Facebook, MySpace: A Race/Class Divide?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Do you ever think that some people read way too much into stuff like Facebook vs. MySpace? Now it is a racial / class thing?

Boyd, who is also a researcher at Microsoft Research New England (Microsoft being a prominent investor in Facebook), described the migration from MySpace to Facebook as being akin to white folks setting up their own communities. Yes, the places that spawned the allegedly desperate housewife. This wasn't that Facebook was newer or cooler. This was "modern day 'white flight.'"
 
Link to the article rather than a blurb exactly the same as the one I just read! what is the point in that?
 
Link to the article rather than a blurb exactly the same as the one I just read! what is the point in that?

Extra ad hit, keeps this place (mainly) free, I got no problem with the [H]'s methods.

Interesting article, wonder where bebo figures in this? As I'm of the biased opinion its mainly Non-Educated Delinquents (neds/chavs) that use it.
 
I don't understand. I don't use either service, but from what I understand Myspace became lamer than it was initially with the flood of crap on everyone's pages so people went to Facebook because it was less lame and had less crap on every page?

I can't imagine getting on Myspace and thinking "MAN ALL THESE DARKIES WTF"
 
I read through the article (which is a bit confusing) and a half way through her actual presentation and she has a point. I think the article may have come across a bit out of context and disconnected, she isn't saying that its completely this way and even provides testimony that states different. What she is saying is that for the most part it is some mirroring of social status or at least some opinionated descriptions that go a long with sites and actions on the internet. I think a better example is the forums here (even General Mayhem) v.s. 4chan

Here you think of more structure and gathering and sharing of information from if not adults certainly professional or those seeking professionalism. While 4chan you think of pure insanity born of the internet, crazy depravity that could only come form the mind of children or sick people that are like children.

Its an expression of the general nature to gravitate to where you are more accepted and like the other people there. Think about it, you walk into a room where you know no one you are more likely to befriend someone who has similar opinions and taste than someone of equal friendliness or openness but with which you share almost no opinions with.

Not really a matter or racism but of class which can include racism and sexism, ageism etc etc. Now what should we do with this and what does it all mean? Probably not too much on a personal level but on a business or information level these connotations should be noticed and for social well being we should probably seek to understand why and what can be done about it.
 
Link to the article rather than a blurb exactly the same as the one I just read! what is the point in that?

You could click on the link that usually in the news posters comments (the text in white) rather than the article's header. I think the header's link is only for linking to the direct article here for later sharing or what have you.
 
like i really care...its universal and ignorant people say ignorant things. Myspace is fun, but it becoming a radio station. you can actually DO things to your space. Where facebook excels is that its interface is much cleaner and easier to navigate. It's almost like the pc vs mac debate. In the end, its all the same crap. If all my friends stuck with myspace, i'd be on facebook as much as i'm on Hi5

but what pisses me off about facebook is that just cause i have a few openly gay friends, it thinks i want to wear tshirts and go to pride parades. Assuming bastards they are...makes me miss the Lando Calrissian and fashion ads they used to annoy me with.
 
both sites suck, i hardly ever check my facebook and i killed off my myspace account a long time ago.
 
How can you take this seriously? She was quoting high-school students opinions, there is zero fact or evidence behind what they said.
 
... because it's much easier to use it like an address book. Myspace always felt like I was surrounded by millions of people and they were all trying to sell me something.
 
Well, initially with Facebook there was a forced class divide, because it was only available to people with .edu e-mail addresses
 
I'd definitely say there is. Seems that the more customizable pages of Myspace attract the more immature crowds; they like "makin it have glitter n wallpapers n shit yo."

I'm not so sure I'd classify it as a race divide, but more of a cultural divide that urban youth seem to be plagued with: Ghetto appeal. But that is a whole 'nother can of worms for the Soapbox, not FPN.
 
Man I hope the major networks all pick up on this to show all the intarweb injustice out there! :rolleyes:
 
I don't know I ditched myspace after 5 years because of all the flashy, blinky, music playin every ones a baller, get as many friends as possible because you need online popularity bullshit. I'm just saying myspace is like facebook on 24" rims.
 
Reading this article I just can't seem to get out of my head. "Ya and this is news because?" "thanks for stating the obvious" etc etc

I mean who doesn't already know this? Seriously?

The bigger question is, who cares? I don't use either site and feel no need to do so anytime now or in the future.
 
Reading this article I just can't seem to get out of my head. "Ya and this is news because?" "thanks for stating the obvious" etc etc

I mean who doesn't already know this? Seriously?

The bigger question is, who cares? I don't use either site and feel no need to do so anytime now or in the future.

Just because you don't use it doesn't mean no one else cares ;)
 
And I'll continue to not give a shit about facebook or myspace.

Exactly.Waste of time.
((insert grampa-voice))
Back in my day, we used to actually go to friends and see them face to face. Imagine! Real interaction!
;)
 
this writer of fiction smokes crack.

people grow up and stop using myspace... meet friends on facebook. i have friends from all races there. all my asian friends use to have asian avenue accounts until age 20 then they realize they are not 14 anymore... same with myspace except for my sister that is 31
 
... because it's much easier to use it like an address book. Myspace always felt like I was surrounded by millions of people and they were all trying to sell me something.

This is exactly why facebook is better. With facebook, you don't get bombarded with spam. Microsoft is shit.
 
And I'll continue to not give a shit about facebook or myspace.

QFT. - All I can see from both of them is a shameless self-promotional tool. I prefer my friends be real, and have real interaction with them. It says a lot to me that I can call and talk to my friends just to see whats up, and the extent that others will communicate is nothing more than a message left on a myspace/facebook page. I have e-mail, class divide or not, just use my goddamn email address.
 
So, then whats Twitter? If Facebook is the white guy, and Myspace is the black guy. Then is Twitter that chick at the bar that looks hot from a distance, but when you get close you see she has cankles and looks like Billy Ray Cyrus with breasts?
 
But the article is on the internet, it must be true!

Why people read too much into social networking as a temperature for society is beyond me.
 
so in Myspace you have a bunch of hyperactive annoying tweens and wanna be ghetto people so those who want to get away from that go over to facebook where they have tons of stupid flash games and internet whores... man tough choices... I choose option C, neither.
 
Status Update: posting
Mood: Happy
Music Playing Now: Shitty stream
Attitude: Dont care for online social networking
-----------------------------------------------------------------
 
I think it might have something to do with MySpace being a Flash-ridden spam Hell Internet 1.0 eyesore.
 
I don't get this article. On the internets, you can move freely between one system to the other. Or use both at the same time. This isn't anything real like the physical divides between low income/high income classes. There's actually a reason to explain something like that. But this... doesn't amount to anything significant. Myspace has a more popularity (I think), so people tend to go there first.
 
Exactly.Waste of time.
((insert grampa-voice))
Back in my day, we used to actually go to friends and see them face to face. Imagine! Real interaction!
;)

Facebook actually helps you do that more often. The "events" feature is really cool and lets you invite all your friends to a part in one click, then they can RSVP with another click.

But anyway, I think people migrated to Facebook simply because it is a better site, for all the reasons everyone else has already posted. Less crap on pages, more intuitive UI, more mature and intelligent user base...etc. When a new technology is better than the old one, people will move to it.

As for the racial divide, I don't think race itself is the primary issue. White people aren't switching to Facebook because they don't like black people. It is just a natural cultural separation; people with similar interests tend to congregate together, because they are more comfortable with others like themselves.

For better or worse, cultural lines in America still often follow racial differences. It's not racism per se, because the divisions of today are motivated not by race itself, but by cultural differences that correlate with race.
 
For better or worse, cultural lines in America still often follow racial differences. It's not racism per se, because the divisions of today are motivated not by race itself, but by cultural differences that correlate with race.

Yeah I agree with ya there. I think a lot of people who have something "against" a certain race, they're actually more against the culture of a particular ethnic group. But instead of saying "I dislike the culture of this particular ethnic group" we end up saying "I hate X people" which causes nothing but problems.
 
Facebook has gone downhill tremendously since I joined up in 2004. I can't stand myspace.
 
I like facebook because you can't see my profile and personal stuff unless I let you. What it has to do with race is anybody's guess.

Here's what I predict is going to happen, a civil rights leader is going to complain about white people not letting a non white user become their "friend" or be able to see their profile and facebook will become just another myspace.
 
Back
Top