like it, but some apparently want to justify it for some incomprehensible reason.

I'm skipping RBB. Why? No export. Sorry, I'm spoiled and now expect to be able to play all the songs I buy no matter which RB disc I have in. I have RB:Lego pre-ordered, but if I find out that it will not export, then I'll skip that too. I will be missing out on some great songs, but they'll have to wait for me to find them at bargain bin/used prices.
 
I'm skipping RBB. Why? No export. Sorry, I'm spoiled and now expect to be able to play all the songs I buy no matter which RB disc I have in. I have RB:Lego pre-ordered, but if I find out that it will not export, then I'll skip that too. I will be missing out on some great songs, but they'll have to wait for me to find them at bargain bin/used prices.

yeap, lack of export is so obnoxious. Switching discs for playlists is really annoying.
 
Look at it this way, to buy the the stand alone game it runs around $50 right? If you were to buy all the songs from the game (all 45 of them) as DLC, you'd be paying about $1.99 each... also known as $89.55.

The DLC that has been announced are the complete albums, but note that some of the best singles from those albums are already in the game.

I picked up the game and Gretch Guitar today and I'm happy. I needed a 2nd guitar for my RB setup as is, and figureed why not spend the extra $30 for something fancier than the RB2 strat. Also note, the dongle that comes with the Gretch has 2 USB ports on the back of it, instead of the 1 like the Strat
 
Back
Top