Pirate Bay Defendants Found Guilty

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
This just in…the defendants in the Pirate Bay case have been found guilty and ordered to serve 1 year in jail and pay fines totaling $3.6M. Thanks to Mark M. and Thad S. for the heads up.

The crime has been committed in a commercial and organized form" - Judge Tomas Norström.
 
Last edited:
awww crap, this isn't good....

So much for the future of sharing all the music that I've written, performed, and produced in my home with all my own permissions....
 
Good, hopefully this will be an example that copyright infringement is not okay.
 
Enter the appeal.


And a few years later, something may actually come of this.
 
awww crap, this isn't good....

So much for the future of sharing all the music that I've written, performed, and produced in my home with all my own permissions....

And shutting down The Pirate Bay does that how?
 
I had a bad feeling about this (and said so), when they were acting like total retards in court, throwing the parties, etc. etc., they weren't exactly getting the courts on their side.

The good news for TPB guys is that there is an appeal process and they all get to stay out of jail until then.
 
And shutting down The Pirate Bay does that how?

TPB isn't even the issue, it's the people behind it. The website will remain up regardless of what happens. Granted, whoever takes the reins is in for an uphill battle.
 
Thats the end, its finally happened.
The Internet is now dead and has been taken over by big business.

How can you be found guilty of no crime.
NO copyright material was on any of their servers.
Its like jailing a road builder for bank robbers used their roads to rob a bank.
 
They said:
The pirate bay wont be shut down, their private economy will be decreased, but thats all they said :)

I earned 45 000 $ USD last year working as a post man, and will prolly earn more when im done with education this year.

So, they got a fine thats split into 1.4 million usd on each, that isnt bad.

Remember, scandinavian paychecks are way higher! they prolyl have some money from TPB shop, and donations aswell as advertisement.

They'll do just fine, they can be glad the court wasnt in USA!
 
As history has shown, when a major one falls, other will pop up and take its place. We have seen this in previous file sharing applications/websites/protocols and drug cartels. The war is not over by a long shot.
 
Well, at least I don't live in that country. Not like mine is much better.
 
Thats the end, its finally happened.
The Internet is now dead and has been taken over by big business.

How can you be found guilty of no crime.
NO copyright material was on any of their servers.
Its like jailing a road builder for bank robbers used their roads to rob a bank.

Hardly the end... but that's a pretty good analogy. If the bittorrent guy was living their, he'd probably be sued in just the same way.
 
How can you be found guilty of no crime.
NO copyright material was on any of their servers.
Its like jailing a road builder for bank robbers used their roads to rob a bank.

But that road was used by everyone and not robbers only.
 
He would not, our justice system is a tiny bit smarter than that, but still stupid enough that a rapist went free from trial just because he covered a girls mouth up so that she was unable to say "no".
 
everyone keeps bringing up the appeal process.

I think this is just flat out WRONG with our legal system.....if you are found innocent you cant be charged for the same crime again (unless you do the exact same thing again) because its double jeapordy......but if you are found guilty you can appeal it who knows how many times until you get a verdict you like or your time on this planet runs out which just isnt right.

Im not saying i agree with the verdict, but come on
 
everyone keeps bringing up the appeal process.

I think this is just flat out WRONG with our legal system.....if you are found innocent you cant be charged for the same crime again (unless you do the exact same thing again) because its double jeapordy......but if you are found guilty you can appeal it who knows how many times until you get a verdict you like or your time on this planet runs out which just isnt right.

Im not saying i agree with the verdict, but come on

The media groups will constantly do appeal after appeal after appeal until the courts side with them. They have to deep pockets afford each and every trial.
 
As history has shown, when a major one falls, other will pop up and take its place. We have seen this in previous file sharing applications/websites/protocols and drug cartels. The war is not over by a long shot.


Absolutly, just like they said shutting Napster Down ended music sharing..
 
so...with this information in hand...what do I want to watch and listen to tonight.....

raise the jolly roger...it's on
 
This is not a good week to be a pirate of any form, lol
 
Thats the end, its finally happened.
The Internet is now dead and has been taken over by big business.

How can you be found guilty of no crime.
NO copyright material was on any of their servers.
Its like jailing a road builder for bank robbers used their roads to rob a bank.

This is my thoughts exactly.

Their name doesn't exactly help their case though ;)
 
as much as I think OJ was guilty

he got double jeapordy..

not- guilty in court

then guilty in civil court

what gives
 
Good! They made a ton of money by hosting a site primarily designed to infringe on other peoples rights. If anything I think they got off far too light on the sentances.

I don't agree with individuals pirating songs getting $150k fines, but the people that profit of piracy deserve stiff punishments.
 
as much as I think OJ was guilty

he got double jeapordy..

not- guilty in court

then guilty in civil court

what gives

IIRC from my limited law classes:

He could not be tried for the crime of murder again by the government, but there is nothing to prevent him from being sued in civil court for the tort of wrongful death directly by the victums.
 
everyone keeps bringing up the appeal process.

I think this is just flat out WRONG with our legal system.....if you are found innocent you cant be charged for the same crime again (unless you do the exact same thing again) because its double jeapordy......but if you are found guilty you can appeal it who knows how many times until you get a verdict you like or your time on this planet runs out which just isnt right.

Im not saying i agree with the verdict, but come on

Appeals are there to protect you. Imagine you were tried for something you legitimatly didn't do and got convicted based on circumstantial evidence. Or in a civil trial, a judge threw the case out because he might not have agreed with it based on his/her own prejudices? Wouldn't you be happy that the appeals process is there?

Sure, it might be abused, but I'd (personally) rather have it than not.
 
IIRC from my limited law classes:

He could not be tried for the crime of murder again by the government, but there is nothing to prevent him from being sued in civil court for the tort of wrongful death directly by the victums.

yup


he cant be tried criminally for murder again... there's nothing saying that he can't be sued in a civil case though
 
Back
Top