Intel Confirms SSD Data Corruption Issue

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It seems as though Intel has confirmed those SSD data corruption rumors making the rounds. The company says it is working on a fix and has suspended shipments of the drives in the mean time. The problem only exists for people that have set their BIOS drive password and then attempts to disable or change it. Hit the link for more details.

Trying to provide its customers with support, Intel has advised users not to disable or change said password, in case a BIOS password has been set. In addition, the chip maker also decided to delay shipments of the new drives, until the issue was solved and a new firmware fix would be available and validated.
 
Ouch, at least Intel is on top of the situation. I know few people will set BIOS passwords on their hard drives, but data corruption and loss is a serious issue nonetheless.
 
Well, looks like the bugs haven't been ironed out completely in SSDs.. just more reason holding me back (though the prices will hold me back for a while to come).
 
It's hardly a serious bug at all, no worse than half the quirks we tend to experience with any cutting edge mobo these days really... I'm surprised they even stopped shipments (considering a firmware fix is all that's needed), and might've even recalled a few shipments back (apparently Newegg canceled a lot of orders for which they had already provided tracking numbers and everything, see the other thread on the subject on the boards).

I guess Intel doesn't want to risk giving SSD's a bad rap before they truly go mainstream though, 'specially since at $210-ish they really start to become a very appealing upgrade option for many ('specially the average user who really doesn't do any processor-intensive work and for whom the HD has long been the biggest bottleneck).
 
This is not good news, even though this would not probably affect really that many. At least Intel is serious about this, and recalled shipments.
 
They stopped/recalled shipments at first because they didn't know if they could fix it with firmware.

After that point there isn't much reason to ship them even if it is just a firmware fix.
 
this is actually pretty old news isn't it? I think firmware fixed drives have been shipping, maybe not.
 
this is actually pretty old news isn't it? I think firmware fixed drives have been shipping, maybe not.

You must be able to buy them today then.
Care to tell us where you got yours from?
 
It's hardly a serious bug at all, no worse than half the quirks we tend to experience with any cutting edge mobo these days really.

So half the quirks we experience with cutting edge mobos these days result in complete data loss?

You are right, data loss isn't serious at all.

I think Intel is doing the right thing. The are addressing the issue ASAP, released a press release about it and have stopped shipping drives. I can't say that Seagate acted as swiftly when they were having issues.
 
So half the quirks we experience with cutting edge mobos these days result in complete data loss?

You are right, data loss isn't serious at all.

I think Intel is doing the right thing. The are addressing the issue ASAP, released a press release about it and have stopped shipping drives. I can't say that Seagate acted as swiftly when they were having issues.

:rolleyes:

Just the same as everyone should hide indoors because Ebola could kill you. Right? I mean... that's serious, right?
 
The difference is that the problem is caused by faulty firmware, which Intel is responsible for. It's not a random occurrence like a crashing hard drive.
 
So half the quirks we experience with cutting edge mobos these days result in complete data loss?

You are right, data loss isn't serious at all.

I think Intel is doing the right thing. The are addressing the issue ASAP, released a press release about it and have stopped shipping drives. I can't say that Seagate acted as swiftly when they were having issues.

Definitely. It's much better that they're taking steps to solve the problem and prevent further people from encountering it while keeping everyone informed.
 
The difference is that the problem is caused by faulty firmware, which Intel is responsible for. It's not a random occurrence like a crashing hard drive.

Exactly, it's not a random occurrence, which is why it's not a serious issue. There are very specific steps to cause the data corruption. If it randomly killed the drive contents, that would be a serious issue. If it killed the contents once you passed the 30GB mark, that would be a serious issue. Not being able to set, then change your HD bios password before getting thier new firmware in a couple weeks is far from a serious issue.
 
The difference is that the problem is caused by faulty firmware, which Intel is responsible for. It's not a random occurrence like a crashing hard drive.

And Seagates early firmware attempts that were bricking peoples drives and removing all acess to their data is clasified as a crashing hard drive?

Like I said earlier, I think Intel is taking the proper approach here. The have confirmed there is a problem. Way, way earlier than Seagate did with their firmware issues on the 7200.11 drives.

Intel has also stopped shipment of these drives. Seagate did not.

IMHO, Intel was in a lose/lose situation. If they do what they did, people bitch about it. If they hold off and ignore the issue, people still bitch about it.

I for one, am glad they addressed this early and swiftly. And again IMHO that is all we could have asked for or expected. Swift action, updated information and hopefully a timely resolution.
 
Exactly, it's not a random occurrence, which is why it's not a serious issue. There are very specific steps to cause the data corruption. If it randomly killed the drive contents, that would be a serious issue. If it killed the contents once you passed the 30GB mark, that would be a serious issue. Not being able to set, then change your HD bios password before getting thier new firmware in a couple weeks is far from a serious issue.

I can see your point, and I agree. The issue isn't serious, the result could be. So to clarify.

Not being able to set your HDD bios password and then change it = Not Serious
Loss of all data if you do set your HDD bios password and attempt to change it = Serious
 
It's a serious issue because nobody is expecting to lose data just from resetting a BIOS password. Data loss through a crashed hard drive is inevitable; hence the reason why people have (or should have) backups. Someone could have stored some important documents under the assumption that SSDs can't crash or die - foolish assumption perhaps but I can understand that reasoning.
 
Even if the data isn't mission critical, this isn't acceptable behaviour for a hard drive.
 
I want an SSD so bad for my next machine, I just can't help but feel that I'm buying into technology that is still in beta.

Hopefully all the bugs will be shaken out by late October/early November, I really want an SSD for my next Windows 7 machine.
 
I feel the same way about them being in beta form Serpico.. sadly for me, I don't see the bugs being shaken out for another year.. and I don't see the prices being reasonable ($ to GB ratio that is) for atleast another two years.
 
I want an SSD so bad for my next machine, I just can't help but feel that I'm buying into technology that is still in beta.

Hopefully all the bugs will be shaken out by late October/early November, I really want an SSD for my next Windows 7 machine.

Might as well make the leap. Everyone thought NVidia's graphics chips were trustworthy and look what happened to laptops last year and early this year.

Shit happens to anyone.
 
Might as well make the leap. Everyone thought NVidia's graphics chips were trustworthy and look what happened to laptops last year and early this year.

Shit happens to anyone.

Yeah, I think I'll make the jump regardless. As for the cost per GB, eh, I think I'm fine with it, the hard drive is the only real bottleneck in any system right now.

If any component I put in my next system is going to yield any significant improvements over my current one (E8400 with a GTX 285), it'll be the hard drive. An i7 920 with my GTX 285 will be faster, sure, but it won't be a massive difference in performance, not compared to when I went from my old Athlon x2 4400 and 7800GT to my current E8400 and 8800GT (which was soon upgraded to 8800GT SLI, then to my current GTX 285 because I got sick of the fan noise).

More than anything else, an SSD will make it feel like the leap in performance that I like to see in my new computers.
 
Also, I've been super lucky with all my hardware. The last time I had any problems was with bad RAM back in 2002 in both my PC and my Mac (I guess PC133 really sucked, I dunno) and the Radeon 9800 Pro that I dumped after six months (crap ATI drivers). Otherwise all my laptops, desktops, operating systems, devices (I've dropped my Palm, Blackberry, and iPhone an obscene number of times) have been a-ok.

I totally jinxed myself and my upcoming i7 build is literally going to explode in my face, thanks especially to the SSD. :)
 
It's hardly a serious bug at all, no worse than half the quirks we tend to experience with any cutting edge mobo these days really... I'm surprised they even stopped shipments (considering a firmware fix is all that's needed), and might've even recalled a few shipments back (apparently Newegg canceled a lot of orders for which they had already provided tracking numbers and everything, see the other thread on the subject on the boards).

I guess Intel doesn't want to risk giving SSD's a bad rap before they truly go mainstream though, 'specially since at $210-ish they really start to become a very appealing upgrade option for many ('specially the average user who really doesn't do any processor-intensive work and for whom the HD has long been the biggest bottleneck).


gotta love how stupid people always say "it's hardly a serious bug at all"

Obviously Intel thought it was and so wil any people who loose data because of it...
 
Also, I've been super lucky with all my hardware. The last time I had any problems was with bad RAM back in 2002 in both my PC and my Mac (I guess PC133 really sucked, I dunno) and the Radeon 9800 Pro that I dumped after six months (crap ATI drivers). Otherwise all my laptops, desktops, operating systems, devices (I've dropped my Palm, Blackberry, and iPhone an obscene number of times) have been a-ok.

I totally jinxed myself and my upcoming i7 build is literally going to explode in my face, thanks especially to the SSD. :)

I've been fortunate with my hardware too quality-wise. The only 2 times I destroyed my hardware was by my own action.

The first time was way back when analog power supplies were phasing out and ATX power was becoming the norm. I was reading this mod site on how to make an AT power supply work on an ATX board. It didn't quite work out too well. The PSU literally blew up when I plugged it in :-P

The second time was when I had a WinTV card way back, and the cable port in the back was loose. The cable grounded itself onto my steel case and shorted out my entire computer. Bleh.
 
gotta love how stupid people always say "it's hardly a serious bug at all"

Obviously Intel thought it was and so wil any people who loose data because of it...


Maybe if you're going call people stupid you should try assembling something a little better then Engrish? Intel held the shipments because they initially thought they couldn't solve the problem with firmware and would have to scrap the drives.

The bubonic plague is a serious problem for the people affected also, it doesn't mean it's a serious problem overall as the number of people inflicted is essentially nil.

Please tell me; how many people buy the latest SSDs, use BIOS HD passwords, change their BIOS HD password within the first couple weeks of use, don't read tech forums where they would have inevitably learned about this bug, and would have missed a warning email from their vendor regarding this bug?
 
Maybe if you're going call people stupid you should try assembling something a little better then Engrish? Intel held the shipments because they initially thought they couldn't solve the problem with firmware and would have to scrap the drives.

The bubonic plague is a serious problem for the people affected also, it doesn't mean it's a serious problem overall as the number of people inflicted is essentially nil.

Please tell me; how many people buy the latest SSDs, use BIOS HD passwords, change their BIOS HD password within the first couple weeks of use, don't read tech forums where they would have inevitably learned about this bug, and would have missed a warning email from their vendor regarding this bug?

In my experience this could have been a huge issue. When I worked for IBM our laptops required a Bios HDD password, and it had to be changed on a regular schedule with our network passwords. Granted I doubt our internal IT department would have rolled out these SSD's or laptops that used them so quickly, but I wouldn't have put it past them to not know about this issue.

Just pointing out where there could be scenarios where this is an issue.

So as I said earlier, I agree that the problem isn't serious. But the result is.
 
I've been fortunate with my hardware too quality-wise. The only 2 times I destroyed my hardware was by my own action.

The first time was way back when analog power supplies were phasing out and ATX power was becoming the norm. I was reading this mod site on how to make an AT power supply work on an ATX board. It didn't quite work out too well. The PSU literally blew up when I plugged it in :-P

The second time was when I had a WinTV card way back, and the cable port in the back was loose. The cable grounded itself onto my steel case and shorted out my entire computer. Bleh.

Man, that second one is nasty. I've never had anything like that happen but now I don't feel silly about being so paranoid about my cabling jobs. :)
 
In my experience this could have been a huge issue. When I worked for IBM our laptops required a Bios HDD password, and it had to be changed on a regular schedule with our network passwords. Granted I doubt our internal IT department would have rolled out these SSD's or laptops that used them so quickly, but I wouldn't have put it past them to not know about this issue.

Just pointing out where there could be scenarios where this is an issue.

So as I said earlier, I agree that the problem isn't serious. But the result is.

Exactly. This may affect only a fraction of a percent of customers but all you need is one or two incidents for a very nasty PR hit against SSDs. Its bad enough trying to push a technology that people are rightfully skeptical of because of cost and the issues that are still being shaken out. The last thing Intel needs is people being scared away from SSDs even further because of a bug that can erase data. Its better that Intel is attacking this now.
 
Liez! It would never happen to IBM drives!

:D

Speaking of which, nearly half a dozen IBM Deskstars back in the day and not one of them failed on me.

Hoo boy, I'm tempting the angry gadget gods in a BIG way right now. :)
 
Maybe if you're going call people stupid you should try assembling something a little better then Engrish? Intel held the shipments because they initially thought they couldn't solve the problem with firmware and would have to scrap the drives.

The bubonic plague is a serious problem for the people affected also, it doesn't mean it's a serious problem overall as the number of people inflicted is essentially nil.

Please tell me; how many people buy the latest SSDs, use BIOS HD passwords, change their BIOS HD password within the first couple weeks of use, don't read tech forums where they would have inevitably learned about this bug, and would have missed a warning email from their vendor regarding this bug?

is that the best you can do is insult how i type? lol well why don't you tell me what happens to the person that looses the data? What will you do to resolve the issue for them?

so before you try to look intellingent, STFU and look at the bigger picture.
 
is that the best you can do is insult how i type? lol well why don't you tell me what happens to the person that looses the data? What will you do to resolve the issue for them?

so before you try to look intellingent, STFU and look at the bigger picture.

I am looking at the big picture. You're looking at a very small picture and producing some half-literate gibberish that would make a 3rd grader look bad.

There a 1-in-a-billion chance in any given day that the Earth will be sanitized by a major solar ejection. Your logic suggested that we should all run around panicking like fucking morons because something with a minuscule chance of affecting us could happen. :rolleyes:

I was just pointing out that you can't even produce a half-literate sentence, yet you're insulting my "intellingence" because you're too slow to wrap your head around that fact that 99.9999% of people won't be affected.
 
I don't know for sure how many people use BIOS passwords on their hard drives, but I think it's fairly presumptuous to assume that "99.9999%" of people don't use it. If nobody used it, then Intel wouldn't have discovered it and motherboard manufacturers wouldn't bother including the feature.

This is a problem that can and is being fixed - we can't do anything to prevent solar ejections. Whether it's a serious problem is debatable and is rather irrelevant now that Intel's taking action.

If nothing else, at least Intel is trying to make sure that SSD adoption doesn't loose momentum due to bad press.
 
I don't know for sure how many people use BIOS passwords on their hard drives, but I think it's fairly presumptuous to assume that "99.9999%" of people don't use it. If nobody used it, then Intel wouldn't have discovered it and motherboard manufacturers wouldn't bother including the feature.

Yup, it would inevitably affect someone and it would be a serious knock on the chin against SSDs in the public eye.

This is a problem that can and is being fixed - we can't do anything to prevent solar ejections. Whether it's a serious problem is debatable and is rather irrelevant now that Intel's taking action.

Yup again, I can't see why people would complain that a company is fixing a flaw in their product.

If nothing else, at least Intel is trying to make sure that SSD adoption doesn't loose momentum due to bad press.

Ding ding ding, hit the nail right on the head
 
Back
Top