Online Electronics Stores Caught in Fraud

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you bought electronic items from any of these online vendors, you could be entitled to restitution. The New York State Attorney General's office says that seven companies will have to pay $765,000 settlement following a recent consumer fraud investigation.

"These companies engaged in the worst kinds of consumer fraud, from classic bait-and-switch schemes to blatant lies and bullying sales tactics," New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo said in a news release that went out Thursday. "Let this be a message to online merchants everywhere: such abuse of consumers and violation of the law will not be tolerated."
 
"Once an order was placed, the companies would call consumers and try to sell them additional or "upgraded" merchandise at inflated prices. If the consumer refused to purchase the additional merchandise, the companies would cancel the sale or claim the item was backordered for months. If the consumer did agree to purchase the additional merchandise, the companies would send them lower-quality merchandise than what was promised, or merchandise that the consumer never ordered in the first place. When customers tried to return the items, they would either be denied or be slammed with undisclosed fees. All of the companies further limited customers' ability to return merchandise by requiring them to speak to a live customer representative during limited business hours, and then refusing to answer those telephone calls."

Wow, ridiculous.
 
Are they all camera shops? Who the hell buys a camera or anything for it without seeing it first?
 
Yeah, Cameras are notorious for the up-sell tactic. This scam was going on over 5 years ago when I was looking for a camera. There would be a dozen places listed that would have cheaper prices than places like Newegg / BHPhotovideo / One Call, but when looking at reseller ratings almost all of them had complaints of up-selling. Some seemed to have pretty good ratings, but it looked like 9/10 were 5 stars and the other were one stars complaining about upselling. It seemed some would ship out the orders while some would just put the order on infinite backorder untill you called and canceled the order. There are others that would send out gray market imports so the coustomer would not get a warranty with the camera and may not realize it untill it is too late.
 
All in Brooklyn, NY. Coming from Brooklyn myself, this is not surprising in the least.
 
Is there another list? All i saw was camera shops.

I was thinking there had to be something else. I can't believe some people buy cameras online I mean i rather go to the store and handle them check out the features and compare at other stores. It's just funny that camera shops are shady lol!
 
Lots of people do...and I did..but I bought it at B&H Photo..because I know they are legit...

Is there any statical data supporting that? I know people buy movies, books, music in large numbers but I find it hard to believe that lots of people buy cameras though they'd be stupid to buy it from less legit places. If its only available online maybe but seriously not everyone is like you buying from legit places. Whoever kept those business going should get kicked off the internet for the rest of their life. We don't need that crap on here.

but these stores aren't legit anyway...............
 
Sounds like me trying to get a mail-in-rebate.

MIR's are horseshit and I will fight anyone that condones their use at all. Just give me the item at the rebate cost, otherwise stop with MIR's they don't work, they suck and they cost a lot more to process then actually giving the customer the cost of the rebate. So simple, yet so stupid.
 
I've read of this before, its always camera shops, dont know why though lol
 
Is there any statical data supporting that? I know people buy movies, books, music in large numbers but I find it hard to believe that lots of people buy cameras though they'd be stupid to buy it from less legit places. If its only available online maybe but seriously not everyone is like you buying from legit places. Whoever kept those business going should get kicked off the internet for the rest of their life. We don't need that crap on here.

but these stores aren't legit anyway...............

I bought my $1000 camera and equipment from amazon.com without ever once going into a store and holding one in my hands. I simply knew exactly what i wanted and got it. I love the camera. Mind you, i did a year of off and on research into what i wanted and what i could afford to come to my conclusion.
 
Yeah, Cameras are notorious for the up-sell tactic. This scam was going on over 5 years ago when I was looking for a camera.

I forget the company I did this with, but it was the same exact thing. Luckily I used an AmEx, American Express will just flat out deny payment if I tell them to.

Yup, was a New York location, too.

Basically I purchased the camera. Then I got "the call" offering me all the stuff that comes in the regular retail box. Turns out they strip out all the stuff in the box, and put cheap ass batteries and stuff in it, and try to sell you the retail stuff for $$$$.

I knew what was going on so after I told them they were selling Gray Market stuff, they called me a "punk" or something, in which case I told them they'd be hearing from their attorney general, and hung up.
 
MIR's are horseshit and I will fight anyone that condones their use at all. Just give me the item at the rebate cost, otherwise stop with MIR's they don't work, they suck and they cost a lot more to process then actually giving the customer the cost of the rebate. So simple, yet so stupid.

Its done because most people won't send the rebates in, or they'll send them in "incorrectly" and not get their money back. Its a very dirty trick that is far too common.
 
Is there any statical data supporting that? I know people buy movies, books, music in large numbers but I find it hard to believe that lots of people buy cameras though they'd be stupid to buy it from less legit places. If its only available online maybe but seriously not everyone is like you buying from legit places. Whoever kept those business going should get kicked off the internet for the rest of their life. We don't need that crap on here.

but these stores aren't legit anyway...............


I don't have any hard data..I'm not sure there is any..:)

I know most of my friends went with an online purchase after researching what they wanted ...most local stores cant compete with online stores ...and there is also the tax advantage for some people...I paid no tax on a $900.00 purchase....and thats a pretty good incentive for a lot of folks.


but you have to do your research....if you just click BUY IT NOW on the cheapest price..well, you get what you pay for..:)
 
Its done because most people won't send the rebates in, or they'll send them in "incorrectly" and not get their money back. Its a very dirty trick that is far too common.

Or it will be claimed that they weren't done right and therefore you won't get your rebate. The whole practice should be gotten rid of or outlawed.
 
This type of 'business practice' has been happening for quite awhile; at least 10 years that I know of. Thanks, Steve, for helping get the word out.

Many of these types of shops even go far beyond 'calls' to customers. Many will start making miscelaneous charges to the credit card after the order is placed online. Buyer beware.
 
Or it will be claimed that they weren't done right and therefore you won't get your rebate. The whole practice should be gotten rid of or outlawed.


The ONLY time I had MIR trouble was with a Circuit City rebate on RAM..... I specifically asked a person that worked there if I would be able to get rebates for 2 sticks of RAM as the rebate offer didn't specifically say that I could only get one.

That was probably he hardest $40 I ever earned after having had to talk to the rebate people multiple times and explain to them that I specifically asked at the store if I would be able to get 2 rebates and was told yes.

Other than that, no MIR problems whatsoever. Just have to follow the instructions to a T and make sure you write legibly which it seems it super hard for most people to do.

But yeah.. I would rather MIRs be done away with as it would end up being a lot cheaper in the long run for the companies to just do instant rebates.
 
Doesn't surprise me at all,the consumer ratings sites have gotten complaints by the boatload for years about New York camera and electronics vendors.They're notorious for ripping off customers.
 
"Once an order was placed, the companies would call consumers and try to sell them additional or "upgraded" merchandise at inflated prices. If the consumer refused to purchase the additional merchandise, the companies would cancel the sale or claim the item was backordered for months. If the consumer did agree to purchase the additional merchandise, the companies would send them lower-quality merchandise than what was promised, or merchandise that the consumer never ordered in the first place. When customers tried to return the items, they would either be denied or be slammed with undisclosed fees. All of the companies further limited customers' ability to return merchandise by requiring them to speak to a live customer representative during limited business hours, and then refusing to answer those telephone calls."

Wow, ridiculous.

Ridiculous,but all too common. I've price-searched many items to get the best deal, and upon further digging (since some vendors are not what you would call main-stream), I've found a lot of these tactics.
I'VE never been duped. All it takes is research..........and if you are in doubt, use a well known retailer like the Egg.
 
They should check tigerdirect as well. they have "bundles" to build a system advertised, but when you call them certain items are "out of stock" (ecen really common and cheap OCZ platinum for example)
they they try and upsell you on all the components which are out of stock.

my freind was going to build a system with them, and explained what happened, I sent him to NCIX with a list and he was happy.

(this is in canada btw, i dont know if tigerdirect behaves different in the US)
 
all stores are based in brooklyn, ny... yes the finest scumbags in the country can be found in good old NY
 
Doesn't surprise me at all,the consumer ratings sites have gotten complaints by the boatload for years about New York camera and electronics vendors.They're notorious for ripping off customers.

They've been ripping people off since before the internet was invented.
 
Is there any statical data supporting that? I know people buy movies, books, music in large numbers but I find it hard to believe that lots of people buy cameras though they'd be stupid to buy it from less legit places. If its only available online maybe but seriously not everyone is like you buying from legit places. Whoever kept those business going should get kicked off the internet for the rest of their life. We don't need that crap on here.

but these stores aren't legit anyway...............
Look at it logically. If there weren't a lot of people buying from those places (AND falling for the tactics), do you think they'd still be in business? Do you think there'd be enough complaints from people who have bought (or tried to buy) for the NY attourney general to go after them?
And how is an average person to know the places are not legit just looking at them? Aside from the lower prices, there's no outward appearance that they guys are scammers, the web sites in question look professional. And since everyone knows that things are cheaper on the internet, I'm guessing they just figure the lower price is because of that. I mean look at the [h] hot deals section, sometimes there ARE very good deals.
The main indicator would be places like resellerratings saying they are scammers, but how many people (even internet savy people) actually check that for a site they haven't ordered from before? There's LOTS of comments on the linked story from people who have bought from those places.
Besides, with the credit card protections being designed to make people feel safe about purchases on the internet, some people probably figure its worth a shot, since they can always get thier money back.

Its like all those nigerian scams (like the guys who claim to have 100 million tied up at a foreign bank and he'll give 10% if someone helps him transfer it) people fall for those constantly, some shell out hundreds of thousands of dollars or even millions of bucks and even some in the government. If you look around you can find lots of news items on that kinda thing. Something like that screams obvious scam much more than the camera places, but people continually fall for it.
 
I was thinking there had to be something else. I can't believe some people buy cameras online I mean i rather go to the store and handle them check out the features and compare at other stores. It's just funny that camera shops are shady lol!

Look at their target customers....usually the "value shoppers"...aka the lowest price shopper. They usually don't use the item all that often, so the odds of it failing are pretty slim (and will often be well past the warranty period), thus less chance of getting busted for selling knock-offs and grey market product.

The people that use their photo gear daily tend to go to brick and mortar shops, to get opinions and reccomendations from people they trust in. The prices are a bit higher, but when you are making money off your hobby (as many serious photographers do....hell, I made 5x the price of my cheapy Nikon in two years just fucking around and selling photos to tourism mags...and honestly, I'm a pretty mediocre photographer at best).

The point is, photography is a hobby where those who are part of the hobby crowd know the innate value of the product is worth the price.....the tourister or novice however do not, and will often fall for lowest price scams like these companies pull.
 
they also sold on ebay, broadway photo tried that crap with me, I won the auction waiting 2 weeks nad nothing, so I called them and they stated out of stock and for $70 I coul dupgrade to better lens, I refused, file a PP complaint, left them negative feedback and of course they left me negative, but I eventually got my refund
 
They should check tigerdirect as well. they have "bundles" to build a system advertised, but when you call them certain items are "out of stock" (ecen really common and cheap OCZ platinum for example)
they they try and upsell you on all the components which are out of stock.

my freind was going to build a system with them, and explained what happened, I sent him to NCIX with a list and he was happy.

(this is in canada btw, i dont know if tigerdirect behaves different in the US)

They are just as bad, if not worse in their actions in the USA.
 
this has been going on far too long, and for the guy that said "who would buy a camera online without holding it first or comparing it" is living under the rock, I personally found myself buying stuff on forums and online stores, saves me time and sales tax of course if you are equipped with the knowledge of what you are buying I don't think you need to hold it in your hand just to buy it. a lot of reputable stores offer no-restocking fees on returned item so that should cover it when you think that the item is subpar... My cousin bought a 5D MII kit for around $3000 at B&H and he saved 9.75% in taxes and free shipping too... he was comfortable enough to buy the item online because he knows what he is getting and where he is getting it from..
 
Look at their target customers....usually the "value shoppers"...aka the lowest price shopper. They usually don't use the item all that often, so the odds of it failing are pretty slim (and will often be well past the warranty period), thus less chance of getting busted for selling knock-offs and grey market product.

I bought my D-80 online as did a few friends of mine.....I bought from B&H who was not the lowest price...but I know they have a good rep..

so I would suggest that their target shoppers are not so much value shoppers, but shoppers who do not do any research.....because if anyone had done a Google search on any of the names of these places..they would have had all the info they needed to stay clear....
 
agreed it's always good to at least do a google check, after all it is YOUR money that is being spent.
 
Back
Top